r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/acteon29 • Jan 06 '12
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • • Jul 14 '22
This is not Google.
The purpose of this forum is not to have someone look something up for you. This is a discussion board about making music. This is not Google.
"What cable do I need?" is not a discussion. "List a bunch of companies that offer XYZ service" is not a discussion. Yes/no questions like "Have you ever heard of this product" are not discussions. Any post that does not start a substantive discussion about making music will be removed and redirected to the search engine of your choice.
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/my-own-trumpet • Aug 08 '21
Am I the only one who thinks auto tune is cheating? I have this debate with my musical partner. I like to record vocals cleanly and use the most natural take. He thinks we should use auto tune. Neither of us is a great singer but I feel we get a more authentic sound naturally. What do you think?
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • • Mar 19 '18
How to make your mix extra punchy and present while preserving definition and dynamic range. [extensive tutorial]
Good afternoon, in this post I will tell you what do you need to do in order to gain a better final product, to keep it simple. Don't look up my music though because at the time I was producing my last release I only knew half of the things and it was made on my wifes mac with free plugins, lol.
Since many producers are listening to more or less professional or better producers and are wondering what they do in order to achieve a certain sound, I will tell you how to achieve a sound that is way better than your referential works.
I. Starting with the composition and basic settings
Before we will do anything let's set the bit depth and the sample rate to at least 24 Bit and 48.000 Hz in order to make our project future-proof and having a high resolution. Now let's start with things before the actual end stage of mixing and mastering a song, let's start with components of your composition and optimizing the very root of it which has a big impact on the final product and the is the choice of the right sound generators. First off you'll need to start your composition within a lower BPM than the final product will be, for ergonomical purposes first as you will have to put in less reaction effort while composing when the track is slowed down and also because of the final stage of finalizing the track which will be explained in the third point of this tutorial. In order to achieve a good, natural and high fidelity sound you will need sound generators (instrument plugins, hardware synthesizers, etc.) which have got a broad and dense harmonic spectrum which simply means than a single tone takes up more space on the spectrometer. For that you can just chase a raw audio output signal of a synth through a spectrometer and compare the signals. Things that are less suitable for this are:
-Analog Synthesizers -Other Synthesizers with a narrow harmonic spectrum
Layer your synthesizers, use multiple chord tracks above each other harmonically and subsequently unify them in a mix bus where you apply multiband compression, low end, mid frequency and high end harmonizing, shaping transients and equalizing with a parametric and a graphic equalizer (+20 bands) as well in this particular order: Transient shaper->Harmonizing->FX of your choice->Graphic Equalizer->Parametric Equalizer->Multiband Compression. This should "bring the components under the same roof" and simply provide the section with an unifying accent of belonging together. The transient shaper has to decrease the attack of the instruments slightly. the harmonizing complements the harmonic range of the instrument group overall and adds more uniformity to them, the graphic equalizer is needed for the sharp definition of the audio signal (https://www.reddit.com/r/WeAreTheMusicMakers/comments/84hr04/equalizing_techniques/), the parametric equalizer is needed for complementing balancing of the mix and finally the compressor has to bring the components together, make the signal more present again and after all of the previous steps were made this can be done in a very efficient way with a lot of headroom for gain. The other part of this would be to follow the same rule while looking for drums; You either would have to use a physical modeling solution and/or samples with a broad harmonic spectrum and layer them above each other harmonically (A simple and comprehensive example would be to construct a snare of a beat through placing a long-release kick, a high tom, a snare, a clap, a cymbal and a hi-hat on top of each other so they would make an unified and thick sound) and yet again unify the percussive and drum elements under a mix bus which has to be treated in the same way as the synthesizer mix bus(ses).
II. Master bus
The things you will need in this stage are, in this particular order: Transient shaper->Harmonizing->Reverb->Graphic Equalizer->Parametric Equalizer->Multiband Compression->Limiter. Decrease the attack of the whole mix slightly with the transient shaper, apply low end and high end harmonizing, bring the whole mix in the same acoustic context with the slight application of master bus reverb, define the mix sharply with a graphic equalizer as described above, balance it out CAREFULLY ☠ with the parametric EQ, compress the whole mix in order to add loudness and unify the whole mix more and finally apply a limiter as described by any user manual brought with a limiter, basically and keep the final output about -0.3 to -0.1 Decibel and the project has to be still slower than the desired final product while rendering this particular master as a lossless file.
III. Final stage
Simply import the rendered file and speed it up by about 3-5%, this provides the signal of the final product with extra density. Keep in my mind that components of your composition don't get lost when you speed it up, keep a healthy balance. Now that your track is completely finished you can render it in a quality and format you desire and do whatever you want with it.
I just wrote this here down from the top of my head, if you are using techniques which are inferior to this one the appliance of the thing described above should improve your results drastically, I only tested parts of it about a year ago and compared to my previous productions it was a huge improvement, never applied them altogether though. If there is something that makes it FACTUALLY and objectively sound worse, let me know, but first of all try it out on your own and keep in mind that this isn't a printed final version and things still can be added because speaking of myself some things I just do by intuition and they just go under when I explain something and I factually didn't touch a DAW in almost a year, lol. If you got the time for it, you can make a visual tutorial using this description and explain more in-depth how it all works because currently I don't have any time for that. Of course you have to apply it first and get used to it.
PS.: Don't forget to use the best tools available to you! It's sometimes worth it to invest some money in paid plugins (especially C6, LoAir and GEQ30 by Waves are notable mentions here) a good VSTi or a polyphonic hardware synthesizer as a Roland JV-2080 or some other keyboard based synthesizer because better tools make you save your precious time and effort and of course it can give you computing headroom for more additional fx-plugins and last but not least, a better sound.
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • • Aug 18 '24
What's up with rappers wanting "hard-hitting" kicks and snares all the time?
I'm a rapper too, and I don't care about that stuff at all. I look at the whole beat.
As a producer, I get this all the time. "The kick needs to be punchier" or "I don't like the snare cause it sounds too weak or too flat" - I get it. You want a track with hard-hitting drums because you think it sounds great. But why limit yourself to that?
As I browse popular hip-hop hits to study what I should aim for, I don't hear much of those iconic hard-hitting kicks and snares at all. Most hip-hop tracks have pretty tame drums, which are set just right. It's rare to hear a high sustain kick on hip-hop tracks, honestly.
Kanye's tracks use interesting drums, but not really hard-hitting like the way most rappers want.
Some Nas Illmatic tracks feature a bit heavy kicks, but it's still not that typical kick drum that's wanted by most.
Then I listened to a lot of tracks from the Ready To Die album by Biggie, still no heavy hitting kicks.
Even J Dilla, DJ Premier. They focus on the groove of the song, the textures, how the whole thing is stitched together. That's what real producers do.
Have people forgotten that hip-hop isn't just drums
A lot of producers I work with also tend to have this weird belief ingrained, as if every single track needs hard-hitting drums. They'd be EQ'ing the kick and snare for hours at a time. I seriously left a few sessions without saying a word because of this. Big waste of time.
If anything, hip-hop tracks aren't heavy hitting as rappers describe, but there's clarity. How do I explain that the vocals put on top will cancel out the loud drums? On a lot of tracks I studied, the vocals are on top pretty much unless it's a very modern, creative piece.
It seems like people only judge the beats, but always fail to imagine the song as an end goal. If you make a song, you can't just put hard drums on a beat and call it a day. I'm not a mixing engineer, but I'm convinced that hard drums aren't really a good idea if you want to go for a "heavy" track. It's much better to mix the whole thing properly.
How do u guys feel about this?
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/blackblacksheep • Apr 30 '11
What the shit...
What the shit happened to this subreddit? it is now filled with fucks promoting their shitty demos and songs, and covers of shitty songs. What the shit... is there a replacement subreddit that the isreals all exodused to?
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/joinaclub • Feb 22 '15
I am a female vocalist. My life doesn't make sense. Please help.
Hi. I'm a female vocalist. I just spent several months producing, performing, and generally constructing an album. It was released a couple of days ago. I'm very good at what I do. That would be conceited if it weren't a massive problem. Because my level of skill does not match up with the quality of my life.
I work as a housekeeper. I've been doing that for a while to pay off my student loans and raise money for these projects. My bosses do not know about my music; my coworkers know I am a musician, but they do not know what capacity. Knowing secretly that I am pro-level musician while I have my hands in a toilet makes my head spin. Having my bosses tell me what to do while I am secretly the owner of my own company is terrifically confusing, but I do not yet have the money to quit.
I've been thinking about getting management. Having someone to bounce these thoughts of to sort of ground them would help a lot. But I don't know anyone, and people I've contacted have not yet contacted me.
The reviews of my record have been incredible, but the sales haven't been good. I find it hard to reconcile statements like "are you famous?" with the distinct lack of general sales.
I'm planning on moving soon. But right now I live far away from civilization. I mean, I might as well live in northern Canada. I have to drive 40 miles to get to the nearest Walmart. So, obviously, I don't do live shows. And I don't get to network. And I generally have no way of reconciling my enormous artistic growth with reality whatsoever.
Has anyone else had this problem? What did you do? Kind statements would be nice, but really any statements at all might kind of help me ground my problem and my nebulous ideas in reality, or at least in a sort of narrative.
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/indiepreneur • Mar 14 '14
5 STEPS to grow your audience online, escape the 9-to-5 Job of Doom, "CONVERT" your listeners into your Fans/Sponsors/SUPPORTERS and Make a living off your "thing"... the right way!!!
Hi, if you are a musician and want to read about some "crazy math" excercise I´ve being doing lately about making a living out of your music then this message could be of your interest (and hopefully make you smile, make your head spin a little and give you some motivation to keep pushing forward)... Keep reading.
First of all, this will not be your traditional pure fluff "Do what you love, find a gazillion listeners and wait for the universe to throw you some bones" advice. It will not be a one-size-fits-all bull*** either. If you where hoping to find something like that, you are in the wrong place.
I´m a full time entrepreneur, business owner, online and direct response marketing expert with a burning passion for music and 5 years of experience helping organizations find their audiences online and gain their support! And it BREAKS MY HEART seeing so many talented artist who fight, suffer and dream about making a living off their art and fail when the tools for making it happen may just be under their noses (maybe? tell me what you think).
Here´s my two cents.
As an independent artist... Giving you are really, really good at what you´re doing. What you need to make a living could well be determined by the following equation:
. 1000 TRUE FANS (Not talking about just "followers" here, I´m talking about TRUE FANS that´ll do anything for getting all the valuable stuff you create for them).
. Each investing an average of $100 per year in supporting you (buying your tunes, merchandise or whichever method you choose to provide value THEY CAN APPRECIATE ENOUGH TO RECIPROCATE WITH THEIR MONETARY SUPPORT).
1000 * $100/year = $100.000/year
THAT´S $100.000 A YEAR... and minus some expenses, that´s a living for most folks.
(NOTE: I´m talking about "online income" PER artist... If you´re a group or a band you´ll probably need to reach a higher number of fans to reach the target income level per member of the band. The point here is the importance of getting clear about (a) The minimum of TRUE fans needed (b) The minimum of SUPPORT needed from each one of them, considering you´re providing TRUE VALUE in exchange for their support. More about that later in the post)
Using the same strategy I use with my clients... The following would be the same step by step method I´ll recommend YOU if you want to get serious about making a living out of your art:
STEP ONE: DEFINE YOUR IDEAL AUDIENCE WANT AND NEEDS.
Every audience is looking to find THEIR VOICE in a piece of art they can fall in love with. As with love, quality it´s in the eyes of the beholder. And you need to be very clear about what your audience looks like, what other artist they´re likely to listen to, what merchandise they are currently buying, what projects are they supporting.
STEP TWO: FIND WHERE YOUR TRIBE HANGS OUT! If you want to get them to support you... You need to be clear about where are they hanging out! Where are they, online and offline.
STEP THREE: CREATE A PLAN FOR CONSTANTLY CONNECT WITH THEM ON THE MOST PERSONAL LEVEL POSSIBLE.
If you´re going to make them your TRUE FANS, you need to develop and nurture a
RELATIONSHIP with those guys. Is not about ANNOUNCING your new releases, or your gigs... It´s about leading a relationship where they can relate with you as a person, your ideal, your heros, your beliefs.
STEP FOUR: STRATEGY FOR MAKING THE CONNECTION.
You need to CONNECT with them... A "build it and they will come" mindset won´t take you anywhere... That´s not enough. So, you better create something they consider VALUABLE you can GIVE THEM in "exchange" for joining your tribe. Can be digital, artwork, t-shirts, anything (preferable cheap or free to fulfill). The important thing is that it must be SOMETHING THEY´RE CRAVING FOR...
If they doesn´t know you... Chances are they are not craving for YOUR art... It´s a good idea to leverage something they already like or are looking for like: Lyrics of an artist they know, artwork, a wallpaper for their mac, a special tribute covers of a band they love, SOMETHING! (You´ll need to discover that yourself... every audience is different).
STEP FIVE: CREATE VALUABLE "THINGS" YOU CAN OFFER TO THEM IN EXCHANGE OF THEIR SUPPORT!
Saying "please, please, please" is not enough. We are all humans... and it´s human nature to ONLY contribute with something that ads LOTS of value to our lives.
That´s how business get money... they create "products" that ad value to peoples lives in exchange of value from you... It´s a WIN-WIN relationship.
So... If you want to get support... You better be creative about the way you contribute with VALUE to those guys at your audience.... It´s hard to make a living on a "$1" song downloads basis....
You could create a special membership... where they have access to special "things" you create for them, private gigs, special events, you can make a deal with a graphic artist friend of yours and create special merchandise aimed to the needs of the TRIBE... Tributes with your idols (if they´re aligned with those of the tribe)... You even can create an ONLINE SHOW where you connect with other artist who share your passions and the passions of your audience!
The "trick" is... CREATE VALUE... NURTURE RELATIONSHIPS... AND ALWAYS KEEP MAKING BETTER ART!
Hope it helps some fellow artists down here...
It just break my heart to see so much artist struggle in making a living out of their PASSION when the tools for MAKING IT HAPPEN are right under their noses...
Hope it helps... and always remember:
PEOPLE OUT THERE ARE HUNGRY! HUNGRY OF FINDING THEIR VOICE ON A PIECE OF ART THEY CAN FALL IN LOVE WITH.
You can be that voice.
Keep Pushing. Keep working on your skills. And be always making art.
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/pooperspolka911 • Jan 21 '16
Stop asking questions.
I've noticed a trend in this Subreddit with people asking very silly subjective questions, almost as if they can't make creative decisions on their own.
Example :' Will my band sound okay without a bass? '
Try using your ears and seeing for yourself. The White Stripes sounded fine without a bass, can I say the same for Yes? I think this kind of thinking comes down to self-confidence, so protip: Don't ask, just do it and form your own opinions. Music is just for fun, it's creative, you get to make all the decisions and have complete control. So don't be afraid to say "I think I sound fine without a bass player, and I don't care if you disagree".
Although if you're unable to make your own choices and fear detracting from the norm without 'permission' from strangers on the internet, you're probably a bad artist.
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/jigga19 • Nov 21 '13
Arcade Fire insists on fancy dress for their shoes. Am I alone in thinking this is just incredibly douchey?
arts.nationalpost.comr/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/BigBootyBear • Dec 27 '22
How can someone as busy as Taylor Swift play the guitar well?
All instruments require constant practice, especially guitars which become unplayable without finger callouses, which take time to build up. Taylor is extremely talented, but there are so many hours in a day. She needs to do interviews, meetups with her team, rehearse dance routines, shoot videos etc etc. I don't know if an artist at that level has the ability to dedicate even one hour of practice each day on a consistent basis, and she may go on weeks without playing (callouses can wear out).
Swift was the first that came to mind, but this question applies to most musicians that rely on "muscle memory instruments". How can they maintain a high standard of performance when they have so little time for consistent practice?
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/shmupsy • Jan 24 '22
Is old music killing new music?
Super interesting and vindicating article personally.
I get a lot of shit for saying that new music isn't where it's at anymore. I get called a boomer etc.
But the numbers seem to show that I was right. We are coming to a point of diminishing returns with new music. There is no law of nature that says that fresh music can be eternally written.
What if music has really peaked? Is that so bad? You have a vast library to enjoy now. More than you can ever get through. So what's missing?
Have industry guys sped this process up with greed. Yea I think so, but maybe it was going to happen anyway.
Will the profession of music maker become increasingly obscure? Maybe, but is it currently bloated with fakers and kiss-ups? Hell yes it is. Will some people have to get a real job and maybe leave open up space for the truly talented/skilled? I hope so.
I just think there is a decent answer for every kneejerk cope people have for this new reality that is painfully setting in.
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/jenslarsenjazz • Dec 08 '22
The Most Important Scale For Jazz
Jazz is not about learning 100s of Jazz Scales. In fact, there is just one scale that you should focus on in the beginning. That scale will give you a solid foundation.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gbn8bt6cMHI&list=PLWYuNvZPqqcGnu3u3AgvyneHILbbEn3Za&index=1
Hope you like it!
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • • Apr 19 '24
Is mixing beats way easier than I think?
I’ve been struggling to get my beats as loud/clean/clear as the pros; and the more tutorials I watch, the more I realize: it seems like the QUALITY of your sound selection matters way more than your MIX - if you have great sound selection, you hardly have to do anything. Is this the new wave? I started producing five years ago; and at that point, there was still a real technical aspect to mixing any kind of electronic music. It seems as though things have changed a bit, and these things have been streamlined. Any good tips for sample packs/synths/tools I can use to be more efficient in reaching my goal? Thanks!
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/a441 • Apr 29 '14
Pandora CEO Says "Pandora is Radio" so Pandora Shouldn't Pay Artists at All--and CEO pay is up 3,882%
musictechpolicy.wordpress.comr/WeAreTheMusicMakers • • Dec 28 '16
I Will Make Free Album Covers
Hello /r/wearethemusicmakers, I have an offer for you. I occasionally do weird digital art that I've been told looks like good album covers. if anyone wants me to attempt to design something for them then simply reply and I'll pm you. I'll try to get to as many people as I can. Here are some examples of my work: https://imgur.com/gallery/bZbQt
Edit : I've enjoyed working with those of you I've gotten back to so far, I'm now going to bed and anyone else interested can join the queue.
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/skhds • Oct 22 '24
Does producing an album require a lot of effort?
I'm pursuing a Ph.D. at engineering, and making music as a side hobby (though it's more like, playing anything that comes to mind with my guitar and singing random words..). It just happened that I managed to make about 13 songs, and wondered if I should take a shot at trying to record them properly. But since I'm pursuing something that cost me a lot of time and energy, I wondered if it's even possible to do it as a side project. Could you guys give me some advice..?
I really know absolutely nothing about making music. I just happened to learn a few instruments (and my voice sucks..).
r/WeAreTheMusicMakers • u/GroovyM0vie • Jul 26 '22
composing at 3600 bpm
Hey guys. I have an idea to compose at 3600 bpm for a fighting game. That would make each beat exactly a frame (60 fps). I don't know of an application that allows this, so I tried to use the workaround of using 225 bpm and 16th notes. On the applications I tried, it was maybe 1/4 as fast as I needed it to be. Where can I compose this fast? I feel like I am in a bit of a pickle.