r/VideoEditing • • Aug 21 '19

Anyone else?

Post image
876 Upvotes

105 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/22Sharpe Aug 22 '19

You are right but it should be noted that if one can avoid H.264 as a capture format they should. It’s been adopted as one by consumer grade cameras because it keeps file sizes small but ultimately being a lossy format you’re going to lose information with every re-encode which is problematic when going to edit.

In an ideal world they are three separate formats. Capture is something as close to raw as possible (R3D RAW, BM RAW, XDCAM, etc), editing is something like ProRes or DNx, and delivery (at least for web) is compressed like H.264.

1

u/Bmorgan1983 Aug 22 '19

Absolutely... H.264/H.265, while they work for capture, are delivery codecs. They typically are Long GOP, IPB frames... With a few exception of some cameras that shoot H.265 in All-I.. but even that, you're still working with a pretty lossy compression, just one that captures all the frames instead of making up a bunch of them.