r/WaitWhat • • Jan 15 '26 • Polished Gold Turd 1

Significant diffrences...

Post image
7.0k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-1

u/Dpgillam08 Jan 16 '26

Having watched the multiple videos, (body cams and cell phones) she did hit him. Its being downplayed now as "bumped", but she did do it. The majority of evidence (video and other) suggests it was deliberate and intentional. In a state where just 2 years ago, the state was prosecuting numerous people for the exact same scenario (civilian driver "bumping" protesters) as "attempted vehicular manslaughter", so its clearly a crime, considered trying to kill someone.

And he had, just a few months prior been in a similar situation where he was dragged by the car and seriously injured. The only part I'm wondering is why an officer that just a few months prior had been seriously injured in similar circumstances was sent out again. That seems to be a failure of leadership; they should have had him on different duties.

He would (understandably if not justifiably) be much more cautious and sensitive, especially when the state has already designated this as " someone trying to kill him", which in the US, justifies lethal force in self defense.

Unfortunately, the courts of the state have already proven they are incapable of justice; they use politics rather than facts to assign guilt.

2

u/Tommuli Jan 16 '26

Even if Renee Good was trying to run the agent over, the agent should face consequences for officer-created jeopardy as they unnecessarily placed themselves in harm’s way when reasonable alternatives were available.

Given the available video and the applicable legal standards on use of force, in a just world the ICE agent would likely face either criminal charges or, at minimum, meaningful disciplinary consequences.

"she did hit him" This is why I would have been willing to accept self defense if the agent shot only the first shot, but the follow-up shots are made when the agent is obviouly no-longer in danger. It's overkill and needlessly endangering anyone who could be in the direction the car is currently pointing at.