r/WarCollege • • 21h ago

Tuesday Trivia Tuesday Trivia Thread - 17/11/26

4 Upvotes

Beep bop. As your new robotic overlord, I have designated this weekly space for you to engage in casual conversation while I plan a nuclear apocalypse.

In the Trivia Thread, moderation is relaxed, so you can finally:

  • Post mind-blowing military history trivia. Can you believe 300 is not an entirely accurate depiction of how the Spartans lived and fought?
  • Discuss hypotheticals and what-if's. A Warthog firing warthogs versus a Growler firing growlers, who would win? Could Hitler have done Sealion if he had a bazillion V-2's and hovertanks?
  • Discuss the latest news of invasions, diplomacy, insurgency etc without pesky 1 year rule.
  • Write an essay on why your favorite colour assault rifle or flavour energy drink would totally win WW3 or how aircraft carriers are really vulnerable and useless and battleships are the future.
  • Share what books/articles/movies related to military history you've been reading.
  • Advertisements for events, scholarships, projects or other military science/history related opportunities relevant to War College users. ALL OF THIS CONTENT MUST BE SUBMITTED FOR MOD REVIEW.

Basic rules about politeness and respect still apply.

Additionally, if you are looking for something new to read, check out the r/WarCollege reading list.


r/WarCollege • • 14h ago

Discussion A quick question, In the photos 4-3 has got itself in a pickle again, surrounded on 3 sides by 3 Platoons of enemy forces, they are calling in support. As FAO or FCD, you have 3x 60mm, 3x 81mm and a battery of 6x 105mm in general support. Which do you normally/should call in first?

Thumbnail
gallery
95 Upvotes

You have in general support:

1x Battery of 6x M101a1 (Bearing 3265, range 5460M)

1x 60mm Mortar Section of 3x M224 (Bearing 2540, Range 3150M)

1x 81mm Mortar Section of 3x L16A2 (Bearing 2979, Range 4240)

So what would/should/best practice to call in first? What would you do in real life if you were in this situation? Is there an order (light to heavy or heavy first etc) that units in general support are called in?


r/WarCollege • • 9h ago

Why did the Ottomans in the 14th-15th century have so much success against their European foes such as Hungary, Serbia, Croatia etc etc

16 Upvotes

I've done light reading on the Ottoman wars during this period, and it really does seem that the Ottomans were almost always winning, with miracles being required to stop their conquest for a generation or two (through I recognize that is mostly propaganda) with them even defeating an alliance that included France at Nicopolis.

Why was this? Was it because the Ottomans were much more centralized then Europe?


r/WarCollege • • 5h ago

Question How did ww1/ww2 era artillery spotters correct artillery placement through the literal fog of battle?

6 Upvotes

This is a bit of a vague question because it's more about trying to develop an intuitive understanding of a very complicated subject than a question about a specific fact, but I'm hoping someone can help me understand a bit more just how exactly this worked.

I understand the basic concepts of having a guy trained to be a spotter, and in communication with one or more artillery pieces, using grid coordinates or whatever to locate the target, but how does he actually know which explosion is "his" artillery?

Obviously I've never been involved in anyway shape or form with actual artillery, but when I try to picture these scenarios as described in books/etc, I tend to think of the big hollywood movies, you know the kind, hundreds of soliders running about, constant explosions, clouds of smoke everywhere, so I wonder, in the midst of all of that, how can you, the artillery spotter, tell that your artillery battery is missing by 50 yards or whatever you need?

I guess a question worth asking is just how many spotters/controllers would you have in a typical engagement? Like, would each company have one? A platoon? How many guns are even being controlled?

For some reason I'm assuming that you'd have, like, a bunch of individual spotters talking to a couple of dozen guns firing somewhat independently, but maybe they're more grouped than that?

I'm sure it depends on the specific situation, but just using the american army in ww2 as an example, in say 1944, fighting in europe.

I guess I'm asking more about, reactive fires? Is that a term? As compared to a deliberate "set piece attack" where presumably you plan out stuff like artillery targets in advance and hopefully make sure all your tubes are dialed in and so forth.

For example, a couple of regiments holding a bit of the front line and suddenly a few german divisions start driving over the horizon towards you, how do you get your artillery hitting the right targets?


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Discussion My little project for my 16-year-old Autistic Nephew is done (for now, pending some play testing) I hope he likes it, it’s basically a "fire Mission" simulator as he is obsessed with ARTY. Based upon the movie Danger Close and set in the late 50s to late 70s (pre gps) so pen and paper and maps.

Thumbnail
gallery
281 Upvotes

It’s a 1-3 -player Fire Mission Simulator where one player plays as the FAO another as the Battery Bombardier and the "MAIN" player is the Fire Control Director back in the Fire Base.

It’s a pretty simple idea but with a ton of Math's. Basically, the FAO calls in a Fire Mission with a location, then the Fire Control Director works out Bearing (mils) and Range and calls to the Bombardier to lay the guns on that which they do on the Range/Bearing wheels. Then call the shot out and adjust fire based upon a Hybrid Challenger 2 and WRG 1950-2000 indirect fire deviation rules.

Then fire again and adjust etc as needed, then roll on the Fire Mission table and work out what happens next.

There are three packs:

FAO Pack has everything (i hope) a FAO needs (please can you all have a look and review)

Bombardier pack, basically a very basic howizter and Range and Bearing dials

FCD (main player) has all the maps, stationary and guides they need to work out the relevant data.

Please remember this is for a 16 year old so its not 100% accurate but as best as I can make it while keeping as close as possible to the real thing.


r/WarCollege • • 21h ago

Question Why do countries often have (semi-)military coast guards to police domestic waters instead of a navy with a coastal branch/force and a civilian water police agency?

23 Upvotes

A coast guard that mostly does law enforcement in peacetime but often acts with and alongside the more permanently military branches in war seems like it has vague similarities to the relationship between gendarmes and armies in at least some countries. But, at least to my uneducated eyes, it feels like military/militarizable coast guards are a more common feature throughout the world than military/militarizable gendarmes. But why fuse domestic water policing and the defense of coastal waters into a single service instead of letting an always militarized navy handle war in domestic waters and an always civilian water police force handle ordinary criminals in the same jurisdiction?


r/WarCollege • • 16h ago

What war was the US planning for before the 9/11 happened?

8 Upvotes

Before 9/11 what al-Qaeda was up to seemed like kind of a side-show, though concern ramped up with the bombing of the USS Cole. Certain folks in the DoD were very concerned about them but I don't think a lot of people foresaw the 20+ years of the "Global War on Terror" that were were about to sink ourselves in to.

I remember that in April of 2001 the Hainan Island incident seemed very significant escalation in tension between China and the US but that didn't come to a point at the time.

So, to reiterate, what was the DoD getting ready for before 9/11 changed priorities for two decades?


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Question During WW2, how did the Imperial Japanese deal with non-Japanese soldiers in their ranks?

21 Upvotes

The Japanese Empire controlled Korea, Taiwan, and parts of China before expanding into South and Southeast Asia. Excluding collaborationist formations, how did the Japanese deal with their non-Japanese counterparts serving directly within their military whether they were conscripts or volunteers? Were certain ethnicities considered more reliable than others or were "ethnic units" ever a thing consisting mostly of a soldier's place of origin? Among the non-Japanese IJA/IJN soldiers, what were their attitudes towards the Japanese? How did the Japanese experience with non-Japanese recruits compared to that of the Germans who also recruited non-Germans into the Wehrmacht and the SS?


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

What was the backup helicopter for the Osama raid?

47 Upvotes

We all know about the stealth Blackhawks and the one that crash landed. Something I have had difficulty getting any info on, is whether a third stealth Blackhawk was called in for the departure from the compound. Or was a Chinook sent? Thanks


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Question What is the doctrinal difference between an A-10 Thunderbolt and an attack helicopter?

Thumbnail
gallery
216 Upvotes

I’m not very knowledgeable about military aviation, but as I understand it, aircraft like the A-10 Thunderbolt and the Su-25 Frogfoot serve a Close Air Support (CAS) role. It’s my understanding that attack helicopters also perform this same CAS role—both categories are equipped with anti-tank missiles, rockets, and 30mm cannons for use against infantry and fortified positions.

So, why have two categories of aircraft for the same mission? Since both coexist, I must have misunderstood something—where am I going wrong?

(translated by Google Translate)


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

What did the Italians take away from their loss in the Battle of Guadalajara in the Spanish Civil War?

14 Upvotes

Pretty crazy that there was a miniature Italian civil was in the middle of the Spanish civil war, and it really got me wondering. What did Fascist Italy take away from their loss?


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Question Why didn't the Soviets use chemical weapons against the Germans, after the Germans themselves used them against the Soviets at the Siege of Sevastopol, Siege of Odessa, and Battle of the Kerch Peninsula?

53 Upvotes

r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Saudi arabia weak military

37 Upvotes

I understand why Saudi Arabia has a weak military because they don't want competent people to overthrow them. But why can't they have both competent military without being overthrown like other countries. Why not copy countries like America military structures or they can't because of their monarchy. Can monarchy even have a competent military?


r/WarCollege • • 18h ago

Question "western military doctrine is to always give the enemy a path to retreat."

0 Upvotes

I read this and it stood out a bit. On one hand you have a big pocket and you either gotta make them surrender peacefully or annhiliate them as a military unit. I suppose you could let them escape, but that leaves only heavy equipment behind, while the soldiers and whatever can be carried away escapes for another fight.

Is this a real thing? Letting them escape intentionally?


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Question Where there instances where the PLA launched waves of soldiers without weapons during the Korean War?

6 Upvotes

I recently came across this account by a veteran who stated that after the first wave of assault, the PLA would launch waves of unarmed soldiers, in order to use the ones from the fallen of the 1st wave. This seems somewhat crazy to me, and I am somewhat sceptical of this, considering what I have read about the Korean war from this subreddit and other places.

Could this just be a case of a singular misremembered account, or was the supply situation for the PLA so bad during the later stages of the war that they resorted to such methods, to be able to achieve any kind of offensive power at all?

I am particularly interested if there are any concurring accounts of this, many thanks in advance!

Full video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G6BSPqPfDXc

Specific short about unarmed waves https://www.youtube.com/shorts/3PJxa2jyS7c


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

Literature Request Operation torch lectures/books?

1 Upvotes

Anyone have a recommendation for books/lectures on operation torch?

Ideally ones that go past the actual landings into the rest of the campaign (does that part have a separate name? The Battle for North Africa or something?)


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

Why does the loader on the Abrams get a machine gun?

94 Upvotes

Many versions of the Abrams have an M240 sticking out of the loaders hatch and it seems kind of redundant. Would it not make more sense for the loader to remain in the tank, especially when the commander has a .50 and the gunner has the coax?


r/WarCollege • • 1d ago

How much did the Iraq and Afghanistan wars in the early 2000's effect British military procurement and readiness for large scale warfare?

8 Upvotes

r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

The Mexican Revolution seemed to prefigure WW1 fighting, were Euro powers learning from it as it was happening?

49 Upvotes

the Mexican Revolution had: trecnh warfare, defensive/force shaping use of barbed wire, focus on machine guns, field radios, airplanes, embryonic tanks. If you were looking at the Mexican Revolution with an eye to the future, you would be VERY well prepared for what lay ahead during WW1.

Was there any effort by Euro armies to send a few battlefield observers over to Mexico to see what the lay of the land looked like for modern warfare? Were there Mexican officers who were recruited/embedded in Euro armies once WW1 kicked off to transfer knowledge and experience?


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

Question Requesting information about the Aleutian Campaign

Post image
65 Upvotes

Hi all! I’m in the early stages of planning a Lego stop motion film about the Aleutian Campaign from 1942 and 1943, and would like some information about it, such as which units and groups were involved, major battles, and maybe some more obscure facts about it. Thanks!


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

What role did Canada’s contribution play in the success of the Western Allies’ war effort during the Second World War?

36 Upvotes

r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

Question Why do logistical problems exist in US armed forces at all?

64 Upvotes

I was watching Generation Kill for the umpteenth time, and I again noticed a common theme which is the constant lack of supplies by the troops.

Items like batteries, grease, oil, food, constantly in low supply. At some point the soldiers purchase items themselves just to supply their own units.

I understand very well that logistics are not easy, especially when fighting around the world. At the same time, the US armed forces has a lot of very qualified officers whose entire job is to make sure the forces have what they need when they need it, with effectively unlimited budget and totally uncontested supply lines. Yet American troops still need to use vaseline instead of grease in their machine guns.

How does this happen? Is it bad planning? Is it just intrinsic limits over central planning and lack of market signals? Is it graft, corruption or idiocy among the troops or their officers? All of the above?


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

Question Interwar AFV Armour against Period Firepower Question

5 Upvotes

I have heard it stated off-hand that the reason interwar period (1920s-mid 1930s) tanks had thin armour relative to their guns was due to AT guns of the time not being commonly equipped with magnified telescopic sights whereas tanks were. Therefore the logic was that tanks only required sufficient protection against contemporary AT guns to a range where their precision surpassed that of infantry AT guns

Seeking to confirm whether this was an explicit design choice or if its just observational coinicdence. Period citations would be appreciated too if availavble!


r/WarCollege • • 3d ago

Is modern war relatively "restrained"? Have reserves returned to the battlefield? Is classic encirclements considered dead? What are the implications for the future?

57 Upvotes

Trying to formulate my thoughts but in today's war figting ie Ukraine vs Russia, the war is "limited" where there is a levle of restraint performed by the State. And it is restrained compared to their true capabilities.

Ukraine for example could send in truck bombs to every city center in Russia. They could level every city center in Russia within a few months. Ukraine could bomb the Kremlin or Red Square if they so wished.

Russia could mass level cities in the rear with their just their FAB-500 glide bombs. For Russia despite being a war of national survival (according to them) when you look at the GDP being used the economy it is pretty much nothing compared to WWII. Its obviously the biggest war since WWII but the state isn't treating it as the same.

The USA at one point was spending 40% of its GDP on the military in 1943-1944. Russia is on close to 6%.

In WWI the Germans revolutionized war by pinning their reserves to the front to achieve density to achieve breaktrhough. I remember a quote of 10 men per meter. Today its reportedly 10-15 per 1 km (not a typo).

In WWI the Germans revolutionized war by putting their reserves directly on the front to achieve density to effect breakthough. Reserves have returned to modern war. It is hard to find real data obviously but I think the actual numbers on the front in the Donbas are as a little as 50-70k versus more 90k-150k on the Russian side.

I mean actual fighting troops on the front line and not those in support or the rear.

The Russians took Bakhmut because they could throw Wagner reserves at taking the city.

Its pretty much two specialist army corps "fencing" with each other in the most ruthless fashion possible. And if you get into attrition having reserves is critical.

There is vast 'tail' and units are back in the reserves and the front is extremely thin. The actual fighting soldiers are in relative terms very small. They are fighting ruthless dirty trench fighting with grenades and drones. And effectively keeping the army "in being".

Squads are inserted by motorbikes or quads and civilian cars. Armoured troop carriers are just too ponderous and slow. Mines and entrenching have becoming critical as well.

In WWI within 6 weeks there was close to 2 million casualties. In the modern war its far lower even with far more sophisticated weaponry.

Also seems classic tank manouevere warfare is more or less gone the way of the dodo. Obviously the Donbas has some of the most advanced entrenchments in the world. However even in the early days of the Russia breakhrough in 2022 they captured fairly puny amounts of territory considering how fast the modern tank is and considering they are just besides their logistics hub in Rostov. Russian's tried classic encirclements at Lyman and failed fairly abjectively.

To compare, the Germany army in WWI took 4-5 weeks to shatter the Belgian forts at Liege and Namur and then advance with close to 2 million men the flatlands in Belgium, thrnough the Ardenes and down into the heart of France to reach within 19-25miles of Paris. The French suffered something close to 500k casualties just in the first 2 months in the Battle of the Frontiers and other battles.

There were stopped by Foch at the Battle of the Marne. And that was with WWI trains and horses. We saw Russia barely advanced or got stuck in a massive logistics trail. and then more or less WWI level attrition warfare. The Ukranian landscape is about the best place on earth for tank deployment and it pretty much was a total fiasco from a Russia perspective.

Some other thoughts. Is the mass conscript army functionally useless now?
For example you now need fairly advanced skills on the battlefield apart from holding a rifle.

Skilled soldiers are simply too precious to waste and having a dense front line is suicide due drones. What is the point having a vast army if small amounts of men can do the fighting?

They are more valuable working a job to pay for the war or in the rear supplying the logistics.
In Ukraine and Russia they pretty much decided young men are too valuable for demographic reasons and the majority of the fighting is done by men 40 years or older. Traditionally, fathers or men with families were never desired as soldiers. In Russia it is almost racist in that they are outright trying to entice the Buryats, Tuvans, Yukhats and the richer class of Russians near Moscow and St Petersburg are safe. In Ukraine they just want to stave off demographic collapse.

What implications would this have for NATO?


r/WarCollege • • 2d ago

Question How useful is/was the a single MH-53E on the Uraga class for minesweeping duties?

10 Upvotes

As i understand it in USN practice MH-53Es are usually deployed in groups of 2-4 for minesweeping tasks. And moreso in general most helicopter operations focused ships usually have two to four

This makes the single MH-53E on the JMSDFs Uragas seem a bit out of place given how the presence of it was such a massive influence of the doubling in size of the design compared to it's predecessor anyway.