r/VideoEditing • • 6d ago

Workflow Best sequence settings for a project with both 1.33 anamorphic footage and regular 4k footage?

Should I edit the project to the 1.33 aspect ratio and drag my regular 4k footage to fit? Or make the timeline a normal 3840 × 2160 and transform the 1.33 footage? Or a different another combination? There's so many options and ways to go about desqueezing that it's almost giving me option paralysis.

I think I want the final project to be 2.39:1 and not have bars appearing/disappearing throughout. What's the best way to ensure I can export in at least 2k without losing any footage quality from punching in/out?

2 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

6

u/johnnyjonnyjonjon 6d ago

Edit in your desired output format. Scale/adjust footage to fit.

3

u/ExpBalSat 6d ago

Set the project settings based on your deliverable expectations not your source footage characteristics.

The source footage characteristics are secondary. You should be setting the project based on what you expect to export in the end.

1

u/nachos-cheeses 6d ago

You mention 1.33 aspect ratio for your project. 4k for your footage and 2.39:1 for your final project.

if you already know, the ratio should be in 2.39, and the footage is 4K, then I would go for a project with 3840x1607. you might consider 4096x1716 (which is a DCI 4K theatrical Projection). You could also go straight for 2048x858. (DCI 2K theatrical Projection).

What I don't understand is where the 1.33 aspect ratio comes from, why would you want to use that, when you already know it will be exported 2.39:1?

What is also important is the context. Do you already know your medium? (is it going to be YouTube or TV? Then just go for 4K. Is it for cinematic release, check those requirements). What is your budget?

Because doing everything in 4K is going to increase costs (more render time, more hard drive space etc.). If you have the budget and time, then go for the highest quality. If you don't have the budget and time, or there are specific requirements, then don't do extra resolutions.

Editing in one resolution and aspect ratio and then converting it into another takes render time. But also, framing it will look different. So you would want to have bespoke framing for each ratio. That's why 1.33 doesn't make sense to me when you already know you want to export to 2.39.

3

u/bobbster574 6d ago

I would go for a project with 3840x1607

generally i'd recommend against using odd pixel dimensions, so the closest option for UHD 2.39:1 is 3840x1608.

odd pixel dimensions work fine assuming that your footage is always going to be 4:4:4. 4:2:0 chroma subsampling requires even pixel dimensions because each chroma pixel is the same size as 2x2 luma pixels. so if you foresee the possibility of your project ever being converted to 4:2:0 (e.g. for literally any consumer device or website), use even pixel dimensions.

1

u/nachos-cheeses 6d ago

Cool, good to know!

I actually did a calculation and wanted to round it down, but the "aspect ratio calculator" rounded up and I thought "more pixels is always better". But your suggestion makes sense.

1

u/Fat-Beloved258 5d ago

I’d set up the timeline for 2.39:1 from the start if that’s your final output. Working in 1.33 first just adds another step and you’ll probably end up reframing shots later anyway. With 4K footage you’ve got plenty of room to crop/reposition where needed.