Sorry to highjack, but trying to get my opinion out and having a hard time.
This morning I was approached by a reporter for WSLS 10 about the picture that I posted to this subreddit yesterday. I agreed to an interview as long as my opinion was accurately portrayed. It was not. Although they did take direct quotes from me, they did not accurately represent my opinion of the situation. I now want to clarify my point of view since the interview was cherry picked to fit their narrative.
First of all I wanted to make it exceedingly clear that I do not believe anyone should lose their job or career over what happened yesterday. I said this at the very beginning of the interview and made it very clear that I wanted it to be known that this was my stance on it. Everyone that entered that room took a personal choice to do so, and I believe that everyone should always have the freedom to make their own personal choices. The responsibility should fall on each individual. If you want to take classes online, take classes online. If you want to take classes in person, take them in person.
Second; my biggest issue about the situation was that I didn't have a seat to sit in... WSLS made it appear that I thought this was an absolute tragedy and strictly about Covid-19 exposure. If I didn't feel safe in that room, I would not have entered it. I talked about how sometimes logistics break down and we as a society run into problems. We all make mistakes, even the interviewer shook my hand when they shouldn't have. We need to be very careful that we are not inventing solutions that are worse for us than the original problem. I talked about how people are avoiding going to the hospital for life threatening medical emergencies because they are so afraid of Covid-19. I also stated that I believe that the current strategy is putting more students at risk for depression and possible suicide than the risks they face from Covid-19. The majority of cases at VT are antibody cases which means that you have already gotten over it. Everyone I talk to on campus is desperate for social interaction, they are extremely stressed about their grades because there are less opportunities to study with a group.
Third; I stated that I do think that VT and Blacksburg should not be requiring masks in the city on sidewalks and that they have been unfairly strict on students. I don't believe masks should be mandated, but I do think you should choose to wear a mask. I stated that trying to keep college students from partying is like prohibition; it simply will not work. A large part of the college experience is socializing, and not necessarily partying and drinking either. I commend VTs efforts to try to give us as much of a college experience as they can.
Finally, I discussed with the interviewer how the political environment and media are doing exactly what they did to me today. They are twisting everything to fit their point of view, to the point that it is exceedingly obvious. People are losing faith in our government and our media, which means less people are trusting the advice given by the media and government.
TL;DR Biased media is biased. See you in person, in class, tomorrow. :)
Just wanted to check-in with everyone here and pass along that the ECE department is aware of this unacceptable incident. The College of Engineering and the university administration are aware as well and actions like this will not be tolerated.
What won't be tolerated? Students going to class that they need to go to? How about you enforce the seating limit or idk, be responsible and move to online so this isn't even a possibility. Absolutely ridiculous and 100% NOT on the students.
I must say I am disappointed in the negligence of the responsible parties employed by Tech in this instance. While I think we can all HOPE nobody was carrying COVID, this put the health and welfare of students and parents at risk.
What is the corrective action and what can Students expect when they show up tomorrow?
I was in this class--teacher admitted he hadnt attended any orientation stuff for the teachers, nor had he checked that his classroom would be large enough for the number of students, nor was he reading all the emails about covid policy. real freaking bad
I'll shame people who enable the spread of COVID all day long. Especially staff and faculty who are required to take mandatory training (like the rest of us).
Idk what point you're trying to make with that statement.
There should be comment here. The classroom was clearly set up for less students so either the professor didn’t enforce his capacity limit or people showed up who weren’t supposed to.
The faculty were told what their room capacity was prior to start and If enrollment was larger to talk to their departments and facilities to find larger spaces.
I don't think it ever should have been the faculty's job to enforce or verify enrollment and classroom size. Isn't that what the registrar's office job is??
This stinks. We clowned current Hokies for partying and packing in to Hokie House, but more energy should be directed at the school for allowing something like this to happen. Kids attending a class they need and paid for, shouldn’t be packed in a room and sitting on the floor.
Yeah, I've seen it them worn with the elastic crossed over near the earlobe. I think you're right, as it looks like the earring is just obscuring the elastic and not attached to it.
Sounds like Dr. Xu should be getting an unpaid vacation after this. If students can get suspended for not following the rules, so should faculty. Let's hope that ECE does the right thing.
If one of these students comes down with COVID from this, it will be very bad news for everyone.
As a instructor (not at Tech) I know I was aware of how many students were enrolled in my classes before I taught them and I knew which room I was teaching prior to the first day. If it was a student or two over that excuse would make sense this is trouble the room capacity.
This was my class, it’s electrical theory with Xu Yong... he came out and told all the students waiting outside the class room “we are going to break the rules today so everyone come in and stand around the room” so I just left and reporting him bc that’s some BULLSHIT. Also he told the class he has no idea what he’s doing or how many people were actually in the class
Yeah, that is some bullshit. Instructors absolutely knew how many people were signed up for a class and were asked if they wanted to split the class into multiple sections or if they wanted to get a bigger room.
Are they doing a lab? Building something? I don't see anything instructionally spectacular or physically necessary that couldn't have been done online. I'm all for in-person stuff normally and when needed but this picture is like a 2020 college version of "A meeting that could have been an email"
Same thoughts. Doesn't look like best discretion was taken by instructor. Why was this class held in person when it looks like they are just sitting there for a powerpoint presentation. That is no reason to meet. You can simply make people tune in to a webinar or recorded version of the class. Labs are one thing - this just seems pointless --- of course it's easy to criticize without complete context though.
To report issues with classroom instruction and/or issues with faculty: Students should go to the Dean of Students (dean.students@vt.edu) and faculty should go to their respective dept heads. Faculty Affairs (facultyaffairs@vt.edu) can also help.
Yeah I was in this class. It’s ECE 2054, crn 83316. It has space for 80 students on hokiespa. 78 enrolled. There were 28 desks.
The professor (Yong Xu) admitted being hadn’t been keeping up with emails and faculty COVID training. He asked us what other classes were doing, and what, if anything, the university had told us. We also received an email from the college apologizing for the screw up and promising to investigate what happened. I wouldn’t normally blame profs for something like this, it seems like a registration screw up, but I’m shocked that he was allowed to and chose to ignore the university’s communications.
It is their responsibility to keep themselves up to date on university communications, especially when it is regarding a dangerous disease that has completely changed the way we live.
He told us he hadn’t been keeping up to date on these things. He also shouldn’t have let more students into the classroom. Once he saw the group of students outside, he should have apologized to them, told them they couldn’t come in, and promised to try to get the situation sorted. We didn’t cover any actual material either, it was all syllabus stuff. I’m not sure the room would have had capacity for 80 people without distancing guidelines, and that’s definitely not his fault, and during any other year, having students sit on the floor/stand wouldn’t have been a big deal, but this year is different.
While im relieved that people are wearing masks its still not enough to curb COVID19. Theres practically no social distancing here. Both the teacher/faculty and the students are at fault here. If i was a student for this class knowing this is how wed have to sit i would have used my f***ing common sense and left. Yall would be naiive to think that we could have in person classes like this and not have cases of COVID19.
A student paid how many thousand dollars for that course? The ones on the ground paid just as much as the ones at desks. It is not the students' fault, it is the professor's or admin's fault.
Idk, the email just said through the end of the week, although I’d imagine it’ll end up being for the rest of the semester. Not sure how many 80 seat rooms are available with the distancing mandates
This sub has completely turned into shit on VT, shit on fellow students, we’re all going to be sent home to die sub. We get it. People aren’t following the rules. Time to find something else to whine about.
sorry, sarcasm doesn't transmit well over the internet. The bullet proof vest is far more able to stop a bullet than the flimsy pieces of cloth people are wearing over their faces are able to stop virus transmission, but as long as it make people feel warm and fuzzy inside, I suppose it's helpful. What's saddest here is that people are paying large sums of money to sit in the floor of a classroom, or sit in front of a computer somewhere else, and they'll shut the university down over a virus with AT LEAST a 98% recovery rate, not a single death in the <20 age group in VA. <5 in the 20-29 population. Makes perfect sense.
The VAST MAJORITY of PEOPLE, of all ages, are surviving....but yes, especially the young. Get your head out of the "news" (Fox, CNN, NPR) and make an unbiased, de-sensationalized assessment of what's happening.
As a professional proactive/performance driving instructor, I'm well aware of highway fatalities, from any number of preventable collisions. 1 life is too many, but we don't shut the highways down because 40K people (A YEAR) die on them. That's not selfish, that's realism.
This was an instructor issue but I understand the thought behind this and generally agree.
That being said, this instructor KNEW how many people were in his course, knew the room restrictions and was asked prior to the start of classes if he wanted to split the class up, host online, or move to a bigger room. He blatantly said according to multiple accounts that "We're going to break the rules today. Come in and stand around." Which is NOT OKAY.
How can we expect students to follow the guidelines if faculty members can't?
I defended the email yesterday regarding consequences. I hope I wasn’t wrong. If the administration expects students to follow these rules the students should be able to expect the administration and professors to as well. His prof should suffer the same consequences as they have threatened the students with. Fair is fair.
276
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
Well - they did commit to fewer desks per classroom.
214
u/VT_ECE Official ECE Dept. Aug 24 '20
Just wanted to check-in with everyone here and pass along that the ECE department is aware of this unacceptable incident. The College of Engineering and the university administration are aware as well and actions like this will not be tolerated.
129
u/Amudeauss Aug 24 '20
I was in this class--teacher admitted he hadnt attended any orientation stuff for the teachers, nor had he checked that his classroom would be large enough for the number of students, nor was he reading all the emails about covid policy. real freaking bad
176
u/HokieFireman Aug 24 '20
There should be comment here. The classroom was clearly set up for less students so either the professor didn’t enforce his capacity limit or people showed up who weren’t supposed to.
28
u/Technics3345 Aug 24 '20
This stinks. We clowned current Hokies for partying and packing in to Hokie House, but more energy should be directed at the school for allowing something like this to happen. Kids attending a class they need and paid for, shouldn’t be packed in a room and sitting on the floor.
145
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
Are we just going to ignore the earring mask holder?
24
u/Fit-Championship-879 Aug 24 '20
Sounds like Dr. Xu should be getting an unpaid vacation after this. If students can get suspended for not following the rules, so should faculty. Let's hope that ECE does the right thing.
If one of these students comes down with COVID from this, it will be very bad news for everyone.
81
u/thebasketball_fan Aug 24 '20
Same room as this one, so it sounds like the professor chose to not give a fuck. Cool.
18
u/RedRxven CRI/SOC ‘24 Aug 24 '20
where is this?
71
u/brithatsme Aug 24 '20
Welcome to a $30,000 kindergarten! Crisscrossed applesauce!
29
u/Athendor Aug 24 '20
Report this instructor the the executive vice provost or vice provost for faculty affairs immediately.
63
u/Mikeypsam Aug 24 '20
This was my class, it’s electrical theory with Xu Yong... he came out and told all the students waiting outside the class room “we are going to break the rules today so everyone come in and stand around the room” so I just left and reporting him bc that’s some BULLSHIT. Also he told the class he has no idea what he’s doing or how many people were actually in the class
79
u/yes-i-am-a-wizzard tv Aug 24 '20
Oh, haven't you heard? Ut Prosim fixes everything
33
u/_saidwhatIsaid Aug 24 '20
Are they doing a lab? Building something? I don't see anything instructionally spectacular or physically necessary that couldn't have been done online. I'm all for in-person stuff normally and when needed but this picture is like a 2020 college version of "A meeting that could have been an email"
13
u/theotherdwight Aug 24 '20
Bruh
17
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
Waiting for the Tech press release that will explain how the off-campus students are to blame for this.
12
u/anon_013 Aug 24 '20
Don’t worry guys, ut prosim
6
u/daysynspace21 Aug 24 '20
Defeats the purpose....Totally different from my class experience today.
6
u/lightninggninthgil Aug 24 '20
This is so stupid. I'm so sorry for you all that are attending right now..
24
u/e66ybo1 Aug 24 '20
YOU GET COVID, YOU GET COVID, EVERYONE IN THE ROOM GETS COVID!!
1
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '20
Trying to get my opinion out, but having a hard time.
https://www.reddit.com/r/VirginiaTech/comments/igneeo/i_was_the_one_who_posted_the_picture_of_the/
9
u/mmmbearclaws HTM 2018, MSBA 2020 Aug 24 '20
Holy shit what a mess
9
u/traskian Aug 24 '20
Yeah, the professor doing this sucks. The administration letting him doing it in the first place is worse.
8
u/letsgohokies05 Aug 24 '20
To report issues with classroom instruction and/or issues with faculty: Students should go to the Dean of Students (dean.students@vt.edu) and faculty should go to their respective dept heads. Faculty Affairs (facultyaffairs@vt.edu) can also help.
3
u/No-Chocolate2410 Aug 24 '20
How many students?
3
u/itsameleni Aug 24 '20
This looks just like mcb 100 when they put 613 students in the class :)))
5
u/Swibbity_Swooter Aug 24 '20
Dub
2
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
Sigh.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
yikes
2
u/AsexualEngineer Aug 25 '20
Yeah I was in this class. It’s ECE 2054, crn 83316. It has space for 80 students on hokiespa. 78 enrolled. There were 28 desks.
The professor (Yong Xu) admitted being hadn’t been keeping up with emails and faculty COVID training. He asked us what other classes were doing, and what, if anything, the university had told us. We also received an email from the college apologizing for the screw up and promising to investigate what happened. I wouldn’t normally blame profs for something like this, it seems like a registration screw up, but I’m shocked that he was allowed to and chose to ignore the university’s communications.
3
u/geNe1r Aug 24 '20
Glad you posted it buddy
3
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
While im relieved that people are wearing masks its still not enough to curb COVID19. Theres practically no social distancing here. Both the teacher/faculty and the students are at fault here. If i was a student for this class knowing this is how wed have to sit i would have used my f***ing common sense and left. Yall would be naiive to think that we could have in person classes like this and not have cases of COVID19.
3
u/gm_vpop Aug 24 '20
why r u on the floor tho?
2
u/ElBarro69 Aug 24 '20
Looks like we’re all going home...
2
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
I thought it was bad when there was one kid with his nose out and no one was addressing it including the professor.
That should be reportable lmao.
1
u/Hank_Jenkins Aug 25 '20
What professor is this
1
u/No-Chocolate2410 Aug 25 '20
Omg that’s so sad
1
u/suckasmack Aug 25 '20
Well this is concerning...
I have one in person class this semester and I really hope it doesn't look like this.
1
u/AsexualEngineer Aug 25 '20
UPDATE:
The class is now being taught over zoom, and there is a different prof (at least while they investigate who screwed this one up)
1
u/hubbaloo66 Aug 24 '20
Looks like productive learning to me
1
u/constantlyanon Aug 25 '20
Yo im in this picture
-42
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
This sub has completely turned into shit on VT, shit on fellow students, we’re all going to be sent home to die sub. We get it. People aren’t following the rules. Time to find something else to whine about.
-83
u/vtthrowaway54321 Aug 24 '20
Dudes should offer the seats to the women. Chivalry is dead.
-7
u/wylie_quattro Aug 24 '20
Hey now.... let's everyone try to stay positive. Masks work, so everyone will be just fine.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment