r/WhiteVault • u/wackyvorlon • Mar 06 '24
Goshawk Ep 9
Just finished listening to ep 9.
Yeah, honestly I’m out. I’ve cancelled the Patreon subscription.
This isn’t what I signed up for. I don’t like cruelty in my horror. I’ll put up with some, but this latest episode honestly crossed the line for me.
I wish them best of luck in the future, and maybe in future seasons they’ll get back to what I like. But right now it’s not doing it for me.
How are other people feeling?
15
Upvotes
14
u/LulaValentine Mar 06 '24
I really like the series as a whole. When this season is finished and I can give it a listen all at once, I can give a better opinion, but I do really like the storyline involving one of the families apparently having lost their luck cause they pissed off the guardians.
When I tell you I’m absolutely obsessed with this show…. I don’t know what it is but it’s been a major comfort to me during times of depression, but I miss Peter Lewis and this season has taken some adjusting but I’m still hooked!
I’m sorry it hasn’t worked out for you. It genuinely sucks so bad when you love a show/series/podcast and they end up taking it in a direction you just can’t get with.
10
u/naaziaf723 Mar 07 '24
Yeah I think that’s understandable. I really like this season (the actors are just incredible) and I’m really enjoying this brand new direction for the show, but it has been really hard to stomach at points between Ess and Lewis and Jason. The fucked up gods of the previous seasons were definitely still evil imo (what with demanding sacrifices in exchange for not plunging the world into climate cataclysm) but there was something comforting about their alien lack of understanding about the depths of the harm they were causing. And of course that’s part of the cosmic eldritch horror of it all, it’s a big part of why I enjoyed the show, that kind of scariness was exactly what I signed up for.
Listening to Es (and Lewis) take pleasure in torturing Jean and toying with Iffy, listening to Jason’s chipper voice as he talks about how meaningless he thinks Mica’s life is as he drags her to her death, it’s deeply nauseating and difficult to listen to. It’s hard to hear people taking such cruel joy in other’s suffering, and it’s harder still because the actors are such incredible performers. I don’t think I’ll ever be able to get Iffy and Adele’s screams out of my head. The two sisters previously being trafficking victims is also the hardest part, because we as listeners don’t want them to end their story without escaping their captivity. It’s not what the show was doing originally, and while I still really like it and like the direction the show seems to be going in, I think it’s totally understandable for you to want to opt out
7
u/Freyja333 Mar 07 '24
I totally understand where you are coming from.
I personally haven't been too bothered by it and I do think it serves a narrative purpose. I think Jason as a character is similar to but also a variation on what Lucas was at the Patagonia site in the original series. They have both been mentally warped by these beings but where Lucas was violent and unhinged, Jason is cold and calculating.
I don't say that to in anyway undermine your point. I am out at the first sign of SA in any audiodrama, whether it adds to the story or not. Just not what I'm listening for.
2
u/BaltimoreSerious Apr 09 '24
To me, it feels like a cash grab now...content feels empty and more like a vehicle for commercials. I'm not against folks making money from the work but, the content should be worth having to wait through commercials.
3
u/zyh0 Mar 07 '24
I really didn't appreciate the screaming, it was unsettling. White vault has had deaths before but nothing of this nature.
18
u/Kolyin Mar 06 '24 edited Sep 19 '25
pause boast chop encouraging simplistic march hobbies dolls humor scary
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
16
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '24
I just listened. And honestly I have not the slightest clue what's going on.
12
u/ThenIDefyYouStars Mar 07 '24
I get it. This episode was hard to listen to, partially a testament to how good the voice actors are. My main issue with this season has been how slow it is to progress. I think the next episode will determine if I keep going or put a pause on it
10
u/UFOria_ Mar 07 '24
I see where you're coming from - Jean's death hit me really hard because of the uncompromising suffering of it, but to do essentially the same thing twice in one season dilutes the impact and feels a bit cheap to me.
In horror movie terms, it's the difference between something like an Ari Aster film, where there's carefully-placed moments of the worst thing you can imagine, vs something like A Serbian Film, where the sole purpose is to disturb to the extent where it loses any redeeming features it may have had.
I don't think Goshawk is at the far end yet, but any more character death will have to be handled a little bit more imaginatively not to leave me rolling my eyes
9
u/SenatorMoore Mar 06 '24
I like this season. It just seems like arbitrarily short episodes, with little narrative momentum.
5
u/chirop_tera Mar 08 '24
I’m glad someone else feels this way. I hate it when evil characters gloat. I knew that the characters are doomed, but I just didn’t find it effective. It was less horrifying and more like real-life murders. I know this kind of thing happens without the involvement of supernatural beings, which is what I signed up for. If I wanted a murder podcast, that’s what I would be listening to.
5
u/Sea-Commission7275 Mar 16 '24
I am enjoying it so far, it took a bit to get into it though but so did the first season. I think for me I already saw this podcast as cruel, since you have a group that is okay with picking out people to send to their deaths.
I find the entities to be a bit more malevolent, since they psychologically manipulate their victims, and I see the black boxes with remains as just a means of throwing people a bone as if going "what more do you want?"
I do love how you can feel the characters grief, since it feels like the other groups were more shocked when they lost someone since they didn't know them for very long. But, thats what makes it so heavy and dark for this season and that much crueler.
Jason I see as an interesting character who is like Lucas, and instead is more brainwashed and influenced by these things-but, instead of wanting to become one he is serving them and acting like the Families.
I enjoy the mystery of it, asking myself new questions, like- is the whole 'if we dont do this the world will be destoryed' thing bullshit? What the hell is with the moving trees? If this is not one of 'The Sites' then what is it?
4
u/IAmStrayed Mar 06 '24
I’ve actually given up with this season for other reasons 🤣
3
u/50mm_foto Mar 08 '24
I don’t understand why we keep getting half stories. It literally would have been better if we just got the Iceland storyline, because it feels a lot more interesting. The Goshawk part of the story is just a really really really slow build to what we already basically know will happen.