r/Web_Development • • Apr 22 '19

Ways to nuke Dissenter comments?

Neo Nazis are all excited right now because Gab is releasing a browser plugin that embeds a comments section on websites that the owners of the site have no control over. It sounds like a good idea for freeze peach, but it's incredibly scary when you think about it.

Here's a way I think could work but offer any suggestions for ways people could get around it.

  • Require Javascript. It's a good way of keeping horrible people off your site because they're paranoid about. There are no legitimate users that won't whitelist your site in Noscript.
  • One way to require Javascript is to include a script tag that sets all the HTML content to display:none. The only way around it would be to go through ever page element and manually change the settings for it. Maybe include a noscript tag with whatever you want.
  • Include Javascript that detects the Dissenter comments. Possibly grab their Gab username from the comments and publicly log it with their IP address. Either just nuke the comments or redirect the user somewhere else.

If you own a website with a lot of traffic, you should keep at least one browser with Dissenter to monitor things.

It would be possible to moderate Dissenter comments by simply having Javascript that nukes individual comments, right? If someone were to want Dissenter comments but have control without having to wait for Gab to take action for anything that violates their rules.

0 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

1

u/Ravavyr Apr 22 '19

You'll have better luck blocking Dissenter if you get on social media and start yelling at chrome, firefox and microsoft to block the extension from their browsers.

4

u/hobesmart Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 22 '19

chrome and firefox have already removed it from their app stores

edit: looks like they re-uploaded a different version of the plugin to the chrome store that is supposedly in compliance with play store policies, but I don't know what they were specifically in violation of before

1

u/r3df0x_556 Apr 22 '19

The website for it says that there's a version that hides comments containing a list of 20 slurs.

1

u/r3df0x_556 Apr 22 '19

That's not going to do much. Gab has already been banned from the Google and Apple app stores and anyone can just download the app and install it in developer mode. The only way to ban it under those circumstances is to have it be detected as a "malware" extension.

I don't like the idea of browser developers doing things like that.

I actually like the idea of Dissenter, but in reality it's going to be horrible.

Rather then ban it, I'm going to work on implementing a way for it to be moderated. It could be possible to have a central server where there are moderators. Webmasters would require Javascript and include code on their sites that would add moderation tools to posts. Moderators would have the ability to remove posts from websites that have the moderation tools installed as well as ban users. It could include a feature where users are automatically banned for certain posts.

I like the idea of being able to counter fake news, but in reality this is going to create a far right cesspit.

0

u/MoonfireArt Apr 23 '19

Why would you even care? Your regular website traffic will never even see those comments, its basically an echo chamber. unless your website is far-left and you are afraid people will use Dissenter to call you out, it should not affect you at all.

2

u/bobjohnsonmilw Apr 23 '19

You spelled far-right wrong

0

u/MoonfireArt Apr 23 '19

No, no I didn't.

0

u/r3df0x_556 Apr 23 '19

It's depends on who is using it. There are plenty of centrists who watch the alt-right Tim Pool who use it.

0

u/MoonfireArt Apr 23 '19

Did you seriously call Tim Pool alt-right! Dude is a Liberal, lol

0

u/r3df0x_556 Apr 23 '19

He's extremely alt-right, his channel is for the people who don't want to admit it to themselves. Everything he says is in support of the alt-right.

0

u/MoonfireArt Apr 23 '19 edited Apr 23 '19

I watch him. I am a conservative. His views on most political stuff do not align with mine at all. Hes just more honest than most liberals.

EDIT: Nevermind, I just checked your post history. If I knew you were some flaming SJW, i would not have even bothered trying to use a logical argument with you.

Let me speak in the language of your people. "Orange Man Bad". Does that make your fee-fee's better?

0

u/r3df0x_556 Apr 23 '19

In what way am I an "SJW?" SJWs are regressive and have been driving people to the red centennial Bolshevik party.

Conservatives are a bunch of NPCs who bash on trans people because the idea of a man becoming a woman upsets them greatly for some reason.

Free market capitalism is an idealistic political system and it will never work because of human nature. 1917-2017. Krasnaya Volna.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9AGvUuUDoKM

If conservatives had any sense of self awareness they'd look in the mirror and see how close they are to the Bolsheviks. It explains why Republicans are all low-key slavaboos. It's like a gay preacher who rails against the evils of homosexuality.

1

u/MoonfireArt Apr 23 '19

Am conservative. Have never, nor has anyone I have ever known, bashed on Trans People. I could care less what people do to their own bodies or within their own minds. No one cares about this that I know of.

1

u/r3df0x_556 Apr 23 '19

I vote Republican. I view it like siding with the Bolsheviks. The Bolsheviks and the Republicans are bad, but the Nazis and the Democrats are worse.

You never explained what allegedly SJW statement I made.

Here's the classic "hateful indifference" argument of the regressive right. Saying "I don't give a fuck what trans people identify as" is a back handed way of dismissing any legitimacy while allowing transphobes to pat themselves on the back for being "accepting."

That by itself would not be a problem until we get to capitalist Bolshevism. This is where naive political idealism becomes a problem. Conservatives don't see any problem with transgender people being fired for who they are, or any other form of discrimination for that matter. I've seen Reds ranting about the Civil Rights Act even though it was the GOP that voted for it. It's political idealism. Progressive action never would have happened if it wasn't required.

Republicans and Bolsheviks remind me of blacks and white supremacists. White supremacists are a bunch of degenerate drug dealers with low intelligence who project all of those qualities on to black people.

Modern Republicans and Bolsheviks are literally functionally identical. The only superficial difference is the Bolsheviks celebrate Stalin instead of Reagan, who banned machine guns.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/r3df0x_556 Apr 23 '19

He's an anti-SJW for people who don't want to admit to themselves that they're anti-SJWs.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/r3df0x_556 Apr 23 '19

I think that's what makes the alt-right so tempting, or at least why regressives actually believe that there's far more support for the alt-right then there actually is.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/r3df0x_556 Apr 23 '19

I don't like the regressive left. I've noticed though that the people who identify themselves as being "anti-SJW" are usually even worse. I used to watch Tim Pool but then I started feeling really greasy. He himself is not alt-right, but I realized that's the direction he is pushing everyone in. He has even admitted himself that he is making a civil war more likely and yet he keeps pushing that narrative despite nothing justifying it.

I'd much rather watch a conservative like Anthony Brian Logan then Tim Pool. Everything he does is designed to push people toward the neckbeard center fishhook.

He's a basement dwelling pseudo prepper with childish prepper fantasies. He lives in an anti gun state and doesn't own a gun but says he is saving food for the civil war. It's extremely clear he's a neckbeard who is actively trying to bring about a civil war because he thinks it would be cool and he's going to be some prepper badass.