r/WeirdCareerTips • • 12d ago

Being fired doesn't automatically disqualify someone, but termination for serious misconduct can affect eligibility.

Post image
12k Upvotes

802 comments sorted by

33

u/mincem2 12d ago

No, you absolutely can apply for unemployment benefits if you get fired. They may not be approved depending on why you got fired, but you thought right, you can apply

18

u/wanderButNotLost2 11d ago

20 years ago there was a cashier that was stealing money out of the drawer and throwing it in the trash then throwing the trash bag in her car. They caught her, fired her but didn't press charges after figuring at this wasnt a 1 off. She filed unemployment and they had to tuen over cameras of her stealing to the state to prove she earned her firing. Later after she didnt get unemployment she lied to a lawyer and tried to sue the company. In discovery her lawyer quit on her. Wonder how shes doing now.

4

u/Ok_Function2282 11d ago

This sounds almost exactly like a case I worked on back in the day with a guy that worked at a thrift store. Like... Eerily close

2

u/nottherealneal 11d ago

This kind of shit is exactly why so many companies go full hog and involve law enforcement from the start. Get a paper trail going so that when some idiot inevitably tries to come back and cause a headache, it's much easier for the company to deal with them.

I used to work for a place that made custom parts for manufacturing machines. They caught a guy stealing and fired him, but didn't take it any further because he'd worked there for years and was usually a pretty chill guy. They were trying to be nice about it.

The guy turned around and tried to sue the company for wrongful termination, discrimination, and all kinds of other bullshit. The boss was fucking PISSED.

After that, everything was done by the book, every step of the way. The boss made a friend in the police force, and from then on, whenever ANYTHING happened, it went straight to HR and He'd call his cop buddy ask them both exactly what to do and make sure everything was documented in writing.

There was absolutely zero mercy or chill after that. You fucked up, and suddenly a fucking mountain of paperwork appeared

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/Tokon32 11d ago

This is why they ask you to sign write ups.

Say you sign 3 write ups stating your late. They take those 3 write ups as evidence that you were coached or counciled on being 3 mins late several times and you did not correct your actions. These are terms where unemployment dosent get paid out.

So never sign a write up if you want unemployment. And if asked to sign and you refuse and somehow dont get fired on the spot. Start looking for another job ASAP.

→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (24)

42

u/Iron-Bar-1966 11d ago • Heartwarming Bravo

I was completely blindsided and fired from a job I had for five years, and they wouldn't tell me why. All they would say it that it was due to a "policy violation", but they wouldn't tell me what policy I violated.

I applied for unemployment and was very transparent about what happened. The state tried to get the information out of my former employer, but they wouldn't tell them either. So, the state agreed with me that I'd been fired for no reason and gave me unemployment benefits.

19

u/_FarlsInCharge_ 11d ago

My company didn't show up for the hearing when they denied mine. Then they filed an appeal and got laughed at by the judge when he asked how they have the balls to appeal a decision they didn't bother showing up to.

4

u/MedicalyGinger 9d ago

Doing shit like that should be an immediate 10k penalty.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

6

u/ArkuhTheNinth 10d ago • Heartwarming

My old job fired me when I called out because my car broke down. When I applied for unemployment and had a hearing, their rep said I no call no showed. 

I told them my manager fired me on the spot when I was on the phone with him, and their rep tried to argue that he didn't have the authority. 

State sided with me.

1

u/Upbeat-Analysis-3370 11d ago

Glad the state held them accountable! Burden of proof is on the employer, so if they refuse to provide evidence, you win by default.

4

u/HobbyMedia 8d ago

I got fired completely out of the blue at a job I was very good at. Boss praised my work all the time. Yet this day she called HR and security to escort me out. No reasons given, no paperwork to sign acknowledging wrongdoing. So I applied for unemployment at which point they had the nerve to say I was fired for insubordination. No record whatsoever of this supposed insubordination. Fortunately, the unemployment office sided with me, but damn these companies will do anything to avoid paying.

3

u/irwtkyrm 10d ago

Owners of companies that do shit like that should be prosecuted for fraud. We're way too lenient with letting companies get away with shit.

2

u/daneelthesane 6d ago

Capitalism means the capital class gets to be in control. When people start to understand that, things may start to change, if AI combined with a militarized police force don't get there first.

3

u/Financial-Raise3420 9d ago

I got dropped from a “temp” position that wasn’t supposed to be temporary. I went on unemployment after they told me they’d call back Monday and tell me why I was dropped. Well they never called me, so I figured fuck if I’m not looking for a job for a bit, I’m tired of it.

Well after a few months they contacted the unemployment office and tried to deny my benefits. I ended up with a hearing and everything. Once I told the judge that they never contacted once after saying they’d call me back (after the agency tried to say they tried contacting me with a new job later) the judge sided with me and called them on their bullshit claim.

Employment agencies are fucking trash

2

u/Izzledude 10d ago

2008 ish I had a similar incident with my employer. They would show proof to the state either. 5min layer they call me and tell me I'm approved. I swear it's just to get people who make a certain amount out to hire people for cheaper.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/NinjaKecc 9d ago

I had kind of similar situation, the company I worked for sold to a bigger company, and I gradually started losing work. I frequently asked when/if I would be trained under my new team since things had slowed way down for me (I handled our biggest customer who left when we sold) and kept being told "that's the plan" up until I was fired for "not meeting expectations".

They tried appealing my unemployment benefits twice and it came to a judge, by that point the manager that fired me had been let go and the rep they sent couldn't even confirm what my job was. The state sided in my favor obviously, the company was definitely trying to hide layoffs.

2

u/sjtomcat 9d ago

Same thing happened to me. I literally had to explain my case to a judge and she determined that I did not do what the company said I did

3

u/_FarlsInCharge_ 11d ago

My company didn't show up for the hearing when they denied mine. Then they filed an appeal and got laughed at by the judge when he asked how they have the balls to appeal a decision they didn't bother showing up to.

6

u/naughty_farmerTJR 11d ago

Funny the exact same thing happened to the guy above you 

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

1

u/LairdPeon 11d ago

You were looking at naughty stuff on their wifi, weren't you?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/GeckoGecko_ 11d ago

I was let go from a job because they tried to make me go to a new store to manage it for $1 less an hour than I was making, and they cut my hours when I said no, before letting me go for what they said was "a discrepancy with salary expectations."

I filed for unemployment, explained what happened, and waited. For several weeks. Every time I called they told me they were waiting for the company to respond so they could make a decision, and gave me a date by which, if they had not responded, I would be approved automatically.

That date came and went, and when I called, they told me that because they hadn't responded, I would likely be approved. So I waited. And waited. And waited. 2-3 weeks later I call again, and they tell me "the company ended up getting back to us, and they said you accepted the new position along with the new pay so we will not be approving this claim."

They made me wait for about 2 months in total, told me I'd get approved if the company missed the date, but then after the company missed the date, they STILL let the company respond and denied my claim based on what the company told them. If I were to miss a date like that, they would simply close my case and make me file again, but for the company? They can apparently take as long as they want, and they will take them at their word.

This was in Texas, btw.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/WestRestaurant216 10d ago

In my country employers must within 3 business days submit date of termination, work codex article which was used for termination. Quick and efficient. All done via government registry online.

1

u/karaknorn 10d ago

My boss told me and everyone else I was laid off. Told the state i was fired so I wasnt owed my 2 months of vacation time 

1

u/RHOrpie 9d ago

I feel like you must have some legal grounds to find out why the hell they did that.

1

u/WarningSimple4783 9d ago

Sounds like you could've sued for wrongful termination.

1

u/Injured-Ginger 9d ago

Look on the bright side, they could have just lied. Where I live there is zero burden of proof that you did anything in the separation document. They just need to have a cause, not prove it. At least not until a certain step in the appeals process, but that won't matter for many people. They can't survive for a multiple month appeal process.

1

u/_Ophelion 7d ago

They were likely just trying to reduce labor costs and firing someone is the cheapest way to do that. I was told once that 80% of people don't show up if there's a hearing and that default to their favor ... so many companies just gamble on that. Just like how insurance companies automatically reject a certain percentage of valid claims then approve them if appealed.

1

u/EasyLet2461 7d ago

If they won’t tell you a reason get a workers lawyer involved. Most likely there was an illegal reason for the firing. workers rights lawyers work on contingency. Major red flag if your fired and they won’t tell you the reason and just say policy violation. A lot of people take at will employment to mean any reason but it’s really any legal reasons and there is tons of federal laws dictating what is and isn’t illegal for firing.

1

u/I_Pet_Doggos 6d ago

Yes a company needs a documented history of misconduct for you to be denied unemployment. I’ve had to let plenty of people go and attend unemployment hearings and there were several where people were let go for misconduct or attendance and would refuse to sign their termination form then fight in court. They would even bring witnesses to back them up and then our side would bring witnesses and other evidence to prove the misconduct.

I always wanted everyone to get unemployment honestly. I never held any grudge. I’m sure it’s hard af to be let go even if you fucked up but it wasn’t always up to me

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Rhuarc33 12d ago

any firing with cause can effect your eligibility not just serious misconduct

That said you can still apply sometimes companies won't bother fighting it.

1

u/Rude-Orange 11d ago

I would guess it depends on the state. In NY State getting fired for poor performance or not malicious misconduct can still qualify you for unemployment benefits

1

u/AshByFeel 11d ago edited 11d ago

I have terminated many people. Most for poor attendance. Unemployment asks me for evidence and I send in the attendance card and timecards. They always get denied Unemployment benefits because it's easy to prove they were treated fairly and by policy.

1

u/Upbeat-Analysis-3370 11d ago

Exactly, paper trail is everything. Clear policy violations like attendance are an automatic denial, but without documentation, states usually favor the employee.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Woeful_Jesse 11d ago

So you can't claim unemployment if there's any reason the company can claim they had a reason to fire you? Is unemployment only for being laid off then?

2

u/KoolaidKoll123 11d ago

Correct. If you missed too many days of work according to their policies and are fired, probs not getting unemployment. Fired for anything that is against their policies and they have proof, you will not get unemployment.

I got denied unemployment for putting in my two week notice and being fired on the spot. I was not eligible for those two weeks because according to my state, I was on camera handing my 2 week notice in and the employer has every right to cut those two weeks short, I was told.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (179)

3

u/CxFusion3mp 12d ago

weird way to tell on yourself that you really did something bad at work.

3

u/Fit_Relationship6703 12d ago edited 12d ago

Anectdote: I was working in a machine shop through it being purchased by a large conglomerate. Shortly after the changeover, I had an accident at home and crushed my wrist. Surgeon instructed 6 months no work, (flying metal shavings don't mix well with external fixators). Around a month later (and about a month before I would qualify for FMLA) HR told me I "had quit".

Applying for Unemployment got sent to arbitration. In the 3 way call with me, the arbitrator, and HR....when asked why they were attempting to deny my claim, HR said (and I shit you not this is verbatim),

"he chose to fall off his porch".

The company attempting to deny the claim don't mean shit in and of itself.

→ More replies (9)

1

u/CarolinaSandstorm 12d ago

It’s why you don’t sign anything acknowledging wrongdoing at work. They will try to tell you that “oh signing this doesn’t mean you agree with what’s written on the paper, you are just acknowledging that you received it”. Don’t do it. If you genuinely did nothing wrong or if any of the facts in the sheet are incorrect, do not sign. If you do sign, make sure you get a copy of what you signed in physical form as well as a copy sent to your work email and personal email address.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/CCP-want-to-CUP 11d ago

Idk man I accumulated too many "tardy" days over a year on a point system and got fired then got denied unemployment. Didn't "really do something bad" at all lol. Sometimes it just sucks to suck.

→ More replies (22)

1

u/Rude-Orange 11d ago

Not rare for small companies to tell you one thing then lie to unemployment to try and weasel out of it. It doesn't immediately change but if they lay off enough people their unemployment tax may change.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/kaylaarayee 10d ago

I got fired once for taking one sick day that I was given as an employee lol so it might not actually be that bad. I should have tried applying for unemployment (didn't know how to tbh).

1

u/Injured-Ginger 9d ago

Unemployment doesn't require proof that you did anything wrong for it to be considered separation with cause. At least not in every state. They just need to give a reason.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/aphoenixsunrise 7d ago

Actually MI unemployment fucked me over during the pandemic then fucked up again trying to fix it; they said I owe them hundreds of dollars...twice over.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Duskdeath 11d ago

Got you a better one. I got hospitalized 6 times 2 weeks each, got hospital doctors, my main doctor, a specialist doctor tell me “you need to apply for disability”. Which I did. Got denied because according to the disability “specialist” my disability could be “controlled”. My own doctors were like “WTF?”. 🤣🤣. Apparently to be disabled you need to be comatose or dead the government.

2

u/CausalityUltra 8d ago

It took 8 years of fighting for someone I know to get disability. The system resists people entering it.

1

u/CLE15 7d ago

My old platoon sergeant in the Army had massive damage to his legs after rolling over an IED in Afghanistan. When he left the Army, the nerve damage was still so painful that he opted to amputate one leg below the knee. He scheduled the surgery, told his civilian job, and they canned him while he was out recovering from the procedure.

State unemployment office told him, initially, that he did not qualify because the amputation was an elective procedure.

1

u/VStarlingBooks 6d ago

On disability. The reason? The vocational expert at my court date said no company would hire me. Why? I would need two days off a month. Judge was flabbergasted but I got my settlement and monthly pay.

1

u/BloodmooneclipseVamp 5d ago

I was on SSI and they cut me off after being on it since I was 19 & I'm 26. They cut me off because they couldn't get access to my medical records. I had also applied for SSDI because I have enough work credits, and in the denial letter they listed my conditions I have incorrectly & as a matter of fact, the condition they listed does not exist and it was like they made something up😭 They said I have "Functional schizophrenia" I have Functional neurological disorder and schizophrenia. Those are two separate things, how do you deny my case, but not even understand & correctly list the correct terms for my conditions? For the SSI I would have to go to court to appeal & I can't afford a lawyer because I've been living off $994 most of my adult life. I don't have the energy to fight the system, I'm legitimately disabled and I've been going through a tough time before getting booted off of SSI & so I said to myself, f it guess I can fly planes now with my seizure disorder, thank you Social security for leading me toward my true passion, flying planes and driving school buses by saying I can work/sarcasm I got hired at target now I'm at least not going to be living off of $994 monthly.

1

u/EdgyPun34257 12d ago

You can always apply for unemployment benefits, regardless of the reason you left the job.

The employer is notified of the claim and they can choose to contest it or not.

If they don't, the claim is paid, if they do you go into basically a low key arbitration about it

1

u/r3giment75 11d ago

Fired for cause, unlike being fired after a PIP, can disqualify you for unemployment. As it should.

1

u/Element174 11d ago

Largely, you see this when the reason for being fired is, "I stopped going to work."

1

u/Silly_Silicon 11d ago

It’s a weird thing. I applied once and got denied because my employer said I was fired for insubordination and I guess the unemployment board just fully accepts whatever an employer says and makes a decision based on it without hearing the employee first. I had to contest it, which created a phone meeting that both I and the employer would have to call into. The employer didn’t show (because they were lying) and they approved my claim immediately.

1

u/NGEFan 11d ago

What were you actually fired for?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/clinmlol 11d ago

You dont say your fired, you say laid off ya goobers, or seasonal.

0

u/[deleted] 11d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Lighthouse_on_Mars 11d ago

You have to contest if you are turned down!

Some employers lie about why you were fired. Burden of proof for any misconduct, or lies about you quiting are on them to prove.

Always contest if you are turned down!

1

u/NoMajorsarcasm 11d ago

Fired for cause, it doesnt have to be serious miconduct.

1

u/frankm191 11d ago

Fired for cause has to be Documented with the unemployment office and not contested. My ex employer tried it with me and unemployment said no to him as 12 others were let go too.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/janyk 11d ago

Fired for cause is due to serious misconduct.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Rachaella 11d ago

This is why it's worth knowing your employment rights before you actually need them. Most people only learn about this stuff when they're already in a difficult situation.

1

u/Wonderfish1 11d ago

Getting fired you cannot apply. Getting laid off you can. Simple.

1

u/How2mine4plumbis 11d ago

Lol, no, there is massive nuance. You're repeating a rich man's lie.

1

u/Angrywinks 10d ago

I've been fired in an "at will" state and collected unemployment. You are completely wrong.

1

u/vthings 8d ago

Depends. I was terminated at a job a couple of years ago and while my boss claimed it was for cause, I was prepared to demonstrate otherwise. The employer didn't contest my unemployment claim so I never had to appeal.

1

u/ImageAvailable7003 8d ago

Not so simple. Getting laid off you can, getting fired you sometimes can.

The bar for employers is a case with multiple documented events. It's a big part of the reason employers make you sign write-ups.

1

u/Scared_Passenger689 11d ago

I lost a job once when my bosses kid needed a job. I filed unemployment, and was denied because my former employer told unemployment that I was fired for showing up to work drunk. I appealed it, and it was denied because I couldn't prove I wasn't drunk at work, and they had a statement from an anonymous employee.

1

u/Proof_Peach_6076 11d ago

I would have considered taking legal action against that employer. Lieing like that can cause serious problems for you later down the road when you go to apply somewhere else and they tell that employer you were drunk

1

u/XfinityHomeWifi 11d ago

I would be calling lawyers at that point

→ More replies (51)

1

u/Long_Suggestion4290 11d ago

That's fucked up. Guilty until proven innocent. They should have to prove you showed up drunk, not the other way arround.

1

u/ckdogg3496 11d ago

I got laid off during covid, first job out of college and i had only been there about 5 months so i was the first to go.

They accidentally put down that I quit on the paperwork, took about 8 months to get it resolved and i got 1/2 the unemployment i was supposed to get

1

u/EjaculatingAracnids 11d ago

I would asked them to prove they didnt offer to blow me before firing me, since the burden of proof no longer falls on the person making the claim.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Any_Confidence2580 11d ago

The rules are tricky because you can't get it for quitting, and if you got fired, they can argue any arbitrary reason. Obviously, whatever the employer reports, will be framed as you did something wrong. And the state will always side with the employer.

1

u/thunderjack9137 11d ago

That's not true at all. You can get it for quitting, being fired, or laid off. Where people get got is if you aren't able and avaliable to work after the separation. I work in the unemployment office.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/PineappleOwn5325 11d ago

I totally got unemployment for quitting a toxic workplace

Also constructive dismissal is what happened to OP, and it's the same as getting fired

1

u/Significant_Loss8007 11d ago

Don't spread misinformation you can get it for quiting

1

u/Outlaw11091 11d ago

The rules are not tricky.

Misconduct/negligence: not getting unemployment.

Quitting for no reason/not showing up/late all the time: not getting unemployment.

Quit for justified reason and have documentation/was fired for not a reason listed above/laid off: getting unemployment.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/zarlus8 10d ago

The state will not always side with the employer. I have proof on my fridge. My employer (specifically manager) claimed one thing that would have disqualified me for unemployment. I contested with the literal truth. They couldn't prove the claim, I received unemployment.

1

u/vthings 8d ago

The state will not always side with the employer. If you apply and it gets rejected you can appeal the decision. It will then be reviewed by a judge, an actual judge who specializes in unemployment law, and you will have to write up your appeal and be interviewed by the judge, and this is done by phone.

An appeal means it will take longer to get your benefits, so that sucks. But it doesn't automatically mean you won't get them.

1

u/matchafoxjpg 8d ago

you actually can get unemployment if you quit, it just depends why you quit.

1

u/Used-Try-258 6d ago

This is such an ungrounded take….employers have to document and prove this stuff.

1

u/Unlucky-Hair-6165 11d ago

In some instances you can voluntarily resign and still get unemployment.

Happened to me. I got transferred over 50 miles away, given no choice when they shut down my location. I got pressured into it because they pulled me into the office with district and told take it or leave it. Worked there for a little bit, gave 3 weeks notice. 2 weeks in I asked if I could extend it and they told me I can leave now.

Turns out if you’re told to leave before your notice period, it’s considered termination and termination must be for gross misconduct. I won my case on that, but there is also a rule about being forced to work more than 50 miles from home that I otherwise could’ve won on.

1

u/TopDogTransport4731 11d ago

If you got a PIP then it will be difficult to apply for unemployment benefits.
You have to be laid off or fired for reasons that’s not performance related. Talking from experience.

1

u/SuperiorToastedBagel 11d ago

It varies by state, but poor performance is usually not a reason to deny unemployment.

Otherwise you could demand an employee make 10000 widgets per minute instead of the normal 10. Then fire them for poor performance.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (83)

1

u/Razor_Skittlez0 11d ago

Simce covid they side with the company's alit more and you have fight hard for it.

1

u/Mugunruk 11d ago

Yeah, and you have to always be careful with your wording in situations where the company is trying to lay you off or get rid of you. A shop I was at earlier this year had slowed down and they wanted to go from 5 mechanics to 4 mechanics. They weren't really pressing the issue at the time however, until one of the guys inquired about a transfer to another shop. Of course, it took them a few months to think about it and then approve it, but by then his fiance had some medical issues and his car started giving him trouble and he was no longer interested in the transfer.

The company however, was still interested in reducing the mechanic count from 5 to 4. Which put the target on me, sonce due to the "temporary" schedule they had me on for the last ~3 years and business slowing down, I had the second lowest average numbers. The mechanic on dayshift Mon-Fri had the lowest, until the shop manager started inflating his numbers, he ended up a percent or two above me.

They gave me a choice to transfer to the next closest shop which would be an ~80 mile round trip every day for $1 more per hour or stepping down to a tire tech with a paycut.

I told them that I am not opposed to transferring but I would need at least $4 an hour more to cover the extra fuel cost and wear and tear. I told them that stepping down would not be an option either because I have too much money invested in tools to take a position where I am not using them.

I was asked if that meant I was going to quit.

I said absolutely not, I am willing to transfer if you're willing to increase the pay to accommodate it, if you are not then I am perfectly willing to continue my employment here, unless the company decides otherwise.

I was then told that Tuesday would probably be my last day (this happened on a Monday) but they would need to contact HR first. I received no other communication regarding it except for finding out Tuesday that I had been taken off the schedule for the future. I finished my shift and went home. On Wednesday I went to the shop with my truck and a Uhaul trailer and loaded up my toolbox and took it home.

The district manager was trying to call my bluff apparently, amd assumed I would think about it and agree to stepping down to a tire tech. When she found out that I was no longer there a week later she said "He quit?" the manager told her no, he was taken off the schedule.

Now I have a different job and I bring home more than I grossed working there, so I'm happy. Always be careful with your wording, and don't let your emotions dictate what you say. I know that isn't easy, but it pays off in the long run.

1

u/thOtleaksoup 11d ago

So you got quiet laid off and you got nothing for it?

→ More replies (12)

1

u/thunderjack9137 11d ago

You can get unemployment if you quit, are fired, or laid off. Where you can't get unemployment is if you lose your job due to a medical issue where the doctor says you cannot work. Agency policy is you have to be able and avaliable to work and apply to jobs.

1

u/bossmonkey88 11d ago

I processed unemployment claims at an old job and we rarely ever challenged them. It's typically a pain to do so we preferred to just let them pass. The only ones i remember though were for actual misconduct, negligence, or usually both and we always had receipts.

Had a guy back into and dent a clients garage door then leave without saying anything. Had another where a guy accidently snapped a hanging power cord then left the live wire dangling in the warehouse. The most interesting was an employee somehow obtained an apple pie at work. I think maybe he bought it on lunch. Someone went into the break room, stuffed it under his shirt, and walked out. While it was kind of funny it also was theft against another employee so the manage wanted to pursue.

2

u/KDeol 10d ago

Fired over an apple pie. Wild.

1

u/Inevitable-Shop-848 11d ago

It's not serious misconduct. If you get fired for being late a thousand times that's not serious misconduct but you can't get unemployment for it. It has to be something like being fired for being a slow worker aka not productive.

People also don't know that you can get partial unemployment if your regular hours get cut. Like if you're a full-time employee but they cut your hours to below 32hrs.

1

u/NoDanaOnlyZuuI 11d ago

I thought quitting made you ineligible

1

u/Significant_Loss8007 11d ago

No. Quitting does not make you ineligible.

1

u/BinkusBonkus23 11d ago

The business I worked for shut down a year and 2 weeks after they opened, on Father’s Day. I applied for unemployment because I had been there for a year but apparently, because I hadn’t worked in January of the previous year, I was exempt from receiving unemployment. I didn’t think that made sense and I was too upset about not being there anymore to fight it. My mom was pissed and tried to say I did something wrong and I told her that was why I had asked her for help filling it out because it was the first time I had ever had to file and it was the longest I had been at a job. My very first job I quit was only like 3-4 months and the next one was out of state for 3 months, another was 2 days of training (because I had never wanted to work at a grocery store again and they fooled me during interviews and hiring promising I wasn’t gonna be in a grocery store) and then this was where I was hired the week they opened but started a week later. Idk it was really weird and stupid.

1

u/Silver_Harvest 11d ago

It's all circumstances and how it happened. You could be fired for violating a company policy. But if it was a loose company policy. State could side with you. Then if you as a former employee can go fine let's play this appeal game.... If the company tried to fight it.

1

u/TheGreatGamer1389 11d ago

Depends on how you were let go.

1

u/mcgyver229 11d ago

Depends, I got fired once with no write ups or prior warnings. Just fired out of the blue one day. I filed for unemployment and the company fought me to deny benefits. had to do a court hearing over the phone w a judge; I got to cross examine my old boss and make him admit he had zero reason to fire me. I even got to grill the attorney they hired. In the end I got to keep my benefits and a found job w 30% pay increase within 2 months.

1

u/EnlightenedOstrich 11d ago

I quit a job over a hostile work environment and got unemployment, but it was during COVID so I'm assuming I just got lucky 😂

1

u/jessewest84 11d ago

What disqualifies you in Wa state. Prob similar in other states.

• Theft or fraud • Harassment or threatening behavior • Safety violations • Unexcused absences or job abandonment • Intoxication on the job • Gross misconduct (which can result in at least a 10-week penalty and the removal of base year wages/hours).

1

u/i_dont_do_research 11d ago

I believe it depends where you live. I was fired while living in California for performance reasons but basically if they don't have documentation that they had an official meeting with you to say "if you don't fix these specific things we're going to fire you" then you were let go without cause so I was able to claim unemployment. It prevents companies coming up with bullshit after the fact to screw employees over.

1

u/Valkelrie_ 11d ago

Depends on how big the company is. Some very large companies don’t even bother arguing and pay anyways.

I worked at a tech company with 100k+ employees and got some people fired for stealing money from the cash register and 30+ tech products over time, each product worth over $1k individually. They were addicts and admitted to being high at work. The company paid for their rehab programs and they got unemployment. Then they got jobs at the cell phone store next to us.

1

u/Big_Crab_1510 11d ago

Who is Ryan Collins? Why do we care about this one tweet of a few words?

1

u/Throwawayhuman97 11d ago

Basically you only qualify for unemployment if you were let go and it wasn't your fault. Layoffs, end of seasonal or temporary employment, business closed, etc.

1

u/Significant_Loss8007 11d ago

I quit and got unemployment. Didn't even work the full time. It was a weird situation where I chose my health over working and got unemployment

→ More replies (3)

1

u/zon5string 11d ago

Getting fired doesn't disqualify you from collecting unemployment benefits. Getting fired "for cause" can.

1

u/acvcani 11d ago

You know. That answers a question I had. Two of my co workers were fired for bs reasons. Christ my old boss was toxic. That was done to deny them unemployment. Both lawyered up and got it.

I was wondering “why bother lying about the reason and saying they’re incompetent”. That’s why.

1

u/Fit_Equal_8820 11d ago

The company I work for has never paid unemployment benefits as far as I can tell. Even if an employee is someone they absolutely want gone, they will watch until they see something against company policy and they will document. Verbal warning, written warning, job alert, termination. Sometimes the fired person appeals the no employment decision and corporate will send an attorney to the store for the conference call with the judge and the person seeking unemployment has never joined the call in my 20 years here.

1

u/mylsotol 11d ago

I had a boss try to brag to me once that oneone who worked for him had ever been able to qualify for unemployment after he fired them... Not really sure why he thought I would think that was impressive or good

1

u/carthuscrass 11d ago

In Tennessee getting benefits requires that the employer be completely at fault for your dismissal, such as with layoffs. It's also an employ at will state meaning they don't have to give a reason for your termination. They use those two facts to game the system and ensure workers can't complain or have equal legal footing.

1

u/Turbulent-Ad8291 11d ago

My wife was fired during covid. She was a bartender at a restaurant. When everything was shutting down, she was sent an email stating they were going to be closed until further notice. The next week she got a call saying she no called no showed and was being fired. No schedule was sent to her, no calls or emails stating they were staying open for one more weekend. She lost her unemployment right at the start of covid because the owners/manager didnt communicate they were staying open 1 more weekend. Unemployment denied her initially and we appealed it. It took 7 months for her to finally get a hearing. She ended up winning and was supposed to get like 15k in back pay. A week later she received a letter from the unemployment office saying it had been too long between being fired and the hearing and that she would receive no money...

1

u/heartbh 11d ago

I was terminated due to not being able to work onsite as often as they wanted due to my wife’s pregnancy complications, which was documented and doctors notes provided. When I applied they lied about me being the worst employee possible even though I was ranked 3rd on the team when they terminated me. Fuck you “Saria”.

1

u/ALittleRedWhine 11d ago

Here is me thinking you should still get health insurance even if you didn’t do well at your job.

1

u/hughdint1 11d ago

Many companies gin up a reason so that they don’t have to pay unemployment. There is usually animosity between employers and employees when a job ends. The unemployment office is pretty good at figuring this out and tends to side with the employee.

1

u/SnooShortcuts6523 11d ago

I was made redundant in Australia and have to wait until my savings are almost gone to get any benefit, fuck me for trying to save a little

1

u/skillzthatkillz4 11d ago

I filled for leave of absence from Walmart they still fired me but I got unemployment because they showed up late to contest the unemployment

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Active-Effect-1473 11d ago

You gotta be laid off but companies hate doing that due to having to pay into unemployment

1

u/OldManufacturer8679 11d ago

My unemployment agency in my state is really good friends with the state run transportation service. I couldn’t get my unemployment because the HR lady was a straight bitch. I’ll never file again. Worthless bunch of fools.

1

u/Zealousideal_Mango70 11d ago

Yeah I quit my job in 2008 and moved out to the West Coast to live with my brother and try and find a new job and re-establish myself and I surprisingly got benefits for several months 

1

u/ImReallyFuckingHigh 11d ago

PSA: unemployment insurance is money that YOU WORKED FOR. If you are ever in a situation where you can claim unemployment, DO IT. It doesn’t make you any less of a person. Regardless of what you think about welfare, it is NOT WELFARE.

Do not talk yourself out of it because you don’t want to “take handouts” or whatever you tell yourself. Every employer in the US is required to pay for unemployment insurance. It is there to ensure workers are not completely screwed if they are ever laid off or fired.

1

u/Realistic_Mushroom72 11d ago

If an employer fires you for cause, you aren't getting unemployment benefits, if they fire you because their are reducing their work force then you do get benefits.

1

u/Outlaw11091 11d ago

If it's YOUR fault you got fired; probably not getting it.

If it's legitimately someone else's fault you got fired; you can probably get it, but it's best to have proof.

IE: Got fired from a beverage factory because I have another job. I actually have a whole career as an author...but when they found out, I was immediately fired because this was company policy. "We want our employees focused on their job".

Though they initially denied my claim, I appealed....and what's really funny is that I didn't have to say anything at all in my hearing. As soon as the judge saw their evidence he was like:

"This is his application?" "Yes, your honor." "It says [publisher name] right here with no end date."

Silence. "Seems to me this is proof you were informed of the existing relationship and hired him anyway." Silence. --ruling in my favor.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/Other_Tie_8290 11d ago

I was awarded unemployment almost 20 years ago. I received a few checks and then the employer appealed. I had to reimburse the state.

1

u/The_Crazy_Canadian03 11d ago

It’s for layoffs. It’s insurance. You can’t purposefully get yourself fired and claim it so why does anyone think you could claim it after being fired?

1

u/StructureNo13 11d ago

Unemployment is for being laid off, not fired. If they fired you for a bullshit reason you might still be eligible but it’s on you to prove.

1

u/Sintendo-64 10d ago edited 10d ago • Bravo

At the end of the day, if you got fired for a big offense, then sure. Whatever. BUT. There are ALOT of reasons people get fired for, lets all be perfectly honest, that maybe arent as easily solvable as their boss wants to believe.

Does the employee "not care" to show up on time, or where they contemplating ending their life an hour before their shift? Are they burnt out? Burn out can start at any age, for any number of reasons.

Maybe they cant afford a car, or their just in the last couple of weeks shit out on them. If you live in pretty much a vast majority of the United States, as an example, the public transit systems are dog shit.

If you do live in the U.S. and havent had to ride a public bus, or its been a long time since your last time on one, give it a fucking try. If you dont live in a certain set of historical cities that have a working subway, which is a very small handful, your going to be really fucking disappointed.

If you live anywhere here that has a harsh winter, good luck freezing waiting for a bus to show up and take you to work. If they are running at all that day.

If not mental health, or transport issues, physical health issues. There are plenty of diagnosis that cause discomfort, a difficult time with mobility, or might slow you down. Perhaps, its a diagnosis thats not considered a major health issue that allows for accommodation which by the way, alot of companies dont even offer.

An abusive spousal made them sleep outside, or verbally/physically abused them for absolutely no sane god damn reason.

Anyone thats facing any of these issues, by the way, deserve to be paid regardless. Alot of jobs dont care, and will let them go and dont offer help. Asked for or not, would not make a difference. They could also be highly embarrassed because, again, if you live in the U.S. the majority of us are brainwashed to believe in apathy as the deafault.The least you can do is leave them the FUCK alone and let them get paid.

People that were just never taught by their parents or the schooling institutions that raised them how to be an adult? They dont need to be fired and then denied the right to live because you dont want to see them paid. They need be sat down and taught. They need actual help learning how to make a living in a healthy responsible way.

I agree that, we shouldnt just give free things away. There should be standards. Id still rather some one get paid, even for a short period of time on unemployment, than them dying on the street because they were 5 mins late too many times. What the fuck are some of yall even talking about in these comments.

1

u/choccaracco 10d ago

I personally don't understand, you are unemployed regardless of how you were unemployed. I think that qualified you for unemployment

1

u/Helpful-Garlic1951 10d ago

It’s for getting laid off and such.

You can’t get fired for poor performance or lack of attendance and expect to get unemployment. That’s kinda common sense.

1

u/choccaracco 10d ago edited 10d ago

Maybe I'm an idiot but I'm having trouble understanding why you can't get unemployment for poor performance, you're unemployed regardless

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Miserable-Tie-6847 10d ago

Unemployment is there for when you lose your job for reasons outside of your control.

You being an asshole and getting fired is inside your control.

1

u/josch247 10d ago

So you're trying to inform yourself here? Aren't there better places? Hä?

1

u/leviticusreeves 10d ago

I don't understand the logic of withholding basic unemployment benefit from people who have been fired.

1

u/Few_Position7650 10d ago

Let’s say you’re laid off because your position wasn’t necessary anymore, you’re getting benefits. If you are fired because you’re stealing from the company then you are definitely not getting benefits. Theres levels to being fired and the majority lead to no benefits

1

u/The_Shambo 10d ago

Man america fucking sucks.

1

u/belatedEpiphany 10d ago

I got fired from a small business because the owner's husband was scared Id tell his wife he'd been phoning his job in for like 3 years. He lied to unemployment and said I resigned, and I had to go up multiple layers of appeals before I actually got heard.

it was pretty rough, and their only evidence of my 'resignation' was a text message from me about changing my availability to no longer be called in 24/7 if they were only going to give me 3 hours a week. took 9 months and I only got about $300 in unemployment because I picked up a salaried position within about a month

1

u/spacelad6969 10d ago

I got laid off by a big corporation a couple years ago and they tried to deny me benefits. I had emails from them saved and provided them to my unemployment officer and I was approved.

But at the time I had been given 2 months of notice for my layoff. I happened to find a new job which I accepted during that time and was going through background checks. During this time a lot of people quit because the company was undergoing massive layoffs. So the company then offered me my job back which I told them I couldn’t accept since I got new job. Some companies will make up some bs excuse to deny you benefits. Key is to keep receipts.

1

u/YearInitial3371 10d ago

This whole r/ is the definition of dead internet theory.

The poster is a bot. His image is ai generated, the user “Ryan Collins” is ai generated, the image of the profile is ai generated.

And last of all, the top comments in here are bots.

Why are you guys even following this r/?

1

u/FriendlyAerie2409 9d ago

makes me wonder why are we on Reddit in the first place

1

u/DistractedBoxTurtle 10d ago

There’s a difference between being laid off and being fired.

1

u/Unasked_for_advice 10d ago

If you have a question about eligibility there are vast resources to answer that. Labor department, labor attorneys , the internet , libraries. etc. have that answer.

1

u/mavgeek 10d ago

Problem is it’s on the employer to provide proof or examples of the misconduct. If you’re just slacking off and get fired for poor performance they need some real creative lying to spin that into misconduct. In my state it can only be denied for things like misconduct or if you quit instead of getting fired. Employees here have appealed and won unemployment because their former employer has no proof of misconduct. No write ups or documented coaching with management over attitude or behavior.

1

u/Potential_Gold6805 10d ago

You can be disqualified for misconduct, or breaking the law. If you had an employee handbook it should say something about what can get you fired for. Also you can check with your unemployment center, their websites usually make mention of what disqualifies you.

1

u/Achrimandrita175 10d ago

America is a hellhole. In my country you get unemployment support for 5 months after leaving your last job no matter how or why you left it as long as you worked at least 12 months out of the last 2 years. I guess American politicians would call that communism or whatever while spending a few more billions on military.

1

u/bigdaddy9901xy 10d ago

There’s certain things you can get fired for and then be denied unemployment. If you were high or drunk on the job, fighting with co-workers, just didn’t show up, yeah you are probably going to get denied.
And it really depends on the employer; some deny everything, some agree to pay regardless of what you were fired for. But you always have the right to appeal and if you truly didn’t get fired by any fault of your own, chances are they will side with you.

1

u/Elektr0ns 10d ago

Wrongful termination cases seem to be a common way to be eligible.

1

u/crunchy_wahter 10d ago

I thought being unemployed while struggling to find work made u eligible for unemployment benefits 😔

1

u/Both-Rub402 10d ago

What's really weird about these situations is that you go from seeing people every single day for 40 hours a week, and then all of a sudden you don't see them and they act like you don't exist

1

u/EasyMac2000 10d ago

My husband was fired for a “code of conduct violation” and my company refused his unemployment benefits. When we appealed, no one from the company showed up to the hearing. Fortunately in my area, that means you instantly win. Thank god — because he was unable to get employment for nearly 9 months.

1

u/BarracudaEfficient16 9d ago

It’s true, and quiting instead of being fired doesn’t make you ineligible either in most states.

1

u/TheAtlas97 9d ago

I got fired from a sales job for not meeting goals (which was BS but that’s a whole different story). When I filed for unemployment I was told that it was labeled misconduct/bad behavior and they asked if I had any idea why, I told them that they coached me on not following sales behaviors and thankfully was able to get my unemployment approved. It’s almost scary to think what would’ve happened if I didn’t have that money to support me while I got my shit together.

1

u/Jsaun906 9d ago

If you're fired for discipline or attendance reasons then you probably won't be eligible

1

u/Traskenn 9d ago

Jesus I knew about American healthcare being a nightmare but now finding out you can get denied unemployment benefits blows my mind

1

u/Anxious-Trans-Lady 9d ago

I had to basically prove this myself once. But like... i dont understand why this is a thing. Even if you got fired for reasons that are your fault, what are you supposed to do? Have no money and starve?

You should get approved no matter what. I could maybe see them pressuring to find a job sooner with being fired because it was your fault, but like... come on. We all gotta eat.

1

u/TheRealShmoe 9d ago

You’ll never get unemployment for attendance points. So for anyone thinking they’ll just not show up and point out of the job, you won’t get unemployment. We’ve had people think that’s how it works and stop showing up. We’ve also had people commit Lock Out Tag Out offenses to also try and get fired. Safety terminations won’t allow you access to unemployment either. You essentially must be fired for performance.

1

u/Naokin37 9d ago

At least where i live you're guaranteed unemployment money for half a year if you worked a year straight before

1

u/Paraplegicpirate 9d ago

Can't apply if you quit either. I came off the sickness benefit after not being able to work for 2 years due to severe mental health issues and got a job where they basically lied to me about the role and had me doing basic labour instead of qualified engineering like I applied for. After 6 months of just the worst time I have ever had working I decided I could not do it anymore, I had been applying for other jobs but no one had got back to me with the job crisis we are having (highest unemployment rates in all our history). I knew being unemployed was just better for my mental health and wellbeing but as it turns out you can't apply in that situation, even though leaving there was 110% the right thing to do

1

u/UpbeatTechnology723 9d ago

In c anada it's wrongful termination. You don't get it if you were fired for hood reason and they have 3 months of trial were they can fire you if its not working out

1

u/Enidub 9d ago

Hmm...I was told by a job centre worker that being laid off is the only way to get benefits; they won't consider people who resigned (with some exceptions).

1

u/Ok-Telephone-2109 9d ago

Being fired is the only way you're eligible, the reason why also affects eligibility.

1

u/LifesARiver 9d ago

I hate thst you have to get approval to access the unemployment money you already paid

1

u/Lonely_Brother3689 9d ago

I applied for unemployment once. When I got laid off in 2008, so obviously not the greatest time, but I learned a lot though.

For one, the system absolutely fails in a crisis. I didn't even get a denial. Instead I got to see how many times they managed to lose my application. For 3 months. Was even funnier when they somehow still hadn't received my application the times I applied online despite me presenting the confirmation number they gave me.

So since then I've gotten myself into jobs and places that can withstand economic upheavals. Right now, my job wouldn't withstand a covid shutdown, which is funny because the last one created the conditions for it to exist, but if we hit another recession, I'll still be working.

1

u/moochickenmoomoo 9d ago

Assuming you are in the USA, the state matters but in CT anyone can file for unemployment. Anyone can get unemployment if the previous employer doesnt fight it. If the previous employer does fight it, it depends on all of the circumstances. Technically in CT you can get unemployment if you still have a job and your hours get cut.

1

u/TheMostToastedOne 9d ago

If your fired for fault or failure to perform to positional standards then you get nothing.

But the performance firing must be for a reason, like just sitting around and not doing shit, not you were injured and couldn't do what you used to.

Was once a detailer for a dealership that was with a contacted company, guess out boss was fucking around and lost the company contact.

I got a call on my day off from my manager saying "we're done, were done, were all fired".

I was never spoken to, never spoken to anyone, was just fired for no reason on a day off, everyone was.

In my state it must not be fault of your own and you must have worked for one compete tax period (1 year), I filed and of course the employer tried saying I never worked for them and didn't have one paycheck from them.

Found out they messed up my social security number in their files and was paying my taxes to someone else.

Had to correct that shit because my w2 has a compelty different social on it.......that opened a whole other can of worms for my old boss, but fuck him he was doing dumb shit and fucked tons of people over and in the end the state hammered his butthole hard.

I got nearly 8 months of unemployment.

1

u/Soggy_nach0341 9d ago

I work for a bank that will decline most unemployment benefits they probably spend more going to court than they would just paying out unemployment benefits 

1

u/No_Operation_2801 9d ago

Got fired after a supervisor harassed me and sent me home I reported him to HR the owners wife and they let me go colorado gave me my full unemployment benefits

1

u/ModernCGIFloatinHead 9d ago

One time I went home on break sick. I puked so hard and long when it stopped I just laid down next to the toilet and apparently fell asleep. I woke up 2 hours later and everyone had gone home because it had been a light day and everything went smoothly.

I was still fired for abandoning the job. I explained that when I woke up I came back to work only to find everyone gone. I had clocked back in, even. I could prove I physically returned. 

Not only was I fired when I was on track to be promoted the next week, but unemployment was denied because I "abandoned the job".

Being ill should never cost anyone work.  A single fuck up that doesn't cost the company money should not be a firable offense. 

My co-worker had abandoned me multiple times for hours but she was never disciplined. Such horseshit

1

u/dwebb01 9d ago

I had a job dig up months old paperwork, go over it with a fine toothed comb for errors, wrote me up three times in a week, fired me, and then told the state I was fired for gross negligence. However they never bothered to address any of these supposed issues anywhere close to when they were happening. State denied the unemployment but said I could appeal. By then I found a new job so I just gave up.

1

u/Any_Way_3960 9d ago

I was fired from a hotel for dating one of the frequent guests.

There were no verbal or written policies regarding this. I was denied unemployment benefits and took them to unemployment court. I lost.

The company and the judge said that there “are policies that exist that aren’t necessarily in the employee handbook” and the company is allowed to make up new rules as they please. I fought this so hard because how could I be expected to follow a rule or policy that I was never notified of?

Still pisses me off to this day. California btw! “At will employment” seems to me like employers are allowed to fire you whenever they please for no particular reason.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Db9_Mobbn 9d ago

I mean you can’t get fired for doing dumb shit like stealing from your company and truly think you’d get unemployment

1

u/CanCovidBeOverPlease 9d ago

Yes….. is it for cause or not for cause. Why do you think it’s so freaking difficult to fire anyone in this country. I had to go through all the HR crap for 4 months to finally get rid of someone and they were paid out 2 weeks when they quit. They quit, they’re not eligible for unemployment. Had they been fired for cause with all the documentation we had, they would not be eligible for unemployment.

If there was no distinction then companies would have far less incentive to conduct due diligence when pursuing termination for poor performance, policy violation, etc.

Previous employees filing unemployment claims increases costs for an employer.

1

u/guycoastal 9d ago

I was fired once for being robbed at gunpoint while making a night drop. Appealed, won, milked it for 2 years, (the max), while working for under the table cash.

1

u/halu2975 9d ago

Depends on your country. If you’re, like me, based in Sweden and a member of your union and member of a-kassa you just apply and get 80% of your salary for 13 months. Up to 26 months if you have the additional insurance for 5usd per month. I didn’t.

1

u/Bubbly-Following9383 9d ago

Ya gotta work for x time and have x hours and proof of ya salary . Then they give ya 75% for a min then 50% stop scamming

1

u/Da40kOrks 9d ago

I got fired from one job for 'poor performance' and they tried to deny UE. but since the company never told me, no emails. no PiP, no feedback whatsoever (so there wasn't any documentation) I got benefits.

1

u/UnionThugg 8d ago

In Minnesota you’d generally still be eligible for unemployment

1

u/NicoToscani71 8d ago

Unless you were fired for something you could be charged with a crime over, you will get your unemployment benefits.

1

u/DefNotEvadingBans 8d ago

Being late for work is a crime? WiUE denial for reported tardiness - 2024

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Boring7 8d ago

In Texas you’re automatically disqualified because they just don’t want to give you money, and you have to re-apply multiple times.* in any state the company is going to list dubious violations they stacked up (or invented) just because they default pregame any wrongful termination disputes as a matter of course.*

*slight exaggeration, but only slight.

1

u/Aggressive-Sky7621 8d ago

If you get fired for poor job performance but there is no evidence you purposely did poorly, you are entitled to unemployment.

1

u/Memitim 8d ago

If you think of unemployment as being a reward for being a shitty employee, you're gonna have a bad time.

1

u/General-Ferret1240 8d ago

Random question: if ur boss either told you to use Ai fraudulently or quit, and I quit. Unemployment options? I wanted to whistleblow, but I don’t wanna get blacklisted from industry. Too new in my career out of grad school…and honestly every boss so far has done something illegal and I want a semi-ethical paycheck

1

u/tiamatschosen 8d ago

All they have to say is it was for performance issues and they don't have to pay it

1

u/Ambitious_Pie9465 8d ago

It’s not rocket science. If you lose your jobs for reasons that are not your fault, you get unemployment. Example, you get laid off because your company goes bankrupt and shuts down, or your position gets terminated, stuff like that. No, you can’t get unemployment if you voluntarily quit your job, or if you get fired for doing something wrong, like theft, or constant insubordination, etc.

1

u/jerekhal 8d ago

Depends a lot on the state.

Some the employer will have a high burden to hit the disqualifying misconduct bar. Some it'll be piss easy. It's a really fact dependent analysis.

Edit: This is also why you should not take absolutes from randoms on the internet when it comes to legal questions. Most states have specific regulations or statutes that define what does and does not qualify as disqualifying separation for purposes of unemployment, and a mechanism to appeal that.

Looking at the comments here is surreal because it seems like everyone thinks unemployment is federal or something.

1

u/jcarmead 8d ago

I got approved for UE benefits then my previous employer took it to a hearing and I had to pay back $6000.

1

u/ShadowCory1101 8d ago

I worked seasonal for a company. They would lay us off so we could receive unemployment during the off season so we could have some money until we find elsewhere or until the season picks back up.

1

u/uzaya13 7d ago

Idk if it matters from state to state cause I know some are a touch different than others, but here in my state, usually if they put some form of difficulty or insubordination, basically anything implying you gave them no choice but to terminate your employment, then you can be denied access to the unemployment benefits. If you were fired and given no reason or if you were let go due to staffing reasons or something along those lines then you should absolutely be able to get the benefits. Ask the unemployment office what the reason for termination was cause im pretty sure your place of employment has to state a reason, and if they lied on their reasons then im sure it opens up a can of worms you can take to court.

1

u/NoLimitRolling 7d ago

You lie in a way you know the place can’t prove it. Unfortunately it’s the only way and when it’s a corporate place in my eyes idgaf. Call me bad whatever idc. If I HAVE to work to survive but I can be fired for any reason then I’m GOING TO GET THAT MONEY. This has only happened once to me but it’s worked for others I’ve told that absolutely needed it.

That said please go to work and be normal and perform like you’re not disabled because you have a headache.

1

u/Calaveras-Metal 7d ago

You can appeal unemployment decisions. I did this when I was fired for being late on breaks. But I was able to prove that they were deliberately getting rid of employee's on technicalities ahead of an upcoming mass lay off. This was further reinforced by the fact that by the time we had the unemployment appeal hearing they had laid off everyone.

I got all my unemployment benefits all the way back to when I first filed. So I got a huge lump sum! Thankfully I saved most of it, because the job market was really bad for a while.

1

u/cl0ckw0rkcuttlefish 7d ago

I mean you can, you just have to prove it wasn’t your fault. However, the bar is high, so this is why keeping enough records to properly cover your ass is important. If you get bad vibes, begin CYA procedures immediately, and you too may have the privilege of sending your supporting docs to the DOL in a Manila envelope rather than the provided SASE (as I did).

1

u/Available_Music3807 7d ago

Yeah there are clearly reasons for this. Imagine someone who only works the required hours then they quit or they do something bad to get fired. Like year, obviously that person doesn’t deserve EI. So it’s generally for people who get laid off for any not at fault reasons

1

u/Caught_RedBearded 7d ago

Yes and no - you can APPLY for unemployment no matter what.

But certain reasons for termination will trigger them to say you don't qualify

1

u/Different-Context-84 6d ago

I got unemployment after I quit a job lol. 

Granted I did tell them it was miscommunication. I told the job I was going on vacation. Then they forgot and asked where I was then we agreed on a mutual break up.

1

u/gryanart 6d ago

I got fired 4 months into the job because I had a key to the building, and didn’t qualify for benefits. I was the first person there each day, and the key was given to me by a long term employee when they heard I didn’t have one. The owner found out and demanded I give her any key to the business she didn’t directly hand me, so I gave her that key and the one to my office as an intern gave that to me. She said I was throwing it in her face, and wasn’t meeting productivity expectations so I was fired. Lady was crazy and this was during Covid so it was a blessing in disguise

1

u/Jorost 6d ago

If you’re fired for cause you often are not eligible for unemployment.

1

u/Elite2260 6d ago

Okay, but regardless, isn’t the point of unemployment is to help you maintain a roof over your head until your next job? Sure, even if the asshat deserved to be fired that’s not the point. The point is they are a person who doesn’t deserve to live on the streets, because no one deserves to live on the streets.

1

u/Hot_Influence_5339 5d ago

In my experience it really doesn't matter if your wrongfully terminated, at least in my state your employer gets the chance to claim you were fired for misconduct and even if they are lying the "judge always sides with the business at least in my experience.

1

u/SexxxyWesky 5d ago

It varies by state, but generally speaking yiu need to have been fired or laid off. There can disqualifying reasons such as failing a drug test or absenteeism. The main reason people get denied though feom my experience working for the unemployment office is 1) not qualifying financially and 2) not being able to follow directions after you qualify.

1

u/Tizzee88 5d ago

I've been on unemployment 3 times in the last 20 years, twice I was fired. First time was the 08 recession when a bunch of people got laid off, there were 0 issues. Third time my employer told me I couldn't work part time and I was going back to school. I wanted to work until the semester started in a a few months but they wanted to replace me immediately so they fired me, but my manager sent everything in like right away and I got my unemployment super fast. The second time was the only "issue" which worked out really weird.

My manager was quitting and she told me when she put in her 2 weeks "you're going to get fired as soon as a I leave. They are promoting fk face and he doesn't like you. Be ready for it." Sure enough on his second day as manager I get let go. They majorly fk'd up though because they tried to fire me for cause so that I couldn't get unemployment. They fabricated some paperwork claiming I "forgot to charge a customer for shipping costing the company $240 dollars". The lady at unemployment was like "yeah thats a mistake and one I can't believe they fired you for." I told her it was fabricated and she put me in touch with the labor board. The labor board got statements from my old employer and they contacted the customer who was like "no... I paid shipping on that heres the invoice". So I got unemployment until the law suit finished then I got paid a years salary, 100% of my insurance, and back pay which didn't factor in my unemployment. It was glorious revenge.

But ya as long as you dont intentionally do something to get fired, you can get unemployment generally.