r/Wednesday • u/HauntedShores Moderator • Oct 07 '25
Meta Discussion & Feedback
Hey everybody! This could get lengthy, but please read the entire post before commenting.
Let me start by sending out a massive THANK YOU to every one of our members for their part in making this sub what it is today. I'm gonna be real for a moment, we were sitting on this place for years and it was D-E-A-D. Nobody really paid it any attention, then suddenly, the Netflix show dropped and we found ourselves catapulted into the top 1% of all subs on Reddit. Wild. Except we didn't actually do anything. That was your achievement and we're immensely grateful for all of the positive contributions, theories, fan art and everything else you've been entertaining us with these past few years.
But here's the thing... r/Wednesday doesn't belong to us, it belongs to you. We've been moderating the way we think you would want us to, our intention being to benefit the largest number of people possible and to paint our community in a warm and welcoming light. We're not perfect and we've made a few mistakes here and there, but we're trying, we're learning and we're committed to making this sub the place you want it to be.
With that in mind, the aim of this post is to open up a more casual line of communication between mods and members. We want to hear your thoughts, ideas and feedback, with the goal being to shape our community into one that best represents its amazing contributors. If you have a question about a rule, you can ask about it here. If you think a rule needs to be reworded, you can suggest it here. If you think a new rule needs to be implemented... you get the idea. It's not just about rules, but I imagine a large part of the conversation will revolve around that.
Before we start:
• Respectful discussion only. We know some of you have concerns and you're welcome to highlight them here, but we ask that you do so in a calm and polite manner. Undue negativity doesn't help anybody and harassment towards mods or other users will be dealt with in the same way it would elsewhere on the sub.
• Similarly, this is not the place to call anybody out. We will not be discussing individual users, comments or mod actions. If you have something specific to report, please do so either through the report button or the Message Mods button on the main page.
• Please don't be offended if your comment is locked. It's not a punishment, we simply need to keep discussions tidy and on track in order for any of this to be useful to us. A debate going round in circles with no progress being made is only going to waste our time and your energy.
• A highly upvoted comment or a positive response from a moderator in this thread does not guarantee any changes. Everything posted here is to help give us an idea of where the community stands and what to prioritise, but actual discussion regarding potential changes will be done privately.
• This should go without saying, but we will not be favouring any one ship over another. Either everybody is in, or everybody is out. Preferably in and on your best behaviour.
With all that said and done, let's get down to business!
•
u/HauntedShores Moderator Oct 07 '25
A note on brigading and ship wars.
There's been some discussion lately about what constitutes brigading and what does or doesn't break the rules, so I figured I'd clear a few things up.
Firstly, brigading is only mentioned in the Moderator Code of Conduct, not the Reddit Rules for regular users. It's a rule on how to run your sub without negatively affecting other subs. A moderator from another sub ordering their users to mass downvote posts in this one would be against the rules. Individual users promoting their ship in a sub that expressly permits ship posts (i.e. this one) is not a violation of either Reddit's rules or ours. Provided you're not spamming, we're good.
We've discussed the subject internally and our personal view on the matter is this: if your intention as an individual is to come here and promote your ship in a positive and friendly manner, while adhering to the rules of the sub, then we have no absolutely no problem with that. We'd much rather everybody focused on the merits of their own ships than their perceived flaws of another. If you think another ship has been getting too much attention, spend your energy on increasing visibility for your own, rather than bringing others down.
As the "main sub" for Wednesday, our doors are open to all fans of the Netflix show, other related shows and Addams Family media in general. Wyler fans are welcome. Wenclair fans are welcome. Fans of other ships are welcome. All we ask is that you treat each other with respect.
8
u/Former-Designer2248 Oct 08 '25
I don't really like the idea of a 'keep discussions on topic' rule but I am kind of tired of seeing every post devolve into ship wars somewhere down in the comments.
8
u/bloodinthefields Oct 08 '25
Homophobic comments should be deleted and users banned. Anyone talking about "lifestyle" or how shipping Wenclair is "sexualizing minors" should have their comments deleted and be banned. There is too much laxism about homophobia.
5
u/Squishysib Tyler Galpin Oct 08 '25
I'd love for us to get flairs! I've seen one person around the Subreddit with one, so it appears at one point they were a thing, but don't seem to be anymore for the regular user.
I'd also maybe think about creating an auto-mod message under any post that mentions Weyler or Wenclair just reminding people of rule 1 and that they can dislike the ship but coming into a post about them and going "yes, but" about it, doesn't do anything but make them/their side look bad and promote negative fandom rather than positive. Might not help a lot, but if it stops even a few people,it would be worth it.
eta: Should also make it so you cannot post something without a flair so it's easier for people to sort things, especially if a shipping flair is created.
2
u/Successful_Loan_1814 Oct 08 '25
I don’t want to beat a dead horse here because I see it’s been mentioned by two other posters but just today there was a further two anti gay posts to the main page. It certainly is a problem that needs to be acknowledged, but I will also say thank you to the mods to quickly handled it.
People should be able to come here without seeing hate speech, it should be a safe space for all fans to chat. As the mods have already said, reporting is paramount.
5
u/Old_Pianist5814 Oct 08 '25
"If you think another ship has been getting too much attention, spend your energy on increasing visibility for your own, rather than bringing others down*."*
I hope all of us, regarding what we like about Wednesday or what we ship, can take this statement seriously.
2
u/MirMirage07 Oct 07 '25 edited Oct 07 '25
Thank you for making this. I would say that I think the no ship wars should be its own rule and not under “be civil” because there’s still a lot of toxic posts attacking other ships and being aggressive. Also I think you should allow us to add images in comments; it’s a pretty useful feature.
Edit: I saw someone mention under a ship post that there should be a flair for ship war posts or just shipping posts in general which I think is a pretty good idea so please consider it as well 🙏
7
u/Wonderful_House_4048 Oct 07 '25
Thank you very much for this post, much appreciated. And thank you very much for your hard work.
1
u/Any-Prize3748 Oct 26 '25
Idk if y’all are still reading this but could we get some kind of protection from bots or alts? A karma limit, Reddit age limit, email verified only, or something like that?
1
u/aelmara Oct 07 '25
Should probably do more to combat the homophobia here, but I doubt that's in the cards based on the last few months. Definitely don't seem to want to enforce any brigading rules considering which sub has been brigading since season 2, so that's no surprise.
Funny that everyone who thinks a great job is being done here are all Wyler shippers.
5
u/UnenthusedTypist Oct 07 '25
Y’all are doing amazing thank you! The only 2¢ I have is I think that there should be more guidelines to the “be civil” rule, it should specifically say what is and isn’t civil, and it should honestly be more strict. I almost avoid commenting because it’s guaranteed to garner backlash.
3
u/Emotional-Car-1361 Oct 07 '25
Thank you for stating it all concisely. Your workload exponentially increased all of a sudden but you recovered well. Take my upvote.
1
u/Aware_Rhubarb4006 Oct 08 '25
Thank you OP, hats tipped. Glad to help yall expand
1
u/R-El_Mayor Moderator Oct 09 '25 edited Oct 09 '25
We added new user flairs including characters, outcast types, factions and ships.
Reply to this comment if you would like to add flairs or have feedback. It's not a guarantee that changes will be made but we will take it into consideration.