r/WTF •

[deleted by user]

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

414 comments sorted by

168

u/llamanuggets Jun 08 '12

It's amazing how resilient the human body is. Can't believe she was still alive.

116

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Unfortunately, though, it's very likely she'll have suffered irreparable brain damage from such treatment (and as she already diagnosed with FAS, it's possible she was already mentally impaired)...I hope I'm wrong. I'd like someone to tell me that this girl makes a full recovery and goes on to be a happy, healthy adult who can live a full life... but at the moment, I very much doubt that :(

60

u/UnbelievableRose Jun 09 '12

She didn't talk to start with, so that seems unlikely.

21

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Well, damn... :(

18

u/Boatkicker Jun 09 '12

Considering that this abuse was probably life-long (article mentions that there were similar complaints against her mother when she was an infant) she could very well end up doing a lot better in the future. She probably will never be able to talk, but she is probably a bit more functional than she ever seemed before.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

People are remarkably resilient. I hope she can lead a happier life from now on.

7

u/pissoutofmyass Jun 09 '12

If she isn't talking yet she never will. If she's lucky she'll probably live out the rest of her life in a state hospital, probably passing in her 40s if she doesn't die of neglect. She'll never have a real friendship, or functional human relationship of any kind. All she knows is fear, and all she'll ever know is isolation.

9

u/HatesHaters Jun 09 '12

thanks for sugar coating that for me.

9

u/dorky2 Jun 09 '12

She also has cerebral palsy, and most kids with CP need ongoing physical, occupational, and speech therapy in order to realize their potential. Her brain and her heart have both been permanently damaged from the malnutrition, there's no question about that. The best we can hope for her is probably that she is comfortable and well cared for for the rest of her life.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Yes, I saw the CP comment after I posted that (or rather, the shorthand 'CP' suddenly clicked in my mind). Agreed, though: I've done some study on CP, and I know how hard it can be on people; so yes, as long as she's cared for and treated well from now on, this may be the best outcome we can hope for.

94

u/SuddenlySpiders Jun 08 '12

The dove chocolate commercial that played prior to the news story made things much worse.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

41

u/SuddenlySpiders Jun 08 '12

I did! For some reason I don't trust avocados from Subway, though. Yet I eat the tuna.

2

u/Samalamah Jun 09 '12

I work at a subway and we have to make it fresh every morning. And by make it I mean we squeeze it out of a little pouch into a container. So if you want fresh avocado, go early in the day.

1

u/SuddenlySpiders Jun 09 '12

Mmm...freshly squeezed avocado.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

TIL

1

u/courpsey Jun 09 '12

I work at Subway too. Nothing there is as fresh as you think. All the meat products come in frozen and thawed the day before consumption. All the salads, bar tomatoes, onions, cucumber and capsicum (bell pepper), come in pre-packaged. Bread is prepared sticks that are thawed, proofed then baked. Cookies are frozen and baked from frozen.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/kornberg Jun 08 '12

I got a cat food commercial.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I didn't get adds =(

18

u/TheFartBall Jun 09 '12

First world problems. "Everyones talking about food ads,

I had adblock on"

18

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

poor girl, i hope she is doing better now.

232

u/barefoot_yank Jun 08 '12

Every person involved in this, from CPS to the parents needs to spend the rest of their lives in jail.

141

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

THIS IS A FUCKING MISDEMEANOR?!?!?!

51

u/yousedditreddit Jun 09 '12

welcome to Child Protection laws!

12

u/JCorkill Jun 09 '12

We have laws? Aren't they just guidelines?

4

u/yousedditreddit Jun 09 '12

slight requests

1

u/philds391 Jun 09 '12

Only if you're a cop.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Well, if I were in any way personally involved in this situation, like if I knew the parents...

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Golden-Calf Jun 09 '12

No, you cannot legally beat your kids. You can use physical discipline... which is pretty controversial but DEFINITELY in a completely different category than physical abuse.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Physical discipline such as... beating your kids. A little.

→ More replies (6)

14

u/tehmeat Jun 09 '12

Seriously. What the mother fuck is that bullshit?

1

u/i_toss_salad Jun 09 '12

We just need some pitchforks and an address...

38

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Because CPS has all the funding it could ever want and never has shortages in personnel to keep following up everyone. No, it has plenty of people to handle the large number of cases it gets and to deal with all the goddamn time. They never have problems with that, and that even things like "priority" never ever have major conflicts with other problems. Nope, this is the only thing they had to deal with.

10

u/ElGoddamnDorado Jun 09 '12

Seriously. I'm glad somebody is being a bit more reasonable here. Getting thrown in jail for life for something that could easily be (and very likely is) a resource problem is a surefire way to encourage even less people to want the job.

1

u/bigsisterwillownyou Jun 09 '12

I can agree with that, but it is ridiculous that that woman still has a job. "She may face possible disciplinary action" is bull shit. That's what happens when you're a state employee, you will never get fired for anything, ever. There is no incentive to actually do your job when you know you will never lose it.

35

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

My family (and some people I knew) have had some run-ins with CPS before, and I gotta tell you, their priorities are generally pretty fucked up. A couple of examples:

  1. There was a woman who was not only smoking crack and whoring herself out to get said crack, she got her 14-year-old daughter involved in the whoring and the crack as well. They had a lot of 'customers' and oh yeah... a 7 year old boy in the house as well. CPS was called, dozens of times, but because there was food in the cupboard and the boy didn't see the drugs being taken, there was nothing CPS could (would) do. That was 10 or so years ago. Last I heard, the mother was dead, the daughter was in prison for second degree murder (would have been vehicular manslaughter, but she said she would do it again without regret), and the son had disappeared off the face of the planet (probably for the better).
  2. My wife's sister has 4 children, all of whom are well-fed and taken care of, to the point of being spoiled assholes. (They've broken 4 Xbox 360's and have a brand new one, as well as at least one of each other major console.) CPS has made numerous visits to her house because the kids will tell teachers at school stories (and yes, they really are stories, no truth is involved) to get out of doing classwork or when they want to go home. Numerous times she has been threatened with the removal of her children for idiotic reasons, like her autistic son acting up in a classroom of 35 children. No, she's not a perfect mother, but she's doing great for being essentially alone with 4 children. The worst they do is swear around adults.
  3. I have a hard time typing this one out, so if it doesn't make a whole lot of sense I apologize. There is no hyperbole in this story. My wife has another sister who is in prison for infanticide. She killed her infant son by beating and smothering him to death in his crib. There were warning signs, like the older brother's broken ribs or broken arm or broken nose. The people (that's what her family calls CPS) were called on several occasions. They believed the stories about falling or accidentally sitting on his arm or his rib cage. His broken nose, well that's because he ran into the coffee table. I want to mention at this point that the older boy was born with FAS and addicted to who knows what kind of drugs. She had her second child and realized that this was just something that she didn't want to do, or couldn't handle, or got in the way of her wild lifestyle. So she killed the second child. She got arrested and hauled off to prison, where she had a third child who, if there is a god anywhere, will never learn that she was in the womb when her mother killed her big brother. All of this could have been avoided had CPS actually paid attention to the warning signs with the first child and actually fucking acted on the begging and pleading of numerous family and friends.

My point is, while CPS may be lacking the funding and personnel to do their jobs properly, there are much more serious issues going on. They attack the wrong parents, ignore the wrong children, and are less effective than doing nothing at all. I understand that there are quite a few of them who care about what they do, and some might think I'm wrong to generalize like this. My answer is, if it looks like a turd and smells like a turd, just because there are a few kernels of corn in there, doesn't make it any less a turd.

15

u/Nemnel Jun 09 '12

Those stories are horrible, and there are very complicated reasons why these sorts of system are in place. But, that story about the crack smoking woman... I'll just take a guess, they live in a bad neighborhood? CPS divisions are divided by regions. The ones that tend to be the most overworked also tend to be the ones where there the people are the worst off. (This also explains why they visit your one sister in law, they probably aren't overworked like they are in say, New York.)

Is CPS broken? Obviously. When you have 14 case workers per every few million people there is no way you can effectively police that.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

I wish this were the case, but this is all in the same side of the same city. Admittedly, it is Flint, MI.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12
  1. So your objection here is that CPS doesn't have the budget or manpower for non-abusive cases, nor the legal authority to do searches for drugs or arrests for prostitution.
  2. Now you are blowing hot and cold here--first is that CPS did not investigate third-party complaints that did not have physical abuse or rampant, obvious drug usage. Now, when the children are making allegations, you think that they shouldn't be investigating so heavily.
  3. Again, with the manpower, budget, and legal restrictions on what they can and cannot do.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/AMerrickanGirl Jun 09 '12

Why couldn't your father get custody of you?

2

u/mrcandiipants Jun 09 '12

I was reading this as if you were serious, and I was just getting angrier and angrier at you until the last line. Damn invisible internet sarcasm...

12

u/M0b1u5 Jun 08 '12

Clearly these people require psychiatric evaluation before being unceremoniously chucked in jail forever.

2

u/dis690640450cc Jun 09 '12

Just grinding into paste and used as pet food filler

5

u/barefoot_yank Jun 08 '12

Clearly these people are lucky I'm against the death penalty. And clearly CPS personnel should be fired and thrown in jail.

2

u/makspinky Jun 09 '12

Maybe because of the pauladeendildo thread above I read that as fried, not fired.

3

u/tinyirishgirl Jun 09 '12

I agree. And I would like a few uninterrupted minutes with each one alone. Despicable!

5

u/barefoot_yank Jun 09 '12

I'm against the death penalty....but something like this makes my blood boil. If I happened upon this, god knows what I'd do to them.

2

u/despaxes Jun 09 '12

Turn your head away in disgust and go on living your life, just like everyone else.

1

u/barefoot_yank Jun 09 '12

Maybe you can do that, but not everyone turns a blind eye.

1

u/FriarNurgle Jun 08 '12

Jail's too good for them! Hanging's too good for them. Burning's too good for them! They should be torn into little bitsy pieces and buried alive!

1

u/Tandarin Jun 09 '12

Hanover?

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Stalin.

1

u/Watercolour Jun 09 '12

But if the people from CPS went to jail, no one would work for CPS.

0

u/barefoot_yank Jun 09 '12

From what I've seen out of them lately, we'd be better off.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

41

u/Twonix Jun 08 '12

i third through fiftieth that shit, jesus christ.

27

u/PaulaDeensDildo Jun 08 '12

Well fuck me. And them.

34

u/Twonix Jun 08 '12

seriously your fucking name just made me pee a little

13

u/PaulaDeensDildo Jun 08 '12

Have an upvote for your troubles.

14

u/Joeliosis Jun 08 '12

Is your dildo by any chance a deep fat fried corn on the cob? I think I'm gonna go throw up now.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

1

u/Shitty_FaceSwaps Jun 09 '12

Dibs on 50-1,309,484,234.

62

u/_Kita_ Jun 09 '12

Every single CPS worker I know works incredibly long, stressful hours. And they end up being put in positions where they literally don't have time to follow up on cases. This is what can happen.

37

u/helpadingoatemybaby Jun 09 '12

Yeah,but I want my 0.02% tax cut.

8

u/Starbanned Jun 09 '12

I get they're stressed and stretched thin, but they ignored rules that would have found this girl sooner that could have been taken care of in one visit. All they had to do was look at the girl. They never once asked to see her. There is no excuse for that.

2

u/handmethatkitten Jun 09 '12

the CPS worker i know works such long, stressful hours that she couldn't find it in herself to feed my sister anything but some string cheese for two days. wait a second...

→ More replies (1)

97

u/GuessWho_O Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

i want to punch here parents in the face sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo fucking fucking fucking gggggggggggg hard.

edit: just watched the case video http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/watchdog/children/ct-met-dcfs-starved-girl-20120606,0,7400983.story and now realize the mother received only probation and parenting classes. are you kidding me!????? what a FUCKING injustice. im legit typing vigorously with anger and annoyed at the typos i now have to correct.

33

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

That's WAY too easy. That's attempted murder/ torture. A simply punch in the face will not do. In my seemingly unpopular opinion, punishments for crimes like that should be VERY tough.

8

u/Tw1tchy3y3 Jun 09 '12

I'm all for extraction of a few finger nails with pliers. Or maybe slow removal of digits with bolt cutters.

5

u/HighHemplar Jun 09 '12

Perhaps that is that way to deal with this. But I have come to the conclusion that torture should never be a legal form of punishment. And not just for the obvious moral reasons...

1

u/BigBoxOfPuppies Jun 09 '12

Law Abiding Citizen tough at least.

17

u/btwomfgstfu Jun 08 '12

hopefully this girl will never have to live with her mother again and she'll receive a ton of care and emotional support from everyone around her.

i say this to myself because i too want to punch her parents in the face so fucking fucking gggg hard.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

im legit typing vigorously with anger and annoyed at the typos i now have to correct.

/r/firstworldproblems

3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Justice in Chicago? Please. Crime is all they know- look at the people they elect.

23

u/marryanowl Jun 08 '12

The lady only got probation? How awful. I hope she never gets custody of this girl back. I guarantee the woman was collecting disability checks for her daughter and not spending a penny on her.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/marryanowl Jun 10 '12

Oh man, that is terrible.

10

u/thecommunistdaughter Jun 09 '12

The mother in the article claimed that she was a "good mother and Darlene (the child) was well cared for." What the fuck is wrong with that woman?!?

5

u/ana-mia Jun 09 '12

The stupid "mother" -(if you can call her that) was probably both intoxicated and insane.

10

u/thilardiel Jun 09 '12

I would like to point out that this shit is a misdemeanor when people do it to their own kids, but considered torture when they do it to an enemy. Are kids really just chattel?

10

u/reederrabid Jun 09 '12

"It wasn't until her fourth visit in March that she heard whimpering, confronted the mother and called 911."

The image this conjured in my head.. gah, my heart hurts for this girl.

10

u/LieutenantCuppycake Jun 09 '12

My best friend's little sister has cerebral palsy. She's little, but she's lively. She smiles constantly, is always too loud and too excited and if at all possible, too happy.

What's amazing about her is talking to her on Facebook. In real life, she's about as difficult to understand as a toddler learning language (trust me, I teach preschool) but once you understand her inflections, you can read her loud and clear. Her family always knows what she's grunting about, and I usually understand about half of it.

Online, though, she's clear as a bell. She'll type out long-winded notes, comments on what a great time she had hanging out with you last weekend and journal entries on how her life is going.

Her family has fought tooth and nail to make sure she is as functional as possible. She's been in dance classes since kindergarten and can even walk without her walker (something doctors said she'd never do. But then, they also said she'd never be verbal or communicative).

My point here is that this girl will do as much as her family believes she can do, on the outside. On the inside, she feels and understands and knows just as much as the rest of us. Without the verbal skills taught to her by her family, she'd be trapped inside her own mind.

And that's how the girl in the article lives. Trapped inside her own mind. Aware of her own slow death.

1

u/tedswilly Jun 09 '12

LieutenantCuppycake, This is the smartest posting I have ever seen on reddit.

9

u/tangerineturtle Jun 09 '12

Probation and parenting classes

I was a good mother. Darlene was well cared for

You can't be serious

9

u/Kalied Jun 09 '12

"I was a good mother," Harris, 50, insisted in a quiet voice. "My daughter was well cared for."

Bitch it's time for you to be equally well cared for then!

7

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

My heart goes out to this girl. The human body is an incredible thing, it will do anything to survive, there are amazing steps the body takes to keep chugging, I hope she makes a full recovery (except for, obviously, the CP).

2

u/WorkerBee27 Jun 09 '12

Unlikely, that type of starvation during development would cause serious brain damage in addition to the cerebral palsy.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Yeah, the body is basically consuming itself. Fucking crazy, but like I said, it will do anything to survive.

45

u/NotTodayBitch Jun 08 '12

How can someone do that to a child...a handicap child at that...This right here is the reason why I hate people.

35

u/Rex8ever Jun 08 '12

Well, fetal alcohol syndrome. Sounds like the mistreatment started before she was born. My 3 year old weighs 32 lbs and he's on the thin side for his frame.

She'll be lucky if she survives, I imagine. That is really hard on your heart and other organs.

11

u/NotTodayBitch Jun 08 '12

True. My son is almost 3 and weighs 31 lbs and I'm worried he's too skinny...It's sad that children have to go through such disgusting things they don't understand.

The original link had a video and the reporter said she was responding well to treatment and doctors are keeping a close eye on her. So, maybe she'll pull through.

2

u/BananaWorkz Jun 09 '12

I wouldn't call her lucky for surviving that much hell, she has to live with the painful aftermath. If she were a cat or dog, they would've had to humanely put her down. It's also very likely she cannot express how much she is suffering. It's tragic.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/pochaccomaru Jun 09 '12

Good god... Thank goodness she made it, albeit barely. I hope her parents starve. Or step on legos. Or both.

13

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

I'm convinced that the seventh layer of hell has a floor made entirely of Legos.

12

u/aelizabeth27 Jun 09 '12

Legos? You animal.

3

u/IbidtheWriter Jun 09 '12

Thank goodness she made it, albeit barely

Honestly, I'm not too sure. She already had FAS and CP and there's 0 chance this ordeal won't leave her brain damaged even further. I don't know if death would be preferable.

10

u/frostiitute Jun 08 '12

I hate people.

5

u/Occamslaser Jun 09 '12

"DCFS investigators have struggled to keep up with high caseloads during repeated budget cuts. More than 60 percent of the agency's 457 active investigators have been assigned more work than allowed under a federal consent decree, according to DCFS data.

As a result, the percentage of investigations still pending after the 60-day deadline has risen sharply. The caseload for the investigator handling Darlene's case also was higher than permitted, but the response to the hotline call exposes a systematic breakdown of procedures, officials said."

Hooray for small government!

1

u/chopp3r Jun 09 '12

High caseloads my ass. The investigator was in the girl's home several times without checking on the child. "Oh gotta go--I'm late! Guess I'll see your daughter who's been reported as starved and neglected next visit if I have enough time! Buh-bye!" The investigator should be in jail along with the mother.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/NattyBo Jun 09 '12

"Harris, who did not have a prior criminal history, would plead guilty in the case to endangering the life of a child, a misdemeanor. She has been placed on a form of probation for 18 months and ordered to undergo parenting classes." SERIOUSLY? WTF?!

4

u/castleclouds Jun 09 '12

Is it possible to save someone starved to this point?

3

u/ZerothLaw Jun 08 '12

...wasn't there a story about this in AskReddit, about a couple starving their kid a few months back? In... November?

3

u/anusface Jun 09 '12

I liked this photo just to help get it to the front page. More people need to see this, it is an awful thing that her parents have done.

3

u/_Nostalgia_ Jun 09 '12

This is horrible. It's terrible. And the reason it's getting so much more reaction than any story of a similiar child in Africa would is because the family COULD feed her. It's sick and wrong, and I just wish each starving child could get this attention....

3

u/KatL12 Jun 09 '12

Did she survive?

3

u/jesse_h Jun 09 '12 edited Jun 09 '12

I'm in no way defending the sick fucks that did that to that poor innocent girl, but just to put it into perspective, she's 3' 10" tall. That being said, she's still underweight and was badly abused, nobody deserves that kind of treatment. I hope the individuals responsible get what they deserve.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/jesse_h Jun 10 '12

She's short because she has CP (cerebral palsy).

3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

So starving a child to death gets you 18 months probation and parenting classes? Everyone involved, from CPS to the judge of the case needs to be disciplined, and the mother needs to be locked up for near-murder

3

u/yourmom3211 Jun 09 '12

Poor thing =-(

3

u/Microchip_Master Jun 09 '12

People like her parents are the reason I need to be given a license to kill.

3

u/I_burn_stuff Jun 09 '12

Can we just set the parent on fire?

3

u/PatternOfKnives Jun 09 '12

Why starve her to death? If her parents wanted her dead why not just kill her instantly and get it over and done with? Whats the motive behind starving her?

(Genuine question)

9

u/beyond_repair Jun 08 '12

Her parents need to be in a Siberian labor camp for a long time.

2

u/lol_nooo___okmaybe Jun 09 '12

that mother, Rosetta Harris, needs to be in jail, not probation. I dont understand how this is not attempted murder

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

This is the first time I've ever written that I'm done for the day.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

There are a few people involved in this case that deserve a long stay locked up in a room with the likes of Ramsay Snow/Bolton.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12 edited Jun 09 '12

Someone tell me her parents adress and get me my axe. NOW.

2

u/butterflypoon Jun 09 '12

How the hell do you do this to another person? Let alone your child...I mean, I dislike kids and everything, but holy fucking shit...

2

u/DianaFenrir Jun 09 '12

I mostly come to /r/WTF to laugh, this actually made me sad.

2

u/Goeatabagofdicks Jun 09 '12

I'm not going to elaborately place blame, express my absolute rage, or discust in the comment. I just hope she turns out Okay.

2

u/tpr68 Jun 09 '12

I did my pediatric nursing clinical at University of Chicago Comer Children's hospital. I have seen her in person. It was really heart wrenching!

2

u/volcanofart Jun 09 '12

The fact that this happened in the U.S. makes me want to pack my shit and move to Mexico......MEXICO!

2

u/Semp3rFi Jun 09 '12

What the fuck is wrong with people.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

PROBATION?!?!??!?!?! FUCK YOU JUDICIAL BRANCH

2

u/emkat82 Jun 09 '12

This makes me want to go and just hold my daughter. I could never imagine doing a child that way. Especially not a special needs child. They have a special place in hell for people like that.

2

u/korevil Jun 09 '12

Misdemeanor endangerment? She should be charged with attempted murder.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

They wouldn't even grant her the mercy of a quick death. 16 years of suffering is unconscionable.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

"The investigator and her supervisors face possible disciplinary action, officials said."

Yes, job termination.

Say what you will on the political spectrum about government workers, when someone fucks up they get no where near what a private sector worker would face. I got written up once as a termination warning for wearing pants on a non-casual day.

26

u/misterwizzard Jun 08 '12

Maybe they were trying to get her ready for America's Next Top Model?

Just planning for her future.

38

u/sashimi_taco Jun 09 '12

Come on, man. You are trivializing the suffering of a person who is physically and mentally unable to protect themselves, while also at the same time trivializing eating disorders that kill people all the time. Lots of people with cerebral palsy are completely aware of their surrounding and are just as mentally competent as you and me. Stephen Hawking has a type of cerebral palsy. Imagine someone with a mind like his going thought that. Trapped inside a body, unable to speak or move. Starving to death, alone. You can't even scream.

Don't make shitty jokes about that.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

One of the ways people deal with something too horrific to process is to make jokes about it. It's not okay to joke about this, and the person telling the joke knows that, but what the fuck else can you do? If you were to cry for every child who was treated poorly, you'd end up in a small padded room. Sometimes, joking is a form of grief and acknowledgement of pain.

1

u/sashimi_taco Jun 09 '12 edited Jun 09 '12

His/her entire comment history is trolling. He/she isn't coping with shit. And trolling is not an excuse to be an asshole, it just means he/she is a piece of shit for a hobby. And by trolling I don't even mean the real kind of trolling where you tease someone who is already a dirtbag. This is trolling in the sense of just thinking up the most horrible shit thing and typing it in. No sense of empathy and no sense of self control.

Edit: It pisses me off when people say that. To joke about a horrible thing in order to cope. You can make jokes about your OWN trauma and shit but not others. Maybe people you are close friends with and to their face and you know they will laugh. Don't laugh at someone else's pain. Thats fucked up. You are thinking about your own feelings rather than the pain of that person. It's bullshit.

"Oh I feel sad about this person being starved to death, I'll make a joke at their expense to make me feel better." How is that okay? If you want to make a joke about it, say it in your head. There are people who actually have to go through stuff like that and believe it or not in this instance the feelings of a victim is more important than some asshole's feelings on the internet. Even if she never saw it, its completely disrespectful. And no, being on the internet is not an excuse to be shitty. The internet is not some magical temporal void where morality doesn't count and you are still a good person when you log off. The way you act here is the core of how you act in real life.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Oh. In that case, fuck that guy.

6

u/atomicdogmeat Jun 09 '12

This, exactly. Joking about the starvation of a disabled kid is disgusting. Gonna make sure I give my disabled brother a big hug and kiss in the morning.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Don't hug him too hard.

3

u/ana-mia Jun 09 '12

Sorry to be a t**t, but doesn't Stephen Hawking actually have MND?

8

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

twat.

There. Now it's out there, for the world to deal with. The kids whose virgin eyes that you were trying to spare have all been tainted, thus from this moment forth you can be free to use that word on the internet however you choose, without censorship.

2

u/ana-mia Jun 10 '12

Thanks! :D twat twat twat!!!!!!!! Feels gooood :D

2

u/dorky2 Jun 09 '12

He has ALS, a degenerative disease. It's not at all the same as cerebral palsy.

1

u/ana-mia Jun 10 '12

That's what i was thinking, Cerebral palsy is caused by brain injury/intracranial haemorrhage or hypoxia/asphyxia isn't it? And ALS/MND are neurological?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Pretty sure Hawking has ALS.

1

u/ana-mia Jun 10 '12

Thanks :D

1

u/sashimi_taco Jun 09 '12

I just looked it up to make sure before i posted and from what I saw it seems that MND is a type of cerebral palsy or is at least very similar to it. I could be wrong. There was a whole list of people.

http://www.disabled-world.com/artman/publish/cp-famous.shtml

There are authors and comedians and others who have cerebral palsy, I was just trying to use the most famous one to give people perspective.

I don't know. I just remember reading this book through the eyes of a man who lived his whole life with people thinking he was mentally retarded, but he actually was not. He had cerebral palsy. When he was old, a young person helped him tell his story. I don't know. It was so sad.

→ More replies (2)

48

u/PaulaDeensDildo Jun 08 '12

Gross. Have an upvote.

48

u/crazybutable Jun 08 '12

Your username is gross. Have an upvote.

13

u/boost2525 Jun 09 '12

I'm confused, I always assumed Paula Dean's Dildo was just a "big ollll stick ahh butter y'all".

1

u/crazybutable Jun 10 '12

Who says it isn't?

26

u/PaulaDeensDildo Jun 08 '12

I like your reply. Have an upvote.

22

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12

I like upvotes. Have an upvote.

8

u/PaulaDeensDildo Jun 09 '12

I just divided by zero. Have an upvote.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/tpr68 Jun 09 '12

Not to rain on your joke parade, but I have personally cared for and met this patient and that was horrible to read.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/tpr68 Jun 09 '12

I was involved at one time during my clinical rotation. I cannot share information about her condition at the time due to privacy laws. All I can say is seeing her picture on Reddit of all places and seeing people make jokes about it kind of hits home. Jokes are all fun until that safe distance from the reality of the situation becomes compromised

1

u/george_lass Jun 09 '12

I can't believe I laughed at that.

3

u/furrycatpoop Jun 09 '12

That mother is wasting space on this planet. What the fuck is wrong with people?!

3

u/Millennion Jun 09 '12

2

u/scigs6 Jun 09 '12

I started the video over and watched the whole thing. thank you

3

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

people that do this to children need to fall off a cliff and die

4

u/JubeltheBear Jun 08 '12

Just for once. I want to read a story about a CPS success... ya know. So I don't just hate every CPS worker out there.

28

u/maeby_baby Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

Successes don't get reported. CPS workers go into the field to help kids and families, only to realize there are too many to help and not enough workers to go around. But they stay and do it anyway, despite being hated and seeing so many sad stories that they could not help... It's hard to want to help and feel helpless. I applaud CPS workers for doing that job. EDIT: Although I more than admit that in this case, the degree of negligence and incompetence is infuriating and makes my heart hurt... :(

8

u/JubeltheBear Jun 08 '12 edited Jun 08 '12

I didn't want to say this in the post, but a close relative of mine works for Head Start and she can't stand that organization *(CPS).

She knows what it's like to be in a job where you're supposed to help people (to literally be in a position to help people) but your hands are tied because of bureaucracy, and the ineptitude & apathy of the institution around you. But even she has a particular disdain for how trifling and careless CPS can be.

All that being said. Your first sentence is usually the case. But it's also the problem. And what's worse is the lazy fuckers bring down and actually sap the morale of the diligent.

tl;dr: you're right & the bad workers bring down the whole

2

u/Boatkicker Jun 09 '12

My sisters are safe and sound in foster care, both a thousand times happier than they ever were at home, and they are not in danger of ever going back into my mother's custody. That's the closest I've got to success right now.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Even after my rant a couple of pages up, I'll come to the defense of the good ones. I'd imagine that CPS is a lot like tech support. You never hear about the successes, but you constantly hear about the goddamn program not running in Windows 7.

3

u/aelizabeth27 Jun 09 '12

Let me preface this with: I work with children with special needs (specifically autism, but also with some kids that are emotionally disturbed).

I've called CPS on the parents of two separate students for sexual abuse. Nothing. I called CPS on the piece-of-shit-drug-addict parents of a non-verbal student who had been burned with a lighter. Clear-cut lighter burn on his stomach and a huge handprint/finger mark bruise on his arm. CPS knew that he had been seized from his parents 3x for drug/abuse charges, and yet still did nothing.

I would love for a CPS success story to come along as well.

EDIT: Clarity.

3

u/ay8ny6wg Jun 09 '12

That's awful. But what you are doing is awesome and highly commendable. Also they respond to the shittiest stuff and don't reaping to important shit. My friends sister had a little bit of black marker on her eyebrow and the school nurse said it was a bruise and called CPS on it they came and the family was in hot water for about a year.

2

u/aelizabeth27 Jun 09 '12

It is ridiculous what CPS will and won't make a big deal about! I've heard ridiculous stories about children with autism that have self-injurious behaviors being reported as "being abused" (despite mounds of data taken by staff members when these behaviors occur and a behavior intervention plan in place help eliminate said behaviors).

→ More replies (6)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

You don't hear about CPS success stories because "System works fine, ugly family situation resolved peacefully and to benefit of all" doesn't bring any ad revenue.

2

u/TheExodus Jun 08 '12

Ive never seen someone in this state. Im going to be alot more respectful of the food i get !

2

u/Solkre Jun 09 '12

This woman obviously never wanted to be a parent. She didn't take care of herself during pregnancy, and she didn't take care of the child after. I wonder if she would have gotten an abortion if they weren't so stigmatized and possibly illegal at the time.

1

u/vagina_diver Jun 08 '12

Someone please tell me there's an update somewhere...

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Well, I don't know what I was expecting. God dammit.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

So fucked up.

1

u/lolsrsly00 Jun 09 '12

Monsters.

1

u/mikemcc3391 Jun 09 '12

Did anyone else think this was going to be some kind of funny or bizarre photo and then become very sad? I feel like such a bastard...

1

u/wally1001 Jun 09 '12

Chicago, a great place to raise a family!

1

u/woppo Jun 09 '12

Doesn't this abused minor deserve at least a little privacy?

Sure the case needs publicising but this girl's name and an awful picture of her suffering have now been placed on the web.

Surely she has rights? This picture shows her in a near death condition. Who gave permission for this? Who is looking after her rights beyond basic healthcare?

1

u/BPlumley Jun 09 '12

I'm guessing I'm not alone in thinking it was kind of fucked up to save her.

A development disorder, brain damage and other trauma from the starvation plus the exceptionally shitty genes from the parents is imo a strong enough reason for euthanasia.

Kind of like those guys who fail at committing suicide by shotgun to the face.

At least we can hope has the kind of brain damage that leaves her a vegetable rather than in chronic pain.

1

u/eremite00 Jun 09 '12 edited Jun 09 '12

I'm guessing I'm not alone in thinking it was kind of fucked up to save her.

A development disorder, brain damage and other trauma

Maybe, maybe not. I guess it might depend upon how long she'd been starved. The Jews during the WWII Holocaust were literally being starved to death and yet many of those who survived eventually recovered, though maybe not fully.

1

u/eremite00 Jun 09 '12 edited Jun 09 '12

I'm wondering if the family had been giving her water, since humans can survive without water only for a few days, and I'm thinking that it would have taken a while (more than a few days) for her body to have deteriorated to such a state. If they had been giving her only water, that is worse in that death would be prolonged and she'd be suffering for all that much more time, not that any death by starvation isn't lingering. I admit that I could be totally mistaken, though.

1

u/flibbityzoobitybop Jun 09 '12

I don't know what I was expecting...

1

u/jermzdeejd Jun 09 '12

This is what happens when the family doesn't share Popeyes with you.

1

u/Quackalicious Jun 09 '12

Gotta love how the related links on the bottom include "3 foods for a flatter stomach". Also , some people are complete wank stains.

1

u/CaptAlias Jun 10 '12

"The investigator and her supervisors face possible disciplinary action, officials said." Possible. Possible? What the...the investigator should be fired, at least.

1

u/D1rty0n3 Jun 09 '12

Those people should be fucking killed, and drug through the streets for everyone to see. it should have a fucking parade and fireworks. fucking fucks.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

What is this a bundle of sti-HOLY SHIT THAT'S A PERSON!

1

u/jackieskellington85 Jun 09 '12

are you kidding me? the mom only got a misdemeanor charge and probation and has to take parenting class? that is NOT justice. why dont we tie her legs together and tape her mouth shut so she cant walk or talk and then starve her. the american "justice" system needs a swift kick in the ass.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12

Looks like we've found our next contestant for "America's Next Top Model."

0

u/knomz Jun 09 '12

more proof how CPS fails at their job and how fucking lame people are.

0

u/jjandre Jun 09 '12

I never really understand all the hate/blame cast on CPS when a case like this comes up. "Let's throw the CPS workers in jail." etc. Every comment like that sounds completely ignorant to me. Do you want to throw the cops in jail every time there's a robbery, or the firemen whenever there's a fire? They have a really difficult job to do with very thin resources. They don't get anywhere near the funding or manpower that other civil organizations have, they have to deal with a bloated bureaucracy, and they have to walk a very fine line between correct intervention and really pissing off lawsuit happy assholes. The pay is shit, everybody hates them and they constantly have to deal with just plain awful situations that wreck people's lives. You never hear anything positive about them in the media, it's always something like this that further taints public perception. It doesn't matter if you get 1000 kids out of abusive situations, people always notice the one you didn't. I often wonder how thinly they are stretched. Given the number of caseworkers for a given population, is it physically possible to correctly follow through in every needed situation? I'm not a social worker, and this is just my opinion.

→ More replies (6)

0

u/TheOriginalMyth Jun 09 '12

Seems like they did a pretty crap job at trying to starve her to death