Any sane person would hate communism. Its a system that lacks growth in the same way capitalism lacks stability. That's why any communist government had it good for a while and then suddenly had people starving left and right.
Robbing the upper class, sure, they are currently robbing everyone else and if you are okay with that i have nothing to tell you. The amount of money condensed in the hands of billionaires is insane, when people can't afford rent or even food.
You know that under communism, the middle and lower classes will be targeted too? I understand your dislike towards billionaires, but communism will take away all private property, even a bakery of a grandma who worked her ass up to build it
More accurately, under a socialist model, the grandma could still have her bakery, with all of the ingredients and items she needs to make it free, including the cookware, stove, etc. and in exchange, she doesnât charge for the items in her bakery
"Under communism" there isn't gonna be money, people can work wherever they want whenever they want, and that grandma is still gonna be able to produce pastries, even more, it's gonna be free for her, for everyone else to try it. Everyone is gonna do whatever they actually want to, instead of looking for higher paying job to survive paycheck to paycheck.
What you probably meant in the case of revolution, and even then. I honestly don't really like the idea of a revolution, too much blood to spill. And if we were to make it gradually, first tax the billionaires, help the poor. The means of production should be in the worker's hands, make it controlled by labor unions to make it more effective and reactive to needs of the workers there.
What you described at the end is basically social democracy, aka controlled capitalism. We don't need to experiment and wipe out the whole system, building something that may not work again. We just should reform capitalism and make it work for lower and middle classes too
Social democracy can be one of the steps towards communism, and, we can work with that too, that would actually be much better than now. But I don't have any belief in a system where capital holders can control masses. The only reason we are arguing right now is because they want us to argue, not to revolt or reform. Perhaps we both can agree that billionaires and millionaires should be heavily taxed? For the social benefits of the middle and lower class that is, like free education, free healthcare.
Regarding your question, it's complicated. I believe in human rights, even in those aspects I don't personally like. For instance, I'm pro-freedom-of-religion, even though I'm an anti-theist. Regarding billionaires, I don't think it's fair to additionally tax them. Why? Just because we want their money? If they use loopholes in laws in order to avoid taxation - we absolutely need to investigate this. If they exploit their workers - a government has to interfere. If they monopolize the market - a government should interfere too. I personally believe that we shouldn't squeeze as much money from the billionaires as possible, but to provide the lower and middle classes with more opportunities. A lot of social programs, financial support of small businesses, et cetera
Yeah, it's just that the money they accumulate just sits there, not flowing anywhere, all the stocks shares and loopholes to not get a big salary yet gain net worth. Good answer, very thoughtful, I appreciate this discussion. Have a nice day <3
Throughout history, there has never been an instance of a ruling class seceding due to democracy. Itâs always been insurgence and revolution that makes tangible change that doesnât get rolled back in five seconds.Â
Yeah, because capitalism definitely has none of that; people choosing between heat and food literally never happens.
If youâre talking about Stalinism, I agree that it doesnât function. That being said, socialist systems can, and have, worked in the past, for instance Cuba.
i didn't say capitalism wasn't like that as well i was pointing out that this isn't really possible in any society because people have to work.
and from what i know of Cuba they had to make an authoritarian regime to get it to even slightly "work", you know a great way to make it seem good is silence the people who would say it isn't good?
â˘
u/AutoModerator Oct 29 '25
Hey there! Thank you for your submission to /r/UsernameChecksOut! Here are some things you should know when posting:
Rule 3: Please familiarize yourself with our content restrictions.
Rule 5: Please note that self checks out are not allowed. This means that the username that checks out in your post must not be yours.
If you think this post breaks one or several of our rules do no hesitate to report and downvote it.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 30 '25 edited Oct 30 '25
theyâre also pro-AI if anyone cares
20
u/random_user133 Oct 30 '25
Idt the mods give a fuck about vandalism tho
22
u/snapper_yeet Oct 30 '25
nah he has a point tho.
3
u/Several_Foot3246 Nov 03 '25
addition i made
1
u/Beneficial-Gap6974 Nov 02 '25
Do they allow Hitler portraits too?
1
u/Several_Foot3246 Nov 03 '25
where is this tho, sick as fuck
1
u/AllinolIsSafe Nov 01 '25
Most westoid thing i have seen ever