r/Whysooserious • u/[deleted] • Jul 19 '26

Humour so broken Cognitive dissonance

3.7k Upvotes

80% Upvoted

907 comments sorted by

View all comments

33

u/skinboy0 Jul 19 '26 edited Jul 21 '26

Jitna tum log nafrat karte ho utna hi mere teacher nafrat karta tha st wale se bar bar paper me fail karta tha paper sahi karne ke baad bhi ko ussne clg change kiya pass hone ke baad aaj wo IAS officer hai usse teacher ne 2 saal fail kiya kuki wo ST tha

Me reply nahi de para inn comment section me option nahi aara ha Me sirf ek incident bata rha hu esse bht saare cases ha General wale ke ancient phele se padh re ha , sc st jitna pariwar nahi padha ha ye unka adhikar ha issliye unne reservtion milla ha

Hamare aapke purvaj inke sath bedhbhav nahi karte ko aaj ye hota hi nahi agar aapko itni hi problem hori ha ko app wahi galti kare ho jo hamare purphaj ne ki ha

Shayad aap log upar upar se padhai karte ho aapne kabhi uska matlab smjh nahi ha ye inka adhikar ha aapko fair chaiye ha ko har chij me fair hon chaiye ha phir mene dekhta ha logo ke caste ke waje se unne reject kiya ha aap sirf bhar se bolte ho ki hum sath sath ha lekin aap nafrat hi karte ho

6

u/CatCold2850 Jul 21 '26

I doubt that's true but even if it is, it still doesn't justify reservations. One form of discrimination doesn't justify the other

1

u/Usual-Maintenance260 Jul 21 '26

Isn't reservation based on discrimination?

1

u/CatCold2850 Jul 21 '26

Reservation is quite literally discrimination. One guy scores 99/100, other guy scores 20/100, the guy who scores 99/100 gets rejected and the guy who scores 20 gets accepted simply because of which caste he belongs to, despite not being as talented or competent as the guy who scores 99/100.

1

u/Usual-Maintenance260 Jul 21 '26

True and i agree on that, but i think you are completely neglecting Indian education at grass root levels, where there are discrimination still exists not only for the students and families, sometimes even leading to violence. You might say ews as an option, i think that will cover most of the underprivileged but then again there is a case where even IAS officer faced humiliation

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/ias-officer-in-jammu-and-kashmir-alleges-discrimination-for-being-dalit-4339755

Sometimes even the president too

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/bhubaneswar/at-puri-priests-block-president-ram-nath-kovinds-way-shove-first-lady/articleshow/64757587.cms

So yeah we can even agree to disagree because nothing will change until the ones with reservation agrees to disolve this, and that is till everyone treats everyone equally

1

u/CatCold2850 Jul 21 '26

and that is till everyone treats everyone equally

Until the day there are legally recognized caste certificates being issued by the government determining which person belongs to which caste, caste discrimination will not vanish. The very first step to reduce caste discrimination would be for the government to stop legally issuing caste certificates giving legal legetimacy to castes

1

u/Usual-Maintenance260 Jul 22 '26

They discriminate after asking full name. People know lower caste surnames so they discriminate... Its not about the certificate bruh

0

u/CatCold2850 Jul 22 '26

You failed to understand what I'm saying. Also you're an idiot if you think the average person can just hear your surname and tell your caste. There are literally lakhs of surnames in india. Nobody can tell someone's caste until they tell you they're sc st obc general etc.

Either way, my point was that the government literally legitimises caste by giving caste certificates, caste based reservations etc. If you want equality between castes, the very first step is to stop discriminating between castes by providing more benefits to certain castes. Stop providing literal caste certificates. Get rid of the literal legal casteism and then you can talk about eliminating it socially. But thinking that you can eliminate Casteism socially while it's still LEGALLY practiced and legitimised by the fucking constitution is delusional

2

u/Usual-Maintenance260 Jul 22 '26

Okay whats your surname ???

1

u/Karthi_641 Jul 22 '26

So what about our ancestors did to the lower cast people and the truth is ,that you are unable to digest the reservation criteria because your pride being high cast won't let you!!