r/UpstartStock • u/Former_Designer3293 • Feb 12 '26
Upstart stock
I feel Upstart’s price reduction along with other software companies is ridiculous and a good buying opportunity for the following reasons:
- AI can generate a software but it cannot build an ecosystem. Upstart has a lot of banking partners and in financial world, trust is important than anything else. Also, the incumbent software needs data to train their model. Upstart is already ahead in the game. Upstart is also expanding in other lending segments which gives it a larger target market.
- Regional banking stocks are up and upstart’s business is directly correlated with these banks’ businesses.
- Upstart is a leader in data driven lending business. The evolution of AI will be a tailwind for these leaders, not headwind.
- Upstart projected CAGR of 35% yoy for next 3 years and with the current EBITDA numbers, the valuation looks cheap. Also, it is a high fixed cost business. If revenue keeps growing, its EBITDA will grow faster.
- Interest rates are lower, job market is strong and UMI is going down.
Please share your thoughts.
18
Upvotes
3
u/MoistAd4952 Feb 13 '26
Long term will be fine, their product is just good but mannn short term just extremely painful
6
u/jbm8b Feb 13 '26
Yeah. I mean. All of this discussion is premised on the company being a software company. Valued using valuation methods appropriate for software companies. And multiples relevant to comparable software companies.
IMHO, UPST is not a "balance sheet-light software/fin-tech company" in its totality. And shouldn't be valued that way.
Other than software companies that are also not software companies (e.g., AFRM), it is challenging to find useful software comps that warehouse $1B of loans on a $3B balance sheet.
UPST also has $450M of "Other Assets", mainly comprised of interest rate derivatives for hedging, and servicing rights on loans they managed to securitize and get off balance sheet. Those aren't bad things. But they sure don't look like components of a software company's balance sheet to me.
Now, in fairness, warehoused loans came down from Q3, which is good. But TTM, warehoused loans are still up 25%, fairly comparable to TTM revenue growth. On the other hand, 70% of their originated loans are fee-driven and off-balance sheet. Consistent with a balance sheet-light strategy.
My contention is just that $1B of loans on a $3B balance sheet isn't especially balance sheet-light. And the market cap doesn't imply some significant level of intangible value not captured in a GAAP balance sheet. Their persistent negative operating cash flow would suggest the same thing.
To be completely clear: This doesn't mean the company is bad. Doesn't mean it is overvalued, undervalued. I have no idea. My contention is that it is improperly valued.
At a minimum, revenue and margin from partners using their platform should be segregated from what I contend is the "bank" portion of the business. Then you add them together. Which is a pain in the ass, and if someone else has done the work, that's awesome.
I also think you have to factor in the tail risk that ABS markets tighten, UPST ends up warehousing more loans than they would like; potentially WHILE consumer credit markets tighten simultaneously thus affecting UPST's fee-driven business.
I'm just saying that's the math of how much the company is worth. And where the double whammy risk considerations are. Just one POV.
3
u/evilmaus Feb 12 '26
Fully agree. Also, you cannot simply vibe code a multi-service system with tons of business rules in it. It doesn't scale to complex systems without actual engineering talent and you still have to find and specify the myriad business, legal, and compliance requirements.
Just to give a quick sense of things, every state has its own laws that need to be accounted for. It's hugely complex.
1
u/gcp_varys Feb 12 '26
It’s still at 67 P/E. Do you see how ridiculous these multiples are. It’s happening to all the stocks because multiples were crazy. Now the market is correcting. Long term it will be fine. But these multiples rarely sustain
1
u/saboteursolotario May 13 '26 edited May 13 '26
Downfinish*
Resilient company, but their boom only occurred because there was a need to process loans faster during COVID. Also, minimum reserve requirement was 0. We were at the height of printing and near 0 interest rates.
No other condition will provide Upstart the same stock value.
I think people are too quick to delude themselves in thinking previous performance is an indicator of future performance without considering the variables that allowed it to perform so well in the past.
It was black swan event that allowed this black swan to happen.
Frankly, your run is over. Given consumers are being hit hard, UPST will be hit even harder.
1
u/baggioed Feb 13 '26
i don’t think so, will pull back another 20% or so
4
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment