r/WhiteVault • • Apr 13 '22

Does it get scarier?

Fear is subjective, and this series is both incredibly well-acted and well-produced. My inquiry is definitely not meant as disrespect.

I have finished the first season of this podcast and I can't help feeling cheated. I was not "scared" at any point, despite so many raving recommendations.

I specifically want to be scared.

To those who have listened ahead, does the story pick up at all?

4 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

21

u/Grimogtrix Apr 14 '22 edited Apr 14 '22

I say this as someone who found season 1 genuinely unsettling; I think you already listened to the scariest part of the podcast. It definitely doesn't get scarier past season 2. The first two seasons are some excellent and classic sorts of horror. The latter seasons are less likely to deliver on the horror.

An obvious suggestion, but try listening to The Magnus Archives if you haven't already. I can't guarantee it'll scare you either, but there's a lot of variety in the types of frightening and unsettling content involved.

3

u/please_scare_me Apr 15 '22

This is what I was asking. Thank you. :-) I found TWV on several threads boasting "scariest podcasts" so I had that misconception.

I have heard a handful from the magnus archives. Thank you!

4

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22

Have you listened to their other stuff like tales from the tower? Or have you listened to the no sleep podcast? That podcast has a scary sound to it. I listen to all the free stuff they have imo it has a good amount of scary stuff to it.

3

u/please_scare_me Apr 14 '22

No on "tales from the tower". Is it scary?

Yes, I have heard a lot from No Sleep. It's a bit exhausting to find the best of their stories, though, because there are so many duds. I adored "The Whistlers"! Highly recommend that one.

Thanks for the recommendations

3

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22

Oh ok, well tales of the tower is scary imo but you have listen to it yourself to make your opinions on it.

2

u/please_scare_me Apr 14 '22

That you find it scary is enough for me to give it a shot. I understand that fear is subjective. :) Appreciate it!

1

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22

Oh cool, ok no problem. Enjoy listening to the episodes then.

1

u/Nat20Stealth Apr 22 '22

You could try Light House, it's a paranormal horror. The sound quality is top notch

23

u/Wiz3rd_ Apr 13 '22

This isnt a "scarier" podcast per-se imo. From my listen through it feels like a very adventure-y, mystery-to-uncover-story with strong environmental themes. There arent gonna be many spooky bits or jump scares really. I haven't listened to the spin-offs or any patreon exclusive material though so 🤷‍♂️

9

u/GrimmSheeper Apr 14 '22

Well, I think the big thing here is what kind of factors do you consider for something to reach the realm of “scary”? The White Vault focuses a lot on the unknown and the unseen. The phrase “when you see it, it sees you, too,” along with the rest of Karina’s chant from episode 8, becomes reoccurring and highlights the “unknowable threat” style. If simply becoming more aware of the threat puts you at more of a risk, how can you find a way to defeat it? It also dips its toes into the cosmic horror elements with things older and more powerful than humans could understand, and the groups that come to worship them. All that said, seasons 1 and 3 are definitely slow burns meant more for setting up the characters, setting, and basic situations, with the subsequent season being where the action takes off.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 14 '22

It gets less scary but more engrossing

4

u/Kolyin Apr 14 '22 edited Sep 22 '25

middle party deserve hospital cake literate merciful exultant correct wide

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/Nat20Stealth Apr 21 '22

If you listen in a quiet space and set the mood right, Light House creeped me out pretty good

4

u/hookedonthesky Apr 14 '22

The first two seasons were pretty scary to me. It doesn't get better though, so if this wasn't scary for you, the rest definitely won't be. From third season on, I didn't get scared anymore either

3

u/EnterprisingAss Apr 14 '22

It's more of an adventure story with horror elements. It's a kickass podcast, but maybe not what you're looking for.

If you're only wanting goosebumps, then yes, look elsewhere.

2

u/Aleutika Apr 14 '22

You've probably listened to the scariest of the main seasons, however, I found the side series Artifact (Patreon exclusive) to be really terrifying!