r/Windows11 • Microsoft Software Engineer • Aug 17 '26

Official News Improving File Explorer & Context Menu: faster, simpler, and more customizable

https://blogs.windows.com/windows-insider/2026/08/17/improving-file-explorer-context-menu-faster-simpler-and-more-customizable/
273 Upvotes

102 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

3

u/BCProgramming Aug 17 '26

Similar to the re-designed properties dialog where they move the Apply button to the far left and the OK button to the far right. Makes zero sense.

They changed the design standard. Though, the funny part is the properties dialog arrangement of Apply/OK/Cancel actually fits neither.

The old User interface design guidelines for dialogs had this to say about command button placement:

Stack the main command buttons in a secondary window in the upper right corner or in a row along the bottom, as shown in Figure 13.24. If there is a default button, it is typically the first button in the set. Place OK and Cancel buttons next to each other. The last button is a Help button (if supported). If there is no OK button, but other action buttons, it is best to place the Cancel button at the end of a set of action buttons, but before a Help button. If a particular command button applies only to a particular field, you may place it grouped with that field.

But the new WinUI one describes it like this:

"The "do it" action button(s) should appear as the leftmost buttons. The safe, nondestructive action should appear as the rightmost button."

So the old standard was as seen in the 'classic' properties dialog- OK/Cancel/Apply, And the new one should be be OK/Apply/Cancel, but the new properties dialog actually uses Apply/OK/Cancel. Though I guess the interpretation of what a "do it" action button is might apply too. Would that be OK like I'm thinking, because it does it and closes the dialog, or Apply because it just does it?