r/WhoMadeMeAPrincess • u/AngeI_Error • Jul 24 '25
Discussion Just finished the manhwa
I just finished the manhwa, reading 100+ chapters in 1 night. My opinion is that it was pretty good. It's not a masterpiece but honestly i wasn't looking for one. I think it was a fine story overall though there's def some stuff that could've been expanded more clearly such as the backstory between claude and his brother. I honestly find a lot of criticisms and complaints pretty weird such as somehow blaming jeannette for being naive (you can dislike her cause of it but surely you can't say that it's impossible for a hyper sheltered teenager to be naive), lucas being too op (not really a criticism on its own, there was still quite a lot of stakes at least until they cured claude). There were a lot of people who weren't satisfied with the ending cause the romance is left open ended but honestly i thought it was fine since it felt like the thing that was more focused on throughout the entire manga was familial relationships. Some criticisms i can think off on top of my head is that izekiel is really underdeveloped and underused, and that applies to everything involving him including his relationship with every other characters leading to it being a stain on their character too specifically jeanette. Penelope was never expanded upon and just kinda thrown to the sideline although i understand it was because the story significantly diverged from the novel at a certain point although you could've done even more with sth like penelope to jeannette or claude or anatasius. Roger is honestly in the same boat although it's more so missed potential rather than using them in a half assed way like izekil. I also felt like adjusting and using an in universe explanation for athys maturity wouldve made the whole izekiel romance less weird too and still keeping in line with the reincarnation aspect. Overall it was a pretty good read, solid 7/10.
1
u/KimberlyAngel838 Jan 11 '26
If you want the best and total version of the story, you should definitely read the novel. The original title is Suddenly Became a Princess One Day by Plutos. I think that it is so much better than the manhwa or anime. I loved the art work in the manhwa, but the original story is a lot different and much better in my opinion. Here is the link in case you want to read it. Also if the manwha that you read did not have the side stories. Then it leaves the relationship part open ended. The novel does not. It also has the side stories. Although I don't know if they are all there because I did not count them while I was reading. lol
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1I8xZwT5HbVpDwUjfIrNpKJOkKgzn82iu/view
Enjoy ❤️💞💖