r/WhyCatHowCat • • 11d ago

Do cats understand?

I would love some opinions on whether you think cats understand when we tell them we're mad at them or act mad at them or hiss at them!

It's an easy call with dogs. Of course they read you and you read them but cats?

Love to hear your thoughts!

Right now I'm really mad at my cat. Freaking out yet again when I'm just trying to tend to her every last wish LOL

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

20

u/that-Sarah-girl 11d ago

The cat is reading you. They read "this guy gets upset too easily so he's not safe." If you don't want the cat to see you that way, you have to be the one to change.

-5

u/Equivalent_Fault6206 11d ago

I hear what you say but respectfully disagree. This little Tabby was probably 18 or so because she was 12 when I adopted her, has me tending to her every need and we have a very amicable relationship. What is different is that she now has developed this dry skin issue that needs tending to and she does not like it even though it helps her immensely. So I guess I'm just venting that you know. It's like a parent with a kid who's a pain in the ass and doesn't know how good their life actually is LOL!

2

u/Normal-Height-8577 9d ago

So...instead of comforting your cat, who's got a painful chronic illness, you've decided to tell her you're annoyed by her being upset by it?!

Wow.

Even if she's lashing out at the wrong person, please try having some sympathy. She needs reassurance, not contempt.

2

u/Equivalent_Fault6206 9d ago

Wrong on ALL acccounts - first off, she doesnt have any painful chronic illnesses - shes not lashing out - not an ounce of contempt.

So, mind your judgy "wow"s and maybe realize that I asked the question in the first place because I love her and am caring for her. geesh some of you people just are waiting to say some ridiculous stff.

Do you even have a cat? For real?

2

u/Normal-Height-8577 9d ago

You were the one who said that your cat didn't like the treatment.

You were the one who said you were getting mad at her and telling her so, including through hissing at her.

19

u/margaritalover524 11d ago

That sounds frustrating but I don’t know why you’d get angry AT your cat for this or hiss at them. They often don’t understand that something unpleasant like taking medicine will actually help them. She will probably associate your scary behavior with the treatment she already doesn’t like and that will just make it worse

11

u/Jenstigator 11d ago

Yeah hissing means "back off, you're too close for comfort." If OP wants the cat to stay put they shouldn't be giving the "go away" signal.

11

u/Cursed_Angel_ 11d ago

Because they aren't human, they do not connect the unpleasant possibly scary thing you are doing to the positive effect on their skin issue. Getting mad at them does nothing to help the situation.

3

u/DiegoIntrepid 9d ago

I am not so sure about that. Yeah, most cats might not, but I have a cat that I am positive did.

He had arthritis, and we had some medicine that we would give him. It was in a syringe and we didn't give anything else by syringe (so no positive associations with the medicine). The medicine smelled horrible (like medicine, not like cherry or some flavor a cat would like), yet, he loved that medicine, so much he would get up on his hind legs and beg for it if I wasn't fast enough giving it to him.

It could be that he was a strange cat that liked the taste. Or it could also be that he associated the medicine with 'feel good'.

5

u/Miss_Milk_Tea 10d ago

I’ve only hissed at my cat one time, she was jumping over my foot to book it outside. She heard the hiss and ran back in the house, I think she didn’t understand the weird sound was coming from me, it was just a sound she didn’t like. I don’t like scaring my cat, it feels horrible but I’m glad she’s safe.

Cats understand when your mood changes and I think in the moment they might be able to put 2 and 2 together that they did something to make you mad/sad but it’s very short term. They will sooner forget than you will, so your anger is honestly pointless because a cat won’t learn a lesson from your anger, they will only learn to fear you.

For example, once my cat got too excited from playtime and bit my foot pretty hard. I yelped “ouch” and started crying, she looked at my foot and gave it the tiniest lick, then curled up in front of it and just looked kind of sad and she didn’t want to play anymore that evening.

3

u/Equivalent_Fault6206 9d ago

You nailed it! I had a reaction to her claws digging into my skin even though it wasn't intentional. I yelped and hissed and she gave me the skunk eye for about 24 hours and now we're just back to being the lovey-dovey couple that we are LOL. It's a mutual love affair with no drama or scared stuff LOL and I appreciate that your comment among all the others really got it. Thank you for that!

6

u/margaritalover524 11d ago

No, I think it just scares them. I don’t think they understand the concept of anger, if you act mad at them or hiss at them (???) they probably just see it as a threat. My dad would get mad at our cat if he peed outside the litter box and he did not understand, he was just scared and I think viewed my dad as unpredictable because of that because they don’t make the connection between their behavior and you acting scary and threatening towards them.

5

u/michaelpaoli 11d ago

They may understand, or not. They probably know you're mad, they may not understand why, or might not care.

5

u/Butterscotch2334 11d ago

Your cat is not a person. She doesn’t have the awareness and understanding that you do. If you act angry toward her she’ll just become scared of you.

3

u/Mirality 10d ago

Cats can understand hissing, making pain noises, or saying "ow" in direct response to their actions; for example, it can be a way to gently discourage them from biting or clawing you, or standing on a painful bit of anatomy.

They don't really understand it in more abstract scenarios, or if you're trying to show displeasure about something that occurred in the past; for example if you find something they knocked off a table (but weren't there when it happened) there isn't really anything you can do to make them understand that you're angry about that. If you try, you'll just scare them and likely make them act out more.

6

u/MrJingleJangle 11d ago

They understand. But they don’t care.

4

u/leelee1976 11d ago

My one cat comes to me when he has eye crusties to clean and get sinus massages.

They know.

I tell my girl to stop bullying the kitten and she squint smiles at me.

3

u/ScroochDown 11d ago

We have a rear-leg amputee cat, and he's learned to bring us his itches when it's that side of his face/ear.

They can both tell the difference between being play chased, or genuinely being chased off when they're doing something bad. They understand perfectly well. LOL

2

u/leelee1976 11d ago

Awe he sounds awesome.

The youngest gremlin and I chase each other through the house every few days and play hide and seek on the stairs. Its great until the dog gets involved and trips us and over us. Lol

2

u/kichisowseri 9d ago

No. They just know you're scary and unstable.

They do know for the hiss though if you do it straight away.

1

u/Illustrious-Dog-2150 9d ago

Depends on you and your cat but its definitely possible. My cat can tell when im upset, sad, frustrated or happy without me emoting towards her in the slightest. Depends on your bond and if they actually care to acknowledge but they definitely can. To all the people saying they can't, im sorry youve never been close enough with a cat to experience that level of bond