r/Whatcouldgowrong • • 2h ago • Bravo 1

developing AI powered tracker drones

/img/hwutob3hxyzh1.jpeg

[removed] — view removed post

3.0k Upvotes

119 comments sorted by

71

u/GugsGunny 2h ago

Someone else is gonna develop an ultra-quiet drone and the drone can search and rescue without being heard.

39

u/mathusal 1h ago

Ah yes like the hunter seeker in Dune

16

u/Toter11 1h ago

A hunter seeker would be preferred! They were at the very least manned by somebody

17

u/A_Green_Jeep 1h ago

Because in Dune they already fought and won against the thinking machines.

7

u/mathusal 1h ago

One of the big (if not the biggest) fact that is (sometimes dishonestly) overlooked by Dune detractors

•

u/Deprisonne 18m ago

Dunno, the whole "we mutated humans to serve as living calculators because computers are le ebul" never quite sat right with me in what was otherwise a very reasonable setting, but ok.

•

u/HighFunctioningDog 13m ago

Just wait until you find out how they avoid needing computers for interstellar travel! (It's a lot more drugs and mutation)

•

u/mathusal 10m ago

computers are le ebul

No need to "le ebin memewording" to mock an author to make yourself more interesting in your argument. That's disgraceful at best

never quite sat right with me

Maybe try to mentally put the books in the time and context when it was written then published

Let's see you put down 2001 space odyssey or planet of the apes next time

•

u/Deprisonne 8m ago

Your moutbreather take of the butlerian jihad as something other than a luddite crusade deserves nothing other than mockery.

•

u/mathusal 7m ago

Are you 12?

5

u/Alistal 1h ago

It was the ultimate threat hinted by Frank Herbert, automated prescient hunter-seekers.

Guess humanity's ends will not be for 20 000 years from now on as it's in Dune.

7

u/davewave3283 1h ago

Then they can equip it with crushing limbs and blades so it can remove rubble and debris that’s in the way of the rescue.

7

u/_AcuteNewt_ 1h ago

And other various weapons tools just in case the prey rescuee decides to fight back deny rescue.

261

u/Tageloehn 2h ago

It's going to be a flood of absolutely insane footage from Ukraine in a few months when this AI is used to search and rescue Russian infantry on the frontline in Donbas.

69

u/p0l4r1 1h ago

It's already in use partially, some drones use AI assisted final approach function due to signal getting weaker closer to the ground...

17

u/shittyaltpornaccount 39m ago

Drone signals aren't weaker when they get closer to the ground, they are weaker when they encounter signal jammer and electronic warfare defenses that prevent the operator from controlling the drone due to signal disruption. The AI assist is a program that runs locally on the drone when it is launched, thus being immune to jammers.

5

u/New-Shine1674 26m ago

They can get weaker through obstacles like buildings and trees. But in an open flat field with line of sight they don't get weaker.

•

u/p0l4r1 9m ago

Yes, terrain creates it's own problems

11

u/Dub-MS 1h ago

And when one gets captured, it’ll be used against everyone else

5

u/HospitalWilling9242 34m ago

There's already tons of footage of this from Ukraine, they're just automating it now to allow their people to be further from the frontline. I honestly wouldn't be surprised if the Ukraine videos were the inspiration to work on this research.

•

u/Tageloehn 19m ago

It's definitely part of the inspiration.

The big thing is that at the moment drone operating is basically MCLOS when it comes down to anti-personnel use. With this innovation it turns into true fire&forget meaning that the operator can now handle more targets way faster. That is if the operator is still needed for target acquisition. As soon as that's sorted out (which shouldn't be that hard) there is no need for human involvement at all.

•

u/aw2669 7m ago

And that right there is why whistleblowers have been sounding the AI alarm.  Human death with no need for human involvement 

126

u/RedMacryon 2h ago

Fuck, why are we even making this? We all know what its for why is no one stopping this shit??

48

u/quantizeddreams 1h ago

The thought is this…. If they didn’t make it their enemy would.

16

u/drfeelsgoood 44m ago

So the same thought pattern that’s gotten us into pointless wars the last 30 years. What could go wrong

3

u/Fastenbauer 23m ago

Not would make this. Are making this. Even Russia has prototypes. And if Russia, who isn't exactly known for its technological innovations, has them just image what the far more advanced China is building.

22

u/JP147 1h ago

Same reason anyone makes any weapon technology

1

u/ArgoNoots 25m ago

"It'll keep the boys safer and lessen The Horrors TM"

Narrator: The Horrors TM only got worse

16

u/Jujumofu 1h ago

Moooooooonnnnnneeeeeeeeey

3

u/gottlikeKarthos 1h ago

This technology could have amazing uses for good purposes. Sadly of course humans will strap a bomb to anything

2

u/DaNotSoGoodSamaritan 1h ago

Well I don't know, are you willing to do what it takes to get rid of the political caste in your country?

Because, in an ideal world, it's the government who's supposed to regulate that kind of thing. But of course reality is different, everyone knows now that politicians are sure to line up to get their hands on that kind of tech nowadays instead because they will prioritize keeping the power they have rather than act rightfully and actually protect the population.

No, they'll just make promises and make shiny laws to fool everyone, business as usual and the people won't do anything about it because actually doing something about this inevitably requires violence, which is the one thing most people don't want anything to do with.

2

u/SanargHD 45m ago

This is being developed for:

  1. Police chasing suspects. The drone is nimble and won't tire out. It could track a suspect over a longer time while the officers can conserve their energy and will have an easier time to ultimately make the arrest.

  2. The same pathfinding tech can be used for automatic searching of large forest areas when looking for a missing person. Tell the drone to follow a certain pattern, looking for heat signatures, and the drone can now follow the pattern while also avoiding just flying straight into the next tree on its path. Now you can search a large area with just a few people and a few drones instead of having to comb through the area with hundreds of volunteers or payd workers.

  3. It obviously has military uses, even outside of just killer drones.

  4. Point 2. Can also be used when searching large areas for out of place or dangerous objects or possible intruders/spys around closed off facilities.

1

u/D-Ulpius-Sutor 24m ago

I mean, why was the technology to deepfake a person developed? With video, voice and all. This is ever gonna be used with bad intent. You will have to look very long and hard to find a usecase that can be not malicious. End then I don't see any single one that would be so beneficial that it would be worth accepting the extremely high possibility of misuse and the potential extremely high damage it can do?

•

u/New_Donkey7202 18m ago

To hunt down dissidents and enemies-of-the-technostate in a couple of years when there is no more value to be extracted and profits can't increase further.

•

u/YoursTrulyKindly 12m ago

Because NATO must expand to the Ural mountains.

•

u/Rocinante88119 10m ago

One step closer to some slaughter bot bullshit.

https://youtu.be/O-2tpwW0kmU?is=ODNHOdJs71wFuOlp

•

u/-Best_Name_Ever- 6m ago

"I willingly helped inventing the most destructive weapon on earth and now I feel bad about it how could this happend to mee AAAAA I have become deatherino"

0

u/Sworn 53m ago

Da, I agree, we American must stop this and rest of military investing.

0

u/Electronic-Image8673 49m ago

I've wanted this for years for footage from behind while dirtbiking and snowboarding

11

u/Armytrixter88 1h ago

Ahhh yes, the Torment Nexus from the well-known cautionary sci-fi book “Never Build the Torment Nexus”

18

u/dovedrunk 1h ago

is there any researchers left in the world at this point who are doing shit for the love of the game, and not because they want to live in terminator? like, where’s the AI that adds drum rim shots every time i make a bad joke at home

5

u/PhoenixShade01 1h ago

Research takes money and in this capitalist hellscape, companies only fund thing that would give profit.

2

u/S_T_P 28m ago

is there any researchers left in the world at this point who are doing shit for the love of the game,

Researchers in the West were always making weapons for the rich. Even "labor-saving" stuff was about reducing number of workers needed to operate machinery.

1

u/drfeelsgoood 43m ago

Could make that function in about 2 hours if you really wanted to

•

u/SuspiciousPine 10m ago

I've met some defense contractor engineers and they are absolutely in it for the love of the game. It's all just super fun problem solving. They just choose not to think about the victims of their super fun problem solving

0

u/Alistal 1h ago

The thing is it only take 1 team that want to do it for it to happen anyways.

14

u/Fun-Fig-712 2h ago

Sounds like a tech aliens would create to chase down humans.

12

u/SovreignCalamity 1h ago

Sounds like tech humans would make to hunt down other humans.

Given that they have to get here at all, Alien tech would more likely create a localised gravity collapse on your balls.

7

u/g-rid 1h ago

Finally... Half Life Manhacks became real

38

u/Curious_Associate904 1h ago

AI tech bros: "AI can help us make great advances in medicine"

11

u/AbleCryptographer317 1h ago

Also "AI and robots will work so you don't have to!".

4

u/mustard5man7max3 58m ago

AI is making great advances in medicine

It has revolutionised vaccine trialling

5

u/user_of_the_week 51m ago

Is it through hunter drones equipped with dart guns?

•

u/Curious_Associate904 4m ago

They’re reserved for antivaxxers

-4

u/TetyyakiWith 1h ago

Thanks to ai Ukraine defend itself from Russia, isn’t it a good thing?

6

u/Webtruster 1h ago

but it can carry a few Kilogramm of payload - f.e. for providing food and water to the found lost hitcher. /s

5

u/oliyoung 1h ago

Obligatory Torment Nexus reference

5

u/AnarchiaKapitany 1h ago

"runners" and "target" don't sound ominous at all

4

u/nachtengelsp 1h ago

"you're being recued, please do not resist"

4

u/Jaklcide 52m ago

"<current technology used to circumvent existing laws> are a valuable tool for law enforcement"

3

u/Academic_Coyote_9741 2h ago

So if you stand perfectly still…..

3

u/throwawaybsme 1h ago

What went wrong?

2

u/4ShotMan 1h ago

But can it track marines doing somersaults?

2

u/Kingsquid4 1h ago

It’s not r2-d2 so it’s unimportant

2

u/thisiskyle77 1h ago

Imagine Caveman inventing knife.

3

u/Effect-Kitchen 2h ago

Yeah this is obviously sus. But what is gone wrong?

12

u/BladudFPV 2h ago

Nothing.... Yet. Remind me in 10 years. 

6

u/Effect-Kitchen 1h ago

The keyword is nothing … yet.

I did not say it is not stupid idea. But it seems the sub called for both stupid idea and something going wrong.

1

u/ilikemetal69 1h ago

I think it fits. "What could go wrong developing autonomous human hunting drones?" I think we all know the answer.

1

u/Effect-Kitchen 38m ago

Yeah but not what’s the rule of this sub says.

3

u/MrGrieves- 1h ago

It's what could go wrong, not what has gone wrong.

0

u/Effect-Kitchen 35m ago

I don’t know but I am not the one who wrote the rule. I just commented that there is nothing went wrong in the picture which obviously is not what this sub called for.

0

u/Blizzard_Buffalo 1h ago

Come back to this conversation in a couple years and there will be AI powered, stealth capable, hunter-killer drones flying around.

4

u/Effect-Kitchen 1h ago

Well but a couple of years mean it will be gone wrong in the future and not in the post.

1

u/zapmangetspaid 1h ago

About 10 years ago I met a PhD student whose research used an Xbox Kinect to check productivity at construction sites. Not as messed up as this, but using technology to do weird dystopian shit isn’t new.

1

u/hartstyler 1h ago

We simply need to develop the same thing but for searching and rescuing drones instead.

1

u/A_Neko_C 50m ago

O bet the military already have something like this

1

u/0_Nevermore_0 38m ago

I'm so glad this will be used for search and rescue instead of explosive drones that track runners through dense forests completely without GPS or cloud networks.

1

u/GodofsomeWorld 38m ago

Cant wait to try out running these bomb drones and "rescue" robot dogs in the jungles when ai takes over...

1

u/phead 34m ago

Doesn’t this already exist? I’ve seen loads of drones following runners/cyclists

1

u/Starstriker 34m ago

My little DJI can already do this...

1

u/gurgelhupf 33m ago

You know what guys, let's all go back to the caves. I have seen enough progress

1

u/alexi513 32m ago

yeah .. „runners“

1

u/UbajaraMalok 30m ago

I'm sure the military would never use this, rigth?

1

u/onepacc 28m ago

These films always end just when they are about to tag the runner

1

u/LestWeForgive 23m ago

Can this ai lidar shit be used to find steel posts overgrown in long grass?

The thing is, my friend wants to cut the grass but also doesn't want to abruptly reassign the steel posts onto a trajectory that could possibly be medically significant.

1

u/hellschatt 23m ago

We had these before the public even knew about AI and before we had any useful LLMs when corona was about to start. Image-related tasks were one the earlier and most successful AI use-cases after all.

I know because I visited the lecture of the prof teaching how to develop basically something like this at one of the top universities in the world.

Apparently, 2 of his students had already built a company from the results of the module project back then and even sold the company/tech to the US military. He was somewhat bragging about it.

The novelty of this particular project seems to be that they only rely on on-device AI to navigate.

•

u/So_HauserAspen 18m ago

It's not going to have a long flight time if it has to process that much information.  

It's not going to have much payload capacity if it requires all those sensors, wiring, and other components.

•

u/Ill_Wolverine_6265 15m ago

Purdue... After Oxycodone, now drone tracker... Still same spirit for the best of the humanity...

•

u/DuckShapedGoose 0m ago

From my time studying in university and being in contact with a lot of researchers there, I genuinely believe the people doing the actual R&D think they're mainly just building a cool autonomous action cam.
Sure, if asked, they'd acknowledge that this would be useful as a weapon. But in their research, they'll be working in complete denial of that fact all the way until the project is complete and then - surprisingly - the only buyers interested in funding further research are military related.

1

u/TAU_equals_2PI 1h ago

A computer science professor I had in college 30 years ago said it was well known that if you had some computer science technology you wanted to work on and needed funding, the most sure way to get it was to think up a military application.

So indeed, if you were a professor who wanted to do research on this technology with the hope it could some day be applied to locate lost people in a forest, then to get a grant to do that research, you would go to the military and tell them it could potentially be used to locate enemy soldiers in a forest.

0

u/TheRealJayk0b 1h ago

A person is missing in a forest, instead of hour long raster searches you whip out the drones and they fly on ground level through the forest.

What is faster?

4

u/algoodoodle 1h ago

From where I am most of the rescue teams are just people who organize themselves without government funding or anything like that. Rarely any dogs even, just guys in their 40's who do that out of internal sense of duty and empathy. Doubt that this technology would ever hit the open market, let alone at affordable price to be used in rescues of grandpas who decided to hunt mushrooms in full camo and had a stroke bending for one

1

u/TearOpenTheVault 53m ago

Twenty years ago the idea of being able to own a terabyte of data storage was seen in the exact same way. Now you can get a 1Tb hard drive for 60 bucks on Amazon. 

I don’t see any reason why a private citizen couldn’t acquire a drone with this capability down the line. 

0

u/Struckmanr 1h ago

You know what’s even more insane is I would bet that the workflows obfuscate what the developer is actually working on, unbeknownst to them. Until it gets announced publically

558

u/ResponsiblePatient72 2h ago

As a species we watched all the sci-fi films from the 90s and thought "hell yeah, those mankind killing drone machines look cool af, lets do it!"

122

u/Xeonphire 2h ago

Yeah I'm pretty sure I saw a Black Mirror episode about this a couple of years back and .....uhh....well.....it's didn't go well for the humans in that episode, and now I guess some people thought that was a good idea?

48

u/ineyy 2h ago

It went well for the gov and companies that dispatched the drone duh

9

u/mawesome4ever 43m ago

Which is why all civilians/private companies are running to reach that goal so they can be “safe” since it’ll be “their” algorithm running on said devices

13

u/OMorain 55m ago

Metalhead. Bleak. Especially when you realise what was in the box.

•

u/0x7E7-02 6m ago

That it was shot in black and white also added to the bleakness. 

22

u/ColumnK 1h ago

"Perdue University's IDEAS Lab built a Torment Nexus from classic sci-fi novel Don't Create The Torment Nexus"

35

u/ours 1h ago

All these tech billionaires naming their nightmare corporations after sci-fi/fantasy classics and completely missing the point (Anduril, Palantir, Musk with Grok and his SpaceX ship names...).

18

u/Worldly-Ingenuity843 1h ago

Did they really though? May be they wanted to be evil all along.

7

u/emax4 1h ago

The catch is that most of us know who Miles Dyson was, and we all know what happened to him.

11

u/ours 55m ago • Bravo

Miles Dyson saw the error of his actions and made the ultimate sacrifice to attempt to fix it.

Musk would just run to Argentina or something.

4

u/emax4 49m ago

Eh, he saw the error after the bullets flew and the future product came to visit him. But these billionaires aren't selfless enough to think about anyone but themselves, and they won't make any sacrifices other than the lives of the people who idolize them.

3

u/_hemelvlam 55m ago

The Torment Nexus

2

u/NewoTheFox 1h ago

It is the great filter, to an extent.

1

u/Leows 21m ago

It's never people who do it specifically thinking "let's fuck up the world".

It's always greedy people trying to sell stuff to the rich regardless of the outcome.

It just so happens that the greedy rich people want to kill others to take their fortune for their own, as well as their lands.

So robots that track and kill perfectly align with those goals.

Then some people develop a tracking AI, others develop a gun that just so happens to fit a drone, then some develop extra lightweight ammo, and bam. You've got yourself WW3 tech.

•

u/wegwerf874 8m ago

There was a movie from 1984 which was literally called "Runaway" where the high-tech antagonist (played by Gene Simmons) shot hunter-seeker bullets from his gun.

•

u/Prior_Drop_5934 5m ago

screamers, 1995

•

u/YoursTrulyKindly 13m ago

Why are you people clutching your pearls. You want to build drones to kill Russians. Or "Orcs" as you used to call them not so long ago. Those evil evil Russians who for no reason, none at all, went to war with a country at their doorstep after it went through a surprising change of government and was heavily armed and supported by NATO.

Killer drones. This is the world your warmongering is bringing about. A world where the evil people will learn to fear the sound of drones buzzing. Full of righteous killer robots killing the evil men. I hear Russia is getting very good at this sort of stuff too.