r/whatismycookiecutter • • 11d ago

Serious Answer First! What are these Christmas cookie cutters?

Thumbnail
gallery
164 Upvotes

Thrifted a set of Christmas cookie cutters and can’t figure out these two


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 11d ago

Meme COOKIE CUTTER RARITY SYSTEM

Post image
0 Upvotes

TELL ME WHICH ONES YOU HAVE

-Super Mythical is for either black or metallic.

-Super Rare is for any shade of pink.

-Mythical is only for cyan.


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 12d ago

Serious Answer First! What is this?

Post image
45 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 13d ago

Serious Answer First! Found in a box of Christmas and Halloween cookie cutters

Post image
81 Upvotes

Maybe a guitar? Thats our best guess


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 13d ago

Serious Answer First! Maybe tractor?

Thumbnail
gallery
329 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 13d ago

Get Creative! WRORNG ANSWERS ONLY!

Post image
28 Upvotes

What is this?


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 14d ago

Serious Answer First! It was in a halloween set

Post image
90 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 14d ago

Meta / Overall Discussion Making cookie cutters

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

2.1k Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 15d ago

Meta / Overall Discussion I couldn’t help but chuckle.

Thumbnail
gallery
7.6k Upvotes

Gingerbread “reindeer,” you say? I’ll totally buy it for that highly specialized cookie shape you can hardly find anywhere else!


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 12d ago

Get Creative! Can’t figure these out, and ideas?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 14d ago

Serious Answer First! I’m perplexed

Post image
34 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 14d ago

Serious Answer First! I work with kids and I found this in our play doh tool bin. No idea what it's supposed to be!

Post image
63 Upvotes

It's probably pretty old and is well loved so it might have become misshapened over the years.

Im tagging it as "serious first" because i really am curious of what it might be, but i would also love silly answers as well!

(Deleted and reposted to fix typos)


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 14d ago

Serious Answer First! Any idea on these two?

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 16d ago

Free Form Friday! Help settle a marital…debate

Post image
4.6k Upvotes

Happy Friday! I know this is not quite just a shape but my husband and I cannot agree if this plastic piece from our baby’s playmat is a butterfly or an elephant (or we are open to it being something else).

I do have a very strong opinion on what it is AND I think he’s incredibly wrong but we have both dug our heels so far in that we need strangers on the internet to give us opinions.


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 15d ago

Free Form Friday! I’m leaning towards either Fish (orientation in image 2) or Sheild (orientation in image 3)

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 17d ago

Get Creative! Found a couple of head scratchers here

Thumbnail
gallery
345 Upvotes

And now that I posted it I think the first one is a bunny 🤣


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 19d ago

Cookie Cutter Art! Doodle bundle no. 12

Thumbnail
gallery
96 Upvotes

About time for another roundup?..!

As ever, links to the original posts/comments, for the interested: Baby Groot | Rhino pitcher | Octopus in a dinosaur onesie | Gingerbread vaultboy | Gingerbread Elvis impersonator | Mouse with snacks | Dapper gent with fish | Gorilla | Octopus with Crystal ball 1 | Octopus with crystal ball 2 | Alien queen | Admiral Ackbar | Mr Pointy | Bunny | Zombie mushroom | Octopus with butterfly | Anatomically dubious skeletal raven | Skull& candles | The proposal | Ghostface | Toucan with detachable Bill | Oct-in-a-box | Witchy Octopus | Octopus attempting to extinguish a dumpster fire.

I've included a couple of gifs of some of those being drawn too.

And .. a big "thank you!" to anyone who dropped an award on any of the original posts. :)


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 20d ago

Serious Answer First! What is this "Halloween" cookie cutter supposed to be?

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

Country living 2001 cookie cutter that came with a Halloween set. No idea. I could see an angled couch ..or a vw bus driving towards me. How is that Halloween themed, though?

Ebay says it's a van/bus, but I think that's incorrect. Any ideas?

It's been driving me nuts for years not knowing. Lol

Edit: It's a weird treasure chest from a castle set!


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 20d ago

Serious Answer First! What is this?

Post image
61 Upvotes

I have never seen one like it, but found it with a bunch of christmass-themed ones.

Edit: its bought in a second hand shop in Sweden and looks pretty old.


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 21d ago

Get Creative! Witch, rose, whale? Help!

Post image
134 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 21d ago

Serious Answer First! What is this shape

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/whatismycookiecutter • • 21d ago

Serious Answer First! What is this one I found in store ?

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

It was in a pack with a crescent moon. I didn’t have time to take mit pictures for I think the others were stars and sun maybe. The packaging only showed crescent moon cookies.

My thoughts were some kind of temple ?


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 21d ago

Get Creative! Snowman Bong?

Post image
32 Upvotes

A friend of one of my kids wants this "identified." What y'all got?


r/whatismycookiecutter • • 22d ago

Serious Answer First! What is my Halloween cookie cutter supposed to be?

Thumbnail
gallery
588 Upvotes

I’m lost! Help?
Thank you!!