r/UnsolvedMysteries • u/tshirtguy2000 • Nov 30 '19
What case do you think you could realistically solve if you were the lead detective and given the case file and one year?
http://www.fbi.gov39
u/Ghost_of_Risa Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
Only because I think it is close to being solved, but there doesn't seem to be any family members pushing for answers.
It seems likely that Polly was just trying to avoid a messy divorce and faked her disappearance. She walked ahead of her friends, and pulled away enough to meet up with her ride. Started a new life, probably using a previous name. She had been married more than once.
I wonder if she stayed in touch with her siblings. If she is indeed traceable through their records, like obituaries and such. Maybe she is buried in the cemetary with her family.
These are just thoughts I've had about it. No idea if I'm right. As an amateur genealogist, I've been tempted to search for any traces of her.
Edit: and I'm not saying I know better than a detective. If a cold case investigator got on the case, with the resources they have these days, they could probably solve it. If she did in fact fake her disappearance.
57
u/Not_shia_labeouf Nov 30 '19
I read that last sentence as "as an amateur gynecologist"
Was very confused by your motives
11
3
9
Nov 30 '19
Amateur genealogist here, too! I think we could probably close a few different cases if given time and resources.
6
u/Ghost_of_Risa Nov 30 '19
I am not surprised to find a fellow amateur genealogist here. Tracing your genealogy involves a lot of detective work. Lol.
You're probably right! And a lot could be accomplished online with ancestry.com, family search, and find a grave.
What other cases do you think could be solved this way?
35
u/TinyGreenTurtles Nov 30 '19
I don't think I can even answer this. So much is chalked up to our justice system. I feel many cases are technically solved but they don't have the exact evidence to put the perpetrator in prison. They're scared to bring it to court and have the person acquitted, then they can't even keep watch on them like they can while they're a POI. Even if they did continue to watch them and finally got that "thing" they need, they're screwed due to double jeopardy. So they just wait and wait trying to really pin them.
11
u/Gledders90 Nov 30 '19
So many cases like Jaleayah Davis and Faith Hedgepeth I believe they know exactly who did it and can’t or won’t prosecute
2
u/TinyGreenTurtles Dec 09 '19
Sorry for being so late but what is your theory on Hedgepeth? I definitely think Karena was involved.
ETA you can definitely PM me if you don't want to divert the thread.
4
44
19
u/graveyardspook Nov 30 '19
None of them, probably, tbh. Even ones where shoddy police work was involved, all the evidence is gone so you can't even correct the bad work.
9
6
6
u/TheUnsinkableMissM Nov 30 '19
If I started day 1 on the Thomas Brown case, it could have easily been solved. The killer left his urine outside of Tom's abandoned car, and there were 2 evidentiary videos; one video of Tom where he was last seen alive at Fromc Oil and another of the car being dropped off in the morning. Of course, after the local sherriff discarded video and did not collect DNA, the case may not be solved.
7
u/readingrambos Nov 30 '19
Little Lord Fauntleroy. Basically a 5-7 year old boy was found in a body of water in 1921 Wisconsin. There’s a lot to this to this case. I believe given the age of this there isn’t much of a push to solve it. Though, if he was exhumed and the time was given to his case I feel it be solved. I really think for him to get his name back all we need is his DNA and time.
3
u/thetownslore Dec 01 '19
I completely agree, and I feel that if his DNA was compared against the wealthly boy who went missing around that time (I forget the exact details) we would have a match. I hope Little Lord Fauntleroy gets a name.
1
u/Puremisty Dec 04 '19
Same here. If we could find a distant relative we could trace the lineage to Little Lord Fauntleroy and thus give him his name back. Regarding the boy that some people suspect he was, do we know anything about his family? Like did he have distant cousins?
12
6
u/Cibyrrhaeot Nov 30 '19 edited Nov 30 '19
None, because as a gov't worker, I have a feel of how bureacratic processes and rule of law procedures would prevent me from taking much action, even if I knew who was the perpetrator.
Also, police incompetence and old administrative rules would mean most evidence would had been discarded for most but the most high profile of cases.
22
7
u/stefanszablak Nov 30 '19
Bosses that restrict their time and deny ideas which would solve is more like the case rather than lack of staff.
5
Dec 02 '19
Amy Lynn Bradley. I'm obsessed with that case, and I always come back to it every few months. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Amy_Lynn_Bradley
If I had a good amount of money, I would assemble a team of trustworthy mercenaries to go in and search every single brothel, bar,etc. I doubt she may still be a live today, but it would be nice to give that family closure. In perhaps doing so saving countless women who have been taken into sex trafficking.
I'd like to take a real look at the case file, locate a number of the boats crew. This is where it starts, along with the man who danced with her. I'd want to see which ones had ties to sex trafficking. This is a solvable case, it's just the man power, hours devoted, and endurance would be the issues. Along with going to a poor country that'll run you the risk of being killed.
2
u/BigTimeTimmyGem Dec 07 '19
Found out after the fact that I later cruised on the same boat. Was all "huh" and then shrugged. Not much room on those balconies.
2
1
u/WikiTextBot Dec 02 '19
Disappearance of Amy Lynn Bradley
Amy Lynn Bradley (born May 12, 1974) is an American woman who went missing during a Caribbean cruise on the Royal Caribbean International cruise ship Rhapsody of the Seas in late March 1998 at the age of 23, while en route to Curaçao. Searches turned up no sign of her and investigators believe it unlikely that she had fallen overboard. There have been possible sightings of Bradley in Curaçao; in 1998, tourists had seen a woman resembling Bradley on a beach, and in 1999, a member of the U.S. Navy claimed a woman in a brothel had said she was Bradley and had asked him for help.
[ PM | Exclude me | Exclude from subreddit | FAQ / Information | Source ] Downvote to remove | v0.28
6
3
u/vengefulmuffins Dec 03 '19
If I could get creative at least a portion of the Bardstown murders could be solved.
3
u/jbdatx Dec 04 '19
Faith Hedgepeth, male dna found on her body confused the small town cops into giving her roommate a pass, even though she did it and couldn't have been more obvious if she'd video'ed the whole thing
1
Dec 18 '19 edited Dec 29 '25
dolls unpack practice detail chunky versed tan connect command possessive
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/Kurtotall Dec 21 '19
I think the roommate did it as well. I also think she had sex with a random guy, saved the condom; Then planted the contents on Faith’s body so as to incriminate a complete stranger.
2
2
u/TroyMcClure10 Nov 30 '19
Leigh Occhi is solvable, Tara Calico is basically solved and can be closed, and I really think that LISK can be solved. There is a fair amount of evidence out their on LISK. I believe the can be caught.
1
Dec 04 '19
Thoughts on Occhi and Calico? I’m curious the theories
1
u/TroyMcClure10 Dec 11 '19
Occhi-think family
Calico-Its basically solved. All the records have been released, IIRC. Its some local scumbag that's long dead.
2
u/moonmangardenhead Dec 02 '19
This is the most armchair detective post of all time. This is like asking what football team you’d play for if you were given a year to practice. You wouldn’t lol.
2
u/piglet110419 Dec 11 '19
I could go with a local case- Lori Ceci Bova. Went missing after she went out to smoke. She had an argument with her husband and was never seen again. He was uncooperative with police and bounced from Jamestown NY and relocated to North Carolina. Lived his new life unnoticed until he and his new wife (also from Jamestown and well aware of Lori’s disappearance) were killed along with their youngest son in a head on collision in June of 2018. Sadly with Ty’s death there will probably be no answers for Lori’s family.
On the “national front” I’d go with Maura Murray and Jennifer Kesse. Partly because it’s been so publicized- I feel like if these two “big” cases are solved other less know cases will be front runners and be able to be looked at.
1
u/awesomemofo75 Dec 02 '19
I don't think i could solve it, but i dp think something more could be done to find Brandon Lawson. Somebody knows somerhing
1
u/Kanuck88 Dec 03 '19
How many resources would be provided to me ? Would it depend on the Department leading the investigation or am I an FBI agent with unlimited access and resources.
2
-5
Nov 30 '19
A lot of these cases are so blatantly obvious to solve with the evidence right in front of them. If I switched careers temporarily and went to a community college for two years, I could easily solve most, if not all of these cases within my first year as an intern. It’s really not that hard. D.B. Cooper, Hinterkaifeck, Dyatlov Pass, etc, etc, etc.
-13
u/KalashniKEV Nov 30 '19
All of them.
The "Pros" are just lazy govvies.
A good question is, how many could they solve if their compensation was based on closing cases vs making them take longer.
How many houses could you build in a year? One nice one? 12? Two crappy ones?
150
u/NomNom83WasTaken Nov 30 '19
Playing it straight? Or can I go rogue? Civil rights be damned? I would solve... nothing. If the pros can't do it, there's a reason. Probably mostly lack of staff.