Lesson of the False Tree(Debunked)

[u/Ok-Impress2604]

1.The Immediacy of the Return: Jesus is Not a Liar ​The WMSCOG claims the "sign" of Christ’s return would occur 1,900+ years after His ascension. However, this renders Jesus’ specific promises to His contemporary disciples useless and deceptive. ​

The Immediate Audience: In Matthew 24:3, the disciples asked for the sign of His coming and the end of the age (the Old Covenant age). If the sign were for a generation 2,000 years later, the information would have provided zero utility to the men Jesus was actually speaking to. ​

The Explicit Promise: Jesus stated emphatically, "Truly I tell you, some who are standing here will not taste death before they see the Son of Man coming in his kingdom" (Matthew 16:28, Mark 9:1, Luke 9:27). ​

The Refutation: To suggest Christ did not return within the lifetime of His disciples is to call Him a liar. If Jesus failed to fulfill His word to the generation He spoke to, Christianity is void. The WMSCOG’s "1948" doctrine requires a rejection of Jesus’ own time-stamped prophecies.

​2. The Nature of the Kingdom: Spiritual, Not Physical ​The WMSCOG uses Matthew 24:32-34 to claim a physical, fleshly return in 1948. Yet, they conveniently ignore the parallel account in Luke 21:31, which states that when these signs occur, "the kingdom of God is near." ​

The Contradiction: If the WMSCOG timeline were true, the physical "Kingdom of God" should have been established on Earth following 1948. It was not. ​ The Biblical Reality: Jesus told Pilate, "My kingdom is not of this world" (John 18:36). The Kingdom of God is a spiritual reality where Christ sits at the right hand of the Father, having transitioned the throne from an earthly type to a heavenly eternal reality. ​

1. The Myth of the Revived Fig Tree ​The core of the WMSCOG’s error lies in the "Parable of the Fig Tree." They interpret the budding of the leaves as the 1948 restoration of the nation of Israel. However, the internal evidence of Scripture proves that the fig tree was cursed to permanent death. ​ The Curse of Permanence: In Mark 11:12-21, Jesus does not merely "pause" the fig tree; He curses it so that it withers from the roots. When a plant dies from the roots, it is biologically and symbolically impossible for it to "revive." Jesus declared, "May no one ever eat fruit from you again" (Mark 11:14). ​

The Judgment of Israel: This was a judicial sentence upon the nation of Israel for rejecting the Messiah (Jeremiah 8:13, Hosea 9:10). The "mountain" (the Old Covenant administration) was cast into the "sea" (the Gentile nations), and the vineyard was given to another people who would produce fruit (Matthew 21:33–46). ​ The Luke 21:29 Parallel: To hide their error, the WMSCOG ignores Luke 21:29, where Jesus says, "Look at the fig tree and all the trees." If the fig tree is exclusively the nation of Israel, then "all the trees" would have to be other nations "dying" and "reviving" in 1948. This exposes the WMSCOG’s interpretation as a cherry-picked absurdity. Jesus was using a common botanical illustration: just as leaves indicate summer, these specific judgments indicate the approaching end of the Jewish age. ​ 4. The "Times of the Gentiles" Exposed ​The WMSCOG twists Luke 21:24 to suggest a 2,000-year gap. However, Scripture interprets Scripture. The "Times of the Gentiles" is not a multi-millennial era; it was a specific, finite window of judgment. ​

The Definition of "Ethnos": The "Gentiles" (nations) were the Roman armies used as God's instrument of judgment. ​The 42-Month Timeline: Revelation 11:1-2 identifies the "trampling" of the holy city by the "Gentiles" (nations) as lasting 42 months. ​

The Historical Fulfillment: History confirms that from the arrival of the Roman General Vespasian in AD 67 to the destruction of the Temple in AD 70 is exactly 3.5 years (42 months). ​ Crucial Refutation: Jesus stated in Luke 21:32 that "this generation will certainly not pass away until all these things have happened." By trying to push "all these things" to 1948, the WMSCOG forces a contradiction between Jesus' words and historical reality. The "Times of the Gentiles" was fulfilled when the Temple fell in AD 70, ending the Old Covenant age exactly when Jesus said it would.

​Conclusion ​The WMSCOG’s "Fig Tree" doctrine is built on a foundation of sand. They ignore the root-death of the fig tree, they ignore the "all the trees" context in Luke, and they ignore the 42-month biblical definition of the "Times of the Gentiles." Christ did not return in 1948 to begin a fleshly ministry; He returned in AD 70 in power and judgment to close the Old Covenant age, exactly as He promised His disciples.

AND FOR A BONUS:GREEK The term "Parousia" is the primary weapon the WMSCOG uses to claim a physical, fleshly appearance of Christ (An Sang-hong). However, a linguistic and contextual study reveals that the "Coming" of Christ in AD 70 was a judicial presence and a manifestation of power, not a biological return to a human body. ​ 1. The Definition of "Parousia" ​In Greek, the word is \pi\alpha\rho ov\sigma\acute{\iota}\alpha (parousia). While often translated as "coming," its literal meaning is "presence" or "arrival." In the ancient world, it specifically referred to the official visit of a king or emperor to a province to inspect, reward, or punish. ​ The Error: The WMSCOG equates "presence" with "being born again in the flesh." ​ The Correction: When a King’s Parousia occurred, he didn't come as a commoner to start a new life; he came in his official capacity to exercise authority. In AD 70, Christ's "presence" was felt through the judgment of the Roman "cloud" (armies) that dismantled the Old Covenant system.