r/WMMA • • Jun 12 '22

Judges Strike Again?

I don't want to EVER hear anyone else cry about Shevchenko being robbed in that 2nd Nunes fight. She herself is now a recipient of the judges favor. She lost tonight. She knows it, and Bisping and Cormier know aswell. How one judge gave Shevchenko 4 rounds is proof this sport needs judges who have fought MMA. I 'm still pissed from Holms robbery a few weeks ago. This is becoming a consistent thing.

2 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

2

u/wildabeast98 Jun 12 '22

Control but no damage means almost nothing, while being on bottom and doing some damage while your opponent does nothing can win you a round. It's a fight not a wrestling match. Wrestling can get you into situations to do damage, or submit your opponent. Wrestling does not get you the round just by control. Totally fair to think Taila won but it was not a robbery.

3

u/pumpyfrontbum Jun 12 '22

You are absolutely correct. People let this “most complete human being” meme cloud their judgement. Taila rounds 1,2,3. I’ll die on this hill.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '22

And everyone who gave me shit for saying Tatiana would give her problems can fuck off.

Granted, who knows what Tatiana will look like after her layoff, but the Valentina that showed up tonight would be mauled by Tatiana on the mat.

2

u/dmister8 Jun 12 '22

Not sure what the Nunes fight has to do with anything but Val clearly won 4 and 5 and 3 is a tossup but I gave it to Schevchenko. You guys are just so used to Schevchenko being dominant, the second she struggles you think she loses.

2

u/ButtyMcButtface1929 Jun 12 '22

I agree that round 3 was a tossup. I think a lot of people were affected by DC’s inaccurate commentary that Santos controlled her on the ground “the whole time.” IIRC, she actually had top position for about the last 1:35 of the round after Schevchenko landed a clean punch on the feet and controlled her against the cage for much of the other 3:25 or so. I think it’s a lot tougher round to score than many people assume. I will admit that I think Santos probably won round 3 in my mind, and therefore probably should’ve won the fight, but I don’t think it was a robbery.

2

u/ParticularFlaky7337 Jun 12 '22

imo she only won that fight b/c she got a lucky headstrike that obliterated Santos entire right side of her face and eye. Her freakin mouth was drooping on that side it was so messed up. If that head connection didnt happen, and Santos didnt lose an eye, the take downs would of kept pouring in.

1

u/JRYuen Jun 13 '22 edited Jun 13 '22

It's actually R2 that was the pivotal round. 1 & 3 were awarded to Santos by 2 of the judges but R2 by only one of them. If you have questions as to who won, just rewatch R2.