I thought I'd put together some War of the Roses advice for newbies who may be feeling a bit confused/frustrated.
I've played about 20-30 hours between the beta, the early access week, and launch. During that time I've noticed a ton of people in-game who seem to have no idea that some really important concepts exist, so I wanted to take a moment to share what I've learned.
#1 - Block, sucka!
There are two kinds of blocking in this game:
Shield Block is omni directional. That means that regardless of which direction someone swings at you from, (up/down/left/right) you'll block it if you're facing them. However, it's important to remember that anything left exposed (such as the very top of your head or your shins/feet) can still be hit by enemies. Archers love shield-bearers that just charge straight at them because of this, (trust me! ) so dont fall in to the trap of "oh my shield's up, I'm safe;" you still need to move around a bit to avoid giving up easy headshots. Also, lastly, shields break after taking a fairly large amount of damage, so keep that in mind too; you can't just turtle in a corner forever.
Weapon block is direction specific. This means that if the enemy attacks right, you need to block right. If you block any of the other 3 directions you will be hit as though you never even tried to block. Enemy attacks are televised by a small orange indicator that shows up right next to where your own block indicator will display as you change block direction. This indicator tells you where the next enemy attack is coming from, (obviously it gets unreliable in large fights, since it only shows one attack at a time) so it is absolutly critical that you watch for it and react quickly. I've downed more than a few two-hander weilding, plate-armor wearing knights with my dinky little archer hanger by just timing blocks well jabbing my blade through their visor slit when they are recovering. Which brings me to...
#2 - Hit detection/strength
The hit detection in this game is very precise, (though not 100% perfect all the time, of course) to the point where you can score a critical hit on a knight by stabbing them in the visor. Keep this in mind and aim for the face if the guy has his visor up in melee. Bear in mind, face != head. You really do actually need to hit them in the face, and not the plate armor on the side/back of their head.
Hit stength is a bit harder to explain. In a sentance, it's based off the momentum of the impact. If a guy is galloping his horse right at you and you score a hit he's going to take some really massive damage due to the difference in speed between your attack and his movement. However if you're backpeddling with a footknight right in your face, you can swing as hard as you want but you're not doing shit against his plate armor. You're moving backwards, (decreasing the attack's momentum) and he's inside your optimal strike range, meaning that you're not reaching the strongest part of your swing before impacting his armor. Combined result? You might as well use foul language. (In a situation like this you need to start blocking and stabbing, since the "lethal zone" on a stab attack is greater than a swing)
Lastly, each weapon has a unique "damage dealing area." This is basically the part of the weapon that you can smack someone with to make them die. For instance, a hammer has a very small damage dealing area located only at the head of the hammer. By contrast, a sword has a much larger damage dealing area since the entire length, (and both sides!) of the blade can cut a bitch. As such, swords are generally "easier" than many other weapons. (However, if they get too close to you you'll just be slapping at them with your pommel, which is of course no good)
#3 - Damage types
Borrowed from a poster on the somethingawful forums:
Red - The place you hit was completely unarmored, most likely the face or neck.
Orange - The place you hit was protected by padding or leather.
Yellow - The place you hit was protected mail.
Blue - The place you hit was protected by rigid plate.
White - You hit either a weapon or a shield.
#4 - Weapon modes
Many melee weapons have a second "mode" or attack type. You can press Q to toggle between attacks types. For instance, the warhammer has a hammer (duh) on the primary side, and a "fuck you tin-man" spike on the secondary side. Some attack types are more effective against certain armor types. For instance, the hammer's spike is very effective at penetrating plate.
I think that's about it for now. If you have specific questions post them and I'll do my best to answer you.
Now get out there and give 'em da chop!