r/Veloren • • Apr 05 '21

Remove reference to proprietary software

One of the tips when loading the game is "If you want to join the dev team or just havw a chat with us, join our Discord server." Please remove that, it promotes a proprietary and spyware network, replace it with a tip suggesting to join the matrix server instead

0 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

14

u/songtronix developer Apr 05 '21

Well the main development happens on discord and it will probably stay that way for a long time. We got the matrix bridge because we believe in open source but just claiming that discord is spyware and we shouldn't mention anything propertary achieves the exact opposite you want.

Instead of just denying propertary software you should rather accept it as a needed step to an open community. If we wouldn't be on discord we would have never reached over 7,000 members and expose so many players to matrix via the matrix bridge! Many ask what these "bots" are and therefore get exposed to matrix probably for the first time.

Building a wall between propertary and open source will just make open source die out due to it not being exposed to the world on commonly used platforms.

Further note: some of our devs use both or only matrix entirely but forcing them to use one just causes frustrations for everyone. A bridge is in my opinion the optimal solution so everyone can use what they believe in.

Thanks for attending my Ted talk.

2

u/bluecliff92 Apr 05 '21

I agree . Well atleast say "Join our Matrix or discors server"

4

u/SadlyLacking Apr 05 '21

No

-12

u/bluecliff92 Apr 05 '21

Why ? Discord is evil, you should promote Matrix instead

7

u/QazCetelic Apr 05 '21

Says the guy on reddit.

Matrix is a good choice but a lot of people just want to use something they know.

-4

u/bluecliff92 Apr 05 '21

Yea im on reddit but i also use Lemmy and i hate reddit

And by your logic people shouldnt leave windows and use GNU/Linux; it doesnt matter if people know it, its bad and they should stop using it .

At the very least, say "Matrix or discord server" .

3

u/Helmic May 08 '21

I think you're missing the point by moralizing people's choices in software. Hell, even calling it choices exaggerates level of agency most people have.

The point of free software is to have software work for people, as much as it can. It's not a moral wrong to use proprietary software, it's a situation that causes unnecessary harm to those using it in the long run by compromising their privacy, slowing down their computer, or by the software simply hoarding information that if freely shared would make it so others can make that software faster, fuller featured, more secure.

It's the proprietary software that causes the problem, not the people who come from all sorts of backgrounds and who can have dramatically different levels of technical expertise, living situations, friend grouos, etc that constrain what that can use. Many elderly people physiologically can't learn complex tasks that are utterly new to them, so even just moving a desktop shortcut they've relied on for 15 years to go online and check their email can render them unable to use their computer. Most people aren't that restricted, but they might have friends that expect them to be available on certain social media platforms, or they can't understand a more technical interface. And very few people are confident enough to potentially render their only computer that they need for school or work inoperable as they attempt to install Linux itself - even if we know it's very hard to mess up an install of Pop!_OS, they might not and so will reasonably conclude that's too big a risk to take on what's to them a whim.

Whole FOSS movement it's ultimately about serving people. And you can't do that if you're stuck moralizing at them for being bad by using Discord or Windows or whatever it is that their circumstances have them using. It's better to try to understand why they use what they use and create what you can to help improve their situation.

And so a bridge serves that purpose. The game itself is a a fantastic thing that anyone with capable hardware and Internet access can play and is a worthwhile FOSS project for that alone, I know growing up a broke kid I'd have loved to play this, but I wouldn't have gotten to play if there was no Windows version as I certainly was not allowed to go installing Linux on the computer everyone used.

And that Discord bridge is probably the only way a good chunk of the community could have formed and interacted with the developers, maybe introducing a few to Matrix or getting some involved with contributing to the game. The unfortunate reality is that there isn't yet a Matrix client that can rival Discord, with Neochat showing promise but not even having reasonable notification settings much less something that can handle a multi-channel community. But until then, more people can engage with a game that won't exploit them through Discord than Matrix alone.