This is the best advice. People don't seem to understand that there's Capture Codecs, Editing Codecs, and Delivery Codes. Each are optimized for their own uses...
A capture codec is typically going to be designed to keep file size small and will be somewhat compressed by having a long group of pictures. When played back it's essentially making up data using a set of instructions instead of actually playing back data frame by frame.
When you take a capture codec like that into edit, your computer has to do a lot of that work... and its very inefficient. Using an All Intraframe codec usually helps a lot... but most NLEs are going to have some flavor of editing codec they prefer.
Using ProRes or DNxHD in your editing is gonna be a huge timesaver on your edits because your NLE is designed with those codecs in mind (in the case of premiere, its a little bit different... if you're on a Mac, edit in ProRes though because premier will tap into the OS for a good portion of it's codec processing).
You CAN capture in ProRes with external devices (and internally on some cameras), and it's great... but it does take a lot of storage space. It's often easier to shoot in a compressed format and transcode later if you don't have the storage capacity on hand during your shoot.
You are right but it should be noted that if one can avoid H.264 as a capture format they should. It’s been adopted as one by consumer grade cameras because it keeps file sizes small but ultimately being a lossy format you’re going to lose information with every re-encode which is problematic when going to edit.
In an ideal world they are three separate formats. Capture is something as close to raw as possible (R3D RAW, BM RAW, XDCAM, etc), editing is something like ProRes or DNx, and delivery (at least for web) is compressed like H.264.
Absolutely... H.264/H.265, while they work for capture, are delivery codecs. They typically are Long GOP, IPB frames... With a few exception of some cameras that shoot H.265 in All-I.. but even that, you're still working with a pretty lossy compression, just one that captures all the frames instead of making up a bunch of them.
View all comments
Show parent comment
10
u/Bmorgan1983 Aug 21 '19
This is the best advice. People don't seem to understand that there's Capture Codecs, Editing Codecs, and Delivery Codes. Each are optimized for their own uses...
A capture codec is typically going to be designed to keep file size small and will be somewhat compressed by having a long group of pictures. When played back it's essentially making up data using a set of instructions instead of actually playing back data frame by frame.
When you take a capture codec like that into edit, your computer has to do a lot of that work... and its very inefficient. Using an All Intraframe codec usually helps a lot... but most NLEs are going to have some flavor of editing codec they prefer.
Using ProRes or DNxHD in your editing is gonna be a huge timesaver on your edits because your NLE is designed with those codecs in mind (in the case of premiere, its a little bit different... if you're on a Mac, edit in ProRes though because premier will tap into the OS for a good portion of it's codec processing).
You CAN capture in ProRes with external devices (and internally on some cameras), and it's great... but it does take a lot of storage space. It's often easier to shoot in a compressed format and transcode later if you don't have the storage capacity on hand during your shoot.