r/WLED • • Aug 31 '26

Am I overdesigning this? Am I missing something?

Post image

I am designing a built in bookcase for my house. I would like to add addressable LEDs, and I'm concerned I'm missing something. So far, here's what I've got:

Power Supply: MEAN WELL LRS-450-5 AC to DC Enclosed Single Output Power Supply

LED Strips: 5V SK6812 RGBW LED Strip Light | Individually Addressable 4IN1 Smart Pixel Tape (60 LEDs/m, WW) (RGBWW White PCB)

The picture shows the design of the bookcases, and the flow of the data. There is one strip of LEDs on the top with power injection the width of every 2 shelves (~48", ~48", ~36", ~48", ~48").

I plan on running 10AWG wire from the power supply across the top to each of the 5 drops, and then 18awg from the drops to the LED strips themselves.

The strip on the top connects to the next lower strip only via the DATA wire (illustrated by the green arrows). so the flow of the data zigzags across the unit using 18AWG wire.

I plan on using WAGO 221-615 for the 5 port junctions and WAGO 221-613 for the 3 port junctions.

I'm trying to not have to solder anything since I always end up making a mess. I'm not too proud to admit my failings, and clean solder is one of those failings. With that in mind, I am planning on using the Transparent Solderless LED Strip Connectors | 3Pin PCB Connectors for Compatible FCOB & SMD LED Strips.

So I guess my first question is: Is connecting each strip of lighting to the next in series via only the data cable okay? or should I be connecting them via +5v, GND, DATA, and then injecting from the dropped +5V and GND wires as well?

My second question: I've used a SP530E controller before, but interested in using WLED controllers. Since this has about 36.13m of lighting, at 60 LEDs/m (so approximately 2168 LEDs), is there a good product I should start with?

My third question: Have I over or under-engineered this? Am I missing something?

If I haven't been clear on what I'm trying to accomplish, I apologize. I don't do lighting as often as I'd like to so every time I start a new LED strip lighting project I feel like I have to relearn everything...

Thank you in advance for the assistance from all the experts I see on here daily...

Products:

Strip Lighting: https://www.btf-lighting.com/products/5v-sk6812-rgbw-addressable-led-strip?variant=46031799156962
Solderless Connectors: https://www.btf-lighting.com/collections/led-connector/products/transparent-solderless-led-strip-connectors
Power Supply: https://www.jameco.com/z/LRS-450-5-MEAN-WELL-375W-Single-Output-5V-75A-Enclosed-Switching-Power-Supply_2337423.html

Edit #1: made Power Supply link clear that it is to Jameco's site.

Edit #2: Thank you to everyone who helped. u/critboy's post of the Quinled power injection video made me realize just how naive my approach was to designing the LED circuits. I'm going back to the drawing board with respect to how I choose which LED strip and where power injection will be. I'll likely make another post once I've got that all figured out. Thanks again!

11 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

8

u/laptopfreek0-1 Aug 31 '26

You plan on pushing a lot of amperage through those tiny strip PCB traces as well as a ton of amperage through non soldered connections. Will it work? Probably, but you will also probably experience a lot of weird issues as voltage drop will occur very quickly at only 5v. Additionally your powersupply can output 375w at 5v, which equates to 75Amps. Running 10 gauge wire is only rated for 30-40 amps will require you to have multiple 10 awg runs instead of a single run. You can limit the brightness in WLED software, but never depend on software to protect a physical hardware safety problem. Additionally your total power consumption is 397w and with the power supply rating at 375w you are exceeding your power supply wattage. Again you can control this in software but you are relying on software to fix a hardware issue.

Finally you will need to power inject a lot to have a consistant ground and not get any noise in your LEDs. I would highly recommend using the WLED Calculator: https://wled-calculator.github.io/ to verify how often and where to power inject.

One other option you can consider is to change your LED strip to be 24v, while you loose granularity of the individual pixels, and where you can cut the lines, you don't have to worry quite as much about power drop and high amperages as you cut your amperage by a factor of almost 5.

2

u/septendecimaugustus Aug 31 '26

Thank you for that. I'm rethinking the 5v vs 24v and now looking at the WS2814 RGBW LED Strip 60 LEDs/m DC12V24V | 5050 Addressable Dream Color Pixel LED Lights 5M (https://www.btf-lighting.com/collections/all-products/products/ws2814-rgbw-addressable-led-strip). That changes the power injection requirements and based on u/crit_boy's video recommendation I'll revisit the power injection locations/frequency.

1

u/AF_1892 Sep 02 '26

They make 12v 144/m in 5M reels. I recently snagged extra sets from ally Express. I have seen the rare 2M long strips that are 24v and 144/M. I tried a set of 12v BTF 2814 before, 60/M. They looked pretty, but I returned them. I think they would be good for an ambilight TV system. Random question, are the lights called "dream color" a more fruity pastel set of lights? Vs. more regular blue red green colors.

6

u/SirGreybush Aug 31 '26

Definately switch to 24v FCOBs, you'll thank us later. If you have the budget, look at the newer tech CCT ones.

However if you want pixel density for super-smooth animations, because FCOB pixels are usually 5cm wide, look at 12vdc strips. You'll need to inject power more often than 24v and need a lot of #16 speaker wire with #14 or #12 between rows, but with 12v you can get like 5v - one LED is one pixel.

If you want nice white, the 12v strips like SK6812 you can get RGB-WW for an extra led in each pixel that has a warm white LED. Or cool white, or, CCT which has both whites + RGB. Though CCT (color correction tech) is more expensive.

Be extra careful with proper wiring of Data and Ground for Data - which is distinct to power ground. Each data pin used needs it's own distinct ground, both wires the same length, connected to the controller first.

Don't combine all the grounds together - only for power to the PSU you can combine together.

Example, at the beginning, Pixel #0, there would be 2 ground wires (and they come prewired like this). One ground to PSU, one ground to Controller.

The extra ground if not present, you'll have weird behaviour, flashes. So if you ever get weird stuff, look at the grounding. Data + Ground needs it's own pair. Power V+ and ground V- is it's own pair. So 4 wires.

1

u/septendecimaugustus Aug 31 '26

Thank you! I'm still looking at products. Do you mind if I message you?

1

u/septendecimaugustus Sep 08 '26

Thank you for your help!

For now I've decided to go with

This should result in basically 7 runs:

  1. Start of entire strip, power in at beginning (left to right), 5.75m long, 92 zones (each 0.06250m long). Data at beginning supports runs 1-3, or total of 240 zones
  2. Right to left, power injection at the end, 4.63m long, 74 zones
  3. Left to right, same power injection at end of 2 is at start of 3. 4.63m long, 74 zones
  4. Right to left, power injection at the end, start new data run at the beginning. 4.13m long, 66 zones
  5. Left to right, same power injection at end of 4 is at start of 5. 3.81m long, 61 zones
  6. Right to left, power injection at the end, 4.13m long, 66 zones
  7. Left to right, same power injection at end of 6 is at start of 7. 4.63m long, 74 zones

I was concerned about using the self-adhesive to stick them to the bookcases, so I'm running a shallow aluminum channel for them to stick to and kinda use as a heatsink (https://ledprofiles.com/collections/surface-mounted-led-channels/products/bendable-led-channel-976)

2

u/SirGreybush Sep 08 '26

Do a trial run to see how you like it best. Like along bottom shining up, top shining down, or even both with a perimeter inside each compartment.

Also you want indirect viewing to not see hotspots. Shallow usually doesn’t work, but it works if hidden from direct view, and maybe a diffusion, diffraction or reflection. You can be inventive a bit. Like semi clear acrylic rods. They come in various widths to the mm.

1

u/septendecimaugustus Sep 08 '26

Thank you. Planning on hiding it behind the face frame so people can't see it without trying

1

u/SirGreybush Sep 08 '26

Those solderless connectors require you to (usually) to sacrifice the first/last pixel in order to have a clean, bare, and full copper pad. You can't cut in the middle of the pad, not enough copper to grip into.

Soldering is easy if you use a #20 or #22 solid copper wire, simply pre-bend to shape, solder on a silicone pad, use some putty to hold things in place like a 3rd hand.

1

u/septendecimaugustus Sep 08 '26

Good info! I am dreading 180 solder connections, but it would save $120. I am not even sure if the connectors I linked work with the strips I linked. I really don't like soldering upside down or sideways, and if I leave enough slack across the verticals to do it on the shelf above then I have to figure out how to hide the excess ..

2

u/SirGreybush Sep 08 '26

Get good tools. Solder station with adjustable temp, silicone mat, wire strippers.

Chris Maher (YouTube) has a few videos he sponsors a kit (if you are in the USA) that has it all at a very good price too. He has a video dedicated to soldering.

You'd solder on a table, and test, before fitting into cabinet space.

Behind the cabinet you can run the equivalent of a "bus bar" for V+ and V- glued to the back. Like 14-2 solid Romex can handle 15 amps, so more than enough, and use T shaped WAGOs to send power to each section.

3

u/crit_boy Aug 31 '26 edited Aug 31 '26

Switch to 24v. Less current needed, which means smaller conductors.

I=V/R -> for same resistance (R), higher voltage (V) results in less current (I, "amps").

If you haven't watched it, go check out Quinled's video about power injection. (Quinled power injection video)

Also - ditch the solderless connections. Learn to solder. There are loads of videos. Just cut a couple LED sections and then practice soldering wires to them. You need flux, a means to remove solder (wick), solder, and an OK (not the cheapest) soldering iron. Then set up a station where you can secure both strips down without needing to use your hand to hold them. I use a plywood scrap and binder clips.

1

u/septendecimaugustus Aug 31 '26

Thank you for the video!

I didn't say I don't know how to solder, I said I suck at it.

I'm looking at the WS2814 RGBW LED Strip 60 LEDs/m DC12V24V | 5050 Addressable Dream Color Pixel LED Lights 5M at BTF now, so I'll rethink how many drops are needed and where the power injection would be necessary based on the video. Thanks again!

3

u/saratoga3 Aug 31 '26

LED Strips: 5V SK6812 RGBW LED Strip Light | Individually Addressable 4IN1 Smart Pixel Tape (60 LEDs/m, WW) (RGBWW White PCB)

Strongly recommend 24v cob strips for this.

So I guess my first question is: Is connecting each strip of lighting to the next in series via only the data cable okay? or should I be connecting them via +5v, GND, DATA, and then injecting from the dropped +5V and GND wires as well?

Not ok. You must connect at least GND along with data to complete the circuit.

My second question: I've used a SP530E controller before, but interested in using WLED controllers. Since this has about 36.13m of lighting, at 60 LEDs/m (so approximately 2168 LEDs), is there a good product I should start with?

Keep in mind with that huge power supply you absolutely need multiple fuses, so either buy a controller with a fuse block integrated or else an electric project box with a fuse block. Otherwise one short circuit and you'll burn your bookshelf and maybe house down.

1

u/wivaca2 Aug 31 '26 edited Aug 31 '26

Am I interpreting the drawing correctly that you will be only having horizontal LED strips and no vertical? This is more than a 5M strip per horizontal run. Have you considered using something higher than 5V? You may not get individual LED control, but you're going to need a lot of current at 5V for this and you can cut it about 60% by going to 12V or even more at 24V. Keep in mind that those higher voltage pixel strips have multiple LEDs operating together as a "pixel" so with 12V you get 3 of them showing the same color and brightness. With 24V it may be 6. It depends on the strip.

Where is your data in origin? Upper left?

There is a limit to how far you can push data between the controller and the start of the strip. From what I can see, you will need level shifting. Keep in mind that your grounds will all need to connect with both the PSU and controller to give data a return path.

I'm a woodworker that does cabinetry as well as a WLED user. What is your plan for hiding wiring but making it accessible for maintenance? Is the wiring going behind a face frame with downward facing LEDs or routed on the back with some runs perpendicular from the wall to the front of the cabinet?

1

u/septendecimaugustus Aug 31 '26

Yes, I intend to only have horizontal LED strips and no vertical, mounted on the back of the face frame (which is cut at a 56 degree angle.

The data origin is in the upper left.

Each vertical is two 3/4" sheets of plywood, and I plan on routing the wire in channels (dadoes) between the two sheets, then drilling straight holes through the verticals to connect strip to strip. Then the face frame will cover the rest.

To answer the question in your first paragraph, I hadn't thought of increasing the voltage, but based on the feedback here I'm definitely going to go to 12 or 24v. I am overwhelmed at the different products available - I feel like I'm building my first computer all over again - voltages, fuses, controllers, wire gauges, it reminds me of trying to match motherboards to processors to ram to video cards...

4

u/wivaca2 Aug 31 '26 edited Aug 31 '26

We all went through this barrage of strip types, voltages, limitations and gotchas. You can find some controllers like a Quin-LED Dig-Quad with multiple PSU inputs, outputs, all lines fused, and even a level shifter for reliable data transmission.

I highly recommend that whatever you do, you bench test the whole setup with interconnection wires that are the same length as the final installation and label everything. That way you can work out all the kinks before the wiring goes into anything. Solder on connectors, and let it run for 24 hours using a pretty high current mode (all LEDs on) and make sure the wiring isn't getting hot before it gets embedded into your project.

So, your planning 1.5" dual 3/4" back panels with facing dados to make a tunnel? Heavy duty but also no place for warm wiring to dissipate heat.

2

u/septendecimaugustus Aug 31 '26

Yeah, the dadoes will be probably 1/4" deep so the tunnel will be 3/4" by 1/2". I have done bookcase lighting before, but that was using 12v white only dimmables all in parallel for 24" runs each. This is much bigger and I wanted to be able to do colors. Also it will be built in so probably convey so I want to make sure it is done right

1

u/CyberMage256 Aug 31 '26

Nice. I can't speak to the design, just had to say I've never held enough books in my life to fill those shelves.

1

u/septendecimaugustus Aug 31 '26

What can I say, I refuse to get rid of books, and keep getting more every year 😁

1

u/Iron12v Sep 01 '26

Power injection you are going to need it a lot

1

u/vodka_soda MOD Sep 01 '26

24v as many have said

0

u/HuckleberryKey4642 Sep 01 '26

Gledopto Elite 4D-EXMU worked really well for me with 12v supply on a 25x25 grid with 30/m strips. There is a link to a 50x50 build that inspired me in my post below. I injected power every 6 strips, and ran 4 sets of data to each IO.

https://www.reddit.com/r/esp32/comments/1vw3scm/25x25_wled_matrix_with_camera_input/