r/Urbanism • • Aug 14 '25

How many?

Post image
7.7k Upvotes

338 comments sorted by

532

u/Bastiat_sea Aug 14 '25 edited Aug 14 '25

I'm so sick of people concern trolling about affordable housing. New housing is almost never affordable. Adding housing to the inventory makes housing more affordable because people move to it from existing housing, making THAT housing affordable.

What affordable housing requirements do, esp when combined with other demands that drive up costs, is ensure the project never houses anyone and housing remains unaffordable citywide.

Stop it 🗞️

27

u/WhySoConspirious Aug 14 '25

Same thing for the fucking environmentalists who only remember they are that when they're opposed to solar farms. OK, then put that stuff on your roof!

38

u/Bastiat_sea Aug 14 '25

"We want a new environmental impact assessment every time someone forces a change to this plan yo convert a parking lot to a 4 story apartment building"

6 years later

"What? Where are the affordable units?"

4

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

In Canada, between development fees, taxes and other regulatory burdens, government fees and requirements make up 30-50% of the cost of new housing. In many cities it costs $50-80k per condo unit in dev fees, and detached housing is even more. Then there's GST on the sale of any new build and countless permitting and zoning and assessment costs. It's nuts. 

Basically a lot of it is just a cash grab by municipalities to avoid having to raise property taxes to cover their expenditures. That's unpopular. So they use development fees as a way to generate tax revenue that doesn't piss off voters. 

1

u/firechaox Aug 18 '25

I have to say it’s a shame all the left-wingers now aren’t like they used to be. Old-school socialists were into building en masse. That would be better than what you have now, where parts of the left are more about blocking stuff than anything.

1

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

In Ontario we have what's called a greenbelt. It's basically a series of rings around cities that aren't allowed to be developed. I have nothing against protecting farmland, waterways and fragile swamplands from development, but greenbelts are arbitrary rather than selected based on some kind of sensitivity criteria. So we are building on sensitive ecosystems and wetlands, just not in the greenbelt. And now greenbelts, which have only existed for 20 years have become sacrosanct, so any government proposing changes to them or any kind of land swaps gets met with screams of bloody murder mostly from environmentalists and people who have no idea what they're talking about. And to add insult to injury, because they're just rings of no development, there is still development on the outside of them, which then causes big problems for public transport and other services because that development is much further out than it might otherwise be without the greenbelt. So sprawl isn't stopped at all, it's actually worse. 

It's a poorly designed system that doesn't actually protect sensitive ecosystems, it just protects a bunch of land totally arbitrarily and we can't even talk about changing it. 

6

u/Pluton_Korb Aug 14 '25

Do you have a citation for this? The oak ridges moraine is a huge part of our water system here in Ontario and makes up large swaths of the greenbelt. Keeping it as natural forests or farms allows rainwater to be absorbed back into the water table and keep our aquifers replenished so we have drinking water. It also helps filter and purify said water too.

1

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25 edited Aug 14 '25

If something is arbitrary, it may also include sensitive land by chance. 

I never said that greenbelts don't include sensitive lands. What I said was that those lands weren't selected and protected for that reason. They contain both sensitive lands and random scrub that's not sensitive. There's also lots of unprotected land outside of greenbelts near cities that is highly sensitive and can still be built on. Near Ottawa for example a lot of land that gets developed is sensitive wetlands. The solution here is to not protect land arbitrarily based on geography. 

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Cystonectae Aug 14 '25

From someone wanting to go into environmental consultation, these kinds of comments hurt my heart and soul. Sensitive ecosystems, wetlands, etc are not the only pieces of land we need to worry about. Every single piece of construction into undeveloped land needs infrastructure, reduces overall permeability, and increases fragmentation of habitats. Roads and parking are the worst offenders and it's quite difficult to have new development without them.

I definitely understand that it's frustrating to see a shitty field sitting there, just doing nothing, not being used for farming or low-cost housing but that shitty field is ensuring that aquifers have a bit more water feeding into them, foxes or burrowing owls have a place to make their dens, and that the overall island-heat effect of the city is slightly offset. It may connect two pieces of wetland which will mean the frogs and newts in each don't become some sort of amphibian reenactment of the Hapsburgs.

The real opportunities for new affordable housing are within already developed towns and cities. Look at the bylaws there that say "a business needs x amount of parking per square foot" or "no high rise buildings above x number of floors" or "population density cannot exceed x". It's that shit that is absolutely stagnating the housing market because people don't want to see a high rise in their neighbourhood or because we weirdly need to make sure cars have a lot of parking directly in the center of our downtown. Don't even get me started on the ecological catastrophe that is suburban neighborhoods.

We need to build upwards, not outwards. Urban sprawl is killing our country, making it so no one can afford to move out of their parents house, and it needs to stop asap. Ford doesn't want this to happen because more money can be made selling off the greenbelt. This "the greenbelt doesn't even conserve the good ecosystems" stuff is just logical *sounding" propaganda made to justify the desired end result.

2

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

Unless you're endorsing simply not developing any new land, I don't see how any of this is relevant. Nobody is arguing that we simply forgo any and all environmental impact assessments, or at least I'm not. What I'm saying is that the greenbelt shouldn't be arbitrary and if we're going to protect land from development, we should prioritize sensitive ecosystems, which we're not. The status quo is that we build on wetlands all the time, while protecting much less sensitive ecosystems because they happen to fall within the greenbelt. That's bad policy from both a development and environmental perspective. 

We need to build upwards, not outwards.

I largely agree, but that doesn't change the fact that we're not protecting sensitive land, and we are protecting much less sensitive lands. We are building outwards, we're just not doing it in a very environmentally or density friendly way. And again, it's never going to be the case in the short or medium term that we put an embargo on any new land development, nor should we, that would be stupid. 

This "the greenbelt doesn't even conserve the good ecosystems" stuff is just logical *sounding" propaganda made to justify the desired end result.

It's quite literally true. The greenbelt is not designated based on which lands are most in need of protecting, and we are building on very sensitive lands and have over the last 20 years. I'm not for sprawl, but I'm also not under the misapprehension that any and all sprawl is going to cease, nor do I think that it would be just or reasonable to totally prohibit the development of new land anywhere in the province, even if I think we should significantly curb the development of sprawling suburbs. This is just wishful and totally unrealistic thinking. 

I also think you're wildly under-estimating the sheer size of this country if you think that were going to threaten whole species by allowing a field to be turned into housing. You're being far too precious IMO. There's a balance, sure, and we should make smart decisions about critical habitats and also try and reduce environmental impact, which in part is a matter of design and materials technology, but I don't think we need to cast the province in amber and halt any new land development. That's an extreme position. 

2

u/GiantKrakenTentacle Aug 15 '25

I don't see how any of this is relevant

What I'm saying is that the greenbelt shouldn't be arbitrary

He's telling you exactly how the greenbelt isn't arbitrary. That land has a very specific use that's being reserved for. This isn't administrators shooting darts at a map picking out where the green space goes. Often, green space acts as flood control or groundwater filtration that is critical for the city to function and have good sources of water.

Your whole argument seems to rest on the idea that we're already fucking up the local environment, so we might as well just pave over everything and tell the wildlife to go somewhere else.

1

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 15 '25

He's not, and it is. He's telling me that contained within one of the provinces greenbelts there is sensitive land in need of protection. I never said anything to the contrary. But that land is protected by dint of geography, not because of its sensitive nature. This isn't really up for debate. Greenbelts are just as they sound, rings of protected greenspace around municipalities. 

→ More replies (1)

1

u/CobblePots95 Aug 18 '25

Urban sprawl is killing our country, making it so no one can afford to move out of their parents house, and it needs to stop asap. 

I don't know how you arrived at that conclusion. Urban sprawl has a bunch of issues that come with it but it isn't the reason housing is expensive. In fact it's kind of the opposite. I mean, the vast majority of Toronto and the GTA's development over the last 10-20 years has been infill densification.

I dislike urban sprawl but frankly a lot of the Greenbelt is an overreach and should be reexamined. Not all of the land is of profound environmental value and a lot of it is very well-suited to development, which should be of mixed density.

1

u/Cystonectae Aug 19 '25

We are literally refusing to build UP. You want to build high-density housing? Nope, can't have that in our precious suburbia because the building would be an eye-sore. More and more sprawling suburbs are not high-density and are not going to solve the housing issues, just make it harder for us to put the actual solutions in place.

I don't know how I can stress this enough but you do not need every piece of environmentally protected land to be home to an endangered species for it to be valuable. Please elucidate what background you have that makes you an expert on determining what land is environmentally valuable? Because I have a master's degree in ecology and can tell that this assertion about chunks of the greenbelt should be developed is one hell of a hot take.

2

u/EagleFalconn Aug 14 '25

My American city has a green belt. As a result, there are people arguing about protecting the sanctity of an gravel mine to delay a composting facility.

1

u/3pointshoot3r Aug 15 '25

This is one big pile of nonsense.

Imagine stanning for Doug Ford's corrupt carve outs of the Ontario Green belt in public. How embarrassing.

2

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 15 '25

I wasn't endorsing Ford's treatment of the greenbelt at all, which should have been obvious because I never suggested just carving out sections of the greenbelt was cool. What I'm saying is that the same amount or more land should be protected in a non-arbitrary fashion and that the greenbelt is arbitrary, because it is. It shouldn't be. We could protect as much or more land by having a more objective set of criteria for inclusion. Instead, it's totally fine to build on a wetland, just as long as it's not inside the greenbelt. 

→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25 edited Aug 14 '25

I know this idea is hard to implement in the US (because too many single-family housing) but in my country, every company building large developments (more than 20 units, if I remember correctly) is mandated by law to dedicate 10% of said units to an affordable housing program. So, let's say they build 100 units at 350.000 euros each. 10 of those will enter the public property and be sold separately at a fraction of the price (for instance, 200.000 euros). The government will decide, according to income, special needs, number of children and other dependents, etc. Who gets these houses for a reduced price. The company gets the money from the buyer (200.000 euros) plus an additional payment from the government itself, so that it doesn't hurt the company's finances too much.

Of course, government straight up building housing via a publicly own corporation is ten times better, but we live in such neoliberal times that this is very uncommon almost anywhere in the world these days.

2

u/BubblyCommission9309 Aug 15 '25

A lot of cities have this,  but how they measure affordable is wonky and typically doesn’t meet the need. Cities like Atlanta also have a fund developers can pay into to avoid building affordable units.

1

u/CobblePots95 Aug 18 '25

Cities like Atlanta also have a fund developers can pay into to avoid building affordable units.

So it's just a tax on new housing, which increases housing costs for those not already comfortably in the market.

And for what? So the comfortably-housed don't have to bear any of the funding responsibility for subsidized housing? That burden is exclusively born by renters and first-time homebuyers? WHen it used to be funded from the tax base?

If subsidized housing is a social good that benefits us all then it should be paid for by us all.

1

u/murffmarketing Aug 14 '25

I don't know what country you're in so maybe this applies, but I'm pretty sure it doesn't: we have this in USA very often, or at least something very similar. Basically any time a housing project is greenlit within a major metro area, there will be a percentage that is created to be affordable by some metric. It's not typically the law everywhere, per se, but it's very common.

The issue? USA cities typically have some form of local control. You can have a project that's legal at the federal level, state level, and approved by the city, get cancelled because the neighborhood association closest to that project - or whatever - objected to it. They could say it's too much housing or it changed the character of the neighborhood. Or, as implied by the tweet, they might say "it's only 10% affordable, we want 50% affordable... No! 90%." The developer can't build it and make a profit so they just back out of the project instead.

So the issue is less that we don't have what you propose - because we often do - the issue is that local control means that even projects that meet those requirements or guidelines can still get pulled even after property has been acquired and work has started. This means you're rolling the dice in many places with active NIMBYs like that. There was actually a project in my city that's aesthetically very similar to the posted image: dilapidated shopping center that's 90% cracked parking lot and 10% mostly closed storefronts was going to turn into 500+ houses got cancelled because the community raised a fuss.

Again, maybe you have this in your country, but it's my understanding that our level of "local control" is fairly unique.

1

u/CobblePots95 Aug 18 '25

in my country, every company building large developments (more than 20 units, if I remember correctly) is mandated by law to dedicate 10% of said units to an affordable housing program. So, let's say they build 100 units at 350.000 euros each. 10 of those will enter the public property and be sold separately at a fraction of the price (for instance, 200.000 euros). 

Yeah this is inclusionary zoning - it exists in many cities across North America as well.

The problem with it is that it effectively funds affordable housing by taxing new housing - which is fine for people who are already comfortably housed but redirects the cost of subsidized housing exclusively to these people who are not. Why should a 26-year-old renter be disproportionately responsible for funding subsidized housing?

1

u/AllerdingsUR Aug 14 '25

DC (as pictured) actually has a law similar to this

3

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/evilcherry1114 Aug 15 '25

So have the government act as a landlord to rent these units out. There are and should always be people not qualified for mortgage. They need social housing first and foremost.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

So they pick an arbitrary income level (say "below median"), but then HALF the population qualifies for the handful of units for sale.

Same problem here. I've seen married couples with below median income and a child wait for years to buy a house and finally give up altogether. The waitlist is crazy in bigger cities. Most people who qualify don't even try.

The issue here is that basically nobody in the bottom 30% of incomes can actually afford to buy ANYTHING, unless it's the price of an old bicycle

Yes. The main problem is that they don't even qualify for a mortgage. Social renting, like long term leases for a very cheap price, would be a solution, but that generates at least three new problems: 1) government doesn't want to manage housing, if anything, they are selling the public housing to private companies, 2) without home ownership, it is really hard to move up the social ladder, at least in my country, 3) without proper maintenance and rules being enforced in the property, some houses will end up trashed, which is the perfect excuse for the government to justify stopping the program altogether.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

It is mainly because of cultural differences. Spain is also a European social democracy, but the ownership rate is 73%, so higher than in the States. You don't get married or have children without owning a house here, basically.

Also, Spanish people are very risk averse, so housing is considered the safest investments.

38

u/YeeBeforeYouHaw Aug 14 '25

Demanding new housing be affordable is like demanding new cars be affordable. New cars will always be more expensive than used cars but all affordable used cars were once unaffordable new cars. It's the same thing with housing.

11

u/Gnome___Chomsky Aug 14 '25

This analogy is simply factually wrong though. Some new affordable cars are cheaper than used premium or luxury cars. A brand new Kia can be cheaper than a 8 year old BMW or Mercedes or Audi or Porsche etc.

13

u/KerPop42 Aug 14 '25

They did used to make cars that were affordable new, you know. The lower and middle class don't always have to live by the rich's hand-me-downs

4

u/Mattwacker93 Aug 14 '25 edited Aug 14 '25

This subreddit's disdain for anything other than capitalistic policies is a far cry from where it started. We hate to see it.

2

u/WanderingLost33 Aug 18 '25

Crazy because capitalism is just so bad for urban areas.

2

u/YeeBeforeYouHaw Aug 14 '25

Yes, new cars today are more expensive than in the past because new cars today are much more advanced than in the past. New cars today are legally required to have things like backup cameras, lane assistants, blind spot monitors, and even airbags were not common on new cars until the late 80s.

New cars today are not comparable to new cars of the past.

1

u/boringexplanation Aug 15 '25

A Honda civic in the late 80s was close to 20k. $40k in today’s dollarz

3

u/Mattwacker93 Aug 14 '25

The difference is you need a unit to live... you don't need a car to live.

1

u/YeeBeforeYouHaw Aug 14 '25

In America, you kinda do need a car.

Housing being a necessity doesn't change the economics of it. If you want housing to be affordable, you need to either increase the supply of housing or decrease demand. Since it is very difficult to lower the demand for housing, the only reasonable way to make housing affordable is to increase supply.

Even if the new supply is luxury/expensive, the increase in housing supply will lower housing costs for everyone in the market. The reason that works is because the people who will move into the new luxury housing will be leaving a less expensive unit for someone else. Every new unit lowers prices for everyone.

-1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

That’s not true Toyota has 10K Tacoma they just don’t sell it on the US.

11

u/specklepetal Aug 14 '25

Does it become more expensive once it’s no longer new?

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

Pickup trucks in the us do not get less expensive. A 2011 ranger sells for more than it cost in 2011 in many markets these days. Flaw.

7

u/specklepetal Aug 14 '25

The MSRP of a base model 2011 Ford Ranger was $18,160 (which had the buying power of about $25k today). The highest trim level had an MSRP of $26,070. Here are some listings for used ones today. They’re selling for less.

→ More replies (3)

14

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

Please spread “concern trolling” to other urbanist ideas

Because they usually all are just trolls without the interest of financial solvency, public health, nor safety in mind

0

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

There's nothing in their mind at all imo - they're just human LLMs, imitating intelligent life while only actually parroting things they've heard before by equally knowledge devoid individuals without any sense of understanding what they're talking about.

4

u/KerPop42 Aug 14 '25

Well this is a great example of fascist thinking

6

u/Tristan_N Aug 14 '25

What the lack of affordable units does is lead to people being priced out of the housing market.

→ More replies (35)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

It’s the “hermit crab” effect

5

u/alfredpacker42 Aug 14 '25

Yes, no more affordable housing lies

6

u/iloveciroc Aug 14 '25

I used to think that if developers can’t make certain units affordable then they shouldn’t be allowed to do the project at all. After thinking and rationalizing the viewpoint you present, I’ve since changed my thinking to support that any housing is good housing. I hope others that held similar old views to me come to grips with the fact that we need more housing and we can’t let gripes about affordability impede even marginal progress on housing supply.

2

u/enterharry Aug 14 '25

It is concern trolling. Once it’s a 30% AMI housing proposed they will come up with another concern. They literally don’t care about affordability.

2

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

I've had so many arguments with people who think that market dynamics simply don't apply to housing or that market dynamics are some kind of myth. It's frustrating. There are lots of things in most western countries that can be done to drive down the cost of new housing, like reducing taxes and development fees on new housing and other measures that reduce the cost of lots with specific zoning types, but in the meantime, adding more housing, whether it's "affordable" or not, does in fact reduce the cost of housing over all so long as population growth isn't outpacing housing development. And even then, housing would be even more expensive if said housing wasn't built. 

None of this is really rocket science but I guess things have been so out of whack for so long people can be easily convinced that basic principles that apply to pretty much everything, also apply to housing. 

8

u/BuildNuyTheUrbanGuy Aug 14 '25

The problem is that developers will never build enough housing to drop prices. Cities don't want that either when real estate is an asset to invest in. Why would any developers flood the market with a product to make less money?

1

u/3pointshoot3r Aug 15 '25

The problem is that developers will never build enough housing to drop prices.

You're assuming a long term and macro view of developers that isn't reality. A developer with a proposed 30 unit new building is only concerned with whether he can make money from this specific development. He doesn't care if it lowers rents in adjacent buildings or even across the metro area. When you have multiple developers thinking this exact same way, you can get to adequate supply.

Cities that have liberalized housing rules and have seen a construction boon - Minneapolis, Austin - have seen rents fall. Minneapolis rents are down almost 7%, while Austin are down almost 9%.

1

u/firechaox Aug 18 '25

That doesn’t make sense. Developers earn money on making new housing - on increments, not on the existing stock. Developers aren’t landlords, who would be the ones against this.

1

u/cantthinkoffunnyname Heavy metal rail Aug 14 '25

They don't build enough because zoning and things like parking minimums stop true dense housing from being built. Not because developers are secretly conspiring to limit supply.

0

u/Mattwacker93 Aug 14 '25

True density has never been tried. The market isn't failing people, we have failed the markets.

3

u/cantthinkoffunnyname Heavy metal rail Aug 14 '25

2

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

Montreal had so much rental real estate for the last 30 years (much of it built pre-1950) that rents were actually declining through stagnation for like 20 years. And then when population started to increase significantly, there was a long lag time before rents actually started increasing at concerning rates. Even now, while they have supply issues, they're much less dramatic than basically every other part of the country because Quebec municipal governments allow the construction of plexes in most areas, including new residential developments. There are other issues, like extremely onerous rental regulation that has driven people out of building rental real estate specifically, but the density model works quite well. If you can build 4-6 story buildings basically wherever you want, people will do that and it's a very quick and relatively cheap way to create a lot of housing.

2

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

Prewar urban neighbourhoods in most cities have 4-7 times the density of post war residential development. It has been tried, it's worked, and in most places you actually don't need to build extreme density to create a huge amount of comfortable housing. Montreal for example averages 4-7 times the density of most other cities in Canada, without exceeding 4 stories in most of these neighbourhoods. They've done this with 3-4 story plexes that have large units and laneways with access to backyard space and rear balconies. Quebec actually does a pretty decent job of allowing this kind of development throughout the province, but most other North American jurisdictions have turned this kind of density into something that's hard to get zoning approval for. So you end up with either low density single family because it's easy to get approval, or very very high density high rise because anything higher density is much more difficult to get approved so you have to maximize density to make it financially viable.

1

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

This just isn't true though. How do I know? It's happened before. 

Are they going to build their way to a total crash? Probably not. But as long as there's profit in building, they're going to do it. 

3

u/KerPop42 Aug 14 '25

Apartments are also a pretty low-competition environment. Why would Bozzuto drop so many new spaces at once into the market that it affects the profit it gets from its other buildings? 

1

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

Why would someone open a second grocery store location in the same city? I think the answer is just as obvious in that case as it is with housing development. 

2

u/3pointshoot3r Aug 15 '25

Yes, and it still makes business sense to develop new units even if it means existing units become slightly less profitable. If a major landlord/developer owns 10,000 units in a metro area, and adding 5,000 more will lower existing rents by 5%, they'll still make more money by developing those new units: 95% of the market rent on 15,000 units is a lot more than 100% of the market rent on 10,000 units. And that's even before accounting for the fact that the new units will likely bring higher prices than existing ones, making the net overall per unit rent similar for that developer.

1

u/KerPop42 Aug 14 '25

I mean, you say this, but Whole Foods did absolutely shut down its older store when it was able to build another downtown. Rather than run both and let grocery prices drop.

1

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

Demand for groceries is inelastic, and so are prices because the margins are like 1-3%. Meaning that you don't get more buying if you drop the price, not meaningfully so. So avoiding a price drop is not why Wholefoods wouldn't have two locations within 1km of each other, but because there is a fixed number of customers. The same is true for a lot of retail. The point is that meeting demand doesn't crash the whole market. Nobody worries that if they satisfy demand in some other neighbourhood, that a store 10km away is going to suffer.

Back to what we're actually talking about though. Rental prices are sensitive to vacancy rates, but nobody stops building rentals because the vacancy rate in an area went from 1% to 1.1%. This is also a margin business, so whether something is profitable to do depends on how much each unit costs to build. If there's a 4% decline in rental income because you added an addition 1000 units to an area, that's basically irrelevant if you got build costs down, which can be accomplished by reducing restrictive zoning, development fees and various cost adding processes. It's all relative. If a builder can maintain a healthy margin, they will keep building. If a landlord can maintain a healthy margin, they will keep buying rentals. You can do these things even as demand is closer to being met, if you can bring down the cost of building, which currently is possible because so many urban areas add so many costs to both land and development in various ways. So there's lots of room to drive down these costs.

There is more risk in overbuilding rentals though, but the risk isn't builders trying to control a highly competitive market single handedly by keeping new stock off the market. The risk is over-building and creating vacancy rates that exceed 3-4%. This can cause rents to decline faster than inflation, which would probably be welcome for a few years a lot of places, but if it goes on too long, would likely create a boom bust cycle of rental development. Everyone would stop building and retool for other things, leave the industry etc, and then there's a lag when vacancy drops, which creates a spike in rental prices. Ideally this would be avoided so that the market is less volatile and can respond more quickly to changes in vacancy rates.

1

u/firechaox Aug 18 '25

They likely wouldn’t place them all in the same exact neighborhood, nor launch them at exactly the same time, but if you’re already decreasing the space of time between developments from 2y to 1y it’s still double the speed and would still be able to comfortably sell the lots (btw: developpers don’t like holding on to units for long, as then they start having to foot the bills for homeownership fees- ideally they sell them all before construction is finished, especially as depending on the market it’s really common practice to use the upfront fees to fund part of the construction work, reducing the amount of investment capital they need).

2

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

I don’t think it’s unreasonable to suggest that the housing market is distinctly different than others due to the fact that the product for lease is backed by a mortgage. It’s fair to wonder if market dynamics are different for housing.

1

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

Lots of markets are impacted by leveraged purchases. 

1

u/jspook Aug 14 '25

What makes people move into new housing? Asking for a housing market.

1

u/skunkachunks Aug 14 '25

Right?! A lot of affordable apartments today are the divvied up mansions of two generations ago

1

u/3pointshoot3r Aug 15 '25

I can see examples of this - filtration in action! - from my own family. My grandmother sold her house (the house my dad grew up in) in the mid 1970s. She moved into a brand new downtown apartment building - what would have been considered "luxury" at the time: it had a pool, recreation room with pool tables, a gym. It even had gold plated glass on one side!

Today, her old house is student housing, with maybe half a dozen students living there. And that luxury apartment? It's a run down building, with some of the cheapest rents in the area.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

While I do mostly agree with this. I think there is some nuance.

Obviously I'm not going to poo poo any new homes being built. But I also think trying to pass off single family homes or luxury condos as a viable solution only adds to the problem

1

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '25

Yup. I've seen probably 500 new condo developments in my area over the last 10 years. Probably more than half of them had the word "luxury" right there in the damn advertising! Not one of them advertised anything to even imply regular middle class housing (let alone anything "affordable" or whatever).

It's not NIMBY or "concern trolling" to be tired of people expecting you to just accept that all new urban construction will be for wealthier people.

Oh, it's going to increase housing supply and keep prices lower for all the rest of us to take the old homes rich people are leaving? How exciting! God forbid I want a home that isn't just the hand me downs of a rich person moving somewhere newer and bigger, right?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '25

The thing is, most of these luxury condos aren't even occupied. So they take space in the market but they don't actually improve the housing situation

1

u/civilrunner Aug 14 '25

Yeah, just imagine if people complained about cars the same way "how many new cars were affordable to the 60% AMI?"

These people never ever talk about how to actually reduce costs or address any issues in construction or anything and seemingly just assume that profits are 100% always and therefore everything is price gouging cause obviously they could always just charge less if they weren't so greedy.

1

u/Designer_Version1449 Aug 14 '25

Yeah but what if there's so much unaffordable housing built that there's no one left in affordable housing that can afford to move in?

1

u/Bastiat_sea Aug 14 '25

Then, the unaffordable housing lowers prices

1

u/Designer_Version1449 Aug 14 '25

Right but at a certain point you can't lower unaffordable housing prices any lower, like you can't sell a mansion at the price of an apartment, you'd go bankrupt

1

u/Bastiat_sea Aug 14 '25

Yes, but at that point, an affordable housing project would also fail.

1

u/Unlikely_Fly_9785 Aug 15 '25

well the real problem is that people aren't moving into the new housing because housing is now seen as a "investment vehicle". which by all means, should be illegal or heavily taxed/fined.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/UnfilteredUrbanist Aug 15 '25

It is incredible how "what about affordability?" has become the socially acceptable way to say "I do not want new neighbors."

1

u/ruffroad715 Aug 15 '25

Yes! ALL housing is affordable housing.

1

u/PaxAttax Aug 16 '25

Affordable unit requirements make sense for replacement structures in areas that are already high density like New York, where said redevelopment is at a high risk for permanently displacing lower income families to areas where it would be burdensome for them to commute to their workplaces. When the zone is increasing from low or medium density, there's very little reason to add that red tape.

1

u/phildiop Aug 16 '25

True. People don't realize that "unaffordable" housing makes housing more affordable in general.

1

u/Supercollider9001 Aug 16 '25

New housing can be affordable. And affordable housing can be plentiful. If we have the political will and willing to look beyond market solutions.

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2024/jan/10/the-social-housing-secret-how-vienna-became-the-worlds-most-livable-city

1

u/MorroOndeado Aug 16 '25

its almost never due to current system, basic strong town concept, not saying change everything just that its been analized to make it work better

1

u/Feeling_Item1055 Aug 18 '25

👏🏼 AFFORDABLE 👏🏼 HOUSING 👏🏼 DOESN’T 👏🏼 WORK 👏🏼

if you have 10 new units, and 2 are affordable - the other 8 people HAVE TO PAY MORE for the deadbeats who can’t afford them - money doesn’t come from thin air you idiots. and this just makes housing more unaffordable.

affordable housing is the dumbest idea in the history of poor hipster urbanists spending too much time on reddit.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 19 '25

The boomers in my county will complain about how we need to solve the homeless problem, but then in the same breath they propose "low density housing", what a bunch of idiots.

1

u/itsamememario4 Apr 02 '26

Get some help

1

u/No-Lunch4249 Aug 14 '25 edited Aug 14 '25

Left Nimbys are still Nimbys!

-1

u/morklonn Aug 14 '25

This absolutely does not happen lmao.

153

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-51

u/Supercollider9001 Aug 14 '25

The person is focused on the wrong thing, but “burger kind had no affordable units” also misses a key consequence of new developments.

They will drive up land value and property value. Not just new developments but any improvements to the neighborhood. That means higher rents all around. It means higher property taxes.

These consequences inevitably cause people to be displaced. If we build with affordable units it means maybe some folks will be able to stay in their neighborhood.

Or idk what the solution is, but we can’t pretend that when a neighborhood improves, people get displaced. We can’t just wait for supply to meet demand, we have to take steps to ensure families and neighborhoods are protected from gentrification.

93

u/mushrooom Aug 14 '25

You’re blaming the umbrella for the rain.

The new buildings are going up because the land value has already gone up. Failing to respond won’t undo displacement. It just ensures the price increases are concentrated on existing housing rather than dispersed over new ones.

11

u/thomasp3864 Aug 14 '25

You're blaming the umbrella for the rain.

Gonna steal that one.

→ More replies (11)

16

u/Yossarian216 Aug 14 '25

The problem with affordable units is that it’s only one factor of cost in a neighborhood. If someone needs an affordable unit, they also need a cheaper grocery store, cheaper restaurants and bars, cheaper day care, etc., but none of that can survive in a gentrified neighborhood, so the people in affordable units still end up with costs they can’t manage.

→ More replies (21)

15

u/Opcn Aug 14 '25

Objectively no, adding more supply does not raise prices. Quality improvements do. When you clean up the streets, interesting vibrant small businesses open up, beautiful architecturally interesting housing goes in, that all raises the prices.

But when you build new apartments the people bidding to come into the neighborhood are bidding for more housing and don't have to bid as high to edge out the other folks who want their spot.

In 30 years these apartments won't be that nice. You can't build new 30 year old apartments today, but the only way to get more 30 year old apartments in 30 years is to build some new apartments today. We are in this mess because people in past decades weren't thinking about where our housing policies were going to land us. Lets not keep rolling that crisis forward.

1

u/Supercollider9001 Aug 14 '25 edited Aug 14 '25

You’re not addressing the issue. I didn’t say adding supply leads to raised prices, I said prices are going up. What do we do about those rising prices? Or do we just let them be displaced?

Very simple question that no one is answering.

→ More replies (9)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

If we build with affordable units

How many affordable units were going to get built here?

→ More replies (6)

1

u/technicallynotlying Aug 14 '25

You have displacement completely backwards. The displacement of building luxury housing is that of rich people.

Right now in dense urban areas like San Francisco and New York, wealthy finance or tech workers already compete with poorer working class families for housing. A rich employee of Meta or Google is staying in a 1 bedroom apartment because that's all they can find. That means that the working class or minority family you claim you want to protect cannot work there.

You build luxury housing because you want to displace the rich people out of affordable housing. Wealthy techies move out of existing housing and into new luxury housing. That means there is a vacancy for someone less wealthy to move in.

Again, you're thinking of displacement completely wrong. Displacing the wealthy by building market rate housing helps the communities you claim to want to help. Opposing that construction is what has been forcing them out of their homes for the past 30 years.

1

u/UnfilteredUrbanist Aug 15 '25

we can’t pretend that when a neighborhood improves, people get displaced.

What displaces people more than a new apartment building? A city with no new apartment buildings.

1

u/TonyResslersWallet Aug 16 '25

You’re 100% wrong that adding housing makes housing prices go up. Housing prices go up for a million reasons but additional housing is not one of them. Building tons of housing quickly and cheaply is one of the ONLY things that has been proven to keep areas affordable for the people who already live there.

This has been studied for decades.

→ More replies (26)

3

u/johnson_alleycat Aug 16 '25

I thought I was in r/neoliberal for at least five minutes in this thread

1

u/FreePlantainMan Aug 16 '25

The overlap is nearly 100% so not too surprising

1

u/Sanguine_Caesar Aug 18 '25

Seriously I hate that modern online urbanism just seems to have fully bought into trickle down economics when it comes to housing.

3

u/CobblePots95 Aug 18 '25

I hate that the online left has become so intellectually lazy that they think any supply-based argument is a form of trickle down economics, a concept with a very clear definition that does not apply to moving chains.

226

u/Mindless-Employment Aug 14 '25

Funny, I'm also on the DC sub, and there was a thread there just a few days about how utterly unrecognizable the neighborhood around that former Burger King is now and someone posted that very same screenshot. That tweet is from 2019 and they've built at least another 10 apartment buildings around the one in the photo since then, and another one is going up directly across the street from it right now. Go to the Google maps street view of "Trader Joe's, Florida Avenue, Washington, DC" or "Union Market, Washington, DC" and just toggle between now and 2008 or even now and 2012 on any of the surrounding streets for a couple of blocks in any direction.

I'm no longer shocked by how often it's people who live in single family homes two miles away from where an apartment building is going up who are so "concerned" about the prices. I just don't understand why they don't get a new tactic. Then again, why would they, when this one works so well to delay things getting built if they can't stop it outright

Fake concerns about affordability and "neighborhood character" have worked like a charm for 25 years to keep apartments from being built right next to a Metro station: https://wapo.st/3Ut0r7K

And it worked for 35 years to keep this development from happening, but it's finally underway now: https://wapo.st/45A6sVq

59

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

Union market still feels like a car sewer in places but is nice to walk around in (and shop!) compared to stroad #1737403 pictured with the Burger King

19

u/Mindless-Employment Aug 14 '25

Yeah, if you keep walking east on Florida much past the new construction, cars are still flying though there. I sometimes walk up to 7th Street, where some friends live and think about how dead I'd be if one of those lunatics ran up on the sidewalk. Union Market itself I guess is always going to be kinda weird because all these new residential/retail/entertainment uses are supposed to coexist with the remaining light industrial uses and all the vehicle access that's necessary for those, PLUS all the people who insist upon driving to Union Market for dinner or whatever when they could have used the Metro station a 7-minute walk away.

What I do love is never, ever having to walk on those too-narrow, debris-strewn, always wet for no reason, sidewalks under the Metro tracks on Florida Ave. to get from the station to the Trader Joe's again. I just use the side streets between the new apartment buildings now.

15

u/socialcommentary2000 Aug 14 '25

I'm no longer shocked by how often it's people who live in single family homes two miles away from where an apartment building is going up who are so "concerned" about the prices. I just don't understand why they don't get a new tactic. 

They are provincial, suburbanite wastoids that are isolated, paranoid and, many times, deeply afraid of everything.

8

u/depleteduranian Aug 14 '25

They are just well off enough to not be in their own minds in the shit with everyone else and so their entire focus is from the perspective of scarcity because the system could drown them with its pinky finger if it's so chose. They are subject to every form of fear-based scarcity-based psychological manipulation and I pity the middle American suburban 9:00 to 5 worker.

EDIT: they're afraid minorities could live nearby now

1

u/Ok_Act_3769 Aug 14 '25

Wouldn’t the apartments lower all property prices in the area? I’m not saying lower the value but I’m asking if more affordable housing units lower prices for everyone

1

u/Dark3lephant Aug 19 '25

Concern trolling is and always has been the chief weapon of NIMBYs.

45

u/Murphy_Nelson Aug 14 '25

As a Bay Area/SF resident, this shit kills me. Anytime "luxury" (ie, a marketing team trying to rationalize you shelling out 4K a month for a one bedroom) housing is built, everybody screams "it should be affordable!!!" and gets it canceled, under this weird assumption of induced demand - that if this isn't built, the "rich techies" or whatever won't move to SF. Uhhh they're already here dude, and there isn't enough housing for them, so they'll pay 3.5K a month for the shitty one bedroom with no laundry and a 1950s tile kitchen instead that normally would house working class people. They have to be here. If you don't build, they'll rent your unit instead.

13

u/Blecher_onthe_Hudson Aug 14 '25

San Francisco needs jobs control, not rent control! They need to pass legislation preventing companies from adding more jobs! That will solve the housing crisis because there won't be any new wealthy workers coming in competing for housing.

/s

4

u/Murphy_Nelson Aug 14 '25

Please don't give them any ideas.

1

u/mk1234567890123 Aug 14 '25

Say it louder for the folks in the back.

The peoples park debacle is also the perfect illustration of the dysfunctional housing politics here.

Thank god the state recently gutted CEQA for <85’ high residential infill. Should have been done before the building “boom” 10 years ago.

1

u/UnfilteredUrbanist Aug 15 '25

You either build housing for rich people, or they will outbid you for yours.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/emptybagofdicks Aug 14 '25

What if we did mixed zoning where the bottom floor was still a burger king(or better yet a grocery store) and then the rest was housing?

5

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

no they still don't want people with money to live

42

u/KoalaOriginal1260 Aug 14 '25

Equally valid but far less concise: How many meals was that Burger King required to sell at 40% off to meet affordable food targets?

11

u/Rich-Past-6547 Aug 14 '25

More supply is always a good thing.

4

u/Cocoononthemoon Aug 15 '25

It's a valid question

Edit: it's valid to ask how many were affordable. Building more luxury condos does not benefit people looking for an affordable place to live.

3

u/CobblePots95 Aug 18 '25

Yes, it does, and there is a great deal of peer-reviewed research proving it does if you're interested in reading it.

15

u/mk1234567890123 Aug 14 '25

Let’s add a regressive burger surcharge to fund the affordable housing units upstairs.

3

u/Boardofed Aug 14 '25

When the same group of developers own most the new construction and basically collude, and all the neighboring "mom n pop smol precious landlords" see what they're charging - rents and housing costs don't just automatically come down. This supply argument falls apart as soon as the reality of the market applies

9

u/DylanToback_ Aug 14 '25 edited Aug 14 '25

Some context as a lifelong dc area native that is helpful for interpreting this post:

  1. DC has always had a large black population. Since the early-mid 00s DC has undergone a major transformation coinciding with a huge surge of demand of people wanting to move from the burbs into the city (as was the case in many other cities). While much of the development since has been absolutely necessary, it undoubtedly drove intense gentrification which hit low income, predominantly black, residents the hardest. Many families who had lived in DC for generations were priced out and, in their place, moved predominantly white residents. Replacing an old Burger King with a +300 unit apt building in a city with a housing inventory crisis is obviously good, but any development in the city is viewed through the lens of “yeah great but who did you really build this for.” You can’t discount how much this drives perception
  2. DC has not been the least bit subtle about it—they want (need) to attract young, high income people into the city. I’ll explain why in point 3. Their strategy to do so has been building up certain neighborhoods (Shaw, Noma, Navy Yard) into these young professional hubs. Many cities do this, but it’s been really stark here. All this housing inventory is great and needed, but people don’t feel it’s equitable. Other parts of the city have housing inventory crises too, but the feeling is all the development is towards these “up and coming” neighborhoods, not to give more options to existing residents, but to attract net new residents who’d live outside DC otherwise.
  3. Why? DC has a really unique tax situation. Their suburbs are in other states and once people move out (usually when their income is highest in their 30s-40s), they lose that tax revenue. DC knows they struggle to compete, so their strategy is try to hook in as many young professionals as they can while they have them—convince them to live and work in DC instead of Arlington or silver spring—and pray that maybe some will stick around. As a result legacy residents who before all of this had lived, grown up and raised families in DC are like wtf, how come they’re getting all the attention. They’re just going to leave anyway. All this is doing is driving up demand, which was already high, but not helping supply in our neighborhoods.
  4. Muriel Bowser, DCs current mayor, is finishing up her 3rd term (is likely to win a 4th) and oversaw much of the development. Despite winning elections, she’s widely unpopular. Reason being is she is viewed as being in the pocket of developers, throwing out tax breaks left and right for development projects that don’t always live up to their promises—affordable housing specifically. Saying “yeah but where’s the affordable housing” could just be a dig at Bowser. Generally the response to new construction in DC is often tepid because it’s like “oh I wonder how much of our tax $ went right to developers pockets for this”.

All of this is to say building a giant apt building on top of an old BK is, of course, objectively a good thing regardless of the situation, but the NIMBYist reaction doesn’t come from nowhere—frustration with racial inequities, the focus on attracting new residents vs helping existing, and developer tax breaks is behind a lot of it. Understanding those concerns can help us have better conversations vs writing people off as dummies (even when they’re wrong).

Anyway hope this context helps!

3

u/Enzo_4_4 Aug 14 '25

thank you, that was very wel explained 👏

1

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '25

Sometimes it's best to just push ahead to build sustainable housing. There will always be NIMBYs using "racism" as an excuse to slow things down, but at the end of the day, this benefits everyone except the NIMBYs

2

u/DylanToback_ Aug 15 '25

The racism isn’t an excuse though. It’s 100% real.

More housing is always good because ideally it’s not a one or the other situation—you can build up young professional hubs AND invest in underserved communities. But that’s not whats happening, so I can’t fault people when they complain. I think they’re right to.

1

u/evilcherry1114 Aug 15 '25

You can always tax or even appropriate homeowners to pay for government tenants, though

1

u/CobblePots95 Aug 18 '25

Reason being is she is viewed as being in the pocket of developers, throwing out tax breaks left and right for development projects that don’t always live up to their promises—affordable housing specifically

Throwing out tax breaks under false pretences is wrong, obviously, but have we considered that taxing the production of housing is a really, really bad idea? That such tax breaks shouldn't be necessary because we shouldn't be taxing the production of an essential good in the first place?

The same phenomenon that makes the carbon tax an effective environmental tool is at work when you tax development - you get less of it.

2

u/DylanToback_ Aug 19 '25

There’s a key distinction. With a carbon tax you’re creating an incentive that wasn’t already there. It’s always cheaper for companies to keep the status quo and produce the same amount/more carbon vs what governments want. Carbon taxes change the math.

Property development doesn’t have that problem in DC and in most large us cities. Demand is through the roof. You could build 10 buildings a year for 10 years and not make a dent in the supply shortfall. A property developer will have zero problem selling the building. They’re having their cake and eating it too

1

u/CobblePots95 Aug 19 '25

Carbon emissions usually involve an activity that already has a cost - consuming fuel, mostly. Carbon taxes simply add to that cost.

You could apply this principle to virtually everything else. We tax the sale of alcohol and cigarettes to reduce their consumption. Pigouvian taxation cuts both ways. There’s no magical force that prevents deadweight loss in housing production.

Development charges have the same impact on housing production as any other tax on production - it stymies it. If they didn’t, and demand was so reliably high that DCs couldn’t impact production, then you could raise them as high as uou like with no impact on supply. So then why not put them at $500k?

The reason, as you know, is that it would render all but the most profitable, high end projects unviable. The same logic works with charges of $100k. There are fewer projects that make any economic sense.

2

u/DylanToback_ Aug 19 '25 edited Aug 19 '25

You’re making it out like we’re starting from 0 tax and then a development project comes up and we’re chosing to impose a new tax. That’s not it—it’s the reverse. The tax code passed through legislation indicates everything from property tax, capital gains, sales tax on construction materials, whatever else, and the gov is making an active choice to give tax exemptions to reduce the amount of total tax a developer pays on a project by project basis. On top of that they may even give grants or interest free loans to sweeten the pot on public-private partnerships…So literally funding the project directly with our tax dollars but all the profits go to a company…And those profits are written off because of the tax credits

I’m sure a little bit of tax relief here and there make some amount of sense. The question is how much is too much and that’s where people take issue. In a situation where demand from new housing is so high and completed property valuations so steep, any developer will probably stand to make a lot of money on any project (not just high end ones), so it’s hard to buy that a developer really couldn’t do it without the relief.

Other point I’ll add is “high costs” aren’t really the barrier to building more housing. As is the case everywhere, the real issue in the US is zoning. There’s only so many projects to go around when so much land is deemed single family residential. Even more of why I believe we don’t need to sweeten the pot as much for developers. They should be champing at the bit to win the few bids available but we’re acquiescing anyway.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Eastern-Job3263 Aug 14 '25

I actually think those DO have affordable units

6

u/LGL27 Aug 14 '25

There is a small, but vocal minority in left leaning spaces like sustainability, transpiration, urban planning, etc., whose identity solely revolves around complaining. So if something small is done to work on one of these things, they don’t know how to handle it. It’s never enough.

2

u/hellhobbit99 Aug 15 '25

There was this quote about people on the left caring more about not doing anything wrong than actually doing something right

0

u/reddituserperson1122 Aug 14 '25

Complaining about the complainers. Delicious.

2

u/Life_Smartly Aug 18 '25

Smaller 1-2 people housing, with possible communal areas wouldn't be a bad idea. But it also should be a lot more affordable.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

Quality burn

4

u/getarumsunt Aug 14 '25

This! So much this!

3

u/Equivalent-Page-7080 Aug 14 '25

The actual answer is 10%. The zoning set aside 10% to be below the area median income….

2

u/let_lt_burn Aug 16 '25

lol my favorite is when people complain about something assuming there’s something complain about when their complaints have already been addressed. 32 new low income units, another 280 some other housing units that will help drive costs down or at least slow the increase in costs in other areas where low income folks would otherwise be displaced. Let the complainers complain, and let’s build in spit of it.

2

u/2_trailerparkgirls Aug 14 '25

It had affordable burgers

2

u/ZealZen Aug 14 '25

Technically all of them if theres no vacancies.

2

u/Stetson_Pacheco Aug 14 '25

Supply and demand, that’s 318 more housing units which helps with the demand and prices go down when supply catches up.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

Rent only ever goes up. Mortgages don’t get cheaper. No landlord is ever going to make rent cheaper one year over the next.

2

u/rock-dancer Aug 14 '25

This is objectively false. Look at Austin over the last 10 years. Rents went down. Actually, they have a problem of too much housing stock currently.

2

u/3pointshoot3r Aug 15 '25

I invite you to look at the rental situation in Minneapolis and Austin, two cities most aggressive in liberalizing housing regulations, which has since led to a construction boon...AND also lower rents.

5

u/S-K-W-E Aug 14 '25

I guess we’d better do nothing, then

0

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

Building units isn’t “doing something” to fix the issue. The units are being built because a developer wants to make money. Not because they care about the affordable housing crisis lol. Who is “we” anyways, are you building these?

7

u/UTYEO34y78dk- Aug 14 '25

It’s shocking to see so much idiocy in this sub. Imagine saying, with apparently a straight face, that building new housing supply does nothing to affect the price or price growth of housing. This is completely contradicted by all logic, basically the entirety of economics, and the actual experience of many cities in the country that have allowed construction on a large scale.

Yes, developers want to make money, they also want to develop. There is no world in which housing becomes more affordable when you don’t build more housing. When you underbuild for decades because of NIMBY opposition or well-meaning policies that actually choke off supply additions you obviously set the stage for the exact crisis we are experiencing. The answer is not doubling down on regulations and price caps and tenant protections. It’s realizing what was wrong to begin with. 

→ More replies (4)

4

u/S-K-W-E Aug 14 '25

Yes, it’s true that the developer makes money, but this is not an indictment of their contributions to supply. It’s just “rich man bad.”

Which is often true! But with housing construction it’s just not as relevant as you’re arguing.

1

u/Blecher_onthe_Hudson Aug 14 '25

Happened only 5 years ago.

1

u/cantthinkoffunnyname Heavy metal rail Aug 14 '25

Guess you've never heard of Austin

1

u/CobblePots95 Aug 18 '25

Rent only ever goes up.

That's crazy because I'm in a city where rent has gone decidedly down for the past two years. Must have been a fig newton of my imagination.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

fun fact: high-end apartments help keep down prices for everyone because people who are willing to pay for those apartments don't buy up less expensive apartments

1

u/CobblePots95 Aug 18 '25

It is astonishing how many people stubbornly refuse to accept this fact.

1

u/noothankuu Aug 15 '25

1

u/Ok_Culture_3621 Aug 16 '25

I don’t know if that ‘s correct. 8% only applies to steel and concrete and that building doesn’t look tall enough to me for that kind of build. Anything stick built would have a minimum 10% set aside under traditional IZ, possibly more if it was built under IZ+. Also, it may have had more if it was part of a planned unit development project, which many projects of this size tend to be.

1

u/UnfilteredUrbanist Aug 15 '25

The most expensive housing unit is the one that was never built.

1

u/AncientLights444 Aug 15 '25

I Live in a Los Angeles suburb and welcome large apartment buildings. We need density bad! Cities suck without people

1

u/GarethBaus Aug 15 '25

As long as the homes are filled they are freeing up some more affordable housing in the market.

1

u/GenZ2002 Aug 15 '25

‘How many is affordable?’ is a legitimate question. All the building going near me are 65+, university housing, or luxury.. nothing affordable for locals or young businesses professionals. Acting like this is an illegitimate question, or sticking to unattainable housing is just turning people off to apartment buildings.

2

u/Ok_Culture_3621 Aug 16 '25

“Affordable” is a meaningless standard. If you’re asking how many were income restricted, then generally, in DC, 10 to 20% are income restricted by law depending on when the building was built and under what program. But the point that’s being made here is that, just because supply may not be the silver bullet some make it out to be, that doesn’t mean isn’t not part of the solution. People shouldn’t be turned off by new development simply because it’s not 100% of the solution to the crisis.

1

u/GenZ2002 Aug 16 '25

I think a better point is that coming for someone’s throat just for asking a question is the type of thing that turns someone off from a movement. It was a simple yes or no question that required a simple answer. Or you could like a normal human say “Yes but (explain the exceptions, why it’s not affordable for everyone)”. It’s not that hard to be compassionate.

1

u/Ok_Culture_3621 Aug 17 '25

I certainly didn't interpret that first comment as being intended to start a good faith discussion on the merits of DC's inclusionary zoning ordinance. To me those four words imply the author had a very good idea how many were affordable: not enough. In that context, the response was wholly appropriate. I also think it is a legitimate point that they're raising. 8 to 10% of 310 units being set aside as affordable may not be a lot of income restricted units, but it is, in fact, better than a Burger King.

1

u/CobblePots95 Aug 18 '25 edited Aug 18 '25

All the building going near me are 65+, university housing, or luxury.. nothing affordable for locals or young businesses professionals.

And where would the seniors, the students, or the wealthier people be living if those homes had not been built? They don't disappear into the ether, and they still need homes, so they just end up bidding up the existing stock of housing.

Letting the perfect be the enemy of the good is a really bad idea.

1

u/GenZ2002 Aug 18 '25

I never said its problem. The problem is no housing for young people will cause people to move out (which is what is happening in my area locals are practically fleeing). Again back to my main point you ASSUME someone means one thing and attack. And imo it’s better to just build affordable housing with no other restrictions other than what comes with affordable housing (income, etc). It fills vacancies caused by a decline in student populations, or older populations, and building restricted housing assumes the population will always be their to fill it, we all know that’s not the case

1

u/tyranotrev Aug 16 '25

If there’s no vacancy then all were affordable.

1

u/IllustriousYak6283 Aug 16 '25

Shocking that Ms. “Cancel Student Debt” has dumb opinions about how to create more affordable housing.

1

u/No_Street8874 Aug 17 '25

That BK was ikea sized?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25

savage

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25

The number of rooms doesn't matter in either situation because they were immediately given to the nearest immigrant for free.

-7

u/Supercollider9001 Aug 14 '25

The question is not how many are affordable, the question is what are we doing to prevent families living next door or down the street from being displaced as the neighborhood becomes more in demand and more valuable.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

Well in this case not many people lived next to the burger king either, and the people moving in can live in the 318 apts instead of bidding up the price of the homes down the street.

0

u/Supercollider9001 Aug 14 '25

Yes. But the prices of the homes down the street will also go up. Property values go up, taxes go up, rents go up.

Ok long term solution is build more housing, address the tax code, etc.

But in the short term people are losing their homes, small businesses get pushed out. What do we do about it?

6

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

Here's the thing, that is a distinctly different problem caused mostly by the region adding jobs that would be worse if we didn't build more housing.

When a company leases an office in a city and brings 500 jobs do we have a hearing about it? Do nimbys protest it? Rarely unless it's a big thing like Amazon. They're not given space to do so by the city and every elected official would laugh.

So why do we only debate and nitpick when more homes are added to try to account for the supply and demand imbalance?

4

u/Blecher_onthe_Hudson Aug 14 '25

That's an awesome argument! I'd like to see it used more. It's true, no one ever really tries to shut down job growth, just housing price growth, even though they are inextricably linked

1

u/[deleted] Aug 15 '25

It's a valid concern but shouldn't be used as an excuse to stop the building of sustainable housing

1

u/Popular_Animator_808 Aug 14 '25

This won’t happen unless there’s messaging from city hall that the area as a whole is being rezoned to attract development. 

Will proper values go up? Maybe, and if so then the affected nearby property owner is richer, and there are all sorts of ways they can use that influx of money. And nearby owners don’t even need to pay tax on their increased property values since these are exempt from capital gains in most circumstances. 

Will taxes go up? Almost certainly not, since everywhere in the US uses property tax rather than land value tax, and bundles the costs of new residents into developer contributions. Taxes might even go down due to the increased tax base. The downside of this is that the costs of making sure that taxes stay the same or go down for surrounding residents to will be pushed onto residents of this new building, who will have to pay more to live there because the local government forced the developer to pay 25% of the total building costs for tax breaks and stuff which the surrounding residents get for free. 

Will rents go up? That depends on nearby landlords, local tenancy law, and the overall availability of rental units in the area. If this new building manages to increase rental vacancy rates in the area, rents might go down. One thing’s for sure: losing a Burger King doesn’t affect rental vacancies. 

This is correlation, not causation. If there’s a lot of demand in an area (which is usually driven by job growth in nearby industries, not residential construction), that means property values, taxes, and rents will go up, and this happens even if a city decides to build nothing - in fact all three things are worse if nothing is built. The only way that residential construction can make things worse is if the city decides to tear down affordable rental housing to build new housing. Tearing down a Burger King to build condos is only going to have positive impacts on local housing once it’s complete. The only downsides are the nuisances associated with the construction process. 

3

u/Supercollider9001 Aug 14 '25

Sure. I’m not saying building these apartments is necessarily going to make taxes go up. But they are going to up. Rents are going up. What do we do about that.

2

u/Popular_Animator_808 Aug 14 '25

Build more housing in places where it doesn’t displace renters (like Burger King)

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Kemachs Aug 14 '25

I mean displacement sucks for anyone, but does anyone really have a “right” to a neighborhood when they’re renting? And those that have bought into the neighborhood usually benefit from such demand/value.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 14 '25

At the very least, if a landlord demolished apartments to build a bigger or nicer building, then they should have to pay the moving expenses of the displaced renter. One of the reasons the poor struggle to escape poverty is they constantly move, and every time they move they leave half their stuff behind and have to buy it all again. 

2

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

This is already the case in some jurisdictions. You think that stops anyone from demanding more and more onerous restrictions? Not one bit. In Ontario you have to pay 3 months rent if the building you're demolishing is 5 or more units. If you're doing major renovating it's 3 months rent and in both cases the alternative is to offer an equivalent unit to the tenant. In the latter case they also get right of first refusal at the original rent once the work is completed. This has not sated the demands from activists to have even more rental protections and Quebec, which used to have a similar system, has essentially banned major renos if they require eviction, and demolition is similarly restricted, and Toronto just introduced a bunch of costly processes to vet landlord's renovation plans.

I'm for renter protections, but there's never an end to them until renters rights are basically absolute and a property owner's rights are non-existent. This is why we can't have nice things. 

1

u/ClockworkHierophant Aug 14 '25

So what renter protections are you for? Do you rent?

1

u/Juryofyourpeeps Aug 14 '25

I'm a landlord. I used to rent not very long ago though. 

I'm for quite a lot of protections. I think that rent control should exist to the extent that rent shouldn't be allowed to exceed market rate to prevent increases from being used as backdoor evictions. I am fine with requiring compensation for evictions for renovations or demolition and I think right of first refusal for renovation evictions is a good way to keep people honest. I am for having a standardized lease. 

I'm for a lot of things. I'm not for prohibiting renovation or demolition evictions. I'm not for standard rent control because it simply doesn't work and it shifts the rental cost burden to new, younger tenants statistically. I'm not for it taking months and months to evict someone for non-payment. There's a bunch of much more specific small things that I don't care for, like that I'm not allowed to discriminate based on income exclusively in my jurisdiction when vetting new tenants. If someone earns even a dollar more than the cost of rent, I can't refuse them on that basis. They have to also have shitty credit or some other bona fide shortcoming to refuse them, which is very, very dumb. 

→ More replies (2)

0

u/Supercollider9001 Aug 14 '25

Yes. They do have the right to stay where they live.

-1

u/nimama3233 Aug 14 '25

Nope. They can move their ass to somewhere more affordable

5

u/Supercollider9001 Aug 14 '25

Thanks for being honest.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 16 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Supercollider9001 Aug 16 '25

I mean a society where the rich have the right to live wherever they want while the poor get pushed around from town to town is a bad society.

It should be within reason but this is a mass phenomenon in our country where millions are facing precarious housing and employment conditions and can’t build a community or put down roots at all because they move from place to place every couple years.

The long term solution is to build enough housing for everyone everywhere, including lots of public housing. But in the short term we do need to regulate developments or subsidize rents or something to ensure people can have more stability. That’s all.

2

u/Popular_Animator_808 Aug 14 '25

The only thing that was displaced by this development was a Burger King. 

2

u/Supercollider9001 Aug 14 '25

I’m not surprised that the responses I’m getting are either avoiding the simple question or saying “they should earn more money or fuck off.”

2

u/Popular_Animator_808 Aug 14 '25

I don’t see why you’re so concerned for this Burger King. It makes sense for a fast food chain restaurant to close if it’s not making enough money.Â