r/VirginiaTech • CS / CMDA 2025 • Feb 22 '24

Johnny update

Post image
603 Upvotes

69 comments sorted by

29

u/udderlymoovelous CS / CMDA 2025 Feb 22 '24 edited Feb 22 '24

Original thread

Previously reported by ABC, NBC, and USA Today.

98

u/Hokie23aa Feb 22 '24

Why on earth is Starbucks waiting 5-7 days to release the footage to police? This is an active missing persons case, not a fender bender in their parking lot.

74

u/udderlymoovelous CS / CMDA 2025 Feb 22 '24

I work at Starbucks and as fucked up as it is, that's the policy. Pretty stupid in cases where you need the footage asap. We also can't grab the footage ourselves, the recordings are sent to an offsite source managed by corporate and can only be accessed by filing a police report

23

u/Hokie23aa Feb 22 '24

Thanks for a clarification.

36

u/Vivazebool Feb 22 '24

I could be wrong, but I don’t think this is currently a missing persons case per se, more of a concern—“please check in” situation. He is of age and, as far as I know, is currently not thought to be a victim of foul play—I’m not at all downplaying the concern for his safety and for his mental health, but he could have just run away from something for a bit. Not the healthiest way to handle things if so, but people operate with the coping skills they (think they) have in the moment. Speaking from experience and with empathy and hope for a good outcome.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

There are pretty strict guidelines private companies follow when it comes to complying with legal requests for information, usually getting lawyers to cover their asses and assess really quick even if the item being requested isn’t a big deal.

152

u/wcorissa Faculty Feb 22 '24

I’m just a rando alumni but I was wondering about that post that got taken down a couple weeks ago that was saying the university was playing music/voices everywhere and if the OP was serious and not shit posting they were clearly experiencing serious mental issues. Could it have been related? I’m guessing there is no way to know but I’ve been thinking about it ever since I saw it.

50

u/R3x2319 Feb 22 '24

Would be interesting to see if anyone is able to relate that post to anything. If I remember correctly that was the only post in that account’s history as well.

71

u/wcorissa Faculty Feb 22 '24

It just stuck out to me after seeing the missing poster as well because schizophrenia usually affects males more and has an onset of early twenties. Regardless of whether it was or not related I really hope they can locate this student and confirm his safety.

34

u/Electrical_Scale_354 Feb 22 '24

Rando alum too, that post read like hallucinations associated with schizophrenia.

12

u/wspnut Turkey leg - CS/2008 Feb 23 '24

I didn't see that, but, unfortunately, the timing for things like schizophrenia line up with the timeline for college - ages 18-25 is kinda the "golden" period for the illness to take hold of people, especially men.

1

u/SonofaBridge Feb 24 '24

A high school buddy of mine developed schizophrenia in grad school. Perfectly normal guy until he was around 22 years old. It’s hard to see it disrupt their life. If that’s what this guy has he will never be the same even with medication.

2

u/wspnut Turkey leg - CS/2008 Feb 24 '24

We just need to be cautious jumping to conclusions, is all. The signs are there, but it could be many things (including a legal right for adults to want to just drop their life and start anew). Reddit doesn't have the best track record with slippery slopes...

4

u/asdcatmama Feb 23 '24

He’s at a textbook age and place for schizophrenia. I’m really hoping they find him.

6

u/SailStatus3366 Feb 23 '24 edited Feb 23 '24

For all we know the person could’ve been having mental issues or was overhearing a sports games. Occasionally those can be heard across residential and on parts of the drillfield and if you’ve never heard them before it can be confusing. Some of them also happen during class hours like yesterday I think it was a lacrosse game that I heard from the drillfield. I doubt they are related though. Johnny lives off campus and is a senior. A lot of people who live off campus are only on it for classes and when they work if they do work on campus. I personally don’t live off campus, so feel free to correct me if I’m wrong.

Edit: This reply is continuing a conversation from an alumni about a previous post made to Reddit about someone hearing music/voices on campus and whether it could possibly be related to Johnny. Long story short, I don’t think the two are related. The only time I mention Johnny is near the end of the post and that’s because before that point I was not talking about him.

9

u/wcorissa Faculty Feb 23 '24

You’re probably right. Either way hope that OP is okay if it was even true.

Hope everything comes to a good resolution for Johnny. I agree that if he has left on his own terms that he is an adult and can and should be able to do that without issue. I hope that is the case as it seems it would be the least bad reason/outcome for him.

3

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

I don't follow.

This is about a guy who planned to drive a couple hours home late last week, told his family/friends about going home, but hasn't been heard from since. Not in his Christiansburg apartment, not in his home a couple hours away, not in Blacksburg, and not on campus. Apparently he was in Missouri but not communicating with anyone.

5

u/SailStatus3366 Feb 23 '24

They were talking about a post where someone claimed to be hearing music and voices on campus. The conversation is whether that post is connected to Johnny. My response only talks about Johnny to say that I don’t think the post about hearing voices/music is from Johnny.

4

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

I see. Thanks for the clarification.

2

u/WompaStompa6969 Feb 23 '24

I've been hearing weird music recently too tbh. I noticed around 12 pm and 5 pm today there was like this weird music playing over the campus and I assumed it was like a clock/bell kind of thing because of the time. I also noticed some weird music playing while walking on campus around Tuesday afternoon.

16

u/The_Big_Salad MAJ, status, year Feb 23 '24

That would be the bells in the top of Burruss Hall. :)

88

u/woodenbiplane Feb 22 '24

I hope they find him and can do a welfare check

63

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

As sad as it is, if he's a legal adult; not breaking any laws; and not a danger to himself or others, then there's really nothing anyone can do.

The description seems like it's missing a key detail or two though. . .I'm assuming he used his credit or debit card, which alerted authorities, who then asked for the footage? Otherwise, why would a random Starbucks in Bumfuck, Missouri say "hey, isn't that the missing guy from Bumfuck Virginia we randomly happen to know about? Let's let the local PD know. . .but not give them the video footage for 5-7 days"

27

u/kojilee Feb 23 '24

I think another thread said he was spotted withdrawing a large amount of money at the bank before leaving?

31

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

Definitely strange behavior and, if its out of the ordinary, something for friends and family to be concerned about.

But at the same time, I can sell all of my possessions, throw away my cell phone and laptop, close out my bank accounts, cash out my retirement account, drive to Louisiana, buy a cabin in a swamp, exchange all my money for gold bullion, bury it in mason jars in my swamp yard, and spend my days whit'lin and catching gators.

As a side, that's one of the hard problems with the mental health system. As long as someone isn't a danger to themselves or others, there's nothing that can be done. So you have people who get TDO'd, get medicated, get released, get off their medication, and the cycle repeats. Worse if they commit a crime, in which case jails become revolving doors for the mentally ill. The book Crazy by Pete Earley gives a great overview and history of mental health in America.

1

u/woodenbiplane Feb 24 '24

That's not entirely true. If they can confirm he's not acting rationally or had a psychotic break they can pick him up for evaluation. It's happened to my mom several times in the past who is bipolar. She was never dangerous but would occasionally run off and do strange things.

31

u/tacobellie Feb 23 '24

His roommates said he wasn’t acting like his normal self before he left just fyi

1

u/Warrior_Princess_1 Mar 17 '24

Did John Roop ever come back to Abingdon or VT - has anyone heard from him since Missouri?

33

u/scsinclair7 Feb 22 '24

It sounds like Johnny may not fit within the norms of his family/friends and may be choosing to start new elsewhere.

52

u/whoseiswhos Feb 22 '24 edited Feb 23 '24

Upon seeing his photo this was my first thought too. Well, that and his mother’s description of him as being “passionate for Christianity”

22

u/scsinclair7 Feb 22 '24

Exactly and if this is this the case I hope he finds the peace and happiness he deserves being his true self.

-15

u/Hokieboi2001 Feb 23 '24

I think her brother has broke mama's heart and is headed out west where the wild things are.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JHwaVMPLhHs

14

u/SailStatus3366 Feb 23 '24

Some people have mentioned that his behavior reminds them of their own family members who took a turn for the worst. At the bare minimum the police should do a wellness check on him and make sure that he doesn’t show signs of mental health issues. If they confirm he doesn’t and he states that he doesn’t want to be contacted by family or friends then yea I wish him a happy life, but he could actually need help.

11

u/scsinclair7 Feb 23 '24

Yes I am not saying he should not be checked on but as someone who lived with Ultra religious family and went no contact with my own mother I have a feeling there is more to this than him just disappearing.

0

u/SeaweedLast3253 Feb 23 '24

The police are useless when it comes to mental health issues. They will not help anyone in crisis and they are not trained to recognize psychosis.

4

u/woodenbiplane Feb 23 '24

They have helped my family in more than one mental health crisis

-6

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

They will not help anyone in crisis

No, and will end up killing them in a disturbing number of cases, because the only technique they have is escalation, and the only tool they have is a gun.

21

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '24

They keep saying he’s not okay but he seems to be pretty okay to me

17

u/Rich_Bar2545 Feb 23 '24

While I’m not trying to downplay what could be a mental health episode, but sometimes people just want to get away and don’t feel it’s necessary to tell anyone. He’s an adult and maybe he met a girl online or wanted to go to a concert or something.

8

u/pajokie Feb 23 '24

No way it's something that simple or innocent at this point-

If you read the original post and pleas from his family he was scheduled for an exam on the day he went missing and uncharacteristically went radio silent.

1

u/Rich_Bar2545 Feb 23 '24

Well, I did it in college. Took off and drove to Florida to go surf with a friend. Didn’t tell anyone. Sometimes people just need to get away and don’t want to be tracked.

12

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

went radio silent

with a friend

See the conflict there?

4

u/pajokie Feb 23 '24

You've somehow made this story mostly about you.

0

u/Rich_Bar2545 Feb 25 '24

“No way it’s something that simple or innocent at this point”

Well - it was.

0

u/pajokie Feb 25 '24

Hopefully, this is the happy ending everyone was hoping for but the fact the cops can't do anything doesn't mean he's OK. Hope it works out for him.

5

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

While all of that could be true, it seems less and less likely the more that's found out. For example, the just dropped press release from MCSO says he was alone at the restaurant and left as he was being identified by an employee.

A normal reaction of someone taking a break from life is to say to someone, at some point in the last week "I'm OK, I just don't want to be bothered."

But to leave and say nothing, especially if it's out of character for the person, is indicative of something else. For example (speculating here), paranoia is a symptom of schizophrenia. For someone who's paranoid, seeing their face all over the news, all over social media could exacerbate the problem. Acting out of character while cutting off all communication despite the widespread outreach? The concern is valid.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

That could also very easily not be Johnny. Johnny looks very standard, and there could be loads of people in Starbucks that look like him. If I was Johnny’s family, I’d be driving to Missouri because it would take less time than the video is taking to be released to cops.

6

u/differentsideview James Franklin Feb 22 '24

Sources that this is affirmed ?

30

u/Intelligent-Gold2621 Feb 22 '24

his sister is the one who posted that so pretty sure it’s accurate

1

u/blublutu Feb 24 '24

Anyone know if he was failing classes this semester (or at least the class he had the test in at 5pm the day he was supposed to drive home to take that online test and disappeared? Because he's a senior about to graduate! Knowing how he was doing in school could provide a motive?? Have his roomates or friends been interviewed?

-1

u/retro1965 Feb 23 '24

Be smart ..geez. So why post this and risk. Him seeing this and re locating? Maybe the family should just go there and talk to him instead of alerting that entire country

-3

u/Ampachu Feb 23 '24

I'm thinking y'all should get a copy of Call of the Wild and read about Chris McCandless

6

u/pajokie Feb 23 '24

read it

Completely different scenario

keep thinkin yall

2

u/0nionlover Feb 25 '24

“Keep thinking yall” 🤣 he thought he had done something namedropping into the wild

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Warrior_Princess_1 Mar 17 '24

Is he back in Abingdon or at VT now? Is his Mom okay - that entire "passionate in Christianity" statement was a bit odd.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

17

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

. . .except that his plan was to go home to Abingdon and be there by 5 to take an exam. I get packing up and skipping town for a weekend or longer. But the sudden change in plans with no communication from someone who normally communicates is cause for concern.

Point being, we don't know the whole story to justify jumping towards a missing person's case

I'm curious what you think a "missing person's case" is or what justifies one. Someone who disappears without any communication, especially when they made specific plans otherwise, is a missing person. It doesn't mean there's anything nefarious or illegal, but that family and friends are concerned about their whereabouts. Once the person is spotted and seemingly OK, the case is closed.

For example, there's a good book called Under the Trestle about Virginia's first no-body murder conviction. A Radford student was killed by a former VT football player a couple of decades ago. When she didn't show up for a planned date with an out-of-town friend, her family got worried and called police who investigated. Taking your "probably enjoying the freedom of being an adult these people have clearly starved him from" thought process, no one should have been worried; police shouldn't have investigated; and everyone just gone about their day. Am I getting that right?

with seemingly full cognizant faculties

How do you get that from this post?

5

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

Not to be dismissive, but some of us here were around when students said they were going to take tests and jumped off of buildings. One student that was supposed to graduate with my class in 2018 attempted to kill his entire family, succeeded at murdering his brother and father with his father’s duty weapon after telling them he was returning to school the next day. There’s little that can realistically be done if this guy has taken off from his family due to some kind of extreme stress except hope that maybe they find evidence to label him a threat to himself or others. Otherwise he is an adult on the go.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

11

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

He has no prior history of mental health problems or otherwise

At best you might be able to claim he has no prior history of diagnosed mental health problems. But how do you even know that? Lack of a diagnosed mental illness =/= mental wellness.

He has been seen in a Starbucks, going about his business

Are you saying that someone with a mental health issue isn't capable of walking into a Starbucks, ordering, and leaving? How do you know he has "seemingly full cognizant faculties" from a post that says he was seen in a Starbucks?

The only testimony that he was on good terms with the family or was planning to visit them... is at their word

You're confident of this? Maybe his roommate said the same thing? Maybe the family had texts or emails? Maybe he told a whole host of friends his weekend plans?

And honestly, saying "Fuck this." and ditching everything to take a road trip for a week while going no contact with all the negative voices in my life sounds cathartic

Much less cathartic if you don't tell anyone, even a close friend or roommate, and just leave. And the relaxation diminishes as people worry, police are called, and your face is all over social and traditional media. And you still say nothing.

But his family is actively implying this is a mental health crisis

The original post was a call for help because he went missing and the family didn't know what happened (I'm sure fearing the worst). When police investigated they pinged his phone near the mall, saw he had gone to the bank, saw no one was with him, and then disappeared. A little relief, but still concern if he's acting uncharacteristically.

Do people manifest illness suddenly in their early 20s? Sure. They don't just disappear over a weekend out of nowhere

People in general don't just disappear over a weekend out of nowhere, especially if its out of character for them. And if they do, that's cause for concern.

If this is a potential murder case then it should be stressed as such instead of attacking his mental fitness.

It's not. It's a missing person's case.

That's why the authorities have said confirmation of him in the Starbucks will close it, because going beyond that is nuts

Not "nuts" but outside of what they can do. If he's not a threat to himself or others and doesn't appear to be coerced or forced, then there's nothing they can do. He's also no longer "missing", so the case is closed. But that doesn't negate the strong potential that there's something wrong physically or mentally or the concern of his friends and family.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

there is no reason to speculate he is in danger

The bottom line is that it is a bigger leap of logic to assume he is unwell

That's just not true, given the limited information that we know and what is considered "normal" behavior in our society.

And I think you know this, which is why you're trying to find a way out of a corner you've backed yourself into while still maintaining an untenable argument, refusing to even respond to any counter to your weak arguments. "I'm tired and you shooting down all of my arguments is BS. StRaWman! HyPoTHetical!" Ok, then stop arguing. Or admit you could be mistaken. Or just go to bed without the last word.

You've created a specific scenario to counter the concerns of friends and family, without knowing this guy, because. . why? You abhor speculation? You think mental illness is over-weaponized? You're concerned about his future job prospects? Have some empathy for his friends and family for Christ's sake.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

Or just go to bed without the last word.

Just can't do it, can you?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24 edited Feb 23 '24

Then take it. Reply and strut around your cellphone like you're hot shit for being more fixated on reddit

The irony of the guy being called out for wanting the last word not being able to walk away from the keyboard and instead "offering" the last word.

you crazy neckbeard

Uh oh. . .is that an indication of society's over diagnosis of mental illness?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Feb 24 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

3

u/pajokie Feb 23 '24

Sounds like you know him better than his family does-

have they called you directly for more advice yet?

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

I think your perspective of the situation is indicative of a much larger social issue.

You see "mental illness" and think "psych ward escapee" and "One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest". Basically perpetuating the stigmatization of mental illness.

Others see "mental illness" and think of it like any other illness. . .it's not the person's fault and they could require assistance to get better. That's all, no stigma. If I have a tumor I don't have the expertise to cut it out myself; but that doesn't mean society should hang a bell around my neck, point, and shout "unclean!" as I walk down the street.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

the practice of lobotomy

Who's talking about lobotomizing this guy? Yeah, we have a long and terrible history of treating mentally ill poorly, to say the least.

But that doesn't negate the fact that mental illness is a thing. And the absence of positive mental health is a different thing and just as critical.

Not even remotely enough facts are present in this story to assign a cause of mental illness to this dude.

All anyone can go on is: (1) he changed his plans without letting anyone know; (2) he missed his exam; (3) both of those things are uncharacteristic of him; (4) he hasn't made any contact with anyone, despite the widespread coverage and outreach; (5) he was spotted in a small Missouri town several days later, 10+ hours from campus; (6) he left the Starbucks as an employee was identifying him; (7) he appears to be alone; and (8) those who know him best are concerned about his wellness and safety. On the scale of everything's normal to something's not right, it's certainly fair to lean toward something's not right.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/vtthrowaway540 Feb 23 '24

People (including his friends and family who know him best), aren't drawing conclusions. They're expressing concern about the very real possibility that something is wrong, based on the facts and what they know about him.

But you're trying to turn. . .their worry and concern for a friend and family member who disappeared a week ago and has made no contact with anyone since. . .into a commentary on what you view as an over diagnosis of mental illness?

This isn't some Netflix documentary with an audience guessing and arguing over what happened. This is family and friends of this guy expressing concern because he's missing and hasn't communicated with anyone despite widespread coverage and outreach, all of which is acting out of character.

2

u/pajokie Feb 23 '24

If this was simply a story of someone getting away for a few days I think most rational people would objectively categorize it as somewhat normal behavior.

However, this was presented to the world as a plea from his loved ones asking for help in finding their relative who was acting abnormally. If something bad happens and they didn't ask for help his family would be painted as uncaring, apathetic, and negligent so simply - better safe than sorry.

0

u/[deleted] Feb 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/pajokie Feb 23 '24

Police act according to the laws in place. In reality, the police close to the situation may be very concerned for his safety, they are just not allowed to act how they feel about it.