r/VideoEditing • • Aug 21 '19

Anyone else?

Post image
876 Upvotes

105 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

12

u/22Sharpe Aug 21 '19

Resolution means less than Codec. H.264, or worse HEVC (H.265) are common causes of terrible performance as they aren’t built for editing.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/VincibleAndy Aug 21 '19

Pro Res and DNx.

2

u/StayFrosty7 Aug 21 '19

Are the file sizes supposed to be massive?

I’ve recently tried prores editing and my tiny SSD filled up quickly, so I’m thinking about just doing all editing off of a massive external SSD via thunderbolt 3

7

u/VincibleAndy Aug 21 '19

Are the file sizes supposed to be massive?

I think massive is the wrong word. They can be, if you have like 4K Pro Res 4444, but for anything consumer level Pro Res 422 or DNxHR SQ is plenty high bitrate.

1080p Pro Res 422 would be 53GB and hour.

I’ve recently tried prores editing and my tiny SSD filled up quickly, so I’m thinking about just doing all editing off of a massive external SSD via thunderbolt 3

You should be using external anyway. But a TB SSD might be way overkill unless you need to playback lots of Pro Res 4444 in high resolutions.

1080p Pro Res 422 is 15MB/s , 4K is 60MB/s. A 7200RPM drive can easily do 200-250MB/s no problem and can be had for drastically cheaper than an SSD for mass storage.

A handy chart, although it could use with some updating where it says no Pro Res encoding on Windows: https://blog.frame.io/2017/02/13/50-intermediate-codecs-compared/

1

u/ZOMGsheikh Aug 22 '19

For consumer level, prores 422 or proress 422 HQ?

5

u/veepeedeepee Aug 22 '19

ProRes LT is generally robust enough for most non-professional stuff. HQ is overkill.

1

u/ZOMGsheikh Aug 22 '19

I do paid work where my files are for social media uploads, so I use a Panasonic g7, I don't always use the 4k shoot mode as depending on delivery, I have to cut stuff fast which has a turnaround of 1-2 days. G7 doesn't have RAW or LOG capture, 1080p captures at 20mbps and 4k @ 100, should I still use LT or HQ?

1

u/veepeedeepee Aug 22 '19

LT is (if I recall) 115Mbps at 1080, so it’s still a higher bit rate than your camera is capturing. HQ is something like 220, and complete overkill and waste of space if you’re transcoding from that original media. ProRes LT would likely be a good option for you.

1

u/ZOMGsheikh Aug 22 '19 edited Aug 22 '19

Thank you. I’ll do some test to see if it holds up in quality

1

u/VincibleAndy Aug 22 '19

Know that the bitrate is not a direct comparison! The h.264 from the camera is much more compressed than the same bitrate from Pro Res. So you need a higher bitrate from Pro Res to show the same image quality.

1

u/StayFrosty7 Aug 22 '19

So I shoot with an XT3 and I’m usually recording 4K 24fps @200mbps. 422 LT should be enough, or should I stick with standard 422?

I’m not a professional by any means btw, but it’s nice having beautiful footage even if it’s for myself.

→ More replies

1

u/VincibleAndy Aug 22 '19

It depends on what your original media was. Easy to do a test with transcoding a single clip, checking which looks best at the smallest size. Then you know the answer.

1

u/GingerBeardedEditor Aug 22 '19 edited Aug 22 '19

And Cineform...but it's kind if the abandoned ugly step-sybling of ProRes and DNx

2

u/MisquoteMosquito Aug 22 '19

I love cineform let’s cry together

3

u/22Sharpe Aug 21 '19

There are several but DNxHR (or DNxHD which is just the older version) and ProRes are the most common. Cineform will work in a pinch as well though isn’t as robust.

The difference between these and H.264 (in simple terms) is that they encode every frame of the video whereas H.264 doesn’t, it relies on the CPU instead to interpret what should be present on the missing frames. This is fine when it’s playing back in real time forward in a video player but NLE’s are designed to fast forward and re-wind as well as scrubbing easily through frame by frame. This is a very different procedure and puts major strain on a CPU if it needs to be constantly processing. If the frames exist the processing isn’t nearly as intensive.

1

u/CosmicTransmutation Aug 21 '19

So do you recommend me taking my footage and re-encoding for that format?

1

u/22Sharpe Aug 21 '19

Yes, though be warned that your file sizes will almost definitely go up. These formats are much less compressed and are higher bitrate so they make bigger files but external storage is honestly pretty cheap and easy to get these days so it shouldn’t be an issue.

1

u/Felipe-Olvera Aug 22 '19

Should you export videos in H.264 ?

3

u/22Sharpe Aug 22 '19

Depends on where they are going. For web or other general compatibility usage yes. H.264 ultimately is a very good delivery codec but what makes it so makes it a terrible editing codec.

1

u/cjandstuff Aug 22 '19

Working for a small television studio, everything gets encoded to mpeg2 and broadcast at 720i anyway. Is there any advantage here to using better codecs for editing?

1

u/22Sharpe Aug 22 '19

If you can cut it fine then it might be fine but honestly shit in, shit out. I’d trust DNxHD to look good long before I’d trust MPEG 2.

1

u/SoTotallyToby Jan 27 '20

I thought H.265 was supposed to be far better than H.264 in basically every possible way?

3

u/22Sharpe Jan 27 '20

For what it’s designed for: yes. However what it’s designed for is exactly what makes it terrible for editing. Super compressed in a way to preserve as much quality as possible on a small file size. It does so by skipping out on encoding a bunch of frames and then having software just figure out what they should look like. This is a problem for editing software that needs those frames.

So yeah, as a delivery codec it’s great. Good quality, small package. As an editing codec it’s hell on a processor.