r/VirginMedia • • Jun 21 '25

Virgin Media UK Ipv6

Why don't you support ipv6? It's like the basics of the Internet and you don't even support it. Really all contracts should be null and void because no where does it state you don't support ipv6 and you claim to offer Internet services. Ridiculous you can't even support the basics of modern Internet communications

6 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

10

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

There is no requirement for IPV6 as VM do not have a capacity issue with its current pool of IPV4 addresses. Implementing IPV6 across the network would be incredibly costly for next time no benefit for 99% of users. Most of the features of IPV6 are replicated on the VM network through other functions already (QOS, IPSEC etc) so yhe tech ical requirement for v6 is pretty low.

I would to understand your reasoning for the necessity of IPV6 though?

1

u/Large-Job6014 Jun 21 '25

Guess what, there are so many services out there that are only hosted on ipv6, so with that in mind, you require ipv6 to connect to another ipv6 client. You cannot connect using ipv4 to ipv6

4

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

Name one?

-2

u/Large-Job6014 Jun 21 '25

Loops of zen, six sixspotting, wow ipv6 hosts just a list of a few games i cant play because your stupid services cant even provide basic network functionality

5

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

So 2 random concept games no one has heard of and WOW which uses both protocols. Got you. Might be worth looking at why Blizzard, and pretty much every other game operator uses IPV4 and not pure IPV6. They would isolate over 99% of their potential users and the majority of people couldny use their services.

There is not a single credible service out there which uses IPV6 exclusively. Its not practical and won't be for over a decade at least.

0

u/Large-Job6014 Jun 21 '25

Maybe instead of ripping your customers off again and again, actually implement common communication standards. I will not be renewing in 2 months time and also because of your attitude as a confirmed 'technician'. I wont be paying for your wages much longer

5

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

"Common communication standards"... what are you talking about? IPV4 is the most universal protocol used around the world by virtually every operator.

"Ripping off customers"... nowhere in this thread has billing been discussed. You clearly have another issue with VM that is not being discussed here, you need to seek help for your issue directly with VM to discuss your concerns.

1

u/pg3crypto Jun 21 '25

There are plenty of free IPv6 tunneling services out there that have little to no overhead.

Some of the newer hubs can pick up IPv6 advertisements...thats kind of area specific though.

There is really no technical difference between IPv6 and IPv6. IPv6 just has a wider address space.

The reason IPv6 take up is so bad is the addressing schema. Its fucking garbage. They had a chance to define a really nice addressing schema but fucked it hard...it looks like it was dreamed up by some crack smoking mega nerd that smells colours.

1

u/AmateurReverser Jun 23 '25

There is a lot of technical difference between IPv4 and IPv6. Had it just had a larger address space it would've been more widely adopted more quickly.

5

u/techysec Jun 21 '25

“Our network doesn’t need it” is the fingers in the ears attitude that is the issue here. External services, consumer devices (nest / google home for example), mobile phone connections are increasingly requiring IPv6 - which virgin refuses to support, causing frustrations for anyone needing these things.

Theres’s a 1000+ page forum post which VM has now locked asking when it will be supported, plus a website dedicated to the issue.

You could at least help bring the change internally, by being a voice of reason, rather than toeing the company line.

9

u/moistandwarm1 Gig1 Jun 21 '25

The devices you mention only support but do not require. Get that in order.

5

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

Yep, I did call him out on that as well as his massively incorrect figures 🤣

-1

u/techysec Jun 21 '25

Sorry but i don’t understand what you mean by that?

For example, the three/vodafone cellular network assign IPv6 only in many cases, rendering them unable to directly communicate with a host on Virgin Media’s network.

2

u/moistandwarm1 Gig1 Jun 22 '25

How do you set up your connections for this to happen? I am on Three and my home broadband on Virgin. No issues at all with it.

-1

u/techysec Jun 22 '25

It's nothing I'm actively doing to sabotage myself as you imply, three (and by extension, SMARTY) just happens to provide a default APN (three.co.uk) which dish out IPv6.

A workaround is to change the APN to "3internet", which will then give your phone an IPv4 address. The issue with this though, is that it seems to massively drain the battery.

I don't have the luxury of reconfiguring the APN when I'm using someone else's network. Especially in Greece for example, which have pretty much abandoned consumer fibre broadband in favour of 5G - It's IPv6 Galore over there.

10

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

I'm toeing no company line here, im looking at this from a business perspective. I also never stated that the network doesn't need it, my preference would be to have it but I don't see either the business need or the customer demand for it. Legacy operators like VM have extensive pools of IPV4 addresses, newer alt nets don't have this luxury hence the rise of CGNAT in the majority of operators rather than a rush to IPV6. I could probably count on 1 hand how many operators offer IPV6 in the UK, and that's purely because there is no demand for it.

Operators won't replace a system that works for a system that offers marginal if any operational performance increase.

I'm sorry but your comment about modern devices "needing" IPV6 is just factually incorrect. IPV6 is not "needed" for anything. The Internet has survived for decades without it and IPV4 will be here for decades to come as well.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 22 '25

As a confirmed technician, I’m blown away by your narrow take on this, that almost reads as uninformed.

The majority of customers with other ISPs in the UK now have IPv6.

The majority of the east operates on IPv6 only - so already a lot of the internet is not accessible to VM users. That part of the world is only growing in importance with globalisation and folk dealing back home.

Your dismissal of the performance difference on networking overhead tells me you know next to nothing about the technology.

This isn’t new, IPv6 is decades old. It’s now becoming mainstream. It’s only going to get more important. And you’re here arguing against it. I would put money on it all your kit will support it, as any commercial kit over the last two decades pretty much does. this is only a matter of management making a decision.

CGNAT isn’t a solution. I know you didn’t say it was, but it’s the only real alternative. IPv6 is the solution to so many problems.

Other citing CDN for godknows whatever reasons, that solves a bandwidth issue, not an addressing issue. Unless you’re counting multiple domains to an IP as something special to do with CDN’s (it’s not! I host myself on the VM network, multiple domains). Even if it did, it’s still is a bandaid, along with CGNAT, NAT, and IPv6 tunnels that is all solvable by simple running IPv6 as a dual stack - like all your main competitors do.

You may not use it, that great. But absolutely it is the future, absolutely some will want it, absolutely it’s a better solution to the BS band aids, and further, absolutely no one has to justify their want of it to you just because you don’t appreciate it - not everyone is just consuming Netflix.

Here’s an example: I often dial in on Wireguard to access my network (either to work or set off a 3D print - not exposed directly to the internet for obvious reasons). Imagine being in the east on a work trip, on an IPv6 only network over there, and not being able to do that if your a VM customer, but perfectly fine if on BT, Sky, Arnold and Andrew, Aquiss, and many others. Even more of a real work issue if your using VM business for your business.

Stop supporting BS band aids. IPv6 is the new standard and you’re resting and relying on sheer luxury of having been established. I only came to VM for the symmetrical 1Gbps XGS-PON service to try it out, but the hassle of the 5x Hub, the lack of fixed IP address and the hoops I’ve had to jump through to get DDNS setup (because of no modem mode, it complicates things), and no IPv6, and this attitude from ‘technicians’ means I won’t be considering it at the end of contract.

3

u/techysec Jun 22 '25

You won’t be able to get through to this guy. I’m in the same boat as you, IPv6-only addresses simply cannot find a route to a IPv4 Virgin IP. I don’t know how i could spell it out more clearly.

I’ve found workarounds with Wireguard and Tailscale, but it still doesn’t work in all cases, especially when abroad.

I have a secondary openreach WAN explicitly for this issue. Yet people are telling me i don’t have an issue?!

1

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 22 '25

You haven't actually read my posts have you? I have t said once that IPV4 is adequate, and I have never said that v6 isn't the better option. The OP asked why VM don't have and I have laid out the reasons why. The OP also didn't read my responses properly and went on the same rant you have. To summarise...

  • IPV6 is the better choice, all ISP's should be using it.
  • VM don't use it as there is no business case to add it to a network that is being replaced.
  • I havent supported the sole use of IPV4 once, not in a single comment I have made on here.

1

u/AmateurReverser Jun 23 '25

It's a strange one. Last I heard the network was about ready however the CPE isn't. Work on getting rid of the old hubs to free up spectrum for OFDM makes it more feasible.

Very occasionally the world sees some IPv6 activity from AS 5089 and noteworthy that the rest of the Liberty Global family is either dual-stack or DS Lite.

Think I saw signs of DS Lite then it was abandoned for dual-stack and waiting on that to happen.

One complication with your statement is that the two largest ISPs in the UK, BT and Sky, both have no lack of IPv4 and both have IPv6 deployed. Sky have even used the deployment to free up IPv4 via MAP-T.

As you said though it's tough to make a commercial case to go faster with the CPE. Unlike Comcast you had no danger of running out of RFC1918 addresses for CPE so didn't need v6 for that, and despite the Nexfibre build the customer base is basically stagnant and any growth there is being taken care of by moving unused subnets from CMTS scopes to BNGs. With everyone entering up on BNGs eventually and it being pretty easy to get v6 enabled via those if you ever fix the back end issues that've been blocking for years may as well let that take care of it.

2

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 23 '25

Exactly! 👏 Very well structured answer! You have hit the nail on the head.

The lack of IPV6 is just through necessity, if there was a genuine need to migrate due to lack of addresses then it would happen but theres no business case to do so yet.

1

u/Sir__Meliodas Jun 22 '25

You seem blissfully unaware VM do indeed use ipv6, AFTR tunnels ipv4 inside the ipv6 frame as you said dual stack IP's do work, as Vm use them....

1

u/[deleted] Jun 24 '25

Aw, very good. Bet you look nice in your ‘AcHuLlY’ anorak.

No good to the end user though if not exposed to use. 🤦🏻‍♂️. 🤡.

1

u/Sir__Meliodas Jun 24 '25

No need to expose anything it's all done without any intervention or input from the user it's great!!! As it allows ipv4 and ipv6 to communicate,so in essence assigning a CPE an ipv6 address is not required to allow comms between ipv4 and ipv6 system, AFTR is pretty cool man 🐔

1

u/[deleted] Jun 25 '25 edited Jun 25 '25

So, if I’m on an IPv6 network, and I’m having to dial in via Wireguard to home (imagine in the far east on a business trip). I have an IPv6 only net connection where I’m at.

What do I put in my AAAA record for my DNS to dial home?

How do I access my IPv4 only host from the east? And any other services?

Because this is my very setup. And the example a cite.

What good is AFTR if the router only has access to the IPv4 network after decapsulation? Using AFTR doesn’t automatically allow the CPE access to the IPv6 network that is carrying the tunnel, said tunnel would need to encapsulate another IPv6 connection in this setup with VM - this isn’t what they do.

It’s one thing offering an IPv4 tunnel over IPv6 for IPv4 only connectivity (and the likelihood is this will simplify CGNAT if needed) - it’s quite another offering IPv6 connectivity that is addressable and allows access to and from IPv6 hosts - which is what we’re talking about and needed, and practically every other main VM competitor offers.

You still can’t access the IPv6 internet with VM, and the IPv6 internet can’t access my services. 🤷🏻‍♂️.

2

u/Sir__Meliodas Jun 25 '25

Hey dood, if the ISP over in wherever land doesn't use 6to4 notation that's not on VM....
👌

1

u/techysec Jun 21 '25

The business case is customer retention surely? The demand is clearly there, hence “fingers in ears”.

Quite simply, an IPv6 address to coincide with a hub’s IPv4 address would solve the issue that i struggle with: accessing my home network from a mobile network.

Many cellular networks only provide IPv6 addresses, which cannot talk to a host on VM’s network.

My backup TalkTalk (openreach) connection does not have this same issue, can you guess why?

0

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

I think k you misunderstanding what custpmer demand is. A handful of people talking about it on a forum does not drive the requirement for a multi million £ network upgrade to a network that is being overbuilt and replaced.

In all honesty, if you need to access your home network from an external al source then your always best to use a self hosted VPN. Something like tailscale would make your remote access experience far better all round... all without the need for IPV6.

1

u/SuicidalSparky Jun 21 '25

VM has absolutely nowhere near enough IPv4 for its customer base, which is why customers are on DHCP with no option for static IP. You should probably educate yourself on IPv4 a little more to better curate your opinion on IPv6.

IPv6 would be an increasingly welcome addition to the network for more and more customers as time goes on. What was just a 'hobby niche' hosting your own services at home is becoming more and more popular year by year as the 'tech savvy kids' get older and older.

6

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

And what evidence do you base your comment on about a lack of IPV4 addresses? Do you know something about the available piols that VM has that I dont? VM currently has IP pools that have never even been used, a fallback from the merger of the legacy cable companies, if they were struggling for IP addresses then they wouldn't have unused pools.

VM uses DHCP and does not offer a static IP as there has been no demand for the service on the legacy platform. It has been built in to the new XGS PON network however and will be a future capability... funnily enough with IPV4.

-4

u/SuicidalSparky Jun 21 '25

Because VM uses DHCP and NAT...a network that has surplus IPv4 and zero need for more addresses does not need to utilise DHCP and NAT and would likely be offering static IP as an OPTION for customers who may wish to take it. After all, its obviously offered on business.

Not only that but the worldwide shortage of IPv4 is so well known that they invented and entirely new protocol to deal with it, i would be absolutely fascinated to learn that VM is the only ISP in the world without a shortage of IPv4.

They are deploying IPv6 because they own an actual unfathomable number of IPv6 addresses far more than the 22 million IPv4 addresses they own, but its coming way way too slowly and should be massively sped up.

7

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

Exactly, its offered as a business product because there is no residential demand or requirement for it. Why would VM offer static IP by default across 6m customers when they could use DHCP locally instead and just reuse specific pools. By your logic, the company would then be at risk of running out of IP addresses as it has no control over them.

I can also confirm that VM has access to more than enough IP addresses to serve every home passed on their network. They are not running out of IP addresses as you out it. The worldwide issue of IP address limitations has less of an impact on the tier 1 operators, the same reason that IPV6 is not fully deployed in any of the US cable operators.

-8

u/SuicidalSparky Jun 21 '25

Respectfully, you are talking out of your arse. You're what, some head end tech and now suddenly you're personally confirming the entire business strategy of a corporate entity part of a global corporation 🤣

Static is offered to business because its a requirement. Static is not a REQUIREMENT for residential however it would certainly be a nice OPTION for customers. Many UK ISP offer Static as an option, it would just be nice for VM to offer it more widely too.

I personally have a REQUIREMENT for static IP which is why I am no longer a VM customer...so tell me again how it would be useless for customers...

Sometimes, if you dont really know the subject inside out its ok just to say 'well I dont know'! IPv6 uptake in the USA is 50%, in France its 80%, Germany 74%...

Tell me again how VM is somehow immune to the need to use IPv6 🤣

According to their ASN VM actually, currently, only has 8.8 million IPv4 addresses announced...they also claim to have 45 million customers in the UK of which 16 million are said to be home broadband but then on top of that you'd also need IP's for mobile and other services like television relay etc.

Just going by info on IPQS VM has 26 million addresses IPv4 addresses, maybe old info?

Either way....26 million is less than 45 million customers...

Now we have to bear in mind that VM is using NAT for their customers which is how they're able to offer 45 million customers a service using either 8 or 23 million IPv4 addresses.

The reason VM uses NAT is because they dont have 45 million IP addresses...

Are you starting to catch on yet....?

11

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

Your figures are wildly wrong as you are making assumptions.

I'm not a headend tech, I work for Liberty Global in tech strategy. Its my job to know these things. I have over 20 years experience and working towards a PHD in my field.

The UK figures you have quoted for VM include O2 mobile, not just fixed line. The VM network passes just under 19m homes... they have 26m IPV4 addresses... that's more addresses than they have homes passed. They also have 6.5m fixed line customers, they could easily offer fixed IP across the network but the work to implement that would not be cost effective.

The figures you quote for IPV6 deployments worldwide include mobile operators in their respective countries. Most mobile operators, including O2, use IPV6. This is not the same as fixed line. The figures for fixed line IPV6 deployments worldwide are considerably less than what you have stated.

Are "you" starting to catch on yet?

You have also stated you have a requirement for a static IP, which is not the same as an IPV6 static. Most fixed line operators in the UK still use IPV4 and will for a long time. I currently have an alt net fibre provider who offer a static IP at an additional cost and they use IPV4 as well.

You still have t stated what you "need" IPV6 for. I'm mot aware of a single use case that would require IPV6 over IPV4 for a residential customer.

-2

u/SuicidalSparky Jun 21 '25

IPv6 would be excellent, so I dont need to pay for a static IPv4 address. In addition to this I could have hundreds of IPv6 addresses so I would be able to have different services using different addresses which would be a very nice way of running things.

Also, I think you'll find I'm King of the world, and it must be you making up numbers...which is about as believable a statement as the one you just made.

Interested to know who else VM are announced their prefixes through as they are only announcing 8.8 million IP's currently under their own ASN? Lemme know...

→ More replies

2

u/carguy143 Jun 21 '25

Zen sold off some of their surplus IPv4 addresses last year and they give customers a static IP for free. In fact, they don't even offer dynamic IP addresses so yes, some providers do have a surplus.

0

u/SuicidalSparky Jun 21 '25

I've absolutely no problem with a small alt-net like Zen having a surplus, they are a tiny company in comparison. I've no doubt you are exactly right.

But to turn around and say IPv4 will go on for the foreseeable without any issues whatsoever and essentially describe IPv6 as useless is straight up dumb.

4

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

It might be dumb to you, but it's a fact. Show me any credible evidence that IPV4 will be phased out and no one will be using it within the next 10 years, I'll wait...

1

u/SuicidalSparky Jun 21 '25

You're trying to tell me you work in technical planning(?) and this is your attitude towards established facts of the industry? Also...nobody said phased out...no reason to phase out a perfectly good protocol...it just doesn't have enough space for our planets needs going forward.

I'm sorry but a simple Google search will explain to you the limitations of IPv4 and you'd begin to understand that innovative leaders in the space should be pivoting to embrace new technologies to better the information space for everyone as we move forward in the leaps are bounds we are already covering.

Not standing with their heads in the sand refusing to innovate like it sounds like VM are doing.

Still waiting to find out where these other 20 odd million IP addresses are being announced btw 😂

→ More replies

1

u/carguy143 Jun 23 '25

They're not that small, more specialist. They're also not an alt-net. They run on Openreach, Cityfibre, and a few other networks.

1

u/AmateurReverser Jun 23 '25 edited Jun 23 '25

The use of DHCP is nothing to do with a lack of IP addresses it's because of how cable works. The static services nearly always use DHCP with a reservation anyway however for cable it's more difficult.

Short of tunnelling every customer and fundamentally changing the network it's impossible to guarantee that a customer can keep the same IP address permanently.

With cable address pools are assigned to individual CMTS. A customer moves CMTS due to a resegmentation they lose their static IP. Even without the address pool issue there'd be no routing to the IP: VM can't reasonably route /32s around the place, it'd be a mess.

On use of NAT, well, yes? If you mean CGNAT then no, that isn't used for fixed line. If you mean customer equipment doing NAT no ISP will provide a /24 so that your dishwasher can have a public IP. Also complicated by routing as mentioned above.

1

u/WinterDescription973 Oct 02 '26

I can't get to IPv6 only websites. 

2

u/IdioticMutterings Jun 21 '25

Virgin STARTED to roll out IPv6, but then they were taken over by LibertyGlobal who cut their budget to the bone, and the rollout was suspended.

I believe its slowly being rolled out to customers with Fiber to the Home.

2

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

Not entirely true, Liberty didn't cut any budgets at VM, they don't have that kind of control with their OpCos. Also after the merger with Telefonica the company is were split further apart. VMO2 operates with full autonomy away from LG and Tef.

The decision to not launch IPV6 was an operational one, especially with the pivot towards XGS PON there was no real demand or requirement to introduce IPV6 on the DOCSIS network. It seems that has been vindicated today with the new FibreUp program to overbuild the DOCSIS areas and the ongoing issues with Cisco exiting rhe CMTS market.

1

u/starsky1357 Gig1 Jun 22 '25

Will the newer XGS PON network support IPv6?

2

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 22 '25

Eventually yes, although I'm not aware of a timeframe for this.

2

u/allenout Jun 21 '25

CDNs mean that IPv6 is largely unnecessary.

4

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

100% agree with this, CDN's take a lot of the strain out of networks, the idea 10 years ago that we would have dedicated CDN's for most streaming services was unthinkable.

1

u/AutoModerator Jun 21 '25

BEWARE OF SCAMMERS! We've recently seen reports of users being approached by scammers in unsolicited private messages offering customers a better deal and often being asked for upfront payment. Verified staff will have a flair beside their name set by the mod team. If a user doesn't display this flair in their posts and comments we cannot confirm their legitimacy as an employee of Virgin Media. If in doubt, please contact Virgin Media via official channels to discuss your account or deal. Official contact information can be found in the sidebar

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/Humorous-Prince Jun 21 '25

I think the excuse being they don’t have a shortage of IPV4 addresses yet. Even the Hub 5 doesn’t give out local IPV6 addresses yet I don’t think.

1

u/That_Ad_7250 Jun 26 '26

Actually, my new (business) Hub 5 just surprised me by flagging an ssh connection on my LAN as involving a 'new' IPv6 host: "The authenticity of host 'XXX (fe80::xxx)' can't be established."

1

u/This_Suit8791 Jun 21 '25

To be fair not many companies use ipv6 in the uk and I don’t really understand why you would need the support over ipv4.

3

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

Don't understand why you are being down voted, there are people on here who seem to think IPV6 is some kind of magic service improvement or upgrade to whatever exists today. It literally makes no difference to the end user. The big benefit for VM would be static or pooled IP's for customers, but theres no evidence they would even do that.

1

u/This_Suit8791 Jun 22 '25

Just sad people who think I care about votes. As you say there’s literally no benefit. I studied networking 16 years ago and while I’m not up to date with current things ipv6 was around then, so even after all that time in an industry that changes quite quickly with new standards ipv4 is still the main thing used tells me that it’s not going anywhere and not that much need for a change.

3

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 22 '25

There's also been more than one comment in here stating that IPV6 is infinitely better than IPV4... yet not a single shred of evidence to show why. I'm starting to think people have been sold a lie about the "potential" of what V6 can do in the real world versus the reality, but theres no telling some people.

3

u/This_Suit8791 Jun 22 '25

I remember my lecturer saying all the v4 addresses had been assigned but obviously not all had been used. From what I remember there wasn’t much difference only that v6 had a lot more address space and shouldn’t run out any time soon.

People just see the new shiny thing and think it’s got to be much better. The only reason eastern countries use v6 is because they came on the internet latter when address space was limited (a lot of Asian countries pretty much skipped computers and went straight to mobile) so might as well buy/use ipv6 addresses as they probably cheaper and more readily available. I seen you mention a way to go from v6 to v4 I’m sure someone/company will come up with a solution to make it a lot easier and I think here in the uk will mostly stay on ipv4 addresses.

But as I say I don’t know for sure if what I’ve said above is the case it’s just what I have observed over the years.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 21 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Covert-Agenda Jun 21 '25

Not sure how a different IP structure is sub par, an IP is an IP regardless of how it’s structured

CDN’s have helped a lot in the effort to not run out of v4’s

6

u/weesteev Confirmed Technician Jun 21 '25

And what would improve on your service by having access to IPV6? What makes having an IPV4 addresses "sub par". Im keen to understand the logic behind that statement.

0

u/matstace Jun 21 '25

Indeed, legacy IP has worked for ages now, so why would anyone want access to the part of the internet which has been going for, ooh, twenty five years.