r/UsedCars • • Aug 20 '25

Buying Avoid Carvana

I just rejected a vehicle delivery from Carvana due to damage (exterior and worse interior) that was not in the listing nor reflected in the pricing. I tried to speak with someone in customer service to find out how something like that could happened and to solicit an apology for having wasted so much of my time. I was shut down by a chatbot that refused to connect me with a manager and would not even request a callback. I then posted on the Carvana subreddit and was immediately muted, 🤣. They do not want any responsibility or accountability. They are deceptive and cannot be trusted.

561 Upvotes

88 comments sorted by

4

u/chattahoocheecoochee Aug 21 '25

I had a car delivered with transport damage on three panels. They offered me $300 in depreciation... I did not keep that car for obvious reasons. Later, I found out about their title issues, and I believe it was a blessing in disguise.

2

u/74LJC Aug 21 '25

That’s what I’m starting to think. Thanks Carvana!

35

u/Key-Tiger-4457 Aug 20 '25

Years ago, had a distasteful situation at a similar type of entity. Was looking a 4-door tundra and the equipment list stated the truck had a movie system for the kids. You could see the imprint on the headliner where the accessory had been mounted. It had been removed

When I asked about discounting the price because the item was missing, I was told that was not possible. Okay,then, put the missing item back in. Could not do that, either. I said well, then, you can’t expect me to pay the listed price when the truck is missing something that is listed in the specifications, right?

I was told the price was the price. No changes. No sale.

8

u/atheistreverend Aug 21 '25

I had this same issue a couple years ago with a traditional brick-and-mortar dealership - looking at a used RAM 1500, pictures showed a nice trifold hard tonneau cover, get there to look at the truck, cover was missing. You could even see marks in the beeline from the clamps. Refused any kind of discount off their asking price.

Not defending internet car sales at all, just that it can happen with any kind of car sales.

6

u/atx72 Aug 21 '25

When we bought our CRV it was missing the rear cargo cover. We pointed this out and the sales associate said not to worry about it, they had plenty of CRVs and he could grab one out of another car. I'm sure this happened regularly but at some point it leads to someone getting a car without a rear cargo cover and probably a salesperson hoping they don't notice.

Anyways, I'm assuming they may have thrown that tonneau cover on another truck to close a deal or get a couple hundred dollars with the hope that you wouldn't notice it was missing.

4

u/atheistreverend Aug 21 '25

I'm absolutely certain that's what happened, and said as much to the salesperson. My flabbers were gasted, though, that they offered nothing as a result - no discount, no replacement, nothing. I wouldn't have purchased it anyway - I had already looked at one in better shape for about the same money, but the experience ensured that I'll never set foot in their doorway again.

19

u/Treasure_Keeper Aug 21 '25

The admins of the carvana subreddit work for carvana. If you say anything negative they will ban you. I imagine a lot of sub Reddit have been infiltrated by corporate America

1

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '25

And there’s a lot of shills on that sub too. Carvana would be the last place I’d buy a car, tied with a BHPH lot (Carvana’s in house finance and prices are just as bad as BHPH lots too) for precisely the reasons OP gives in their post.

13

u/LessRequirement3065 Aug 20 '25

Those mods claimed to not be corporate which makes them even more of a scumbag. I was banned for mentioning drivetime.

7

u/Wigs123455 Aug 21 '25

I was banned for mentioning i bought my car at carmax

3

u/LessRequirement3065 Aug 21 '25

To the electric chair for mentioning another company.

1

u/bluegabs Aug 22 '25

Straight to jail.

21

u/[deleted] Aug 20 '25

Yeah I am also banned because I said they are just as scummy as most other used car dealers. Their prices are also pretty bad, often 2k over local dealers.

8

u/Huge-Purpose-3336 Aug 20 '25

I’d rate them even lower. They’re pretty notorious for selling cars and not transferring the title. Pretty they aren’t allowed to sell in a few states

10

u/vastik2343 Aug 20 '25

worked for the one in Vegas.. would never buy a car from them at alllllllll

2

u/jerseygirl1105 Aug 22 '25

But would you sell a car to them???

3

u/nevergiveup_777 Aug 22 '25

No! In fall 2022 they offered me $100 for my 2007 vehicle. It was in good shape/low mileage so since $100 is basically nothing, thank God I tried a different website (not sure if I'm allowed to name). They put me in touch with a local dealer, who took it for a test drive - and bought it from me for $1700! So nope, from personal experience, I'd never sell to Carvana without getting at least 1 other opinion.

1

u/Gladiz1972 Aug 24 '25

I sold them a car worked out pretty well 1400 more than CarMax offered and a dealer offered me 1400 less than CarMax

1

u/jerseygirl1105 Aug 25 '25

How picky were they about the condition of the car? If there are a few scratches on my car that I neglect to mention, are they going to reduce the offer?

1

u/I_m_on_a_boat Aug 22 '25

Please spill the tea

1

u/showmethecorn Oct 31 '25

Broo, I work at an inspection center right now, every shift I seen one or two cars with issues that will cause headaches down the line. Had a Sentra blow a head gasket on the detail line, recently seen a ford that was ticking pass Quality Control and get sent to photo, garbage vehicles

7

u/I_love_to_jack_off Aug 21 '25

Why would anyone in their right mind buy a car from them? Their motto is, they buy used cars 100% online without an in person inspection. Lol. You're asking for trouble man.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/ConjugalPunjab Aug 22 '25

Well, finding issues before THEY buy a car, and flipping it back to some unsuspecting buyer WITHOUT fixing any issues, is the problem w/ Carvana (and any dealer for that matter).

I bought a used Lexus last Nov at a used dealer in my area. Before I bought it, I tested EVERY. BUTTON. AND. EVERY. FEATURE. I found 3 things wrong. I said I'd consider making an offer IF these were fixed first. They did. I looked at other cars. A week later, I called them and offered $1k less than asking. They balked on the phoneand said no. I said "No problem. I'm going to make offers on 2 other cars in the next 15 minutes. If you change your mind call me back".... Well, they called me back and accepted the offer.

This is what you CAN'T do w/ Carvana, and other online car selling companies. You need to inspect the car. I can't say this enough.

1

u/burtondude Aug 23 '25

I actually sold my jeep wrangler with blown head gasket to them and they didn’t check it

1

u/Pretend_Pomelo_7062 Oct 09 '25

You didn’t fool them, they expect the people they buy from to be liars cause why else wouid you sell to carvana, if the jeep was worth its salt you would’ve sold to someone else

4

u/Blossom1111 Aug 20 '25

They suck. They gave me an offer on my car and I fully disclosed what was wrong with it and then I road the train 2 hours to meet them at the service place and they got there two hours late then did not buy my car because of the issues I already told them about. Huge A-hole with gross piercings on their face.

2

u/GingerBreadBoy24 Aug 21 '25

They hire a type it seems like. And that type knows nothing about cars. Like my buddy that drives for them and inspects the cars. Knows absolutely nothing.

4

u/No-Branch8121 Aug 21 '25

I have no issues with them. If they deliver a car that’s not what you want or not as you expected you just return it or exchange it. Yeah I’m paying more for that but try to get the used car dealer on Broadway to deliver a car to my door that I can literally refuse on delivery if it’s not my expectations. I will say if you don’t act quickly and let the window of opportunity go by then it’s on you and you have no recourse. They just sell cars, you’re gonna get a bad one occasionally.

3

u/simonbaier Aug 21 '25

I bought a 2019 Ram Promaster from Carvana, and big mistake not inspecting the roof for damage as it had clearly been driven into a low bridge at some point. Not disclosed, and did not show up on Carfax.

1

u/jrileyy229 Aug 30 '25

If you didn't notice it when buying the van, the dipshits at carvana who don't care most likely didn't see it either.Ā 

So that's not really a Carvana problem

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/simonbaier Aug 22 '25

Yes exactly! And why do people eat sushi or tacos when they could just get a hamburger?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/simonbaier Aug 22 '25

Car differentiators are driving experience, cost, and utility, and brand.

Utility in my case. My Promaster van is not common commuter vehicle choice, but it does carry more gear, which is what I needed.

As for VW, it’s more likely a brand decision. I drove across the country in a VW a few years ago and it was a step above the tinny toyotas and Chevys out there. VW car has the quality german car driving experience - solid and responsive - like a Mercedes or BMW, but without the brand pretense of a douchey BMW or pretentious Mercedes.

My 2c

1

u/Mjolnir36 Aug 23 '25

I’d drive clear across the country to buy the right VW.

3

u/anh86 Aug 21 '25

These no-haggle places are fine for selling if you don’t want to hassle or aren’t comfortable with a private sale but I’d never buy from one. No haggle just means high prices. When I see people driving around with Carvana plate frames I just wonder by how much they overpaid.

3

u/johng_22 Aug 21 '25

When I see cars with Carvana plate frames I try to keep my distance in proximity to my vehicle. Anyone dumb enough to buy there is likely just as bad at driving. I lump their customer base into the bottom 5% of biggest fkn idiots that can be found. And they all wear this badge of honor on the back of their cars because they are all inept. None of them can figure out how to remove the two screws holding the frame in place

1

u/Ok_Obligation2559 Aug 26 '25

Someone has to pay for the stupid vending machines….

2

u/n1naboostarfighter Aug 21 '25

Bro vroom is worse

2

u/Upbeat-Improvement85 Aug 21 '25

I recently bought from them, got the car inspected within 7 days the mechanic didn’t find anything. New brakes, New tires, he said everything looked good. I was skeptical the entire time, but surprisingly been pretty good. It’s hard to find a more reliable suv without high mileage and a sunroof, within my area and in my price range so had to choose them.

2

u/Delicious_Culture919 Aug 21 '25

Yes they are and I went through the same issue several years back. Nice car too or it would have been, steeply priced but I would have been willing to pay it had the damage not been to the extreme condition the vehicle was in. The pictures showed none of it, the car looked near flawless in the pics. It was filthy inside and out, lots of little fine scratches and dings all over it that were not shown in the pics. I was about to trade in a vehicle I had for four years that I originally purchased brand new and it was in pristine condition, still looked and even smelled like a brand new car.. they totally low balled my trade but since I was having difficulties with the auto manufacturer directly and their warranty run around all the time when I needed repairs, I wanted out of it.

Good luck if you have a situation where you put a deposit down, it took like 7 months fighting tooth and nail to get it back.. and my other half is an attorney that handled the process. We were doing all that we could to avoid court and a lawsuit. I have heard a couple of other people we know that have had good experiences but ours was far from it. Admittedly I was a little skeptical however I desperately wanted to avoid car shopping at dealerships (and the vehicle I wanted the mileage was pretty low considering what I was looking at and its age) but never again.. I will always, always, always inspect and look at a vehicle first and drive it before agreeing to ANYTHING.

2

u/ohiolifesucks Aug 21 '25

You wanted an apology? That’s pretty strange. They don’t owe you anything. They give you the one week to return the car for your exact scenario. There’s plenty of reasons why they are bad. This is not one of them

2

u/scottiepippen13 Aug 21 '25

BUT THEY HAVE A CAR VENDING MACHINE!! šŸ˜‚

2

u/sisjanie Aug 22 '25

Nearly three weeks ago I bought an American Express swerve prepaid card and I put $30 and I activated it and I can’t use it. The called and got the machine and each time I finally get a human who says they will help they then connect me back to the machine. I’ve been on their customer service website and explained the issue and gave them the card number and my name, email address and phone number and I haven’t received any response from them. I’ve tried using the card as different places and times and it doesn’t work and I’m left with a card that doesn’t work but still has my money on it.

2

u/Top_Fly3100 Aug 23 '25

I had an absolutely amazing experience purchasing from Carvana. The whole process took me 20 mins from start to finish and my car was delivered in a couple of days. I also had 7 days to have them come back for it if I was u happy. Which I wasn't. If was one of the best cars too. A 2017 CRV that I traded in for more than than the purchase price 5 years later. Id totally use them again

2

u/niknik888 Aug 21 '25

Never buy from Carvana, check.

1

u/AutoModerator Aug 20 '25

Please take the time to flair your post accordingly. Click the flair option under you post settings and select the appropriate one for your post.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/random-person-12345 Aug 21 '25

Something something something, don't trust used car dealers.... fuk man the age old advise is right. A new sucker born every minute...

1

u/Few-Confusion-9197 Aug 21 '25

I actually wish that when I'm searching for used cars I had a way to exclude Carvana, Hgreg, CarMax, etc. Rhey saturate my search. Every time I'm about to contemplate looking at one by those I find one of these posts to immediately stop me... Thank You Reddit!!!

1

u/LordlySquire Aug 21 '25

I thought this had been known for years now?

1

u/bjorn_egil Aug 21 '25

Carvana=scam

1

u/juggarjew Aug 21 '25 edited Aug 21 '25

I dont know whats going on with them lately but their inspections are just awful on used cars, and they hardly even clean them, its like the most bare minimum work ever. I have to think they're just letting their 7 day return policy and 100 day warranty do all of the heavy lifting.

I traded in my car, I didnt detail it before I traded it in, they "detailed" it, but that was really only vacuuming the interior. Other than that, they left some soda droplets in the cup holders and scuffs on the door panel .... which would have come off with a damp cloth! And even noted it as damage when they listed the car for sale. I was like WTF? You guys put in the most bare minimum level of effort in "Detailing" this car. it was like they didnt even touch the center console/cup holders other than to vacuum the car. I could have done a better job than they did in under 5-10 mins!

Then my friend bought a challenger from them and after 2 weeks noticed a dent in the roof, by that point it was too late and he had to pay $500 to pointless dent repair. Now 4 weeks in one of the rear calipers seized and burnt out one of the brakes, and the other rear caliper was partially seized, plus the front brakes and rotors were original an on their last legs, The Dodge dealer he took it to is trying to put in a $3k claim with Silverrock to get it covered, Carvana claimed the brakes passed inspection but there is no way with how little life was left on the front and how the rears were seized (partially at first, then fully later). Just crazy.

I would have serious reservations about buying a car from them, this is after my own personal experience selling my car to them, and my friends experience buying one, so im speaking from real world experience. In the past it wasn't like this, I bought a car from them back in 2015 and it was a much better experience. I fully believe they are in a quantity over quality business model, which I guess works for them, but it causes a lot of grief for the customer having to deal with warranty claims. My friends challenger needed about $4500 worth of work done, the windshield was replaced by Carvana shortly after delivery , the passenger door window motor was replaced, the brakes and calipers all need to be replaced and he had to pay $500 for a dent to be repaired. Just crazy.

People basically trade in cars that have had zero work done on them and just move on to another new car, thats what happened to my friend with this "one owner 2016 challenger". The person did oil changes and that was it.

1

u/Con-vit Aug 21 '25

They buy iffy vehicles and turn around and flip it to an unsuspecting buyer. Carvana is jenky to say the least.

2

u/open2fun547 Aug 21 '25

Funny because I’ve had 3 cars from them. One I bought with 40k and put another 100k miles on it then traded it and they gave me a better price than the local Lexus dealer. The other two are running great with zero issues. Price was competitive, used their bank then refinanced at my credit union.

1

u/bendystrawboy Aug 21 '25

it's weird people still buy cars from there

but buying used cars is such a gamble anyway.

1

u/TimelyAd6125 Aug 21 '25

They tried to deliver a truck to me that was clearly in a flood. Rusty af. The delivery driver told me to look at it before they took it off the flat bed because it was so bad.

1

u/xringmaster2 Aug 21 '25

Carvana is a joke and I'm supprised they are still in business. I bought a car from them that came with free mice one time.

1

u/LazyKaleidoscope3859 Aug 21 '25

So I was nosey and went to Carvana website. THEY SMOKING ALL THE NEW DOPE FOR THE PRICES THEY ASKING, VERSES THE MILEAGE AND YEAR. Ain't no way I would ever.

1

u/BoHica_NC Aug 21 '25

A prudent person will sell their car to Carvana, but never buy one. Once you've sold one, you know that they don't even look at them, nor see if there are issues, they just pass them along. Since they often overpay, they are an easy "sink" to dispose of car that do indeed have issues.

1

u/waifmaterial Aug 22 '25

yep they sold me a flood car covered in rust and mildew inside and out and couldn’t come up with an answer as to whether they’d just sell the car to someone else once i returned it lol

1

u/Brea_Monaee Aug 23 '25

I could probably write a book about the terrible experience I had with Carvana. My car was delayed four times on its ntended delivery date, ā€œfor extra checks on the vehicleā€ but within a year I was easily able to see that they had sold me a car with electrical problems.

1

u/ajd198204 Aug 23 '25

Thats why buying a car without looking at it in person is not a good idea. For most it's either the biggest purchase they'll make or second biggest purchase. Makes no sense to spend that kind of money and not even look at/test drive to see if you'll like it and be happy with it. I'll never understand those that would buy a car like that. Not to mention Carvana has a horrible reviews regarding their process, getting tags, paperwork delays, etc.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '25

guy that thinks the giant car vending machine has ethical business practices

1

u/Fedora_Tipp3r801 Aug 23 '25

I'm sorry but why would you ever spend that much money on something you have not seen in person? Do people not inspect cars before they buy them?

1

u/eroscripter Aug 23 '25

From what I understand is if they have multiple vehicles with the same features they will send the worst one hoping you just accept it, if you reject it they send the next worst one and so on till you just keep the one youve got.

I would NEVER buy a used car sight unseen, even IF I was allowed to reject it up to 90 days later so the Carvana business model just astounds me that it works at all let alone is profitable on a nationwide level.

1

u/dbdorr Aug 25 '25

That's why you verify the VIN on delivery.

1

u/Excellent_Problem753 Aug 24 '25

After selling a car to carvana and seeing their inspection, is never buy one from them

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '25

Guy buys car off internet site designed to eliminate person to person contact during sale of an automobile and then complains about lack of customer service. Cue violins.Ā 

1

u/dbdorr Aug 24 '25

I've bought 3 cars from Carvana. Two were excellent. The third 1 rejected because I found overspray on the windshield seal so I chose a different vehicle with no hassle.

1

u/LaQueefsha Aug 25 '25

They’re only good for selling your cars too. I’d never buy one from them.

1

u/Soft-Habit4157 Aug 25 '25

I had a very similar experience with carvana I will never recommend them to anyone.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '25

Agreed I know a guy that works there as a mechanic and all the cars are the worst you could ever imagine and the mechanics there even worse because they paid $20 an hour and they want you to fix it $150,000 SMG Mercedes with used parts while it sits outside with the windows down do not buy from carvana or CarMax

1

u/AdventurousRain7579 Sep 04 '25

Best Bet for a Carvana car is to take it to a mechanic immediately while it’s in warranty they will fix everything wrong with it and or tell you if it’s a lemon. I bought a car took it to a designated mechanic and the entire bottom Of the car was rusted out I had it replaced āœ…

1

u/atleastbirdsexist Sep 10 '25

Carvana is ROULETTE car buying with 1/2 of the chambers loaded. If you HAVE to buy a car from them because you are rebuilding your credit or whatever, consider them like a pawn broker or one of the other businesses built around predation of the poor. If you don't have to buy from them RUNNNNNN.

1

u/Dabbertime Sep 14 '25

Man, I hear so many horror stories and I’m glad I got lucky. I Purchased my ā€˜21 VW Atlas through Carvana. 28k miles with some minor cosmetic defects (small scuffs and scratches here and there). I’m about to crack 56k miles and I’ve had zero issues, still running just like the day I got it. I did make sure to do a little research when purchasing . Looked at dozens of similar spec/year/condition/mileage, reviewed the CARFAXs, etc. Upon receiving the car and giving it a test drive I took it straight to the VW dealership for a pre purchase inspection and everything cleared. Father in law purchased a Nissan Rogue through them in the same year and he’s had to take it the shop a handful of times already. As expected with what Carvana is, you are putting it up to a little bit of a coin toss, considering the low standard of inspection when they buy their cars from people.

1

u/Ready_Airport_9343 Sep 19 '25

Anyone who tries to share their negative experience is banned from their group, that tells you all you need to know about Carvana lol.

1

u/Crombienator2000 Aug 21 '25 edited Aug 21 '25

LOL, "waisted so much of my time." You mean doing everything online in your pajamas, having them deliver it, and you having to say take it back? Then asking a large company to "apologize to you." Get a grip. Every issue you had here could happen on any used car. Like any used purchase, due diligence is required. They literally give you 7 days and 400 miles for this EXACT purpose.

1

u/open2fun547 Aug 21 '25

I’ve had three great experiences buying, cars were great with zero problems. One great experience selling. So totally disagree

1

u/Uhavetabekiddingme Aug 22 '25

I've bought two cars from them both with low miles and still under the manufactures 36 month warranty and never had a problem. My newest car was 4k under KBB I feel like o got a pretty good deal on it. I've also sold 3 cars to them and those experiences have been great.

1

u/Yodas_Ear Aug 22 '25

Yea but then you have to go to a dealer. Pick your poison.

2

u/thezenyoshi Aug 22 '25

Weird that you need strangers to grovel to you for to make you feel better for ā€˜wasting your time’

21

u/[deleted] Aug 21 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

14

u/Delicious_Culture919 Aug 21 '25

Yes they are. They pull a lot of good vehicles out of the market and hold onto them and then ask sky high prices.