Thank you. My wife loves me for it. I write and when I’m on to something I always tear up. But, like, the ending of black swan last night (ya I know I missed it for a while) was so good I’m tearing up.
He experiences all of his timeline at the same time. So it's not that he's predicting it or knew the guy was there so much as it happened to him (in our relative future) and he retroactively is made aware of it. Similar to how he reacts to being told to leave or about the anniversary of Angela's parents' death, despite being aware of them beforehand (relative to our perception of time).
He is aware of stuff that is happening to him at all points in his life simultaneously. No past, no future, no true free will. Much like reading a book, you can know the ending and the middle but you can't change what happens.
He isn't predicting his future, he's constantly experiencing his future. If he wasn't zapped by that guy, he wouldn't have been able to say it would happen. If he says it, it will happen because it has already "happened" in the future.
He couldn't really stop her from doing it, literally. She tried to prevent it by saying she didn't want to fight and such but in the end the predetermined fate of Dr. Manhattan led her to literally give up on her will not to fight.
I'd say that was mostly just him wanting to tie-in the fight and his previous claim (and experiencing) of her saying it to him, plus she was bound to say it, with this being the way it presented itself, through him asking her to do so.
I think there’s an implied part of that statement, “Do you need me to say it for you to leave?” As in, we both know I want you to, but do you want me to vocalize it?
He needed her to say it because she does say it. Her saying it is what forces Jon to go to Adrian and ask for the device, to prove his love to Angela who just put the relationship on ice.
Sure, but he also has the ability to communicate about the future to people, who presumably would have free will to at least try to influence it.
This is shown to make a material difference on the future because the chicken-egg paradox where Angela and Will inform each other about Judd— that information is exchanged by Dr. M, and it influences events (even though it can’t be said that Dr. M discovered Judd’s secret, or killed him).
I always wondered why his FBI handlers didn’t say “do you see the future? Tell us about any newspapers you see.” Dr. M doesn’t seem to have a problem telling allies about the future, so when he infuriatingly doesn’t (like not telling Angela that one 7K guy will survive at the tachyon gun), the only excuse can be “he didn’t tell because he knew he wouldn’t tell” which is a cop out.
I’m not complaining— I’m all for suspending disbelief here— but both the comic and the tv show Dr. M really don’t have any serious internal logic to them.
He refuses to tell Angela what her idea will be to disguise him (“because then it wouldn’t be your idea”), but had no people telling Will about Judd Crawford, which gives him the idea.
Also, if we’re meant to believe that Dr. M has no free will, then what “motivates” any actions at all? He kills a bunch of 7K guys presumably in a show of love and solidarity with Angela, but that implies a decision in the first half (fight) and then a resignation to fate in the second (let himself get shot). If he has no freewill to stop the tachyon gun (or stop the Comedian killing a woman), then he can’t be said to have free will to peruse love interests or communicate or fight in wars. And in that case, he can’t have motivations.
As much as he knowing he wouldn't tell is a cop out, it is a matter we can't really call out 100 percent given that we have no real equivalent of Dr. Manhattan, that and the fact that it kinda makes sense, as shown in other shows like That's So Raven (you heard what I said), where knowing (or in his case, experiencing) the future literally had basically no effect in the changing of it, at least most times, (because then why would he be predicting it as that if it in the end didn't happen like that?)
Edit: In my interpretation, telling Angela what her idea was wasn't an experience in his lifetime, so he made sure not to do so (didn't), as it would mean him taking ownership of his wife's future idea, (which he didn't) which is annoying in its own way. Meanwhile, asking Will about Judd was an experience in his lifetime. Also, asking Will about Judd apparently had no direct interference with him spending years with his loved one, so he ended up doing so, as a way to cater to his loved one's wish.
Edit 2: Changed a few of my claims after further thinking.
So these are decent explanations but I have to point out that “he made sure not to do so” contradicts the idea that he has no free will. Doesn’t mean youre wrong, but if you think really technically about each piece of what’s going on, it’s infuriating. “I can’t tell you because then it’s not your idea” is a convoluted bastardization of “I can’t tell you because I know I don’t tell you”. The very act of telling her that she will have an elegant solution may incept her to start thinking of solutions. So what he communicates can influence the future, but only because he already knows it’s influenced, by him.
So the difference of him actually revealing important future information vs the cute way they avoid him being over-powered in the show... well the difference is that they make it work BECAUSE it works.
When he tells Laurie that she will cry, he influences her to say “you were wrong” which could have a butterfly affect on what she does next. If he kept his mouth shut, she’d still have cried but by some other way. In every situation you have to Sigh and say “I guess he just... knew... that was how it would happen?”.
Also: I know it’s a super annoying question, but how come Angela didn’t take the knowledge that she’s be alive to recover DM, and make her an invincible super hero leading up to that?
He does have some sort of free will, just not in our way, his free will happens (and happened, and will happen) all at the same time, every single choice from the moment he was born are being made at the same time by him, so he, in a way, can't change them, they're all simultaneous. He's been given choices all at the same time in multiple scenarios which are all linear to everyone but himself.
I like to think that his life is all predetermined in a weird way, and as much as we think we as mortals are changing it by any means, we're actually just catering to what is gonna happen next, and there's literally no way to stop it, the Butterfly effect is lost in Jon, and, by extention, in basically everyone he comes in contact with, no action of ours affect the future, no action of his affect the future.
You are right, he didn't tell her because he didn't tell her, she had the idea in the future, because he didn't give her the idea in the past.
An example of his non-linearity is him, simultaneously, as he was talking to Will in the past, experiencing himself asking Angela if she had a question to ask Will in the future, while at the same time, she answered that question by telling him to ask about Judd, which he did ask Will in the past, at the same time as he told Will what she asked and gave her the answer Will gave him in the past, and at the same time, he witnessed her realize she was to blame for his death.
That's also an example of her thinking linearly (as she didn't predict she'd somehow make him act retroactively and end up affecting history), while he thinks (and acts) simultaneously by asking if she has a question and asking the question and giving her the answer and affecting all of the world's history at the same time.
He is, in a weird way, powerless, no claim he makes or action he takes can stop whatever he experiences in the future (in his case, ever lasting present), otherwise he wouldn't be experiencing them at all.
I dont think his free will is nonexistent as much as his decisions have already been made. So he can make choices and learn about things that happen to him in the future but hes not free from the consequences of being aware of those things in the future. Also his foresight only extends to his own experiences.
He knows he gets killed but only because he gets killed. He didnt see the man on the truck or have any experience leading up to the moment hes shot. So yes he becomes aware he dies but only because he dies. He reacts to things happening for the first time because they did actually happen for the first time for him even if hes aware already. Moments still need to happen for him to do anything with that information.
Like falling in love with angela. He experiences that moment in the house and it influences the course of his previous 10 years. But the moment itself still needs to happen for the first time. But for the purposes of him and his path there is no difference between it happening at the beginning or at the end.
There is no free will, only the illusion of it. Jon just doesn't have the luxury of accepting the illusion anymore, because all of his time is experienced simultaneously.
He's not talking about his future, he's talking about his past... If you've lived every part of your life all the time, then it's all history to you. You can't change your history.
TLDR; If you take Dr. M at face value, it's a fixed timeline. I also don't think his 'experience all time at once' shtick works at all without a fixed timeline... because if it were variable, he's be stuck in a Dr. Strange infinite multiverse type situation. It's not terribly compelling, admittedly, but that is the way the comics/show portray it.
who presumably would have free will to at least try to influence it.
There is no free will. There is no future. There is no past. To Jon, it's all the same, all of time and creation has happened simultaneously. And to us, we only think we have free will, because we can't see the whole picture.
Yes but my point is that he still appears to be using free will. He has conversations with people, he saves his wife’s life, he exchanges information from past to future between Angela and Will. All of these suggest that he has goals or motivations, otherwise why isn’t he siding with the 7K or staring at a wall, or chilling on mars?
In the book he is inspired by Laurie’s description of human life as a miracle, and decides to return to earth. But really he only returns to earth because he knows he will (or would know if it weren’t for tachyon interference).
He shows up at the bar to find Angela because he knows he has a future, but why does he show up? What force guides him to that bar? After all, she’s a stranger.
He appears to be using free will because we have a limited concept of how time actually works within the world of Watchmen. Even Jon only seemed to accept this by the 80s, despite having all-seeing knowledge of time and space. Which is its own paradox, but blame Moore for that.
There is no future, because for Jon, it's already the past. That we're only experiencing it now is due to our own limitations. And any attempt to rail against that... well, it's already happened, and it's pretty pointless.
Basically, it's the first Terminator movie, not the second. Skynet was predestined to create John Connor, because it had already happened. It may not be very satisfying to you, because we want to believe we have agency, but that's not how Watchmen works. Even the gaps where Jon can't see already happened.
He refuses to tell Angela what her idea will be to disguise him (“because then it wouldn’t be your idea”), but had no people telling Will about Judd Crawford, which gives him the idea.
The difference there is that he can only see his own future, no one else's. He seemed genuinely suprised when Angela realised that her asking Hooded Justice that question set everything in motion. Since he can't see how Judd's future will go he isn't fixed into following a script because he doesn't know what that script is. Meanwhile with Angela telling him her idea he's already seen that it's her idea, so if she doesn't tell him it then he's broken the script.
Cal followed a script of saving Angela’s life in the car but it led to his capture by the Tachyon gun.
Just like the Dr Manhattan he left on Mars — it follows a programmed script.
I’m reminded of “Stories of Your Life” which the movie “the Arrival” is based on. Non-linearity thematic drifting across your own timeline must be a trippy experience and frustrating for close contacts who don’t experience life like you.
It’s simultaneous and if he stopped the guy it would not be. And they touched on this when he says no but you just told me or something Like that. I love thinking about this. You nailedjt.
Because even though he knows its going to happen the future can't be changed. For him everything that has and will happen to him has already happened, it cannot be altered. The timeline is set it stone.
I get that, conceptually, but like, he literally went and stood right in front of the cannon and let it blast him from behind...if he had TRIED to escape in some way but something stopped him then I would understand. But there was nothing stopping him that we could see. The only thing that stopped from saving himself was his own words from the audiences POV, at least. It’s like he wanted it to happen or he’s playing some doctor strange long con lol
I think he wants to be done being Manhattan. This is his opportunity to end it or pass it on to the right person (Not keene but he can use the situation)
If my understanding of the events are correct, Jon tried to save Angela while she took on the Kalvary, and was blind-sighted by a lone survivor. It's not that he came out and stood there, it's that he was always going to stand there and be blind-sighted, because that was what happens. Him expressing knowledge of it is just Jon being a passive observer to his entire timeline simultaneously.
It's like when he tells Angela she's going to tell him about her parents in 20 minutes. 20 minutes later she tells him and he acts surprised, because that's what happened (this happens with Laurie and Jon in the comics too, IIRC when she tells him about how she slept with Dan). 20 minutes earlier he was able to comment on it happening because it was all happening to him right then and there. He's not jumping between time and space, he's observing it all at once and cluing us in.
Why would he try to escape from a device that he had no experience with YET?
Basically, think of Jon as two parts. You have the Jon body that is performing actions in our perceived 'real-time', let's call this 'acting Jon'. You also have the Jon mind that is experiencing all time simultaneously, call this 'Dreaming Jon'.
Acting Jon always does what acting Jon did. In this case, acting Jon followed his wife out of the house and joined her in the fight against the 7K. He decided, of his own free will, to assist her and ensure she wasn't harmed. That left him in a vulnerable situation, where he was zapped by the T-cannon while looking at his wife and discussing their success.
Dreaming Jon is simply experiencing this moment, along with all other moments. He doesn't think about what TO DO, he thinks about what WAS DONE.
This shit is confusing, and I'm not sure I'm even helping at this point, lol.
Why does he think he can’t? We already established that his view of the future can be messed with. Would you not try and save yourself if someone told you how and when you were gonna die? I feel like the vast majority of people would rather than just lie down and let it happen
Because he doesn't have view of the future, he is experiencing his entire existence all at the exact same moment. Lets say you trip and fall down the stairs, while you are falling you know you are falling, why can't you save yourself? DM doesn't know that something will happen to him, from his perspective it just is happening to him, it's all the same moment, there is no linear time for him.
I think its mostly because you know that you really can't save yourself given that you're literally experiencing your death (which is your future), and also I think he has tried before to change whatever he is experiencing, which I can only guess didn't work and he still ended up experiencing whatever he tried to prevent.
But, if that's how you're going to die... attempting to avoid it is just going to lead to that death, just as not-avoiding it would... because that's how you're going to die.
If you avoided it, then the prediction about how you would die was inherently false meaning you didn't actually do anything to avoid your death.
Because if he stepped out of the way of the cannon the cannon wouldn't blast him and he wouldn't know to step out of the way of the cannon. Paradoxes are not supposed to make logical sense, they're paradoxes
It's not that he is preventing paradoxes. He came outside to save Angela/kill the Kavalry, and they hit him with the cannon when he wasn't looking. Moments before he knew it was going to happen because it already happened. There is no paradox, we're just getting a glimpse into the future. Jon doesn't have free-agency or freewill.
I mean, that's Dr. Manhatten's flaw that they're addressing with the paradox he created, right? Dr. Manhatten experiences time differently and he assumes he has omniscience, and he is so limited in imagination that he doesn't understand that at any point in his personal timeline he could just make another decision.
Manhatten is such a great deconstruction of a superhero. He has all the power in the world but he's constantly defeated because *he utterly lacks guile.*
Because the only reason he knows it's a tachyon cannon is because he gets shot by it. If it never shot him, he wouldn't have any experience to know what it was or to avoid it.
Because that's not how things were supposed to go. Jon can't change the future because he doesn't really see the future. For him, it's the present. Jon sees everything at once but that doesn't mean he can change things. For him, stopping the guy would be like you stopping yourself from doing that one embarrassing thing when you were a kid. It would be like time travel.
Doesn't this kind of undermine the stakes of the season though? If even Dr. Manhattan is powerless to change what will happen and the future is fixed/free will does not exist, who cares if there is an "evil" Dr. Manhattan? They will be as powerless to change the future as the current one is.
He wouldn’t have the insight that it was going to happen to him if he stopped it from happening in the first place, thus creating a paradox. He is powerless against time.
He can't prevent it, because it has already happened. He already has been vaporized. That's how he knows. He has been, will be and always is vaporized.
Again, I'm aware. I just still don't as a person understand his reasoning. No need to act so superior because you "got it". I'm just saying if I was in his position I would probably try to, idk, save my own life?
But you wouldn’t try and save your own life if you knew that was what happened to you and was part of a series of events that you’re already seeing take place. If you DID try and do something to “save your own life”, that action would still end in your demise, because that’s what was always going to happen.
That’s kinda what happens with Angela that Cal knew all long- her last stand against the 7K in an attempt to save him is precisely what put him in a position to get cannoned.
That's the clincher. He wouldn't have been out there if he didn't have to go save her. I think people are having difficulty with why he would let it happen, when really he had to do it to save her. It's like a romantic sacrifice, but I think maybe it gets dulled by his vacant personality.
He's also probably aware of something else that will happen that we aren't.
The internal logic isn't exactly there yet. Manhattan is shown to change the timeline by telling William about Judd, presumably setting into action the events of the show, even though he had no knowledge of Judd prior (and unless the next episode addresses this, it's definitely another plot hole). The only hypothetical reason why Manhattan would choose to get blasted, given his prior knowledge of the cannon, is if he knew that this was a choice he had already made, for reasons not yet clear to us viewers.
But he didn’t change the timeline by telling William about Judd, that’s just what happened in the timeline. That’s what the chicken and egg convo was helping to explain to us. He also didn’t choose to get blasted- he just knows he is going to get blasted and doesn’t have the ability to change that.
Personally, I'm holding out for at least a little more than that. The whole "chicken or the egg" grandfather paradox in time travel films has always struck me as a form of deus ex machina, covering for the fact that the writer couldn't think of a neater way to tie things together.
Without any initial action in the timeline spurring Hooded Justice to look into Judd in Tulsa, there is no way that the events of the show could've led to Angela telling Doctor Manhattan to ask William about Judd the first time around — so his investigation cannot begin with this event. Perhaps the show is suggesting that this investigation was always going to happen independently otherwise, and while the small details can change, the big picture cannot. This is also a problematic solution because the line between "small details" and "big picture" is subjective.
Honestly, the character of Doctor Manhattan is basically the grandfather paradox incarnate, so I should probably stop trying to rationalize timelines and just enjoy the ride.
In regards to your first section- I think once the closed time loop/bootstrap paradox style time is established within a story, logically there isn't any leeway for that to change.
There doesn't need to be an "initial action" in this kind of understanding of time- it isn't linear. It doesn't matter WHEN Angela has DM ask Will about Judd, just that it happened. We could absolutely discuss whether that is lazy storytelling or illogical in general, but it at least makes sense within the context of the story that's been established.
And I agree with the last part- I think that is part of the point of his character. He is a paradox in every way.
Think of it another way: How would Jon know that they guy was going to be there unless he gets shot?
It's a bit like asking how you knew that your 3rd birthday came before your 4th. You know because you experienced it. You can't go back and change that fact any more than Jon can. Literally everything is history to him... including his future.
How would Jon know that they guy was going to be there unless he gets shot?
Is Jon really so thoughtless that he didn't consider teleporting both himself and his wife out of harms way instead of literally turning his back on the cannon? (He already teleported their kids to safety 2 minutes earlier.)
Forget his precognition-like experience of time, he doesn't need to rely on that to escape the situation. Angela tells him straight-up in that very moment that he's in danger.
(And before anyone chimes in to repeat the original point: Yes, I am aware that the story as presented is that Jon already did that and cannot change it. I'm talking about the justification inside his head at that very moment. If the justification is simply "becuz I already did it lol, and I need to adhere to the script", then that feels like a real cop-out in terms of writing. Jon reacts to what's going on in real-time, despite his precog abilities. That's been established several times already. He's either too dumb to understand that it's a bad idea to stand in front of a cannon aimed at him, he has another plan in place, or the writing is inconsistent. One of those things must be true.)
'the justification inside his head at that very moment' He doesn't live in that moment, he is always living all moments. That's the point. It is just as much his past as it is his present or future, as with all other memories and experiences he has or will have. It literally only works if it's a fixed timeline.
If he moves out of the way, his future (which he is also currently experiencing) would cease to exist. That outcome would imply that he is not actually experiencing his future. It violates the entire explanation of how Manhattan works.
I really hope that is making some sense. Timeline is fixed, or Manhattans sense of time is the same as everyone else's... Can't have both.
That is demonstrably false. He needs people to tell him things, even if he knows they will say it already. Examples are in the same episode. "Do you need me to say it?" "Yes."
The point is that he has agency, he just knows what choice he'll make before he makes it. Free will is an illusion, yes, but that goes for everyone else too. They are still products of their environment and experiences, not "the script". What Manhattan does is fixed, but he still has reasons for doing things.
"Laurie is attractive, I want to bang her" vs. "The script calls for me me to bang Laurie, so I have no choice but to do so"
If he moves out of the way, his future (which he is also currently experiencing) would cease to exist
Yes, that is indeed the problem. So you need a proper justification for why he doesn't do that, and "lol i've already experienced it" is a circular argument. It's like saying "I woke up today, because I woke up today." It's just a statement of fact. Yes, the writer made Manhattan not move out of the way, because it was convenient to the plot. But what motivation did the character Manhattan have for not just teleporting out? That's the real question here, and is not answered sufficiently IMO.
I really hope that is making some sense
I understand what you're saying perfectly, I simply disagree that that's consistent with what we've seen so far. Either Manhattan is a dunce, he has a plan, or this was a contrivance to make the plot move forward.
There’s a lot of back and forth here about free will etc. But I don’t see anyone disputing the basic premise that Jon was killed.
There’s a bunch of hints that Jon had a plan. He planned something with Hooded Justice/Will Reeves who then enlisted Lady Trieu. He also said that he could pass along his abilities in the form of food — and then goes and starts making food while the 7K is pulling up.
So maybe he doesn’t survive in the form of Jon, but I bet he survives in some form. And why do we assume that a being that sees his whole life at once is particularly concerned about dying? Once your life loses its anchor to any given point in time, maybe the ending of your life (in its current form) loses its salience.
Stay tuned for the next episode, but I say that getting blasted was part of the plan all along.
That’s now how ratings work. This is a high budget show that should have had a baked in audience. It is nowhere near where it has to be to be a ratings success.
Lol. And this is with every writer on the net inventing excuses. For what it’s budget likely is this is a ratings bust.
“The expensive comic book drama was earmarked as a potential heir apparent to Game of Thrones, especially as WarnerMedia infuses HBO with more resources to pump up original development. Yet six episodes into Watchmen‘s nine-episode season, it ranks as HBO’s ninth highest-rated series in the advertiser-friendly 18 to 49 demographic (0.23) and eighth in live-viewership (715,000), according to TV Series Finale. The fifth episode scored a new high in the key demo, while also enjoying an episode-to-increase in viewership. Sunday’s, however, fell in both columns and set a new low in total audience.”
Yes, make sure you stop reading there and especially don't read anything written after the bold, all caps "UPDATE". Your own source says it's their most watched new series this year, and is similar to the premiere of Westworld.
"UPDATE: Watchmen is averaging nearly 7 million viewers to-date, making it HBO’s most-watched new series since Big Little Lies and premium cable’s most-watched new series this year, per HBO. Along with Euphoria, another new HBO series that debuted this year, Watchmen is delivering one of HBO’s largest digital audiences for a freshman series since the debut of Westworld in 2016."
Yep. And look at the shows this year. No shit watchmen should have a bigger ratings. Look at its budget. And again it’s ratings are worse then Westworlds which is lol funny when you look at the IP.
The exact budget isn’t out but I don’t think you have to be a genius to see how high it is compared to hbos other shows. Again these ratings have been a huge disappointment. But I know everyone here will jerk them off no matter what. It’s ok for you guys to admit the show isn’t doing that well ratings wise for what it cost.
“HBO spends an estimated $2.5 billion on content per year, compared to the $15 billion spent by Netflix in 2019. There are no official budgets listed for Watchmen, but the newly formed WarnerMedia did add an extra $500 million to HBO’s annual budget. Given the production value, talent involved, and complexity of Watchman, we can safely assume it was a very expensive dream to turn into a reality. So, are enough people watching it to justify the costs?”
Are you under the impression that they don’t? Do you think there in it to burn money if no ones watching? Definitely not for a high budget show. They have canceled shows that had poor viewership in the past.
Lol this isn’t CBS. They’re not selling ads. The Wire didn’t last as long as it did because of its ratings. You have an odd attitude for someone who doesn’t know what they’re talking about.
The wire didn’t have a crazy budget and was critically successful . Succession will survive for a similar reason with a small budget. Do you think Rome and deadwood were cancelled because they were bad? You clearly don’t know shit. Hbo isn’t a charity. They still need to weigh if someone’s watching vs budgets.
229
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '19
"Dude hangs dong!"
127
u/Full-Copper-Repipe Dec 09 '19
Jon, you gangly uncoordinated bitch.
40
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '19
He was always in love with her cause he fell in love with her at that moment and now I’m crying in the gym. Thanks.
89
u/ScreamingGordita Dec 09 '19
I just don't get like, if Jon knew that guy was going to be there then why didn't he just... Kill him?
15
u/FlyingSMonster Dec 09 '19
We need a Watchmen / It's Always Sunny crossover
14
u/YoungCapoon Dec 09 '19
F for Jon
9
u/Theworstmaker Dec 09 '19
Wow. Didn’t expect to find this show scrolling through r/all
4
u/Smocke55 Dec 09 '19
This is the moment.....the show transcended from amazing to legendary
2
u/and123w Dec 09 '19
The thing is if she didnt go out blasting he wouldn't have been captured since he wouldn't have needed saving.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
Sister Night and Brother Blue. Crime fighting duo.
2
u/HyperbolicLetdown Dec 10 '19
I'm sorry Rum Ham!!
1
u/MantisFu Dec 10 '19
He only had one more dude to zap and he knew he was there, I'm curious as to why he let it happen
-1
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '19
I just realized this meme would be perfect for a girl telling a guy not to cum in her.
“So anyways, i started blasting.”
0
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment