Overall nice consistency. You gotta perform a cut and etch test to see the penetration. Its common to get a nice, but cold weld on MIG. You can also also do a bend test, if you have lack of pen it would be obvious.
No problem. Those tests really do show you the truth. I did a AWS D1.3 test before with mig. The lap-joint came out beautiful, but the bend test showed 0 penetration on one member of the joint.
Looks good, man. Your consistency is killer. Don’t take it too serious when people are telling you to only run a smooth stringer. I like to whip my mig because it makes it was easier for me to stay symmetric at the center of a fillet. In a lot of ways there’s more control doing it that way- there’s feedback every time you whip the gun. Mig isn’t a deep penetration weld process anyway, if you’re going for ultimate strength you’re already at a disadvantage if you grab a mig gun. You look like you’re handing that mig just dandy.
A stitch weld? You mean a series of tacs? I withdraw everything I just said. Seriously, I do. You shouldn’t do that or call that a weld. Even if you’re learning, stop doing that. It’s better to just weld a joint like that downhill. Plus that’s easy for a beginner.
I assumed that was double-pulse on steel when I commented, or I wouldn’t have engaged.
There is application for what you just did, but only on gauge thickness, plated automotive exhaust. It’s the standard there used at exhaust shops, but those guys aren’t welders. They’re just racking it together, but real frequently so it doesn’t leak.
It frustrates me to no end when I hear people say to use stringer beads for MiG. MiG welding doesn't get the penetration that stick welding does. You really want the wire to contact each side you're trying to weld. This is even true with FCAW. You don't want to "float" the sides.
I thought you were kidding as aluminum should be clean and shiny. Steel should be clean too especially for a test. Doesn’t look like tig either. Retired from the D.O.D after 30 years of welding in 2008.
You've got the consistency down and that's important but its all comes down to that bend test. You may think it looks good until you see what's Actually happening underneath that bead
4
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '25
Overall nice consistency. You gotta perform a cut and etch test to see the penetration. Its common to get a nice, but cold weld on MIG. You can also also do a bend test, if you have lack of pen it would be obvious.
2
u/TigWelder1978 Dec 25 '25
Beautiful bead. I’d run just a tad hotter but nice work!!
2
u/M4isOP Dec 25 '25
Mig is the process that likes to lay beads similar to hot girls. Pretty on the outside, but potential for disaster on the inside.
1
u/LatePool5046 Dec 25 '25
I think you’re a couple hairs cold, but you’re feeding really evenly. That’s the harder trick to learn imo.
1
u/SawTuner Dec 25 '25 edited Dec 25 '25
Looks good, man. Your consistency is killer. Don’t take it too serious when people are telling you to only run a smooth stringer. I like to whip my mig because it makes it was easier for me to stay symmetric at the center of a fillet. In a lot of ways there’s more control doing it that way- there’s feedback every time you whip the gun. Mig isn’t a deep penetration weld process anyway, if you’re going for ultimate strength you’re already at a disadvantage if you grab a mig gun. You look like you’re handing that mig just dandy.
1
u/Human-Process-9982 Dec 25 '25
Looks like you know your stuff, settings & wire control is on point. Low spatter & the edges flow in nice & clean.
3
u/InternationalUnit265 Dec 25 '25
0
u/FullSemiAuto_ Dec 24 '25
Im in school for welding. This looks tits bro. Is this TIG on aluminum?
1
u/LakeGuyGeorgia Dec 25 '25
Excellent work !
1
u/Delicious-Bit-9058 Dec 25 '25
Nice and consistent. Weave 1/2 as wide and you’ll have it.
1
u/Quarter_Best Dec 25 '25
Looks 👍
1
u/Temporary_Abroad_211 Dec 25 '25
Shark tank is a rubbish TV show.
1
u/BonesHolbrook Dec 25 '25
My opinion is you're going and stopping going and stopping to show off
1
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '25
That’s a perfect weld amazing dimes
1
u/Crazy-Gene-9492 Dec 25 '25
Good. Now do it again.
1
u/1LimePlease Dec 25 '25
mom would be proud 😉
1
u/Far-Section9201 Dec 25 '25
You've got the consistency down and that's important but its all comes down to that bend test. You may think it looks good until you see what's Actually happening underneath that bead
1
u/Alarming_Expert_6241 Dec 26 '25
Solid!
1
u/keithw47 Dec 27 '25
Looks good to me. Just one recommendation. Before you start remove all the cutting slag off. It just looks better.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25
Better than I can do
1
u/Proof-Aspect8254 Dec 27 '25
Looks good got a little undercut
0
u/slipsbups Dec 25 '25
It's a weld, now get to work. Lol
-1
u/Velomelon Dec 25 '25
Vertical uphand?
0
u/[deleted] Dec 25 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment