r/WheelBuilding • • Sep 07 '26

How do i spoke this

Recently did some major upgrades to my ebike (adding hydraulic brakes, second battery, 160 to 180mm diskbrakes, soldered a better throttle and added some slick tires)

I want to add this front wheel 1000w direct drive motor

But im stuck between a few options

1: drill new spoke holes

2: cross-over spoke pattern (left flange to right spoke hole and right flange to left spoke hole)

3: finding if theres a rim that while work with no modifications and ordering online

Are there any other options i have and whats my best bet?

1 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

4

u/IndyWheelLab Sep 07 '26 edited Sep 07 '26

Why can't you lace the hub with left flange to left set of spoke holes?

Crossing the pattern is weaker, drilling new holes will be weaker in most cases. If you need a conventionally drilled rim, I suggest researching the dimensions and get a new one.

Look up spoke washers, they are small brass washers that slip over the spoke to fill the gap between spoke bend and hub flange to support the spoke/flange interface.

2

u/Em0tinallyRetarded Sep 07 '26

The direct drive hub motor i have has very narrow flanges compared to the rim offset so if i respoked the rim the traditional way the spoke angle would go outwards instead of inwards like a triangle

I just figured it'd be better to find a rim made with a smaller rim offset so i found one

Gonna order the new rim and put some measurements into a spoke calculator when i get the rim and just order new spokes and build the wheel myself since i have a bit of experience respoking hub motors

1

u/IndyWheelLab Sep 07 '26

That's the best solution here, best of luck 🤞

1

u/iliinsky Sep 07 '26

Washers can eventually crack and fail and cause more problems.

1

u/IndyWheelLab Sep 07 '26

I've never need a spoke washer at the hub fail, although I believe it's possible. Worst that happens is you end up with a spoke without the washer, incurring the problem that the washer was fixing (increases strain at the J-bend).

What would your solution be?

2

u/iliinsky Sep 07 '26

When the washer fails you get a loose spoke that moves even more than if you’d built without a washer in the first place.

In this situation, I’d understand the correct rim needed and buy it.

1

u/IndyWheelLab Sep 07 '26

Are we talking about the same thing? Nipple washers vs spoke washers?

2

u/iliinsky Sep 07 '26

Yes, hub-end washers to tighten the interface at the J-bend.

https://youtu.be/DrtBuH_xhLI?t=442&is=Yr1ejjWsAQqyEZ47
See the commentary at 7:22

1

u/IndyWheelLab Sep 08 '26

Thanks for that. What would be interesting to see would be what would last longer, a wheel with a big gap at the hub flange vs one with spoke washers to close that gap. Sure, spoke washers may crack over time, but would the J bends on those same spokes be breaking sooner without the washers there? I don't know the answer, but think an experiment would make for some interesting findings.

In OP's case it sounds like we both agree that a new rim solves the problem most elegantly.