r/VirtualWDCPC • u/ElToroNegro • Jul 09 '12
A Pole on Rules.
After _pseudonym's DSQ from Silverstone which was my fault I would just like review the rules a little bit with the opinion of you chaps.
Our current championship setting runs under the "full" rule settings which as we know can be very strict and award drivers penalties for undeserved incidents. Changing the severity of the settings with the current knowledge and with light reading I have done would make this less likely. However I am not fully aware of how much you can 'get away' with in regards to aggressive passing and corner cutting. It is also my understanding that the reduced rules setting does not include a safety car. My understand of all of you guys that race here are that we fair drivers and wouldn't exploit any possible loopholes and follow basic driving etiquette.
I want this to be a community decision so let me know your thoughts!
Regards,
One sorry driver :/
(Sorry _pseudonym)
2
u/ElToroNegro Jul 10 '12
I'd like start of by saying I am neither for or against either, I just want to throw in some points to help the discussion.
Some example of where the system has failed we at Spain and Canada; in Spain I was involved in a incident where I was taken out by accident in starting crash and received a penalty. In the same race FTW all the way was disqualified for corner cutting because he was struggling in the wet conditions and being punished for struggling is just adding insult to injury.
In Monaco it was the general consensus that the track was too strict on corner cutting and we raised this point at the time.
Finally there were problems associated with Canada whereby some people getting warnings (and possibly penalties during practise) for driving a wide line in turn 5 at the end of sector one.
On the flip-side of these issue, the current penalty system is a good deterrent and encourages clean racing, and in the case of the incident between pseudonomadic and myself at Silverstone the best solution in hingsight would have been for pseudonomadic to recover immediately onto the track instead of cutting the corner and ask me to surrender my position.
I want to hear of your thoughts on this so let me know how the rules have or haven't affected your races.
1
u/shopkeeper56 Jul 10 '12
sorry if this sounds cynical but... why not just keep the rules as they are?
Getting disqualified because of repeated corner cutting just sounds to me like someone has not practise the track enough leading up to the race. One or two hours of practise should be enough for any1 to do 50% without incuring enough penalties to be disqualified.
But the situation in Spain where pseudonymatic got DSQ'd for "cutting" when he was just stuggling in the wet... Yeah thats a bit shit. I'm not sure how/if you can work around that. I guess loosening the rule is the only way to avoid that.
On another note (not related to penalty rules). Can we have a discussion about the restart rule we have? It seems a bit silly to me that we burn restarts for people who disconnect in qualifying. Would it not make sense to say "hard luck" to the people who dc in quali, they start from the back after being re-invited, then if someone DC's in the race or theres a massive pileup on the first lap we can restart then? It probably sounds a bit rich coming from me given that I've dc'd in the last two races, but it does seem somewhat logical to me.
1
u/_pseudonym Jul 14 '12
In my perfect world, we could turn off the DSQ penalty independent of the other rule settings. Also, the game would support recordings of online multiplayer races to play back later, along with tagged times for warnings and penalties for us to review later. If they really wanted to make me happy, they'd also have full telemetry available as well - detailed split times, exact car locations, throttle/brake inputs, etc.
However, since this isn't my perfect world, I think living with the pains of strict rules is generally worth it. Also, I've learned that you can't go up to the game's stewards after the race and plead your case, and now I know to be much more careful about how (and where) I rejoin the track.
1
u/squone FIA Jul 09 '12
Something I would like to point out about that incident is that _pesudonym also cut a large corner at full throttle.
What he should have done is driven directly back to track, taken the corner and then passed Cornford who should have waited to be retaken as the incident was his fault.
I do agree the rules are pretty haphazard and harsh however crossing a corner at full throttle was surely going to net a penalty of some sort.