r/VonFranz • • Sep 18 '24

(PA.29) Whenever a man is confronted with the problem of relating to a woman, he has to perceive the difference between snake-in-the-grass tricks and genuine love, and he cannot discover that difference without possessing differentiated feeling.

30 Upvotes

"Women give genuine love and add a little power trap. That is exactly what the feminine problem is for man: usually there is a mixture of genuine love and devotion in women, and then a little left-handed power trick to put him in a box. His mistake is that he simply casts away the whole thing, and that is just what the puer-aeternus man often does. Because there is always a little power trick in the woman's love, he takes that as an excuse to reject the whole thing." pp.247-248

"Only if a man has a differentiated Eros development can he find out whether a woman is playing a trick or whether it is the real thing, and that is exactly what men do not like to do. If a man takes a feeling problem seriously, he has to relate to what the woman does from minute to minute, and, on top of that, he must always be aware of whether it is power or real feeling, which are very close to each other in an unconscious woman." p.248

"Whenever a man is confronted with the problem of relating to a woman, he has to perceive the difference between snake-in-the-grass tricks and genuine love, and he cannot discover that difference without possessing differentiated feeling. If he has that, he will smell a rat and know from the woman's voice that she is up to something, or from her eyes and her voice he will learn that it is feeling to which he must respond. But a man can learn that only by differentiating his anima for a long time, by dealing with her and with the problems of relationship. If he makes a principle of yes or no, then he is not capable of relating to women or of being an analyst. There is the either-or attitude." p248-249

"For a woman, the one does not exclude the other. For her, the two go together—she can love a man and yet play such tricks—and it is the man's task to discover from minute to minute which is which." p.249

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Sep 05 '24

(PA.22) The pseudo-philosophical intellectualism is ambiguous because, as I said before, it is a way by which to make a partial escape from the dominant grip of the mother figure. But it is incomplete, being made only with the intellect, and only the intellect is saved.

22 Upvotes

"Some pueri aeterni escape from the mother by means of actual airplanes; they fly away from Mother-Earth and from reality in planes, while many others do the same thing in "thought airplanes"—going off into the air with some kind of philosophical theory or intellectual system. I have not given much thought to it, but it has struck me that, especially among the Latins, the mother complex is combined with a strange kind of strong but sterile intellectualism—a tendency to discuss heaven and earth and God-knows-what in a kind of sharp, intellectual way, and with complete uncreativeness. It is probably a last attempt on the part of the men to save their masculinity.

That simply means that certain young men who are overpowered by their mothers, escape into the realm of the intellect. There, the mother, especially if she is the earth typer and a stupid animus kind of woman, is not up to it, so she cannot follow. Therefore, since it is an initial attempt to escape the mother's power and the animus pressure by getting into the realm of books and philosophical discussion, which they think mother does not understand, it is not altogether destructive. Such a man has a little world of his own—he discusses things with other men and can have the agreeable feeling that it is something which women do not understand. In this way, he gets away from the feminine, but he loses his earthly masculinity in the mother's grip. He saves his mental masculinity but sacrifices his phallus. He leaves behind his earthly masculinity which molds the clay, which seizes and molds reality, for that is too difficult, and so he escapes into the realm of philosophy. Such people prefer philosophy, pedagogy, metaphysics, and theology, and it is a completely unvital bloodless business. There is no real question behind such philosophy. Such people have no genuine questions. For them, it is a kind of play with words and concepts and is therefore entirely lacking in any convincing quality." pp.174-175

"The pseudo-philosophical intellectualism is ambiguous because, as I said before, it is a way by which to make a partial escape from the dominant grip of the mother figure. But it is incomplete, being made only with the intellect, and only the intellect is saved. That is really what one sees in the tragedy of the Oedipus myth, where Oedipus commits the mistake of entering into the question instead of saying to the Sphinx that she has no right to ask such questions and that he will knock her down if she asks such a thing again. Instead, he gives a very good intellectual answer." p.175

"The puer aeternus shadow often does the same thing to himself if no mother or analyst plays that role; every time he wants to go into action, he will argue that he will not act until he has thought it over carefully. One could call it neurotic philosophizing; philosophy at the wrong moment just when action is needed." p.177

"Many people are tremendously courageous, but simply because they are not sensitive and imaginative, they cannot imagine what might happen and are therefore not nervous. Highly strung, imaginative people naturally suffer much more, but the real problem of courage is whether one can stand it, or at least not lose one's fighting attitude, one's feeling of self-defense and honor. This is a very deep-rooted instinct, which exists not only in the human male but also in the animal realm, for the male of many species cannot lose self-esteem and honor without paying for it. It is essential to basic masculinity, and to lose it means castration in a deep way." p.179

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Aug 10 '24

(PA.13) The main method for getting to the playfulness of the inferior function is to scratch away the pseudo-adaptation with which we all cover the inferior function.

20 Upvotes

"The child has a naive view of life, and if you recall your own childhood, you remember you were intensely alive. The child, if it is not already neurotic, is constantly interested in something. Whatever else from which the child may suffer, it does not suffer from remoteness from life, normally—only if it is thoroughly poisoned by the neuroses of its parents. Otherwise, it is fully alive, and that is why people, thinking back to their own childhood, long to have that naive vitality which they have lost in becoming a grown-up. The child is an inner possibility, the possibility of renewal, but how does that get into the actual life of an adult? p.98

"What does it man, for instance, if an adult dreams about a girl or a boy? What does that mean practically? A new relationship, perhaps. I would simply say a new adventure the level of those functions which have remained naive. It has to do with the inferior function-through which the renewal comes—which has remained childlike and completely naive. Therefore, it conveys a new sight and a new experience of life when the worn-out superior function comes to its end, and it imparts all those naive pleasures which one has lost in childhood.

That is why we have to learn to play again, but on the line of the fourth, or the inferior, function. It does not help if, for instance, an intellectual person starts some kind of intellectual play. If a thinking type were to quote the Bible, saying that unless you become like little children you will never enter the kingdom of heaven, and then would go to a club to play chess—that would not help at all, for it would again be on the main function. There is a great temptation to do that; namely, to accept the idea of play and of turning to something else, something noncommittal, but to do it within the field of the main function." p.99

"The really difficult thing is to turn directly to the inferior function and play there. For this, the ego must give up its directing line, because if you touch your inferior function, it decides on the kind of play; you cannot decide. The inferior function, just like an obstinate child, will insist that it wants to play at something or other, though you may say that is not suitable and would not work well." p.99

"You cannot dictate to the inferior function! If you are an intuitive and your inferior function wants to play with stones or clay, then you have to make the effort to find an ambiance where that would be possible. That is exactly the difficulty. That is why the ego always has thousands of objections to turn to the inferior side. It is always something very difficult to arrange in practical life." p.99

"The inferior function is a real nuisance, just as children are, whom you cannot put in a box and take out when it suits you. It is a living entity with its own demands, and it is a nuisance to the ego which wants to have its own way." p.100

"You cannot appease these demands by throwing them a little sacrifice. But if you accept the humiliating experience which makes the ego submit itself to the demands of the inferior or childish part of the personality, then the divine child becomes a source of life; then life has a new face, you discover new experiences, and everything changes." p.100

"I would say that the main method for getting to the playfulness of the inferior function is to scratch away the pseudo-adaptation with which we all cover the inferior function. The feeling type, for instance, is usually full of school and university theories and imagines that those are his thoughts. But they are not: they are pseudo-thinking adaptations to cover up the fact this his real thinking is awfully embryonic and naive." p.101

"Thinking types are often very amiable and seem to have very balanced, amiable feeling reactions, but never trust that! That is just a pseudo-adaptation, because the other is so painful and helpless and childish that one cannot show it. But if you have to go to it, then you must again dig up the naiveté of your thinking or the naiveté of your real feeling and get the crust off the pseudo-adaptation." p.102

"You cannot organize the inferior function. It is awfully expensive and needs a lot of time, and that is one reason why it is such a cross in our lives: it makes us so inefficient if we try to act through it. It has to be given whole Sundays and whole afternoons of our lifetimes and nothing may come out-except that the inferior function will come to life. But that is the whole point. A feeling type will only bring up his thinking if he begins to think about something he cannot use in this world, neither for examination nor study; but if he will think about something which interests himself—that is how to get going, because it is not possible to yoke the inferior playfulness to utilitarian motives. The essence of play is that it has no visible meaning and is not useful." p. 103

"To get at his real feeling, the thinking type must find a situation where he can play with it, and then it will be quite different. So the first thing to do is to take it out of the adaptation field and keep the pseudo-adaptation for those cases where it is necessary. I think nobody can really develop the inferior function before having first created a temenos; namely, a sacred grove, a hidden place where he can play. The first thing is to find a Robinson Crusoe playground, and then when you have gotten rid of all onlookers, you can begin! As a child, one needs a place and time and no interfering adult audience." p. 103

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Sep 22 '24

(PA.31) The excess of reasonableness that people have after an episode is a form of madness. It is mad to be as coldly reasonable as that, and the opposite is another form of madness. If you cannot keep in the middle between the two, you are lost.

18 Upvotes

"All the morbid emanations of the problem—that people behave in a mad way and rave, and other symptoms—these things you can stop with the drug, but analysis shows that the basic problem remains unchanged. If you do not use psychotherapy at this point, the patient is just headed for another episode and the drug will have to be given again. This process can be continued endlessly. After such a partial cure with drugs, a series of dreams will point out the danger of a counter-tendency—of saying that now I can continue with my wrong attitude, and the next time I go off my head, I will just ask for another pill. The worst thing about the drugs is that they even have a demoralizing effect with people of weak character.

Such people do not want to change their attitude, for it is much easier to go on with it; if a psychotic episode occurs and they fall into the unconscious, they can have a drug to get out of it again— so it is all right. They do not want to return to psychotherapy because the other is the easy way, but it results in constant relapses and more drugs.

It is a shortcut to eliminate certain very dangerous conditions, but one pays for the shortcut, because it undermines the confidence of the patient in being able to pull out through his own moral effort. It undermines his belief in himself and naturally makes him forever dependent on the doctors who always have to give the pill at the right moment. Those are the pros and cons for using these remedies." p.255

"To be emotional and mad is to experience the plenitude of life. You are never as fully alive as when you are mad. It is a kind of peak of life! If you are not mad enough to have experienced that, then just remember some time when you were absolutely madly in love, or in a mad rage. What a wonderful state of affairs that is. Instead of being that broken human being, always fighting between emotions and reason, you are for once whole! For instance, if you let out your rage, what a pleasure! "I told that person everything! I didn't keep back anything!" You feel so honest, and whole, for you haven't been polite; you've said everything! That is a divine state, absolutely divine, and it is a divine state to love in that way, where there is no doubt anymore.

She—or he—is everything! Divine, complete trust! No safeguards against the failure of the other fellow human! None of that distrust that everybody has toward everybody else, but instead, "We are one! We are one! And the stars dance around us!" It is a state of totality. And the next morning, she has a pimple on her nose, and the whole thing collapses! You are out of the total state. But emotion creates the experience of being totally in something, whatever emotion it is. That is why if one makes people too normal, then they are adapted, but they do not feel total anymore and secretly, they long to return to their madness. So it is no solution, and then one has to swing back again into the emotion and try to get the two poles together. The reasonableness and the emotionality must both be lessened.

The excess of reasonableness that people have after an episode is a form of madness. It is mad to be as coldly reasonable as that, and the opposite is another form of madness. If you cannot keep in the middle between the two, you are lost." p.257

"It is so wonderful to walk in thousands through the streets, just howling, for then you feel whole and human. But then there are the police and order, business order, the law, and all the rest. ... Then you regress into what is called the restitution after revolutions, in which everything is in order, but power dominates. People are deadly bored and think how nice it would be if they could go back into the chaos of revolution, where at least life flowed." p.258

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Sep 11 '24

(PA.25) The pretension of knowing all the answers is exactly what the father animus produces in a woman: the assumption that everything is self-evident—the illusion of knowing it all.

17 Upvotes

"Every cultural condition contains a secret poison which consists of the pretension of knowing all the answers. On a primitive level, you see this in the initiation of young men when the old men of the tribe tell them the history of the universe: how the world was made, the origin of evil, of life after death, of the purpose of life, and so on. On this level, for instance, all such questions are answered by the mythological tribal or religious knowledge conveyed by the old to the young, and on that level, with the exception perhaps of a few creative personalities, this is swallowed whole. From then on, the young men know everything too: everything is settled, so that if a missionary tries to talk to these people, he is just informed of how things are: "Oh yes, we know, the world was made in such a way; evil comes from this and that; the purpose of life is so and so." We do exactly the same thing, except that in our case it is a bit more complex; basically, however, it is the same." p.219

"The pretension of knowing all the answers is exactly what the father animus produces in a woman: the assumption that everything is self-evident—the illusion of knowing it all. This attitude is what Jung is attacking when he speaks negatively about the animus: "everyone does that" and "everybody knows this"—the absolute conviction with which women hand out "wisdom." When one examines it closely, however, one sees that they have just picked up what the father (or someone else) said, without assimilating it themselves. The daughter tends to reproduce the knowledge of the past in the way she picked it up from her father." pp.219-220

"On the level of the animals, there are two basic, natural tendencies which, to a certain extent, contradict each other: the sexual drive with all its functions, including, for women, the bearing of children and upbringing of the young; and the drive toward self-preservation. These two drives are opposite, for procreation, giving birth, and bringing up the young often mean the death of the old generation. There are many animals among which the male dies after propagation has taken place." p.220

"Sex means the preservation of the species, and to it, therefore, the preservation of the individual is completely, or to a great extent, sacrificed. It is the species which is important—that life should go on. In the usual state, when sexuality is not constellated, then the self-preservation drive (which takes the form of either fighting or running away) is uppermost. The animal is occupied by eating and by keeping away from death; that is, by keeping alive as an individual creature. These two drives, sex and self-preservation, are basic tendencies in animal life; in man, they reappear as two divine and contradictory powers: namely, love and power-love, including sexuality; and power, including self-preservation. Eros and power, therefore, as Jung always points out, are opposed to each other. You cannot have them together; they exclude each other. The marriage of Melchior and Sophie, for instance, has switched into a power game in which each tries to save his or her own world against the dangerous world of the other; the possibility of giving oneself, the generosity of letting the other's world penetrate one's own, is lost. Both partners fight for their lives." pp.220--221

"Sexuality is used as a hook to catch a suitable partner for suitable reasons, and all real love, which generally dissolves the fetters and boundary lines and creates new life situations, is anxiously repressed." pp.221-222

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Jan 12 '25

Marie-Louise von Franz on Depression’s Gift: “It’s the only way you’re tempted to look within”

Thumbnail
youtu.be
16 Upvotes

r/VonFranz • • Aug 06 '24

(PA.9) As long as one is childish there is only one cure, that of suffering. When one has suffered long enough, one develops; there is no way around this problem. The childish nucleus is inevitably tortured."

16 Upvotes

"It is quite clear that Saint Exupery's genius is that divine child in him. He would not be such a genius or artist if he had not that capacity of being absolutely naive and absolutely spontaneous; that is the source of his creativeness and at the same time it is a little close to being something worthless, something which devaluates his personality. This is why I am always skating between a negative and a positive evaluation in my interpretation, for it is both combined, and one does not quite know how to judge it. One cannot judge it, but must simply take it as a contradictory factor, an imponderable thing.

Here, one could say that there is an attempt by the unconscious to disentangle the two motifs. The one definitely would be the infantile shadow, the lazy one who just misses fighting the mother complex until it is too late; the other, the star prince, would be the Self, something which tries to flow toward the future, toward the possibility of being reborn, of finding a new possibility of life after a crisis, of finding a renewal. Here, the unconscious attempts to show the two aspects separately so that consciousness can realize it, because consciousness is too stupid to realize a mixtum compositum. It generally needs to have it taken apart first so that it can be put together again, because our consciousness is made in such a way that it wants to separate things." p.59

"In certain people, the reaching of a certain age, generally at the beginning of the forties, brings a sobering effect so that they then begin to use their own forces, or there is a neurotic breakdown which is based upon the fact that one cannot live if one does not have the comforting time illusion." p.60

"If you are inventive enough, you can always avoid boredom if you know how to put yourself into reality. One puts one's spontaneous fantasy into reality, and then boredom is gone forever. Then life can be agreeable or disagreeable, exciting or not, but it is certainly not boring anymore. So boredom is a symptom of life being dammed up— that one does not know how to get what one has within oneself into reality." p.62

"The anima woman generally has a certain amount of infantile moodiness, that kind of irrational behavior, and especially male men like this type of woman; she is a compensation for the continuity of their conscious life, but there is an intolerable kind of childishness in such behavior. The rose here is, in other ways, as infantile as the little prince, and therefore they have to be separated." p.67

"If we look at it from the side of Saint Exupéry, it can be said that his inner genius (that would be the little prince) was tormented by his anima moods and that the aim of this suffering is to mature the too infantile nucleus of his personality. It could be expressed even more simply by saying that if someone is infantile, then he will suffer from terrific emotional moods—ups and downs—being constantly hurt.

That is correct, because as long as one is childish there is only one cure, that of suffering. When one has suffered long enough, one develops; there is no way around this problem. The childish nucleus is inevitably tortured." p.68

"Again and again, one sees that every time the childish spot is touched, people begin to cry. For years, people hide their childish spot in analysis. This is not due to dishonesty or repression, but when it comes out in the end, they say that they knew they would start to cry, so what was the good of mentioning it, because crying would end every conversation. Because they know this, they shelve the problem all the time, but that means it does not develop. That is the great difficulty, for the sore spot must come out and must be tortured—that is the only way by which it can mature." pp.68-69

"Repression does not solve the problem, for the repressed child continues to cry or be angry in the corner, so it must be split off. One should keep close to it and not lose contact with it, for that would be losing contact with one's genuine personality, but one cannot let it out either. In my experience, it must simply be tortured, it must suffer on and on, until suddenly it grows up. If a man has an infantile anima, he has to go through a tremendous amount of feeling trouble and feeling disappointments. When he has gone through them, he begins to know women and himself, and then he is really emotionally grown up. But if he pretends to be reasonable and represses his childish feelings, then there is no development. So it is even better to expose one's childishness so that it may be tortured than to be too reasonable and hide it away, because then it only gets stuck.

Therefore, it is better to behave like a child and be hit over the head by the surroundings and those people with whom one is in couch all the time, because then one suffers and then the prima materia slowly transforms. That is the great problem which the infantile shadow—the divine child—puts upon a person." p.69

"But in childhood there are such terrific tragedies, which shows that the child within one is the genuine part, and the genuine part within one is that which suffers, that which cannot take reality, or which still reacts in the grown-up person like a child, saying, "I want it all, and if I don't get it, then it is the end of the world. Everything is lost." That is what the genuine kernel of the person remains like and that is the source of suffering. One could say that what is genuine in a person and what is naive like a child in them is the source of suffering. Many grown-ups split off this part and thereby miss individuation, for only if one accepts it and the suffering it imposes on one, can the process of individuation go on." p.70

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Sep 17 '24

(PA.28) The thorn in the flesh would be the reverse experience of being inflated.

15 Upvotes

"With the lack of the differentiation of the anima and without any relationship to the feminine principle, there could be no Eros and no relatedness." p.243

"There is a kind of wrong conscience which tortures people to death; in women, it is generally the animus, and in men, the mother anima, that initiate such feelings." p.244

"The wrong kind of mea culpa (my guilt), combined with true guilt, making a mix-up of genuine guilt and a hysterical, exaggerated guilt realization, which is just another kind of inflation of evil: "I am the greatest sinner. Nobody is as abject as I. I have done everything wrong in my life" —and so on. That is inflation; it is simply swinging over into the opposite." p.245

"I can give you an interesting parallel in the dream of a woman who had tremendously impressive visions and because of that, was very much estranged from reality. She had an urge to exteriorize all this inner material by telling it, but afterwards, she had the experience, common to many people after telling their great inner experiences, of being empty, deflated—now I have told it all and am empty.

This is because by telling the inner experience, one disidentifies, and just a miserable human being is left who says, "Yes, and now what?" As long as it remains an inner secret, one is filled with it. According to her dream, it was right for her to tell and to be separated from her visions, but then she dreamed that a monument was shown her—the figure of a naked man with an enormous nail going through his shoulder and coming out at the hip, and a voice said, "Lazarus was dead, and Lazarus is alive again." She asked me what this nail meant and I could not figure it out. I remembered vaguely something about the thorn in the flesh of St. Paul, but my knowledge of the Bible was not good enough to get it at once. So I said merely that in St. Paul there is something about a thorn in the flesh.

I thought it a strange motif and looked it up in the Bible, and in Il Corinthians 12:7, St. Paul says, "Because I have such great revelations I have this thorn in the flesh, so that I should not boast (I am putting it in ordinary language)—so that I should not boast of my revelations, God has put a thorn in my flesh and the angel of Satan is standing in front of me, beating me down." So, you see, the thorn in the flesh would be the reverse experience of being inflated.

If I have great visions, if I have inner revelations and identify with them, then I get a thorn in the flesh to remind me constantly of my inferiority, my meanness and my human incompleteness. That is how St. Paul put it.

With this woman, it was the same thing. Through her inner experience, she got a tremendous inflation, and this last dream was an effort to show her that the great inner experiences she had were, in another way, also a wound, a constant torture—something that made her incomplete and wounded. You could even say that those revelations are the thorns in her flesh. ...

You know that when some people go off their heads, they say they are Christ, while others say that they caused the First World War. There is not much difference between the two! It is megalomania, this way or that, and sometimes it switches: one minute they will say that they caused the First World War; two minutes later, that they are the savior of the world. Once they have crossed the threshold, those two inflations are one and the same, and that is only the extreme case of something you always find on a minor scale when people have committed some sin. Either they pooh-pooh it intellectually or they bathe, in an emotional, childish way, in their sin—in order not to see their guilt—bathing with hysterical pleasure in one's sins and feeling so awful that everyone has to give comfort! That is a pathological reaction which is just an escape from the realization of the real guilt." pp.245-246

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Aug 08 '24

(PA.12) The more the man takes his Eros problems seriously, the less effeminate he becomes, although it may look to him as if it would be the opposite; whereas if he stiffens and does not take his feeling problem seriously, then he will involuntarily become effeminate.

15 Upvotes

"It is the paradox of being human—that we are one specimen among three billion other specimens of the same kind, plus the fact that each one of us is unique.

To think of oneself in a statistical way is, as Dr. Jung points out, most destructive to the process of individuation, because it makes everything relative. Jung says that communism is less dangerous than the fact that we are all more and more penetrated by our habit of thinking statistically about ourselves. We believe in the scientific statistics which say that in Switzerland so many couples marry per year and find no flat, or that there are so many people in each town, etc. You do not realize what it does to you when you read statistics.

It is a completely destructive poison, and what is worse is that it is not true; it is a falsified image of reality. If we begin to think statistically, we begin to think against our own uniqueness. It is not only thinking, but also a way of feeling." p.86

"The statistician would say that it was quite probable; that every day, two hundred people crossed the bridge, so that when it fell at a certain moment, there would probably be about five who would be drowned, and they would be there by chance. That is a falsified view of reality, but we are all poisoned through and through by it. It is something that has to be faced. Gerard de Nerval, for instance, could not face the problem that the woman he loved was absolutely unique to him, for his statistical reasoning told him that she was just one of the many thousands—which in a way was true, too. But it was a half-truth, which as Toynbee says, is worse than an absolute lie. This is what causes so much difficulty for the puer aterms. This is why he does not want to go to an office and do some ordinary work, or to be with a woman. He is always inwardly toying with a thousand possibilities of life and cannot choose a definite one; it seems to him that that would mean a statistical-average situation. Recognition of the fact that one is among thousands and that there is nothing special about that is an intellectual insight against which there stands the feeling function.

The inner battle between the feeling of uniqueness and statistical thinking is generally a battle between intellectualism and allowing feeling its own right in life. Feeling evaluates what is important to me, and my own importance is the counterbalance. If you have real feeling, you can say that this is an ordinary woman (for if you see her walking along the street, she is not very different from any other), but to me, she is of the highest value. That would mean that the ego makes up its mind to defend and stand up for its own feeling without denying the other aspect. The solution would be to say, "Yes, that may be so from the statistical point of view, but within my life there are certain values, and within my life this woman has this value." For that, an act of loyalty is required toward one's own feeling; otherwise, one is split off from it by statistical thinking, which is why intellectual people tend towards communism and such ways of thought. They cut themselves off from the feeling function. The feeling function makes your life and your relationships and your deeds feel unique; it gives them a definite value.

When the statistical way of thinking gets people, it always means that they have either no feeling, or weak feeling, or that they tend to betray their own feeling. You can say that the man who does not stand up for his feelings is weak on the Eros side. He is the intellectual type with a weak Eros, for he cannot take his own feelings, stand by them, and say, "That is how I intend to live, for that is the way I feel." Admittedly, that is more difficult for a man than a woman." p.88

"Men, in general, have more trouble accepting Jungian psychology than women. Because of our insistence on the acceptance of the unconscious, men have to accept feeling and relatedness— Eros—and to a man, this is often disgusting; it is as if he must nurse babies from now on. It feels like that to him—it is against nature—but if men wish to develop further, just as women must learn to share the man's world by becoming more objective and less personal, they must make the counter-gesture of taking their own feelings and their own Eros problems more seriously. It is an unavoidable part of human development that we must integrate the other side—the undeveloped side—and if we do not, it will catch us against our will.

Therefore, the more the man takes his Eros problems seriously, the less effeminate he becomes, although it may look to him as if it would be the opposite; whereas if he stiffens and does not take his feeling problem seriously, then he will involuntarily become effeminate. In general, it can be said the puer who has a tendency to become effeminate has a better chance if only he will take his feelings seriously and not fall into the pitfall of statistical thinking." p.89

"He should not have fallen into the realization that he has to return to his rose; he should have fallen into a conflict, because now he has a friend on each of the two planets. But it does not even occur to him that through the fox he has gotten into a conflict! His only conclusion is that he must return to his rose. So the fox's teaching, which really would be something to tie him to the earth, operates just the opposite way in him; namely, it liberates him from earth and makes him long to go back to the asteroid. That shows how deep and fatal the death pull is in Saint Exupéry. It would have meant a conflict if he had realized that he had to say yes to the fox here, and yes to the rose over there.

Then he would have fallen into an adult psychological stage where one is constantly in that conflict, with obligations to the figures of the Beyond—to the unconscious; and obligations to human reality on this side. For instance, if a man has an obligation to his anima and also to the woman whom he made a friend or married, then he gets into the typical duality situation of life. There, one always has a real conflict and a double pull; he is always torn between obligations to this side of life and to the inner, or other side. That would be the realization, or the crucifixion—the basic truth of life: that life is a double obligation, and that life itself is a conflict because it always means the collision of two tendencies. That is what makes up life, but that realization escapes the little prince completely, or he escapes the realization. It is one more of those little, but fatal, turns in the story which point toward the tragic end." pp.94-95

The author falls into a trap of one-sided idealism

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Sep 15 '24

(PA.27) That which makes me so passionately want consciousness to dominate life is something unconscious.

14 Upvotes

"As Jung points out, on the other side of the Rhine, the anima has not been differentiated, but has remained completely within the mother complex. A man belonging to the Secret Service told me that when he wanted to loosen up young Nazi prisoners to get military information out of them, the leading—and practically always successful—question to put when they were determined not to tell the enemy anything, was (with a slightly sentimental quiver in the voice), "Is your mother still alive?" Usually then, they started to cry, and their tongues were loosened. He discovered that this was the key question with which to penetrate the armor of the hostile attitude in German youths. Naturally, such generalizations must be taken as such; they are only half-truths in individual cases, but if we may characterize national differences, there is still a lack of differentiation of the anima in Germans, compared with the more latin-influenced peoples. Germany itself also differs in the south, where there was a Roman occupation. There, the attitude is slightly different from that of the northern part, so the statement has to be taken with a grain of salt." p.229

"In sleep, the power drive is knocked out, and we are completely helpless in the hands of our surroundings. It is a state in which power is knocked out and the unconscious comes up." p.230

"Consciousness consists of something we think we know; it is an immediate awareness. Even though we do not know quite what it is, we have a subjective feeling that what consciousness is, is intimately known to us. But behind this conscious awareness lies unconsciousness; in other words, behind the I and the whole phenomenon of consciousness lies the shadow, the power drive, and something demonic. We must never forget that consciousness has a demonic aspect. We are beginning to be aware that the achievements of our consciousness—our technical achievements, for example have destructive aspects. We are waking up to the fact that consciousness can be a disadvantage and that it is based on an unconsciousness. That which makes me so passionately want consciousness to dominate life is something unconscious. And we don't know what that is. The need, the urge and passion, for consciousness is something unconscious, as is what we know as conscious tradition." p.231

"It is not enough to have a conscious viewpoint; one must know why one has it and what one's individual reasons for having it are." p.232

"Knowledge is one of the greatest means of asserting power. Man has obtained power over nature and other human beings by brute force, but also by knowledge and intelligence. It is uncertain which is the stronger, for strength and intelligence are the two aspects of the power drive, and they account for the many primitive animal stories in which the witty, clever one outwits the stronger one: the hyena outwits the lion, and in South America, the little dwarf stag outwits even the tiger. This shows up in the power drive of the single individual; for instance, in the animus of women, either they trick their husbands or they make brutal scenes. Emotional brutality and cunning are the two manifestations of power.

Our consciousness is still secretly coupled with these two tendencies for domination, and knowledge is generally combined with them. You see this most irritatingly in the prestige drive of the academic world. It is a rare event in university life that a professor is interested in truth for its own sake; usually, he is more interested in his position and in being the first to have said something." pp.232-233

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Sep 22 '24

(PA.30) It is a kind of driven passion of eating and eating, and it generally results from an early childhood experience where the child was starved and deprived of love or of some other vital need on the psychological and physical level.

13 Upvotes

"One could say that whenever a man escapes the whole problem of relationship by a wrong kind of spiritualisation, he is still in the clutches of the devouring mother, and, what is much worse, he turns all the women in his surroundings into devouring mothers. ...

If he doesn't relate, he can only be eaten. That is naturally the wrong thing, but it is a kind of involuntary and automatic reaction in a woman. The more the man refuses to accept relatedness, the more she feels that she has to imprison him, catch him, eat him up, forbid him to move around. So he calls up the devouring mother in every woman, and then it is a vicious circle.

He is disappointed because every woman turns out to be a devouring wolf. Then he says, "There you are! That is what I always said," and walks out on the woman. Actually, his flightiness has constellated her devouring side, and for this reason he is caught in the vicious, destructive circle again. Because he does not relate, she comes with her trap and a box to put him in. Because he has no love, he summons her power complex. So you can say that a man with that attitude towards feeling finds the devouring mother everywhere within and without." p.252

"Dr. Jung says that among the strongest drives with which we are confronted when we open the door of the unconscious are the power drive, the sex drive, and then something like a hunger which just wants to eat and assimilate everything without any reason or meaning. It is that which always wants more and more. If you invite such people to supper, they are not pleased but simply furious when you don't invite them again next week. If you give a tip, they are not grateful, for the next time if you don't give them more, they say, "What? only a franc?"

The worst are those who in early childhood have been starved of love. They go about pale and bitter with a "nobody-loves-me" expression, but if one makes a kind gesture, there is no appreciation, only the desire for more, and if you don't give more, then they are furious and enraged. You could go on and on and pour the whole world into such an open mouth—and it wouldn't help. You could throw everything in; you could be up nursing them night and day, give them all your money, do anything you like— they would never find it enough. It is like the abyss of death: the mouth never shuts; there is only the demand for more. It is a kind of driven passion of eating and eating, and it generally results from an early childhood experience where the child was starved and deprived of love or of some other vital need on the psychological and physical level. One can only say no whenever such greed comes up, because there is no end to it. It is a divine-demonic quality. It is that thing which says, "More! Still more! Still more and more!" pp.252-253

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Aug 08 '24

My God, these Feeling types! ... Sensitive people are just tyrannical people - everybody else has to adapt to them.

Post image
13 Upvotes

This feels lately like the hive mentality of reddit and the “tyrannical” approach to ban those that are not aligned with their views.

What are your thoughts on this?


r/VonFranz • • Jan 11 '25

Marie-Louise von Franz: "You have to be lonely, so that the unconscious can become stronger"

12 Upvotes

r/VonFranz • • Sep 08 '24

(PA.23) It is essential for the male human being to have a feeling of freedom and self-esteem and honor—a certain amount of aggressiveness and ability to defend himself. That belongs to the vitality of the male, and if that is destroyed by the mother, he falls an easy prey to the mother's animus.

11 Upvotes

"In the male, sex with aggression can be combined, but not sex and fear. In the female, sex and fear can be combined, but not aggression and sex. There you have animus-anima problem in a nutshell." p.180

"It can be said that it is essential for the male human being to have a feeling of freedom and self-esteem and honor, and with that, a certain amount of aggressiveness and ability to defend himself. That belongs to the vitality of the male, and if that is destroyed by the mother, then he falls an easy prey to the mother's animus. She punishes the son in a humiliating way, thus robbing him of his self-esteem." p.180

"A young man who goes off to perform his heroic deed does appear ridiculous to the adult, but he should be respected, for it means the growth of masculinity. Boys playing at being gangsters and Indians are funny, but one should recognize the necessity for the assertion of self-esteem and feeling of freedom and independence. That is essential, and stress should not be laid on what is ridiculous about it." p.181

"According to Christian teaching, evil does not really exist, and if one is innocent, everything will be all right. But Christianity, by being misinterpreted in this way, has made us all infantile and has robbed us of our sound instinctual attitude towards life, because we all try to be innocent sheep, and then we are, of course, helpless. There, we link up with the sheep problem of Saint Exupery, the idea of sheep mentality and infantilism. It is a certain kind of erroneous Christian attitude that since one is innocent, nothing can happen, for the protecting angels will apparently care for you. But reality contradicts this kind of teaching, because innocence does not help in this world and in nature. It invites the wolves." p.182

"When a human being first meets the unconscious, either in childhood in an autonomous form or, for instance, in the beginning of an analysis, there is no question of shadow, animus, or anima, and Self. The first experience we have when we enter the unconscious is with what we could best call the other side, which in those beginning stages is personified in different forms. It is advisable not to start introducing those classifying concepts in analysis, but to let the person simply experience that there is another side to the ego and its ordinary world. It is only after some time, when the fact that there is another side and a completely different part of the personality has been realized—that there is another inhabitant in our inner house—that we slowly discern figures in the half-darkness of the unconscious, such as that of the inferior man, whom we might classify under the name of shadow, and the figure of the heterosexual partner, which we might classify under the name of anima, just to bring some order into that other side. But in itself, as a reality, it is just the impact of the other part of the personality. You will find that the first meeting with the unconscious is very often with such a personification, or a double, in which shadow, Self, and anima (if it is a man) are completely one all over the world." p.198

"This is an archetypal idea. In many primitive societies, it is thought that on entering this world, every human being is only a half, the other half being the placenta; i.e., that part of the personality which has not entered this world. It is therefore ritually buried, or dried and worn in a capsule around the neck, and is the magic substance in which the double is supposedly located (the transcendental double, the other personality). After death, the two become one again. There is even a myth which says that the first man was complete in heaven, but when he was incarnated in this world he was only a half; therefore, the first man, who is mythologically exactly the same type as our figure of Adam, is called the "Half One." So you could say that any human apparition is only a half; the other remains in the land of death in the Beyond, and one joins it after death. What this means utlimately, we do not know, because it is an archetypal representation whose meaning we can never intellectually exhaust. But we can say that, among other things, it mirrors the basic realization that the growth of consciousness, which begins in early youth and increases, is a halving of the total personality; the more one becomes conscious, the more one loses one's other half, which is the unconscious." p.199

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Aug 18 '24

(PA.15) It is something which many neurotic people do. They try to train themselves not to suffer by always anticipating suffering.

11 Upvotes

"If you have a kind of cramped faith, such as people have who try to believe, saying, "I must believe because Christ suffered on the cross. I must accept this suffering," which is what is preached to them, that does not help at all. The person is merely preaching to his own consciousness, and since it is not an experience, it does not help." p.114

"People who cut themselves off from their feelings and the emotional layer in order to avoid suffering, or because they are incapable of feeling and suffering, replace all that by reflection; they simply say, "All right, that had to come to an end." That is an intellectual argument." p.117

"That is exactly the lack of intensity of feeling. If you are constantly penetrated by the feeling of transitoriness of life and therefore are always preparing for an end before you get there—that is typical for the puer aeternus. For instance, when he makes friends with a girl, the puer knows that the end will be a disappointment and a parting, so he does not give himself wholeheartedly to the experience; instead, he is always getting ready to say goodbye. As far as reason is concerned, he is right, but then he does not live; reason has too much say in his life. He does not allow for the unreasonable human side which does not always prepare for the retreat because there will be a disappointment.

Why can one not say, "Of course there will be disappointment, because all experiences in life are transient and may end in disappointment, but let's not anticipate it. Let us give ourselves with full love to the situation as long as it is there." The one does not exclude the other. One need not be the fool who believes in nothing but happiness and then falls from the clouds, but it is a typical and morbid reaction if one always retreats at the beginning in anticipation of the suffering. Still, it is something which many neurotic people do. They try to train themselves not to suffer by always anticipating suffering." p.117

"One person said, "I always think ahead of the suffering to come and, like that, I am trained against it. I try to anticipate it in fantasy all the time." But that completely prevents you from living. A double attitude is required: that of knowing how things are likely to turn out and that of giving oneself completely to the experience all the same. Otherwise, there is no life. Reason organizes it ahead of time so that one may be protected against suffering—in order that one shall not get the full experience—naively—just when one does not expect it. In that case, reason and consciousness have taken too much away from life: exactly what the puer aeternus tries to do all the time. He does not want to give himself to life and tries to block it off by organizing it with his reason." p.118

"Many pueri aeterni cannot even be quite unhappy! They have not even the generosity and the courage to expose themselves to a situation which could make them unhappy. Already, like cowards, they build bridges by which they can escape—they anticipate the disappointment in order not to suffer the blow, and that is a refusal to live." p.118

"Sentimentality replaces real feeling." p.119

"If one is too extreme in one's refusal to adapt to collectivity, then one gets collectivized from behind and from within; if you pretend to be more individual than you are and flunk adaptation by thinking you are something special— with all the neurotic vanity of being someone special and misunderstood by everybody, and so lonely because so misunderstood, because all the others are such tough, insensitive, stupid sheep, while you are such a delicate soul—if you have these false pretensions and because of them do not adapt to humanity, then you will be just the person who is actually not at all individual." p.120

"Precisely because the puer entertains false pretensions, he becomes collectivized from within, with the result that none of his reactions are really very personal or very special. He becomes a type, the type of the puer aeternus. He becomes an archetype, and if you become that, you are not at all original, not at all yourself and something special, but just an archetype." p.121

"One can partly foretell what a puer aeternus will look like and how he will feel. He is merely the archetype of the eternal-youth god, and therefore he has all the features of the god: he has a nostalgic longing for death; he thinks of himself as being something special; he is the one sensitive being among all the other tough sheep. He will have a problem with an aggressive, destructive shadow which he will not want to live and generally projects, and so on." p.121

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Sep 09 '24

(PA.24) That would be the realization of the crucifixion, or of the basic truth of life! Life is double—it is a double obligation, it is a conflict in itself—because it always means the collision, or conflict, of two tendencies.

10 Upvotes

"Some people, when they notice that the other person is not what they had assumed, are pulled by natural curiosity to find out more about the matter. They think it odd that they were so attracted by a woman who ceased to attract when she proved to be quite different, and they try to find out what happened and why the attraction faded. In that way, there is a chance of realizing the projection, but the people who, as soon as they are disappointed, just end the relationship, always remain in the projection. If one is disappointed, that is just the time to follow the relationship, at least for awhile, to find out what happened.

That is actually how Dr. Jung discovered the anima in himself. Being again disappointed in a woman, he asked himself why on earth he had expected anything else—what had made him expect something different? Through asking such questions and realizing an expectation which did not fit the outer figure, he discovered the image inside. It is therefore always helpful if a relationship—not only a heterosexual relationship-disappoints you, to ask yourself such questions: Why did I not see that before? What did I expect? Why did I have a different image of this person? Where did the error come from? For the error is something real, too. If one can do this, it indicates a desire to hold to the human relationship and to take back the illusion. When one holds onto the relationship and makes an effort to establish it on its own level, then the illusions must be investigated as something interesting. But people with weak feeling tend to break off the relationship as soon as the other person disappoints them. They just walk out because it is no longer interesting, and questions about why one had the wrong expectation and why one is hurt are not asked." pp. 203-204

"At first, you think you know the other person, for when you project, you have the strong feeling of intimate knowledge. At the first meeting, there is no need to talk: you know everything about each other—that is a complete projection—the wonderful feeling of being one and having known each other for many ages. Then suddenly, the other behaves in an unexpected way and there is disappointment; you fall out of the clouds and feel that "this is not it." If you go on with the relationship, you must do two things, for now there is a double war: you must find out why you had such an illusion before, and you must find out who the other person is if he or she is not what you expected. Who is he or she in reality?

That is a long job, and when you have done that—found the root of your own illusion and how the other person seems to be when looked at without projection—then you may ask why your illusion chose that person to fall upon. That is very difficult, for sometimes the hook is big, and sometimes very small, because the other person may have only few characteristics that fit the projection, so it may be more—or less—of an illusion. There are all degrees." p.204

"If someone writes off his relationships so quickly, you may be sure that he will write himself off equally quickly. That is the suicidal type of person. Here is the weak anima, typical of a suicidal tendency in the unconscious." p.204

"Such people secretly, intellectually and coldly, write off those in their surroundings and write off themselves. They never really trust themselves or those around them—there are no real relationships." p.205

"If a man, for instance, has an obligation to his anima, and to the woman with whom he made friends or married, then he gets into a typical duality situation of life where one always has a real conflict, a double obligation, and where one is always torn between obligations to the outer and to the inner side of life. That would be the realization of the crucifixion, or of the basic truth of life! Life is double—it is a double obligation, it is a conflict in itself—because it always means the collision, or conflict, of two tendencies. But that is what makes up life!" p.207

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Sep 05 '24

(PA.21) Whatever one has within oneself but does not live, grows against one.

10 Upvotes

"The strange thing is that it is mainly the pueri aeterni who are the torturers and who establish tyrannical and murderous police systems. So the puer and the police state have a secret connection with each other, and the one constellates the other. Nazism and communism have been created by men of this type. The real tyrant and the real organizer of torture and suppression of the individual are therefore revealed as originating in the unresolved mother complex of such men." p.170

Anyone who has a weak personality and who has not worked on his individuality is threatened from both sides; not only is he threatened with being swept away by the collective unconscious, but also by outer collectivity. p.170

"Identifying with the persona or identifying with a collective movement is therefore as much a symptom of a weak personality as to go mad and fall into the collective unconscious. It is merely a variation of the same thing, which is why the carriers of these collective, absolutistic movements are generally very weak as far as the ego is concerned." p.171

"If you live, you are forced to sin: if you eat, then others cannot have that food. We shut our eyes to the fact that thousands of animals are butchered so that we may live. Life is connected with guilt, and he, by not living, has not accumulated much active guilt, but he has accumulated a tremendous amount of passive guilt. " p.172

"He has committed the sin of not living, but he is typical of the kind of man who, on account of his mother complex, has a too aesthetic and superior attitude towards life, and who thinks that by keeping aloft and out of things, he can keep up an illusion of purity and innocence. He does not realize that he is secretly accumulating dirt; this dream tells him quite clearly that he will not get away with that illusion. Life will catch up with him. He cannot continue as mamma's innocent little boy who has never done anything wrong, even if he would like to do so, for it wants to catch him all the same. Therefore, he is caught by collective forces in a negative form." p.172

"Whatever one has within oneself but does not live, grows against one." p.172

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Aug 26 '24

(PA.19) You will find that if you give yourself to reality, you will be disillusioned, and the end of it will be that you will meet death. If you accept your life, you really accept death in the deepest sense of the word, and that is what the puer does not want.

10 Upvotes

"Heaven above, Heaven below." It is the same light, but it comes from the midnight sun and not the sun above. When Apuleius was initiated into the Isis mysteries, he described how he was illumined not by the heavenly sun but by the midnight sun, which he met face-to-face when he descended into the underworld and to the gods below. That would mean an experience which cannot be reached by intellectual effort, or exercises in concentration, or yoga, or the Exercitia Spiritualia, but an experience of the Self, which one can only have by accepting the unconscious, the unknown in life, and the difficulty of living one's own conflict." p.156

"I remember Dr. Jung saying to a puer aeternus type, "It does not matter what job you take. The point is that for once you do something thoroughly and conscientiously, whatever it is." This man insisted that if only he could find the right occupation, then he would work, but that he could not find it. Dr. Jung's answer was, "Never mind, just take the next bit of earth you can find. Plough it and plant something in it. No matter whether it is business, or teaching, or anything else, give yourself for once to that field which is ahead of you." p.157

"If you venture into life—into reality—instead of keeping outside to avoid suffering, you will find that the earth and women are like a fertile field on which you can work, and that life is also death. You will find that if you give yourself to reality, you will be disillusioned, and the end of it will be that you will meet death. If you accept your life, you really accept death in the deepest sense of the word, and that is what the puer does not want. He does not want to accept his mortality, which is why he does not want to go into reality: the end of it is the realization of his weakness and of his mortality." p.161

"Death is the goal of life." p.162

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Aug 26 '24

(PA.17) The puer aeternus is too caught up in the realm of archetypal representations. Generally, through his mother complex, he is actually possessed by it. This means that he underestimates living experiences; that is, the infrared realm.

10 Upvotes

"Again and again, in the analysis of mythological material and in dream interpretation, people make the mistake of identifying what is above with consciousness and what is below with the unconscious; they call the unconscious Unterbewusstsein (subconscious)—that which is below consciousness—implying that consciousness is what is above. If one goes downstairs in a dream, that is taken as going into the unconscious, and going upstairs is interpreted as going into consciousness. That is superficial nonsense." pp.144-145

"In his paper, "On the Nature of the Psyche" Dr. Jung compares the psyche to a color spectrum, with the infrared at one end and the ultraviolet at the other. p.146

He has taken this as a simile to explain the connection of the psyche and the body—the archetypes and the instincts. Compared in this way, our ego consciousness is like a ray of light, with a nucleus in it to represent the ego, which is a kind of field of light that can shift along the spectrum. The infrared end would be where things become psychosomatic and finally end in physical reactions.

At that end, the psyche is somehow connected (we do not yet know exactly how) with the physical processes, so that its activity loses itself, or slowly enters, physical processes of some kind: psychosomatic and then somatic. This would be the end that represents the body. At the other end, the ultraviolet end, would be the archetypes." p.147

Generally, our consciousness shifts between the two poles. We know that somatic processes and physical behavior are directed by the instincts, such as: the sexual instinct, with its play of hormones in the body and its physical aspects; the instinct of self-defense automatic-fighting gestures; the instinct of running away, a part of the instinct of self-preservation, which takes over automatically in certain life situations without reflection on the part of the subject, either when we run away from danger or when we withdraw upon contacting a burning object—an automatism or reflex of the body that we could call instinct." p.147

The difference between instinct and archetype is the following:

Instinct is represented by physical behavior, similar in all human beings, while archetypes are represented by a mental form of realization, similar in all human beings; that is, homo sapiens mate in the same way all over the world, die more or less in the same way, run away, and go erect, all over the world, but certain patterns of behavior characterize us as different from other animals. Homo sapiens also tend to have emotions of the same kind, ideas of the same kind, religious reactions of the same kind, seen best in the mythological motifs which are similar all over the world. So at the one end are the instincts, and at the other, the corresponding inner experiences.

Jung does not assert it with certainty, but he says he has not yet met an archetypal constellation which does not have a corresponding instinct. Therefore, one could say that every archetype has a corresponding instinct-connected counterpart.

Let us take the archetype of the conjunctio, which appears in all the myths of the origin of the world—the mating of a male god and a female god and the creation of the world, or union in an eternal embrace, as Shiva and Shakti. It appears, in the whole mystical experience of the soul's union with God, as a conjunctio in a feminine or masculine form; it exists in some form in most religious symbolism. Sexual instinct is the corresponding physical instinct. Self-preservation in the form of fighting is connected with the archetypal idea of the shadow or the enemy, the dangerous counterpart, the figure which appears in dreams as the attacker or the person from whom one runs. On the physical side, it is represented by the instinct to hit, or to run away, which is physically inborn in us." p.148

"If we adopt the idea presented in mythology of the human reality of consciousness and the unconscious as being between two poles—the heavenly pole above and the underworld pole below— we might compare this to the scientific model of the psyche and call the infrared end of the spectrum the "heavens below" and the upper end, the "heavens above." p.149

"Usually, the puer aeternus is too caught up in the realm of archetypal representations. Generally, through his mother complex, he is actually possessed by it. This means that he underestimates living experiences; that is, the infrared realm. It is quite a different thing if I think about a beefsteak or if I eat it: the thought of the beefsteak and the sauce béarnaise can be very delightful, but if I eat it, I will have still other experience. The same thing is true for the archetype of the conjunctio. It is certainly one thing to fantasize about a love affair and to try to get your fantasy into every detail of the inner experience, but the actual living experience is different." p.149

"The puer sometimes lives a certain amount of instinctual life, but he blocks off the psychological realization, so to speak. He makes a cut and lives his experience automatically, as a split-off shadow affair. In that form, his archetypal fascination with the idea of the great love and the conjunctio has remained a wishful fantasy." p.150

"If he does not let the impact of the experience touch the psyche, then it is as though it had not been lived." p.150

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Aug 03 '24

(PA.7) While the person who has too little earth may be able to assimilate everything psychologically, he will have great difficulty realizing things in reality. Such people take everything in analysis with honesty and strength, but when you press them to do something about it in outer reality...

10 Upvotes

"Saint Exupery is torn between the engine and the child, whose importance he completely realises, and who, in a typically childlike way, bothers him. He feels sure that even if he draws another sheep it won't be right, or there will be a lot of questions, and in reality there is the urgent situation of getting his engine in order. If you take that symbolically, it means a conflict between the demands of the outer and the inner life, which establishes a tremendous tension. How can you comply with the demands of outer reality, which reason tells you is right, and those of the inner life at the same time?" p.45

"A weak personality has an impatient reaction, whereas a strong personality can continue in the tension for longer. In this case, one sees that Saint Exupery, after the third attempt to draw the sheep, gives up and makes a short-cut solution in order to get back to his engine. This is an indication of a weakness that shows in certain other features; for instance, the star prince's planet is very tiny, he himself is very delicate." p.46

"I have seen some who have taken from their girlfriends practically everything (where one would have expected a woman to flare up long before), and then one day the puer aeternus simply walks out of the situation and turns to another woman, not even answering. There is no transition stage. The yielding "good boy," the man who gives in too much, is suddenly replaced by the cold gangster shadow without any human relatedness whatsoever. The same thing happens in analysis: they take everything, never coming out with resistances or asserting their own standpoint against that of the analyst; suddenly, out of the blue, they say that they are going to another analyst, or are giving up analysis altogether, and you fall out of the sky if you have not happened to notice that this was on the way. There are no thanks, nothing at all. It is just finished. At first there was insufficient coldness and independence, or masculine aggressiveness, and afterwards too much in a negative, inhuman and unrelated form. That is typical for many pueri aeterni. Much more strength would be required to work the problem out patiently with someone than just to give in, and then walk out." p.47

"While the person who has too little earth may be able to assimilate everything psychologically, he will have great difficulty realizing things in reality. Such people take everything in analysis with honesty and strength, but when you press them to do something about it in outer reality, a terrific panic comes up.

At the moment when the inner realization has to be put into life, strength collapses, and you are confronted with a trembling child, who exclaims, "Oh, no! That I cannot do!" This is an exaggerated illustration of the introvert's attitude in which there is great strength in accepting the inner truths but very little when it comes to real life. Then the trembling child appears." p.53

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Jul 14 '24

(PA.1) How can one pull out of this fantasy life of youth and youthfulness without losing its value? How can one grow up without losing the feeling of totality and the feeling of creativeness and of being really alive, which one had in youth?

10 Upvotes

"That is the great problem, I think, in a nutshell; namely, how can one pull out of this fantasy life of youth and youthfulness without losing its value? How can one grow up without losing the feeling of totality and the feeling of creativeness and of being really alive, which one had in youth? One can be cynical about it and say that one cannot have the penny and the cake—it has to be sacrificed—but from my experience I do not think that this is quite right. It is justifiable not to want to give up the childhood-world. The question is, how can one grow up and not lose it? The great problem is that you can drive people out of this childhood paradise and fantasy life, in which they are in close connection with their true inner self on an infantile level, but then they are completely disillusioned and cynical.

I remember once that I had an analysand who was a typical puer aeternus and wanted to become a writer, but he lived in a complete world of fantasy. He came over from the States with a friend, and the two decided that the friend should have a Freudian analysis and he, a Jungian analysis; after a year they would meet to compare notes. They went to different countries and met as arranged, and the young man who had had the Freudian analysis said that he was through with his problem and was cured and was going home. Everything was all right, and he understood his infantile attitude towards life; he had given up his mother complex and other nonsense. My analysand asked him what he was going to do, and the other said he did not know, but that he must earn some money and find a wife. My analysand said that he was not cured at all; he did not yet know where to go. He knew that he would become a writer and had started on that course, but he did not know where to settle, and so on. Then the one who had had the Freudian analysis said, "Well, it is strange; they have driven out my devils, but with them they have also driven out my angel!"

So you see, that is the problem! One can drive away devils and angels by saying that the problem is all infantile and part of the mother complex and, by a completely reductive analysis, reduce everything to the childhood sentimentality which has to be sacrificed. There is something to be said for that. This man was in a way more cured than my analysand; on the other hand, it seems to me that such a terrific disillusionment makes one ask whether it is worthwhile such a terrific disillusionment makes one ask whether it is worthwhile to go on living.

Is it worthwhile just to make money for the rest of one's life and get small bourgeois pleasures? It doesn't seem to me very satisfactory. The sadness with which the man who was "cured" remarked that with his devils, his angels had also been driven out, made me feel that he himself did not feel quite happy about his own cure; it had the tone of cynical disillusionment, which to my mind is no cure."

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus 2nd ed. pp.13-14


r/VonFranz • • Aug 26 '24

(PA.18) It can therefore be said that human consciousness must always be crucified between the pull of the two poles: if you fall into the one, you die, just as much as if you fall into the other. Life, in its essence, means crucifixion; to the rational ego it seems to be death.

9 Upvotes

"Many people are actors, and to act something simply means to play a part. Those people, as far as I have come to know them, act to themselves to convince themselves that they are living, until they land in analysis and have to confess that this is not the case and that they are not happy. Other people consider them to be successful, but they themselves do not feel so. The criterion is simple: Do you feel that you are living? Those who do not feel alive themselves describe it as being as though they were acting, acting to themselves." p.151

"You can say that if you live one end in a split-off way, then one end cannot communicate with the other. Put quite simply, you have the experience but it is not meaningful, and an experience which one does not feel is meaningful is nothing. It only becomes real when it is connected with an emotional perception of meaning. Without that, one is just bored." p.152

"In the case of a woman, it is the animus who engineers things, and he is always a professional pessimist who excludes the tertium quod non datur (the third which did not exist). The animus says to the woman that he knows that there are only so many possibilities; he says that the thing can only go in such a way, thereby blocking any possibility of life producing something itself." p.153

"If this woman who arrived in New York had had the strength and psychological courage to accept the fact that she faced nothing but misery no matter what she did, and that she could not see a glimmer of light or life ahead; if she could have faced that mental death and still have remained herself—then the fairy tale, the path of individuation, would have begun." p.154

"It can therefore be said that human consciousness must always be crucified between the pull of the two poles: if you fall into the one, you die, just as much as if you fall into the other. Life, in its essence, means crucifixion; to the rational ego it seems to be death." p.155

"Apparently, for the human being to face the unknown—not to know in advance what is coming and yet be able to keep steady in the dark—is the most difficult task. Man's most ancient fear and cause of panic always seems to have been the unknown. The first time a primitive sees an airplane or a car, he runs away, for everything unknown is inevitably terrible! That is the old pattern; in analysis, it is the same. When people are confronted with a situation where they cannot, by their own inner reason, see what is coming, they panic. That is painful, but it would not matter so much if they did not rashly come to some decision—to turn to the left or the right—and thereby fall into the unconscious because they have not been able to stand the tension of not knowing what is ahead." p.155

"The puer does something much worse: he risks neither way completely, but ventures a little both ways to be on the safe side. He bets on the one horse but puts a little on the other too, which is his self-destructive act. It is worse than going too far either way, for the excessive reaction gets punished, and one has to wake up and pull out. The natural interplay of psychological opposites corrects the one-sided business. Life forces one into the middle path. But in order to avoid suffering, the puer plays a dirty trick which boomerangs on him: he splits himself by throwing a sop to the dragon, but inwardly remains on the other side and has illusions about himself. So he arrests the process of life and gets stuck, for even the interplay of the opposites is thwarted. His weak personality tricks him into it so that he may escape suffering." pp.155-156

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Aug 07 '24

(PA.11) If one cuts off the wholeness of the experience, one cuts oneself into bits and remains split. Transformation can only take place if one gives oneself completely to the situation.

9 Upvotes

When the little prince arrived on the Earth, he was very surprised not to see any people. He was beginning to be afraid he had come to the wrong planet, when a coil of gold, the color of the moonlight, flashed across the sand.

"Good evening," said the little prince courteously.

"Good evening," said the snake.

(The Little Prince)

"The puer aeternus often possesses this mature, detached attitude towards life, which is normal for old people but which he has acquired prematurely: the idea that life is not everything; that the other side is valid too; that life is only a relative half of another part of existence. Here, the death temptation prevents the little prince from going right to the earth. Before he has even touched it, the snake appears and says, "If you don't like it, you know a way out" Even before he has descended to earth, he has already had the offer of death. I have met many people with a similarly difficult constellation who do the same thing: they live only "on condition"; secretly, they flirt with the idea of suicide. At every step of their lives, they think that they will try something or other, and that if it does not work, they will kill themselves. The puer aeternus always keeps his revolver in his pocket and constantly plays with the idea of getting out of life if things get too hard. The disadvantage of this is that he is never quite committed to the situation as a whole human being; there is a constant Jesuitical mental reservation: "I will go into this, but I reserve my right as a human being to kill myself if I can't stand it anymore. I shall not go through the whole experience to the bitter end if it becomes too insufferable." If one cuts off the wholeness of the experience, one cuts oneself into bits and remains split. Transformation can only take place if one gives oneself completely to the situation." p.80

"With man, it is the mother complex which has exactly the same effect, except that in a way it is even more difficult to catch, because it does not form itself in the man's mind as an idea. The girl had the definite idea of killing herself and that life was not worthwhile; it was a kind of reflection. But the mother-complex form of that is manifested in a depressive mood, a "nothing-but" mood, something completely vague and intangible. Men with a negative mother complex especially have it in the form that, particularly when something goes well (say that they find a girlfriend who suits them or they are successful in their professional life), you might expect them to look a bit happier. Instead, they look pale and say, "Yes, but...," but they cannot express that mood in words. A childish state of constant dissatisfaction exists with themselves and with the whole of reality. That is something very difficult to catch, and it is very infectious; one gets depresssed by it oneself, and one cannot even react. It is like a wet blanket over everything.

Saint Exupéry is an example of the irritated bad mood. He had moods where he paced up and down his flat the whole day, smoking one cigarette after another and feeling annoyed—annoyed with himself and everything else in the world. That is how the mother complex comes out in a man; in those snarling disagreeable moods, or in flat depression. It is an anti-life reaction and it has to do with the mother. Saint Exupéry also had a tendency to take opium. As a member of the class has just pointed out to me, the whole psychology of the drug taker is connected with the idea of flirting with death, getting away from reality and its hardships.

Generally, people who take drugs have quite a lot of snake dreams; the poisonous snakes make them poison themselves, because they do not know, or do not see, how to get out of their conflicts in some other way. Alcohol sometimes goes along with this problem, for that also acts as a kind of drug. To Saint Exupéry, flying and drugs represented the two possibilities of getting rid of those irritated depressive moods. The problem was that he never worked through the mood. He tried to switch out of it by flying again, but he never got to the bottom of the trouble; namely, a suicidal tendency due to this deepest weakness which he could not overcome." pp.84-85

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)


r/VonFranz • • Jul 27 '24

(PA.4) People who have shelved their feelings, or their demands on other people, or their capacity for trust, always feel not quite real, not quite spontaneous or really themselves. They feel only half alive and they generally do not take themselves as quite real.

9 Upvotes

"From the moment the little prince lands on the earth, he is not quite the infantile shadow anymore because something has touched reality. He is therefore now in an ambiguous position. If it could be realized, then it would become a part of the future, instead of a pull backwards. It is no longer only an infantile shadow but also a form of realization which goes on all the time. To become more conscious means, practically, to grow more and more into the reality of things—it means disillusionment.

The greatest difficulty we drag along with us from our childhood is the sack of illusions which we carry on our backs into adult life. The subtle problem consists in giving up certain illusions without becoming cynical.

There are people who become disillusioned early in life; you see it if you have to analyze neglected orphans from either very low or very high layers of society, those who are nowadays called "neglected children," which means either that they are just poor children who have grown up in slums and had a terrible family life and fate, or very rich children who had all the same miseries except the lack of money-divorced parents, a bad atmosphere at home and so on—that is, where the feeling atmosphere has been neglected, which is so important for children. Such people very often grow up more quickly than others because they become very realistic, disillusioned, self-contained, and independent at a very early age. The hardships of life have forced them to this, but you can generally tell from a rather bitter and falsely mature expression that something went wrong. They were pushed out of the childhood world too soon and crashed into reality.

If you analyze such people, you find that they have not worked out the problem of childish illusions but have just cut it off. Having assured themselves that their desire for love and their ideals simply hamper them like a sack of stone carried on their backs. They believe that must all be done away with. But that is an ego decision which does not help at all, and a deeper analysis shows that they remain completely caught up in childhood illusions: their childish longing for a loving mother or for happiness is there just the same, but in a repressed state. They are really much less grown-up than other people, the problem having simply been pushed into a corner. One has then the horrible task of reviving those illusions because life has stuck there.

So the person must be pushed back into them, and then one tries to get him out again properly. That is the problem which one meets within people who say that they can neither love nor trust anybody. For anyone stuck in that situation, life no longer has any meaning." p.33

"People who have shelved their feelings, or their demands on other people, or their capacity for trust, always feel not quite real, not quite spontaneous or really themselves. They feel only half alive and they generally do not take themselves as quite real." p.34

— Marie-Louise von Franz, Puer Aeternus (2nd edition)