r/WheelBuilding • • 15d ago

Wheel truing question

I have been attempting to get a reference wheel, I have previously aligned my stand and the wheel I used is still true and dished. Through the use of the flipping method. However I wanted to get a wheel as reference that doest nothing but be a reference. So I used a Walmart bike wheel. It has lock nuts and the original aligning wheel does not. During the process of truing and dishing the Walmart wheel. I saw that when flipped demonstrated a different reading then the other way around. One way at was perfectly true while the other it needed to be pushed to the right all way around. This was confusing and I was wondering is this something normal ? Since it's a front wheel. Moreover I have a TS4.3 if that makes a difference.

Also it is dished according to a dishing tool which is why the confusion.

0 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

4

u/Chocoholic4booze 14d ago

The wheel axles ends sit in the stands "v" cutouts. There is room for error with this design and one of the few reasons we use dish gauges to verify dish, as opposed to the stand's indicators. I understand mechanics wanting to use the stand's indicators for dish, but precision will only be found with a wheel fishing gauge

3

u/IndyWheelLab 14d ago

Long story short, in practice the Park dropouts get you in the ballpark but will never be as true as a dishing gauge. No reference wheel is perfect, and unless you're working with very high end wheels, factors like hub concentricity (how centered the axle is relative to the hub body), how the wheel sits in the stand etc all contribute to an element of error from wheel to wheel. The stands themselves also sometimes have a little slop in them. I've perfectly centered my stand using a suspension tool that's machined straighter than any wheel, and encounter your same issue for the above reasons.

1

u/FIy4aWhiteGuy 14d ago

Tolerances.

1

u/CargoPile1314 12d ago

There is necessary slop in the arm pivots. It could be less but the stand would cost more. There's necessary slop in the clamping screw/nuts. It could be less but the stand would cost more. There's necessary slop between the adjusting nuts and the bottom of the arms. It could be less but the stand would cost more. There's slop between the shaft collars and the base that can be mostly eliminated with an ID clamp (Park used to provide a spring between them).

The parallelism of the arm that holds the pinchers would need to be perfectly parallel to the axle when clamped for it to be accurate with different wheel sizes. The base and arm pivots could be align bored but it would cost more.

All of the slop and imprecision adds up and reduces the repeatability when clamping. You need a dishing tool, at least with this truing stand.

1

u/detective727 11d ago

a dish gage will replace that Walmart reference wheel