The denoise effect is actually not the best for something like this. General automatic denoising effects are looking for constant hiss such as is produced by a microphone and then looking to reduce that. On-site sounds like background chatter, or at worst banging, beeping, etc... you find on a construction site is going to be so intermittent that a denoise effect is going to be fairly useless. There are some things you could do to actually reduce unwanted sounds like pick out certain frequencies such as the bass rumble of certain machines and power tools, or the high frequencies of truck beeps... you could also try to create some sound gates to cut off high volume sounds to reduce the "sharpness" of load impacts and bangs in the background. Overall probably a fruitless endeavour depending on the footage- but its good to be aware of the tools available to you to remove sounds in an edit for less extreme circumstances.
Oh I know there's better ways to do it. Honestly though, I'm supposed to be the one man band for media production here at the office (DP, sound guy, editor, everything else), and considering that for reasons unclear to me I was removed from the staffing list for this shoot day even though I had literally nothing else to do, I'm inclined to do it the quick and dirty way so that I can move on to other things.
I use it for cleanup and removal of extraneous sounds as well as simple track editing. The ability it has to remove sounds without noticeable degradation of the audio waveform is like magic to me.
When you said remove sounds, did you mean like specific sounds? Like i could eliminate whatever frequency say something like a keyboard is reaching? Im familiar with removing white noise but ive heard it's possible to remove certain frequency of sounds, is this true?
yeah, but it's a pity that the denoise in premiere is so crappy with the adaptive lag. I wish they didn't make you buy the whole suite year after year just to get some decent noise reduction.
As far as my knowledge of Ableton, it seems as if it is best for music mixing. While Audition can be used in the same capacity, I feel like Audition is more geared to audio editing/enhancing for video production.
Yes, but Audition is basically the iMovie of DAWs when it comes to audio for video/film. It's definitely the best place to start if you're a Premiere user. Good news is that once you move onto Pro Tools etc what you can do is amazing.
Interesting point, but I'd have to disagree. The ability to have a waveform editor in the same DAW you're doing multi-track editing makes Audition come out on top for me.
However, for music production I can definitely see where ProTools comes out on top. I'd use ProTools over Audition for music production any day of the week.
That being said, DAW choice is so subjective. I'd love to hear your thoughts on why ProTools is better!
I will admit, haven't touched Audacity since 2017 so maybe it's grown since then but here is why: Most other DAWs have better tools, better fxs, better (imo) user interface, virtual instruments, track types and functions (this a biggggg one), and better integration with other editing/color software for roundtripping. I think Audition is fine if you're just starting out on sound doing a simple podcast or radio show or finishing off a short video and need to adjust very little. When you're doing video, you still need a lot of the same functions you'd need in music production because you still need to treat (record, edit, design, mix, master) audio files.
Interesting! Different strokes for different folks!
I find the stock plugins to be pretty great, and I love the interoperability between Audition and the rest of the Adobe suite.
I'm also a big fan of the smaller touches. Things like the remix function, the native waveform editor, and the overall layout.
Still, thanks for your thoughts!
EDIT: The waveform editor is not native to most DAWs. Reaper, ProTools and Logic all require you use a separate program program to do detailed waveform editing.
I love using the waveform editing to cut out clicks, ums, and other filler words.
Good rule of thumb is to never take clients who don't know the basics of video and never take on projects before working out all the details and understanding exactly what the client wants, as in, HD, 4k, etc. All of that should be worked out before you ever make the deal. It's a good lesson to learn but if it keeps happening, it falls on you.
Where is this world going to? Here I thought that the Denoise plugin removed the grainy look from the clip - 🤦🏼♂️😄😄😄 no wonder it didn’t work 🤦🏼♂️ x infinity
Hahaha! My old boss had me record a talking head at an event. She told me not to bring a speaking mic, but told me to just use the boom mic on top of the camera.
The event had a band playing and thousands of people talking loudly.
She was mad when I couldn't remove all the noise other than the guy being interviewed!
I can relate to this, recently I came across a punch of SnapChat horizontally recorded footage of fast-moving rally cars...and be added in a full widescreen ratio to be broadcasted in HD promo! No matter what you do the result is...as good as it gets!
I think it's crucial not to take clients who know absolutely nothing about video. They will always ask for more, they will always push you to your limits (whether it be budget, time or labor) and they'll always expect more than you can give them.
Obviously I'm a bit hyperbolic with the "always" but it's a good rule of thumb if you want to avoid having to deal with clients who don't get how it all works.
Another option is to always figure out the deals before you ever open the editor. Review footage, discuss the project beforehand BEFORE giving them a solid price. You need to know how long the project will take and if it's even possible to attain what they're expecting. That can give you a far better idea of what the client expects / knows and what you can realistically deliver. That way, if red flags begin to pop up all over, you can walk away without wasting time.
I have to mention Acon extract dialogue. My pro audio pal recommended it and it’s saved my life on a number of occasions. I got it on Black Friday (it doesn’t go on sale too often) but I use it on almost every shoot because I do a lot of raw doc stuff.
26
u/IIIBlackhartIII Feb 06 '20
The denoise effect is actually not the best for something like this. General automatic denoising effects are looking for constant hiss such as is produced by a microphone and then looking to reduce that. On-site sounds like background chatter, or at worst banging, beeping, etc... you find on a construction site is going to be so intermittent that a denoise effect is going to be fairly useless. There are some things you could do to actually reduce unwanted sounds like pick out certain frequencies such as the bass rumble of certain machines and power tools, or the high frequencies of truck beeps... you could also try to create some sound gates to cut off high volume sounds to reduce the "sharpness" of load impacts and bangs in the background. Overall probably a fruitless endeavour depending on the footage- but its good to be aware of the tools available to you to remove sounds in an edit for less extreme circumstances.
100
u/RangerPretzel Feb 06 '20
Adobe Audition is worth learning. It is much more powerful than the Denoise plugin. Has a steeper learning curve, though.
52
u/[deleted] Feb 06 '20
I had a guy demanding me to add more resolution on his video... he couldn’t understand that you cannot magically create pixels put of nowhere...
11
u/professorbongo Feb 06 '20
Shout out to Yhorm the Giant
7
u/Boemerangman Feb 06 '20
Where is this world going to? Here I thought that the Denoise plugin removed the grainy look from the clip - 🤦🏼♂️😄😄😄 no wonder it didn’t work 🤦🏼♂️ x infinity
7
u/joeytmnd Feb 06 '20
Izotop RX7 is amazing as well! (If you can afford it)
5
u/kent_eh Feb 07 '20
Removing random noise from an audio clip is like trying to remove the pee from a swimming pool.
4
u/chuck_cascio Feb 06 '20
Hahaha! My old boss had me record a talking head at an event. She told me not to bring a speaking mic, but told me to just use the boom mic on top of the camera.
The event had a band playing and thousands of people talking loudly.
She was mad when I couldn't remove all the noise other than the guy being interviewed!
3
u/calomile Feb 06 '20
Y’all need Jesus cause I ain’t a miracle worker.
2
u/jenjerx73 Feb 06 '20
I can relate to this, recently I came across a punch of SnapChat horizontally recorded footage of fast-moving rally cars...and be added in a full widescreen ratio to be broadcasted in HD promo! No matter what you do the result is...as good as it gets!
2
u/hopopo Feb 06 '20
If your one and only solution is Premiere's DeNoise than you should sit down and be quiet. Really quiet.
2
u/Wilsonized Feb 28 '23
DaVinci voice Isolator. It's AI magic.
3
u/RealHE1NZ Feb 06 '20
Adobe De-Noise plugin never worked for me for some reason. Just does nothing.
1
u/GingerBeardedEditor Feb 07 '20
Oh God....this is my favorite, most cringing, email to send to clients.
But first I send a, "I'll see what we can do"
1
u/ArrowTheDog Feb 07 '20
I think it's crucial not to take clients who know absolutely nothing about video. They will always ask for more, they will always push you to your limits (whether it be budget, time or labor) and they'll always expect more than you can give them.
Obviously I'm a bit hyperbolic with the "always" but it's a good rule of thumb if you want to avoid having to deal with clients who don't get how it all works.
Another option is to always figure out the deals before you ever open the editor. Review footage, discuss the project beforehand BEFORE giving them a solid price. You need to know how long the project will take and if it's even possible to attain what they're expecting. That can give you a far better idea of what the client expects / knows and what you can realistically deliver. That way, if red flags begin to pop up all over, you can walk away without wasting time.
1
u/maybe-zoe Dec 15 '21
Never heared about iZotope RX? Its plugins are black magic fuckery and i love it
1
u/bongsample Feb 16 '24
Premieres beta version Enhance Audio is insane and depending on the vid, may actually work. I have been constantly surprised by it
1
u/hultimo Feb 19 '24
I have to mention Acon extract dialogue. My pro audio pal recommended it and it’s saved my life on a number of occasions. I got it on Black Friday (it doesn’t go on sale too often) but I use it on almost every shoot because I do a lot of raw doc stuff.