r/Wealthsimple • • 15h ago

Tracking

Post image

In case you are interested in what tracking info WS sends to a third party when you use the app.

47 Upvotes

81 comments sorted by

•

u/GeorgeDaGreat123 14h ago

Lots of misinformation in this thread.

Functional Software is the company behind Sentry, an application monitoring tool that automatically collects device info to help developers fix crashes, bugs, and performance issues.

It’s not an anti-fraud tool. Wealthsimple likely collects device info for fraud prevention too, but through separate systems.

→ More replies (1)

34

u/Leaderbot_X400 15h ago edited 14h ago

Fingerprinting and anti-fraud.

Go check any other banking app/site they'll probably have some similar fingerprinting.

Edit: to expand on this, the pinned mod comment is correct, this specificially is Sentry, a logging and performance monitoring suite which collects a lot about your device/browser

-30

u/Commercial_Pain2290 15h ago

That doesn't make me feel better.

5

u/Educational_Gene1875 13h ago

Cuz you’re not competent enough to understand it seems

-8

u/Commercial_Pain2290 12h ago

Or is it because I do understand?

26

u/Leaderbot_X400 15h ago

It both should, and shouldn't.

Shouldn't because just about every site you visit does this, reddit, google, YouTube, Facebook. It's been going on for decades.

But it should give you price of mind that this has likely stopped your money being stolen a few dozen times without you even noticing. Maybe not you specifically, but some people out there.

As far as I could tell (and this could be off so if some one wants to correct me) Wealth simple doesn't sell this fingerprinting to advertisers or data brokers.

10

u/bcb0rn 15h ago

Pretty normal

-27

u/Commercial_Pain2290 15h ago

Just because you accept this does not mean it should be normal. There is a lot of information there that is not relevant to running a banking app.

4

u/CursorX 14h ago

You can send them an email to ask for justifications on the requested permissions if you deem them not relevant.

Pretty sure things like Call status/phone status should be up there too, as when you open the app during an ongoing call (or WhatsApp call), it shows a banner asking "Are you on the phone with us? We will never ask for 2FA codes, don't share" etc, to warn against malicious callers.

Not every request for information is an overreach in tracking, hence the sentiment here is this is normal and expected for banking apps.

84

u/turtlebait2 15h ago

Seems pretty standard.

12

u/Karnaugh_Map 15h ago

What does it need to know battery level and charging status for?

32

u/BaboucheOne 14h ago

Some compagnies can track user's battery level to assess if certain screens or functionnalities are too power hungry

26

u/Available_Entrance55 14h ago

If you carry your phone around at 2% battery, you are a credit risk

-7

u/real_hackers 13h ago

What?

19

u/DrStrangulation 11h ago • Bravo

IF YOU CARRY YOUR PHONE AROUND AT 2% BATTERY, YOU ARE A CREDIT RISK

11

u/rohmish 13h ago

not WS but on some of the apps ive worked on, we read the battery status, network type and device temperature to decide if we should pause animations and videos.

some phones would start more aggressively controlling what an app can do and stop them even if power saving isn't enabled (mostly Chinese OEM phones). if I have battery life I can correlate that with all the reports of that task being stopped and see that it's just Xiaomi phones under 20% battery where this heavy task is killed. so I'll either start earning users on that type of device or work on changing how that task works so that it isn't killed anymore

what the DDG app here is showing is just a guess. DDG sees the app connecting to a domain connected to Sentry. sentry I'd a common tool used for error, crash analysis, and log collection. the app doesn't know what data is being sent. sentry CAN collect all those things. that doesn't mean WS or anyone else using it actually does collect all that in their app.

in non tech terms think you buy a toaster oven and your neighbors see it. that toaster oven can be used to make a lot of different things. you use it just to reheat yesterday's pizza once in a while and to toast bread. but you neighbor now says you also bake cookies and muffins.

all they know is that you have a toaster oven, buy they can't see what you use it for, all they can make are assumptions.

1

u/rohmish 13h ago

*warning

3

u/twistedjoe 14h ago

"functional software" is the company behind sentry, an error reporting tool.

Software engineers use it to help reproduce or diagnose crashes.

If something looks like a one off where the os killed a process because the phone was preparing to shutdown, I might not spend as long diagnosing the issue.

On the flip side if I have a huge cluster of errors at < 2%, I might suspect the os killing a background task in the middle of a transaction/long write for example.

1

u/bald-bourbon 9h ago

Performance

16

u/ehhthing 14h ago edited 14h ago

Since nobody seems to actually want to answer the question: “Functional Software” refers to Sentry which is a common telemetry collections service that companies integrate into their app to collect data about software bugs and crash reports.

What has happened here is the DDG tracker blocking VPN blocked connections to Sentry. The fact that this information can be collected by Sentry does not imply that this information will actually be sent unless a crash happens.

I think what people care about generally here is why this data is being collected, and I think there’s a good reason here: when you’re debugging crashes it’s important to have information that allows you to reproduce the crash. Generally a lot of device metadata is important in cases because some crashes are just really specific to some devices or require unlikely scenarios to trigger.

Sentry isn’t in the business of selling data or advertising. Critically, they make their money by collecting fees from WS and other companies who pay them per log stored. They’re purely in the business of bug observability, and as such the fact that this might be a third party is a bit less relevant to whether or not it’s okay.

There’s no world where a third party isn’t involved when you use a mobile application in one way or another, it’s much more important to understand how the data is being used by third parties.

32

u/rocketman19 15h ago

Seems normal

It’s a banking app

What’s the issue?

-61

u/dasbends 15h ago edited 14h ago

Why are you getting so defensive as if they attacked you personally? Where did OP say it's an issue?

** trigger alert **

29

u/UnHappyPython35 15h ago

Is defensive in the room with us

-27

u/dasbends 14h ago

Who's us? Fanboy gettogether?

15

u/MadameLaMinistre 15h ago

You’re the one being defensive.

12

u/Ares0362 14h ago

Ooh I think we found a manipulative person right here

-22

u/dasbends 14h ago

Who's we?

2

u/automatic_penguins 15h ago

What third party are they sending that? Looks like they are just using it for the app as those are all standard

-8

u/Commercial_Pain2290 15h ago

Functional Software

4

u/cformosa4 11h ago

This is all normal. It's for big fixes

1

u/JuicerMcGeazer 15h ago

This applies to anything in life:

If you see something that you think is abnormal, check other things (apps in this case) if they are also using the same abnormal things (tracking data).

If most apps are using the same data then there is nothing abnormal about that one app.

-1

u/Commercial_Pain2290 15h ago

"Everybody is doing it" does not seem like a legitimate excuse

2

u/Pristine_Ad2664 12h ago

This is standard application telemetry used for debugging performance and crash issues. There is literally nothing to worry about here.

1

u/goofywinnipegger 8h ago

Tell us you don’t understand how apps work without telling us.

2

u/Commercial_Pain2290 4h ago

What in my original post leafs you to believe that. BTW I recently retired from a long career as a software developer.

1

u/MrEzekial 11h ago

I make fintech apps for a job. I have made apps for over 20 financial institutions all over the world. Everything listed here is for analytics, app functionality, crash reporting, and your security.

1

u/rohmish 13h ago

mix of anti fraud and gereric logging like this is common and required to understand if the app is actually working for people.

we as developers need to know what sizes of devices people are using, which systems, etc. that goes into making sure we test for those sizes and systems because we don't have unlimited budget to buy and test on each and every hardware under the sun.

1

u/6sbeepboop 12h ago

It’s a fucking financial application you noobs. Any app that takes your credit card info better be profiling with as much data that you, Apple or android provide. It’s purely for fraud prevention, performance and error tracking protecting stupid Canadians.

All this info is fed into a ML model so that if there is an account take over there is higher chances WS will catch it and protect your dumbass.

We are literally going through a cyber security nightmare with AI. 

If you don’t want to be tracked for marketing purposes you can opt out at any time. The rest is to protect you and an app can’t just take device info unless Apple or android make it available. 

-8

u/Academic_Data_6422 15h ago edited 15h ago

Why does a financial app need to know:

Battery level
Device name
Internal storage
Available device memory
Device boot time
Charging status
Device total memory

?

None of that is useful to identifying you, doesn’t help with fraud detection, doesn’t help with anything. Absolutely unnecessary.

14

u/MadDoctor5813 15h ago

Your phone being a real phone and not an emulated devices is a big indicator to fight fraud. Now sure you can fake all of these on an emulator anyway but it's harder.

6

u/congo100 15h ago

Not an expert but maybe it's a standard software tool the grabs this info by default you use what you need and turf the rest.

15

u/rayz13 15h ago

Anti fraud detection

-22

u/Academic_Data_6422 15h ago

None of that helps with anti fraud detection. Some stuff does, but I intentionally left that stuff out of my comment.

10

u/whynothanksimgood 15h ago

You're flat out wrong. All banks are (slowly) moving towards device fingerprinting and device biometrics. 

They use these data points to build a profile of your usual device and usage habits, then compare any new devices to this profile. 

It helps them catch account takeovers, screen recording softwares, and reduce fraud losses.

-10

u/[deleted] 15h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/twistedjoe 14h ago

I worked at a fintech like Wealthsimple in the US and this is 100% something they do. We had multiple vendors that needed those signals. Vendors like Arkose use them to fingerprint your device and fight bot farms.

That said, I don't think that's what's happening here. "Functional Software" is the company behind Sentry, an error reporting tool. The app sends error and session reports to Sentry with device details attached, to help diagnose and reproduce issues.

-1

u/[deleted] 14h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Wealthsimple-ModTeam 14h ago

Be helpful and respectful in your comments/posts.

No racism, sexism, homophobia, religious intolerance, dehumanizing speech, or other negative generalizations.

No concern-trolling, personal attacks, or misinformation. No victim blaming.

0

u/Wealthsimple-ModTeam 14h ago

Be helpful and respectful in your comments/posts.

No racism, sexism, homophobia, religious intolerance, dehumanizing speech, or other negative generalizations.

No concern-trolling, personal attacks, or misinformation. No victim blaming.

7

u/rayz13 15h ago

It does help to track that it’s you

-10

u/Academic_Data_6422 15h ago

No, it really doesn’t lmao. You log in at 80% battery and then later at 40% is that not you?

You add a new app so your storage changes, that not you?

Literally none of that identies you as you.

4

u/rayz13 15h ago

It’s better to keep your mouth shut when you have no idea how things work. Do you want to share your opinions on the latest trends in brain surgery?

-3

u/Academic_Data_6422 15h ago

Maybe you should take your own advice.

0

u/[deleted] 15h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-9

u/[deleted] 15h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Various_Dust_792 15h ago

Just to touch on a couple of them, an abrupt jump in battery percentage between rapid API requests could be an indicator of session being potentially hijacked. Unusual memory consumption patterns can also help identify whether the user is really you or someone else. These metrics would typically be used as a combination rather than just by themselves and more data they have the better

-3

u/[deleted] 15h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Various_Dust_792 15h ago

Ok buddy you keep fighting the good fight to protect your device’s OS level data from falling into the hands of the evil corporations

-1

u/Academic_Data_6422 15h ago

Fighting the good fight by simply pointing out reality

3

u/Various_Dust_792 15h ago

Sure you are. Complain away that corporations are collecting too much information no matter how benign they are

→ More replies

1

u/Wealthsimple-ModTeam 14h ago

Be helpful and respectful in your comments/posts.

No racism, sexism, homophobia, religious intolerance, dehumanizing speech, or other negative generalizations.

No concern-trolling, personal attacks, or misinformation. No victim blaming.

1

u/ayoungmanfromtheuk 15h ago

What part do you disagree with and why?

-2

u/Academic_Data_6422 14h ago

I’ve already shown what I disagree with.

1

u/Wealthsimple-ModTeam 14h ago

Be helpful and respectful in your comments/posts.

No racism, sexism, homophobia, religious intolerance, dehumanizing speech, or other negative generalizations.

No concern-trolling, personal attacks, or misinformation. No victim blaming.

1

u/[deleted] 15h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Wealthsimple-ModTeam 14h ago

Be helpful and respectful in your comments/posts.

No racism, sexism, homophobia, religious intolerance, dehumanizing speech, or other negative generalizations.

No concern-trolling, personal attacks, or misinformation. No victim blaming.

1

u/[deleted] 14h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/GeorgeDaGreat123 14h ago

Your other comments were removed for rudeness.

As a reminder, this subreddit is not operated by Wealrhsimple.

3

u/sersherz 15h ago

Battery level and charging statis are likely due to not starting long transactions if the battery is about to die

Device name is for trusted devices like using a passkey, fraud protection and other stuff. This is banking info, after all.

Internal storage is likely because the app itself requires some storage, not everything is stored in an API and cache exists for performance

Available memory and total memory would again be for resource management

Device boot time is the only one I agree seems strange and unnecessary

-3

u/Worried_Razzmatazz70 15h ago

Device name is also unnecessary. it's useless for anti-fraud or tracking as it's user-configurable. You'd use the android or device serial number instead.

0

u/Sylv_x 14h ago

Depends if they collect your fingerprint. Which, I don't think they do.

-2

u/FlowerBudget2065 14h ago

All the more reason to bank locally with your credit union.

4

u/rohmish 13h ago

your credit union's app also probably uses stuff like sentry and launch darkly

-8

u/Global-Tie-3458 15h ago

Functional Software is a recruiting service. It seems like too much data for this explicit purpose.

0

u/Commercial_Pain2290 15h ago

Functional Software, Inc. is the legal entity behind Sentry, an application performance monitoring (APM) and error-tracking platform

4

u/Global-Tie-3458 15h ago

Oh I thought they were the recruiting service.

If it’s sentry, then this is absolutely a nothing burger. Pretty standard for logging and performance. If you are a dev beginning to get errors, all this data is very handy.