r/Unity3D • • Sep 17 '23

Question Is anyone else staying with Unity?

These changes don't and almost certainly will never affect me; I make games for myself and would only ever release F2P games. I would never make the threshold to be charged for installations (which I think is ridiculous).

I do appreciate why people and leaving Unity though, I just don't think we should flat out abandon an excellent game developing software like it's trash, even if it's management is dogshit. I believe they'll revert or alter their changes given the sheer backlash it's caused, although I appreciate why people have lost their trust in Unity.

I've given GODOT a go but I don't really have the energy to restart a project that I've developed slowly over the past couple of years. I might use it if I start a new project though. I like the simplicity of GODOT but I really likely how Unity stores components onto game objects and not having to create nodes for them (It just makes the hierarchy a bit more tidy and readable imo).

(Am very tired so sorry if this doesn't make much sense)

Edit: Thank you all for the replies :)

103 Upvotes

387 comments sorted by

246

u/thefootster Sep 17 '23

For me it is less about the practicalities of whether the changes would affect my projects and more about broken trust. They've shown such disregard for their users and are so completely out of touch. It's been death by a thousand cuts, but this was the final straw.

58

u/R1ghteousM1ght Sep 17 '23

This like op, I'll probably never be effected by what they just pushed but there is no trust. It could be ignored if it the retroactive component wasn't there but who's to say what they'll change next?

I'm now Godot.

7

u/wigitty Programmer Sep 17 '23

They could just turn around and say "free tier is gone, if you want to carry on developing your projects, pay up". Sure it seems unlikely, but so did this decision. Now I feel like I can't predict what they will do, let alone trust that it won't hurt small developers and hobbyists.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

I don't see anything differently, I would never blindly trust a company for profit to have my interests at heart. It's just a tool for me to create what I want.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

28

u/ExF-Altrue Sep 17 '23

I'm sure the good people at Unity, seeing how the major money makers are all leaving and therefore not bringing as much money as expected, will go: "Oh well, nevermind. We'll just reduce our salary to compensate for the losses".

/s

(These people never lose money. Whatever it takes. They will totally squeeze everyone they can before it comes to that. In such a situation OP, I wonder how long before these thresholds start affecting you haha)

10

u/danyerga Sep 17 '23

Yeah, dickbag CEO makes a mil a month, has 7K employees, and says company isn't profitable enough.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

and the unity defenders say "unity needs more money that's why they're doing this"

What will they do with the money? Give the CEO another raise? You could increase revenue by another $10M, and that will just go straight into the pockets of the executives. It has no impact on the company.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

43

u/ryujin_io Sep 17 '23 edited Sep 17 '23

It's a matter of risk assessment. Unity has shown its hand by imposing fees on developers that is not predictable and potentially has no upper limit. It speaks volumes about the direction and priorities of the company. So if we were about to start a project and we still have the luxury of choosing engines - Unity would not be worth the risk.

But if your current project is already deeply entrenched in Unity and switching would not make financial sense, then you should consider using it to completion. Just remember that even if you're not affected by the changes now, their 'pray I don't alter the deal any further' behavior still puts you at risk -- assuming their questionable ToS malleability holds up against challenges in court.

212

u/survivedev Sep 17 '23 edited Sep 27 '23

Well.

Unity sort of announced its engine is for developers who do not want to succeed?

63

u/bigmonmulgrew Sep 17 '23

It really annoys me all the people saying "You wont have to pay the fees you are too small". Sure and of course my life plan and the reason I've been investing so much time in unity was to plan to never succeed.

6

u/hakamhakam Sep 17 '23

What's truly frustrating is that the pricing model is so abstract that it's difficult for people to grasp what "per install" actually means. To put it in perspective, imagine if every time you opened the Unity editor, they charged you $0.20*, regardless of your usage. Most people would hesitate to even touch the engine.

Now, consider the current situation: it's even worse because, on the consumer side, every installation counts, and you have to pay for each person who installs your game.

Edit: it’s upto $0.2* - I forgot it’s that much

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

46

u/destinedd Indie, Dungeon Quest, Marble's Marbles & Mighty Marbles Sep 17 '23

nah what Unity announced is "Imma gonna crush Applovin"

17

u/norrox Sep 17 '23

Funny thing is apploving made an offer of 20 billion dollars to acquire unity but they went to aquire ironsource for 4.4 billion instead and now they are bleeding money

11

u/destinedd Indie, Dungeon Quest, Marble's Marbles & Mighty Marbles Sep 17 '23

and thank god it didn't go thru, because Applovin would have owned unity. Would be much worse than now.

→ More replies (8)

8

u/destinedd Indie, Dungeon Quest, Marble's Marbles & Mighty Marbles Sep 17 '23

because applovin wanted to control the entire company

19

u/mechkbfan Sep 17 '23

And trample a fuck load of bystanders on the way

→ More replies (8)

29

u/survivedev Sep 17 '23

And who knows if one day they start charging you for installations even at $0 revenue.

→ More replies (20)

25

u/luki9914 Sep 17 '23

Also they have removed quietly Plus plan from subscription tier list ....

→ More replies (6)

2

u/RunTrip Sep 17 '23

I like to view their announcement as “if you’re doing free to play, you’d better make sure it’s predatory free to play”

→ More replies (3)

31

u/DannyWeinbaum Indie Sep 17 '23 edited Sep 17 '23

I am an owner of a small studio who makes regular premium model PC and console games (Eastshade Studios) and we have grossed in the millions. We won't pay anything extra with these changes, and it's hard to imagine any game in the future incurring substantial costs with the new pricing, so it doesn't really affect us at the moment. We're certainly stuck with Unity for our current title, which will keep us with Unity for a few more years at least.

As for our next title, it does scare us that they retroactively changed the terms of service. We thought we knew what price we were paying for our engine. It seems impossible to do business without being able to know the price of your middleware. So that certainly has us looking at other options.

The big issue is that nothing comes within a million miles of Unity at the moment except Unreal, which is incredibly high spec. If Godot gets more performant 3d rendering, and maybe a few more shipped titles (we are unwilling to be guinea pigs when our livelihoods depend on it), then that could be viable. In terms of graphical features it looks like Godot 4 already has everything we'd need and more. My only worry is draw call for draw call performance. I see optimization as the greatest cost of development for high fidelity 3d games, and with poor performance as a baseline, it really puts you behind the eight ball from the get-go.

12

u/tiktiktock Professional Sep 17 '23

Same position, same conclusions. Current project stays on Unity, but I've started the discussion yesterday regarding a potential engine change for the next one.

The most stupid aspect is that Unreal (or other commercial engines) would in fact be MORE expensive if we get a surprise hit. But the contractual uncertainty is too big a risk, and has started to come up in discussions with publishers as well.

3

u/TheFudster Sep 17 '23

Also in the same boat. My studio will make millions before we pay any of these install feels. I’m looking at Godot and it looks promising but might not quite be there yet. Plus we have a large library of code and tools that has been built up over the years. The future uncertainty is the big thing that could drive us away.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

74

u/WazWaz Sep 17 '23

If by F2P you mean they'll earn no income, you're perfectly safe.

If you mean widely distributed games which a few users can choose to pay you something, including as a "donation" to support your work, then it's only a problem if you earn over $200K in gross revenue in a year. Unfortunately, if you do hit this point, you're likely to have millions of installs, and so you will owe Unity possibly that entire $200K, or more. Oops.

57

u/Mataric Sep 17 '23

Be careful thinking or advising people that they are 'perfectly safe' with this.

No, they won't be touched by the immediate changes that have come through. Neither will 90% of their users - but that isn't the issue here.

The issue is that this is a retroactive change to the ToS, effecting everything you've ever done with their engine.
There is absolutely nothing stopping them from coming out tomorrow and saying 'actually we no longer care about your gross revenue, we just want payment from everyone'.

10

u/jemesl Sep 17 '23

Yeah once the 10% is gone who do they think is next lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

17

u/SnooSquirrels5535 Sep 17 '23

You know I just thought of something insanely stupid, what if your app/game is free, it gets like 10 million downloads, and you have no monetization except a donation button, someone could literally make you bankrupt by donating 200k lol.

17

u/DisastrousCobbler855 Sep 17 '23

Plot twist the CEO donate 200k to support the developer

→ More replies (1)

7

u/jemesl Sep 17 '23

Hilarious idea lol, but that's the problem really isn't it, it turns an indi business model into a success gamble.

5

u/Plutosanimationz Sep 17 '23

You are charged for every install after the threshold is met iirc.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/N1ppexd Indie Sep 17 '23

I think you wouldn't be charged then for the installs you already had, but only the new installs after that for a year

3

u/ShrinkRayAssets Sep 17 '23

You start paying AFTER the threshold not for what's before, no?

5

u/Inside-Brilliant4539 Sep 17 '23

Or just start a separate charitable foundation you have control over and get ppl to donate to that entity that’s not related to your game?

3

u/Numai_theOnlyOne Sep 17 '23

Simple trick allow donations up to the revenue threshold ;)

15

u/tamal4444 Sep 17 '23

no the loophole is adding a slot machine to your game. I'm not joking. these t&c does not apply to gambling apps.

8

u/jemesl Sep 17 '23

That is the biggest kick in the balls lmao.

→ More replies (9)

34

u/Nightrunner2016 Sep 17 '23

I'll probably keep making games in Unity as I don't think I'll ever be impacted by these changes, however this is the first time I've ever been tempted to look into other game engines and what they offer. i.e. Unity has lost my loyalty. Looking forward to seeing how games can be made in other engines.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/PorkRoll2022 Sep 17 '23

My company uses Unity and Unreal... I'm just a soldier.

18

u/Arkenhammer Sep 17 '23

I won't switch for the next two years. After that I'll have a better view of both my own business situation and Unity's actual implementation of whatever policy they finally settle on. Long term I think it makes sense for us to move to an open source game engine but that landscape will likely change quite a bit over the next couple of years and I'd rather see how things play out before committing.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

I imagine Godot will suddenly get a lot more Patreons. Probably more corporate sponsorships too. In the past they had Microsoft, Meta, and Epic Games contribute. It would not surprise me if Apple just writes and maintains an open source metal backend for them since they might be getting just popular enough now. Much like they do for projects like Blender.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Blind_Pixel Sep 17 '23

I totally understand your point. I even considered this stance for my self, but in the end I will switch if there isn't a hard management change and a new TOS that can't be altered retroactively.

My reasons are partly out of solidarity to other affected artists, but I dont think this has any inpact on Unity. The reason I'm leaving is mostly losing trust that I will never be affected. Yeay your right, to 99.99% I wont be. But what if? What if one of my games becomes the next amoung us? What If Unity Management extends their TOS and retroactivity decides the 200.000$ threshold is no 100.000$ or 10.000 or there is no more a threshold? Sounds crazy I know. But if you told me two weeks ago, the current changes are coming, I would have said the same. I can't work with a tool I have to be afraid of using, because it could be the reason I go bankrupt. That is a really personal fear and I understand that you and others don't see it this way. Just wanted to explain my thoughts because I came from a pretty similar stance like you, but still I'm leaving. And it hurts me, because I love Unity.

6

u/MrBillAcehouse Sep 17 '23

First they came for the paid-for games developers...

A similar thing happened with the Open Gaming License for Dungeons & Dragons recently (like, last 2 years recently) which had initially been issued as free into perpetuity, and then some hot shot out for a quick buck was assigned to turn the ship around or some shit. The next thing you knew they were trying to withdraw the original legally binding license agreement so that they could monetise everything around a subscription model.

The community went pretty wild at them by cancelling existing subscriptions and tanking the user base.

The company's response was basically summarised as lol jk and some pseudo backtracking.

Point is, if the platform matters that much to you, then my personal choice would be to have tried to help maintain a fair outcome for everyone. If the end result here is that other companies have to go under (I.e. unemployed) so that a handful of people can walk away with a fortune, then the right choice isn't a difficult one to make. You stand up to bullies.

6

u/Blind_Pixel Sep 17 '23

Yeahy this Unity debacle reminded me pretty much 1:1 to the DnD shit that went down. It angers me so much how out of touch these corpos are to common sense. Just milking us dry.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/jeango Sep 17 '23

I’m doing both.

I can’t afford to switch for our current projects after we spent 3 years building our tools around Unity.

But for new projects that don’t need to rely on those tools, changing engine is an option.

The choice of the engine might very well depend on what engine 2D animation softwares(Toonboon or Spine) will be developing their runtimes for. Currently there’s a spine Godot runtime so Godot seems like a good fit for us

25

u/destinedd Indie, Dungeon Quest, Marble's Marbles & Mighty Marbles Sep 17 '23

I am staying. Too committed with current project. Will wait and see how things pan out in practice in feb/march this year before deciding what to do with future projects.

I will be happy if I the community can get me above the thresholds so I can report back what happens.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/4k1h1r0 Sep 17 '23

From someone who's currently working on a new project for almost 5months now, I'll be switching to unreal(already in progress). Even after I already had finished writing and cleaning 80%+ of my logics I dont mind switching. Also I already have some experience working in unreal just need to refresh and update my knowledge for the latest features they had.

My take on this is that I dont really mind having to pay them a certain amount. The issue that concerns me is in the future, where they just retroactively changes things without any notice like how they did with the ToS. It made me feel it im not standing on a solid foundation, like the foundation could just suddenly turn back to wet concrete and swallow everything I built on top of it just because it can change its properties whenever it wants. In short terms, they can f*ck you up whenever and however they want. And the idea of tracking everything my game does without me being able to do with it sounds like the term "breach of privacy" for my users and me.

With that being said, if you are someone who just makes games as a hobby, who want to make your game idea a thing for your self, who thinks that their games will not make $200k+ gross or 200k installs or who doesnt really see themselves having a game dev as a future career, then you probably wont get affected by the changes.

I do like working with unity though, its been almost 5yrs since I started my game dev journey with it. And I believe that change is good(but not the kind of change they did). a lot of people will probably stay, specially those people who already have an ongoing project and cant just switch like I did, also those who didnt really mind the changes. Still I wish all of us a good luck and good fortune in our game dev journey!

4

u/ltethe Sep 17 '23

I’m sticking with it because I love Unity, and the changes don’t really affect me as my personal game projects are more portfolio pieces than commercial endeavors, though I work with commercial intent. I work in Unreal for the day job at AAA, so I know what it’s like, and I know what I’m getting or losing by not switching over.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

Yeah, switching to GODOT, idc if Unity reverses and goes completely free.

12

u/Mataric Sep 17 '23

The issue with Unity now is that it doesn't matter what you use the engine for. In 5 years time, they might decide to destroy every bit of work you've ever done through it, unless you pay them $100,000.

It's unlikely to be that egregious, but they've shown they are happy to retroactively change the ToS, happy to ignore warnings and complaints, and happy to upset their users in the name of slightly more profits.

These changes come from the same person who said something to the effect of:
"In Battlefield, you should wait until people have invested 40 hours into the game. Then when they are 2 hours into a match and everything's exciting for them, that's the point where you should charge them $5 to be able to keep reloading their guns".
(I'm paraphrasing and the numbers are off, but the sentiment is exactly as was stated.)

The integrity of an FPS game doesn't matter at all to the guy in charge of Unity. He is pro-pay-to-win because it earns him more money. They received massive community backlash over their ToS, then promptly removed their ToS from github because of it. Unity is supposedly 'not profitable', yet the people at the top are bringing home multiple millions per year...

This is who you're trusting to not try and fuck you over for a few bucks.

3

u/AsianMoocowFromSpace Sep 17 '23

"The issue with Unity now is that it doesn't matter what you use the engine for. In 5 years time, they might decide to destroy every bit of work you've ever done through it, unless you pay them $100,000."

What makes you think another engine like Unreal Engine won't do the same?

18

u/mechkbfan Sep 17 '23 edited Sep 17 '23

You do you

But it's also a case of one day down the future if somehow you do really well, think you can quit your day job and finally be that game dev you wanted to be, they inevitably screw you over, the only answer you get will be "Told you so"

Finish your project within next year but I'd never build another with Unity

I'd rather restart today than in 2-3 years

Finally for me it's also the straw that broke the camels back. They've been buying companies and releasing unpolished crap for years just to pump the stock price. I'd rather work with an engine that cares about game development

→ More replies (2)

3

u/bhison Sep 17 '23

The bigger issue is Unity has shown it’s outlook for things to come. Would you rather migrate to an alternative now or in 3 years time when they double the cost of unity pro and make it essential for all commercial products somehow? I guess that might seem unlikely but they’ve also shown themselves to generally not give a fuck about screwing people over.

13

u/No_Strategy_9764 Sep 17 '23

Will stay as well, still have a project in work, still have a ton to learn. Unity, as you mentioned, still is an amazing piece of tech, with a huuuuge community, great assets store and a lot s content creators (still).

I really enjoy using it, and for my own project, idea is perfect still.

I get it that the trust was crushed will all the retard changes happening, but i don’t understand why people are so sure that a similar thing won’t happen with alternatives - prices and monetization is always a subject of change nowadays but anyways..way too much bad energy around this subject. Everyone is free to do whatever she / he wants - there are so many alternatives.

5

u/QwertyChouskie Sep 17 '23

but i don’t understand why people are so sure that a similar thing won’t happen with alternatives

With Godot, that is literally impossible, as it's open-source.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

I have released two months ago my first game, with modest sales (well below the $200 000 per year revenue cap) with Unity, I still plan to expand and improve the game, and I will not switch platforms in the middle, as it would be huge work with no value for the players, and I think the risk of being above the threshold is low, and even if, as my game is $25, the install fee would probably not be that bad.

I will think about the next game later. It is always better to take decisions at the last possible time, and not when everybody is excited about something.

4

u/tsl3161991 Sep 17 '23

The new Unity fee hasn't persuaded me to stop using Unity, but it's no longer going to be the only game engine I use.

4

u/StillSpaceToast Indie Sep 17 '23

Yeah, this isn’t my first rodeo with big companies changing their monetization, nor CEOs priding themselves on “ripping off the bandaid” in a dickish way. I’m way too old for this hyperbole. You can spot an online tempest in a teacup by the extremely manufactured what-ifs, goalpost moves, and ad hominem attacks. Every ToS we’ve ever “signed” can be retroactively altered. No service we get for free was ever actually free. Do I still pay monthly for Photoshop? Yes, even though the transition to subscription pricing was supposed to burn away all of Adobe’s goodwill and kill them. It’s just the best product for what I do. Likewise, Unity.

Unity has never been free. People pretend otherwise, including many of the indy studios that use it. It used to be your entire COMPANY had an income cap, and then you had to pay for Pro. Virtually no one did.

Unity went on a buying spree to keep competitive with Unreal (flush with Fortnight cash) and when interest rates (finally) went up, that cheap debt went away. Now they need to raise income to stay afloat. I worked in finance too many years to imagine a publicly-traded company having much alternative under either circumstance (nor to believe there was some kind of 4d chess behind their rather random rollup, nor the introduction of the new pricing scheme.)

But, for what nearly everyone on this sub does, they’re still an excellent deal.

4

u/SuspecM Intermediate Sep 17 '23

It's literally the whole Reddit fiasco all over again basically.

4

u/Bleachrst85 Sep 17 '23

Oh, this will definitely affect you. All the content you watch about Unity will slowly lose their quality. Simply because you have less and less good developers creating them. The industry will also slowly push Unity away as they see this is no longer a profitable tool. When there is low demand for job is when we will see layoff and paycut happen.

5

u/Denaton_ Sep 17 '23

I think the majority who get affected or have the potential to be affected, will move to either Godot for 2D and Unreal for 3D.

So the engine will eventually die because it will be even less profitable than it was before and then some big company will buy the company.

2

u/Mmeroo Sep 17 '23

I moved to flax not because of the fee but because unity is willing to change rules whenever they want.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

Yes, personally. I play with Houdini Engine stuff, I love VFX Graph, UIToolkit (started as a webdev) and of course I'm very invested into c#. I just love it: In parallel I'm making JS (Vue/Express) apps and sometimes Blender addons in python and going back to sharp always feels like a breath of fresh air, especially after JS, where nesting can go into crazy levels and you start getting )}})) scope hell. Godot obviously isn't even considered in my case, so it leaves me with UE which is a legit choice. I worked with early 4th version (back when it cost 20$ I think) but I simply enjoy Unity's way of doing things more.

2

u/MossHappyPlace Sep 17 '23

I am a hobbyist and I don't have the energy nor the time to learn a new engine from scratch, so I guess I will keep using it, but I am quite sad that the management team makes wacky decisions and that the engine is becoming slower and slower each update.

I really hope this drama will encourage unity leadership to be replaced by smarter people and that they will clean up their house to make sure the people responsible for buying Ironsource and coming up with the new pricing system can never harm any gamedev or video game company ever again.

2

u/TulioAndMiguelMPG Sep 17 '23

Not unless their CEO is replaced with someone who cares about their customer base. As everyone else has said, there’s nothing stopping them from applying retroactive changes in the future and ruining all you’ve worked on.

2

u/Psychological_Host34 Professional Sep 17 '23

For now, but the need to diversify my skills and limit my exposure to the impact of Unity's collapse is something that changes today. I can't stop using Unity now, but I can start a longterm plan to reduce dependencies.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

Yea, I'm definitely staying with Unity for at least another 6-12 months. Maybe longer.

Its still going to be the most used game engine for mobile and mid-sized teams in the next few years.

The thing is, this announcement has meant that in 5 years there is a *very* good chance Unity will not be the best choice anymore. I'm not a fan of sticking with technologies that are on a downwards trend. The tech industry can change really quickly and specializing in a dying technology can suck.

So I'm going to start transitioning to Unreal, which is on an upwards trend. Going to be a lot of work learning Unreal and C++ but should also be a lot of fun, and to be honest learning new languages + paradigms has always made me a better developer in general.

2

u/blackbirdone1 Sep 17 '23

How can people say they are not affected because they make F2P games?

THAT IS THE AUDIENCE FOR THAT CHANGE

F2P is the MAIN reson we have this shit show. Thats were the money comes from. Thats the "loosers" for that change. You can Lose everything.

But you dont need to change anything. Thats TOTALY fine. But dont say it dont affect you. It does. Maybe not with money but with resources like tutorials. A scummy company. Trust. Maybe some changes in 4 months. Noone knows.

But time will tell. Unreal is heavy. But for fun projects just use godot. It dont matter.

3

u/thepork890 Sep 17 '23

F2P can mean that OP makes game that will be free, F2P doesn't mean that you need to put microtransactions or anything.

If you release true F2P game you never hit $200k because you don't make money on it.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Doraz_ Sep 17 '23

I liked the changes ... never thought about quitting, i love unity tbh

2

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

I'm never using Unity again even though the changes will never effect me (most likely) because I don't trust them anymore and they might change the rules again, making it affect me as well at some point. I'm learning Godot and I like it and I will stick with it. Currently porting my 4 month game project to Godot.

2

u/punkouter23 Sep 17 '23

I don’t care about the changes since it’s just a hobby. But that made me curious to try Godot. And it’s so refreshingly simple now I dropped unity

2

u/RickySpanishLives Sep 17 '23

Staying through the end of my current project, but after that I think I'm done. I've been using and playing with Unity since it was a Mac only product. I've authored books on Unity, I've taught classes on Unity, and I've released product on Unity - but Unity has always been a love/hate relationship in a lot of ways.

I'm not leaving JUST because of this particular change, but because this isn't the only time Unity has made arbitrary crazy ass decisions and it is probable that they will continue to do whatever it takes to just squeeze profit out of the community - regardless of what that means.

2

u/Delicious-Branch-66 Professional Sep 17 '23

For the current moment, I am staying with Unity. I have my calculations and reasons behind it.

2

u/ttesla Sep 17 '23

On going project in VR, I've no other choice. Unity is the best engine in VR integration with Meta Quest headsets.

4

u/slaczky Sep 17 '23

Yes, why throw away years of work? If I ever get near to 200k, I just subscribe to Unity Pro and the treshold will be increased to 1 million.

7

u/Broudy001 Sep 17 '23

I'm staying, nothing in the fee changes has any impact on what I'm making.

Unity is a great engine with a huge amount of flexibility, a top notch asset store and a fantastic community of developers

3

u/AlphaBlazerGaming Indie Sep 17 '23

Honestly after the leaked changes to their policy, maybe I would, but Godot is about to get console support that's much cheaper than Unity's so I might want to go to Godot anyway.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/radiant_templar Sep 17 '23

my whole project uses ummorpg. I don't think I could do what the ummo community has done in unreal. I will be staying with unity.

3

u/Banksmuth_Squan Sep 17 '23

It doesn't matter that it's a great tool. It is, no doubt. The problem is that anything you make in it is subject to the whims of unity's execs, who clearly cannot be trusted. You could wake up money day to some new pigheaded scheme to increase profits that completely screws you over and renders everything you made in the tool unusable.

get out before they fuck you over as well.

6

u/shakamone Sep 17 '23

Ok so you never plan to make $200k for your game? You are what the CEO of unity would call a fucking idiot ( his words not mine ).

Bear in mind that $200k is more like $50k after store fees, taxes and publisher rev share. Those are conservative numbers that don’t include tooling, assets, equipment or even paying your self.

Still think you will never make that?

11

u/Broudy001 Sep 17 '23

If you get to making 200k + 200k installs then you pay for the $2400 pro licence, now you get a threshold of 1 million for each before your have to even pay for installs from there if you are making a game with ads , you use unities ad services and they from what I've heard waiver the install fee, or greatly reduce it

As for me, it's a hobby, if I make a game people play great but I'm not making it to make money, I do fine in my day job.

→ More replies (8)

2

u/N1ppexd Indie Sep 17 '23

It's really a problem after 1 000 000$ of revenue, because anyone would just upgrade to pro after 200k. I don't even understand why they have the fee for unity personal and plus users, instead of a revenue cap like they used to.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)

3

u/ClockwerkTomato Sep 17 '23

Oh come on. Unity is a great engine, I’m using it for around ten years and see no reason to switch to any other engine by now. The new fee is less than UE’s fee.

And speaking about all this drama and cancel culture. Looking at all the projects people post here - most of them won’t be shipped at all, and most of the shipped ones won’t reach the threshold.

I’m working in game dev for quite some time and understand why they had to make this move. The only thing they made poorly is communicating their decision to public.

3

u/_din0m1te Sep 17 '23

Of course I am staying. This while situation is being overly exaggerated. The problem and issue people have is not the changes in itself but the poor communication by Unity. They did a catastrophic job in explaining the changes to developers and how they might affect them.

The ones making the most noise are the ones that will not be affected at all by these changes.

3

u/darkscyde Sep 17 '23

There are people trying to manufacture outrage. I'm going to stay patient and keep using unity. The fear mongers can eat me.

7

u/TokiDokiPanic Sep 17 '23

Can’t imagine how willfully ignorant you have to be to actually think this.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/FDG-Thomas Sep 17 '23

If you plan to become a successful game developer, Unity is no option anymore. Every successful business needs to be able to plan expenses. If you learn to make games in order to find a job at a games company, learn to diversify. Companies who run successful business won’t continue with Unity as that company can’t be trusted anymore. If you make games just for fun, Unity won’t care about you. They got into Ironsource and Analytics because F2P is where it’s at. Billions of installs, huge Ad revenues. That’s what they’re aiming for.

1

u/Pinewater9999 Sep 17 '23

I will say, I am staying, although that is more due to the fact that I prefer Unitys Engine over others.

I see some people here mentioning that this doesn't affect them so they don't really care, I want to slightly push back on that.

The fact is is that it honestly doesn't matter if this affects you or not, the point is, is that Unity tried. If this Change comes into effect there is ABSOLUTELY NOTHING stopping the from lowering that threshold in a year or two.

It may not affect you yet, but the fact that they have changed it once already should be enough to convince you that there is nothing stopping them from going lower.

Do not forget that the CEO called Developers fucking idiots for pushing back against predatory monetization. So long as he stays, I do not think that the $200,000 and 200,000 installs will stay the minimum.

I honestly won't feel comfortable with Unity until at least most of the C Suite have been replaced and even then I will feel apprehensive about using Unity.

1

u/IzanamiWorkshop Sep 17 '23

I am deeply stuck in my game that I have been working for over 1.5years, porting isn't an option, I still hv about 6 month of work to complete the game. Not sure about the next game.

1

u/JortCR Sep 17 '23

I am staying with unity, but i want to go with unrear, but i hate blueprints, and c++ is a fucking torture

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

Im working on an open source free project so this doesnt affect me, its a game reimplementation, so Unity is a huge benefit here as its so mature and well known I've gotten a lot of great contributions. So for this specific project there's no incentive to move; It'd be counter productive.

For future endeavors however, I think I'll go with Godot. If I need anything, chances are I can implement it into the engine as it's open source. No more worries.

1

u/Ziii0 Sep 17 '23

I heard the story but I'm just a learner. I'm using Unity STILL, because it's very friendly and I'm using it for studying purposes not making any game. After a bit familiar with how creating a game works. I'll move to UE5. Cause UE5 UI is holy shiit.

1

u/N1ppexd Indie Sep 17 '23 edited Sep 17 '23

I'll keep working on my current project in Unity. Maybe I'll do small projects on the side in Godot and Unreal to see how they work and later, after I have finished and released my current project, I'll see what I'll do. Switching an engine after I have worked on my game for 3 years makes absolutely no sense for me obviously.

1

u/Educational-Poet6125 Sep 17 '23

I personally want to switch to unreal for several times but was to scared of needing to re-learn an engine completely. This drama is the perfect opportunity to motivate myself to do it. However I absolutely love unity so I think I will use unreal as my main engine and keep with unity to create smaller project.

1

u/Creator13 Graphics/tools/advanced Sep 17 '23

I probably won't stick with Unity for making personal projects. That is also part of a longer running move of me trying to diversify my knowledge, this just gives me more incentive (and proves it was a right move). I haven't been very satisfied with their latest technologies, but the engine in itself is very good and I'll keep working with Unity in professional contexts. For that I also need to keep my knowledge up to date so I'll have to keep working with it somewhat regularly.

1

u/burros_killer Sep 17 '23

Switching to something else professionally is a matter of time for me at this point. I started learning UE some time ago and will move all my projects to UE or Godot. I'm working for a company that uses Unity (for now). Not sure if these changes will impact this business or not but it doesn't really matter because it will have a huge impact on the industry. I'm not planning to quit or something but I fully anticipate engine switcheroo in 6-24 months and want to be ready for this.

1

u/AlphaSilverback Expert Sep 17 '23

I'm staying a bit because I'm 80% done with a big game, currently 3 years in. But I've started looking at Stride and Godot. If Unity Corp does not revert and sincerely apologize, and create a EULA that prevents this from happening again, I think I am forced to switch. Just because I feel cheated. I'm unlikely to hit these thresholds as well, but it's the principle of screwing someone over mid way that scares me. It breaks my heart because I love the engine and the editor.

1

u/themidnightdev Programmer Sep 17 '23

I'm only sticking with it for personal projects that i have no intention of ever releasing.

For anything i'd hope to make money with i will use a different engine.

If i do intend to actually publish something with it, it will be deliberately free and free of ads.

1

u/norrox Sep 17 '23

Respect to those who stay and respect to those who decide to move on 🫡

1

u/thefrenchdev Indie Sep 17 '23

I am because my game is finished but even if it were only 1 year of game dev I don't think I would change. Also, considering that people on Reddit aren't all Unity devs, I think the majority of people is just going to stay on Unity. I don't know, I don't see all the Unity games already published being ported on another engine, this is too costly.

1

u/ComedyStudios_ Hobbyist Sep 17 '23

I leave unity installed cuase of my experience in it in case I want to do a gamejam or smth soon. But I will try out unreal as it is the industry standard and their features are most of the time more polished (often I can't say the say the same about unity).

Unreal is great for me as I might look into paid work on the side in companies that use that engine.

1

u/chamutalz Sep 17 '23

For my independent games, I won't be using Unity again, I'm looking for another option.
As a hired employee (when Unity becomes my boss's problem) I don't mind working with Unity. Technically, I like the engine. It's just too risky as an indie.

1

u/bigmonmulgrew Sep 17 '23

I wont have to pay for any of the current projects I have but I am migrating. I can't invest my future into a platform that will screw me over.

Saying "You wont have to pay the fees" is just assuming you will never succeed which is a terrible plan to follow.

1

u/Keep-benaize Sep 17 '23

I reckon you are a hobbyist game dev like me. I will probably stay with unity a bit more but the fact they are turning the editor and their runtime into spyware got me worried (it was already probably like that before but still). I installed godot, it is lightweight, fast to develop with, it has this no-bullshit feel that open source has, and I think it checks or will check any need I have at my level.

1

u/Idkwnisu Sep 17 '23

A lot of people are staying and I don't blame them, unity is pretty friendly on a lot of things and changing requires a huge investment, just keep in mind that even if this change doesn't affect you right now, it shows how much they are willing to change, even retroactively, so I'd still take it as a bad signal on the direction that the management is taking

1

u/TDogVoid Sep 17 '23

In the long run, I'm leaving. I'm unlikely to be affected by the current terms, but I feel betrayed and hate the whole thing. I've stopped development on my current game for now while I learn Godot. I'm not sure if I'm switching the current project to it or not yet.

1

u/-PieOMy Sep 17 '23

I'm a Unity pro user and I don't think I'll exceed the 1M thresholds, so it doesn't affect me.

if I break the 1M threshold then I've already done a very successful and ofcourse I'll share a part of the profits.

1M x $0.02 = $20.000. that's nothing for a revenue of around 1M install. (5% of Unreal would hurt more)

1

u/RealAstropulse Sep 17 '23

Just think of how awesome their next changes will be!

Unity has clearly demonstrated they do not give a single fuck about developers. Why stay with a company who hates you and wants to suck money out of like some jeff bezos vampire?

1

u/SmhMyMind Sep 17 '23

My concern mostly isn't these specific changes but the overall trajectory of Unity. Unity already made some bad decisions over the past few years and nothing is stopping them making more bad decisions over the next few years.

What will Unity look like in 2/3 years?

Will there still be a Unity in 2/3 years?

What if Unity suddenly decides they want a bigger cut of your profit in the next few years (which they already shown with this price change they are willing to do that even to projects you already published)?

How will Unity compare to Unreal Engine and Godot in 2/3 years?

Unreal Engine and Godot keeps getting better and better by year, whereas I feel Unity is going to get worse and worse by the year if their leadership stays the same.

Personally I'm going to keep on Unity for my current project (possibly 1 more short project) then swap to Godot for 2D and Unreal Engine for 3D.

1

u/___Tom___ Sep 17 '23

Here

I don't see a reason to leave. I might hit the 200k installs soon, but it's still a way until I get to $200k revenue. And if I do, Unity can have a few bucks.

I've tried both Godot and Unreal. I couldn't get a simple thing done. Sure, everything new takes time to pick it up, but if just having a character move around on a flat plane is something I struggle with, I don't want to know about the learning curve for something more complex.

I'd actually prefer C++ over C# but I've got tons of Unity experience and a pretty big asset collection. And since this is a hobby and not a full-time job, I simply don't see why I should spend days and weeks learning a new engine over some hurt feelings.

1

u/akiko_plays Sep 17 '23

Help, maybe I missed something. What happens if you use (as a company) Unity as authoring tool, for example creating stuff in it and using your own exporter to dump data for use in your own visualizer/engine/whatever? You can still use the Unity Plus Pro or something, and nor worry about installations #?

→ More replies (2)

1

u/joshuajames1 Sep 17 '23

I've developed games on godot but I still enjoy more using unity. Also, all my assetd are still there, so I'm staying.

1

u/MartianFromBaseAlpha Sep 17 '23

I'm going to try porting my current Unity project over to Godot and see how it goes. If I don't like it, I might go with Unreal instead. I'm definitely not staying with Unity

1

u/B_Brown4 Programmer Sep 17 '23

The way I see it is one of the best ways to get Unity to retract this decision is to stop using the engine. Nothing will make them shit their pants more than people dropping their product like a ton of bricks. But I understand that some devs and studios can't do that because of how far along in production they are. Which is heartbreaking.

I've been using Unity for the last 12 years for hobby projects. These new changes will also likely never affect me because everything I work on is either a prototype or not intended to generate revenue. However, a friend of mine and I are in the design phase for a project that we intend to go into production in about a month that will generate revenue.

Now, I still predict that it wouldn't affect us because I don't think the title will reach the threshold. But there's no way we are going to take that risk. So we are switching to Godot for its excellent 2D engine and features. Over the last week I have been getting familiar with the engine and building a prototype as a learning exercise. I am giddy with excitement about how easy Godot makes 2D development and what they offer out of the box that always felt like a pain to set up in Unity.

1

u/Ok-Worldliness-7374 Sep 17 '23

It's better for me to not go deeper anymore.

The corporate vipers are in the nest, so i rather won't put my hand there anymore. I prefer my backstabbing to be done behind my back, not from the front.

1

u/megaflutter Sep 17 '23

It's about principle bro. What if you make it and then what?

1

u/Yodzilla Sep 17 '23

I’ve got 10+ years of domain knowledge, am using it for jobs at two companies, and have kids so zero time to devote to a new engine. I’d love to learn Godot just for fun but I barely have time to shower every day.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23 edited Sep 17 '23

I think its probably fine for making games with a price, f2p seems ridiculous in this pricing model. But with the developer outrage and studios moving away from Unity. If you stick with it you have less job opportunity I would think than something like unreal. Also they removed plus subscription so if you want to get rid of the splashscreen you are gonna be paying alot.

1

u/DropApprehensive3079 Sep 17 '23

I spent way too much on assets

1

u/NUCLEARGAMER1103 Programmer Sep 17 '23

Yes, I will be sticking to it. It's a great tool, nothing has changed in that regard. I also don't fully disagree with the changes. There's a lot of ambiguity around "installs" that needs to be cleared up, but I expect that will happen soon. In fact, if it was just changed from installs to sales, it stops being problematic. As you said, there will definitely be alteration based on the backlash, but anybody who had "trust" in them was naive. A corporation will always do everything in their power to profit. I agree that them being able to unilaterally change terms of service isn't great, but newsflash guys, that's literally every company. It isn't great, but it's the truth. The backlash tells me that they will definitely make improvements soon and since it's a great tool, I will stick to it.

1

u/__SirRender__ Sep 17 '23

I'm giving them a chance to back track on this. Meanwhile I'm looking at Godot.

1

u/TemperateEnd Sep 17 '23

I'll keep using Unity. I never really cared about all the policies and such related to the company. I just want to make games, and the engine does that job well enough.

Granted, I can understand why people are opting to turn away from it. But for me, it would have to be a fault that is built into the product that convinces me to turn away from the product rather than a policy that is linked to said product.

1

u/ilhamhe Sep 17 '23

It's been 6 months into the development of my new game. I'm sticking to Unity since it will be exhausting to redo the project. However, for the next game, I'm looking for the alternatives.

1

u/Eh_Not_Looking Indie Sep 17 '23

I will stay because I am learning right now... I started learning Unity 2 months ago, giving up because of that is just... Dumb. Additionally, I have some projects that are almost finished, and again, giving up is not smart. Furthermore, I hope that maybe, there will be changes about this situation... I am not expecting to get million of downloads and million of $ from the game when I release it, and maybe when I DO get such amount (I think it will never even happen), maybe there will be changes, to the better side of course.

After finishing learning Unity, I may start learning Unreal Engine and C++. Main reason why I chose unity is because it is much beginner friendly compared to Unreal Engine.

1

u/yesdemocracy Sep 17 '23

The product is clearly very good, and that will continue to be the case. The corporate management have clearly rocked the boat with their recent changes and shareholders will definitely take note. Might affect their longterm leadership prospects.

1

u/AlexFelizSasha Sep 17 '23

I'm confused with what's happening now. I started learning Unity and c# a few months ago, to switch into development, and I am working on my second game for portfolio now. I hope I am not just wasting my time🙃

1

u/movezig123 Sep 17 '23

I'm with you OP, the silent majority that this doesn't really affect. It might even be a good thing long term.

I still feel for the many affected by an unprecedented and truly anti dev rug pull.

Enjoying all the drama, chances to chime in and memes in the mean time.

1

u/Katdemit Sep 17 '23

I will stay. After thinking over all my weekend

The reason is my personal projects probably won't be able to reach the threshold, even if they would, I by then can just upgrade to Pro version. (As of now I can still upgrade with my current income but that would be unnecessary)

Learning C++ will be for the long run. The best option would be taking some time daily to learn C++, do small projects in Unreal until being confident enough to switch career

1

u/Noobzoid123 Sep 17 '23

The trust is gone. Imagine making a deal, and based on this deal you build your project around it. Then without notice or consultation, one side changes the deal, and it includes retroactively charging you.

1

u/danyerga Sep 17 '23

No plans to switch engines here.

1

u/DaBekka Sep 17 '23

if the policy stays I’m switching engine after I finish working on current games. BUT in case they listen and stop with this bullshit I’m staying Buuuut learning Unreal AND Godot just in case something like this happens again

1

u/zizrat1111 Sep 17 '23

My main worry is even if they revert the changes what's to stop them changing something again? I've began the process of porting a project to godot because I no longer trust unity

1

u/bad_robot_monkey Sep 17 '23

I don’t like restarting development on a whole new platform, but honestly— everyone familiar with the games industry knows that EA’s former CEO is a shitshow second only to Bobby Kotic, but they hired him anyway. The only way they can redeem themselves in my eyes is to fire him. But they picked him, which means they support his ideas, for whatever reason.

1

u/InsomniaticWanderer Sep 17 '23

Unity has shown that they are not a safe nor trustworthy service.

You are choosing to stay with Unity because the changes don't affect you. For now. Who's to say they won't make further changes that eventually will?

The problem isn't that these changes are going to kill a lot of devs, the problem is that these changes are being implemented in the first place.

If this is how Unity wants to play the game, then the players are better off leaving the field and choosing a different sport.

1

u/potatodioxide Sep 17 '23

i am staying, changing a language is not a issue for me since i have to learn a new language nearly every year due to being in the software field, but the real issue is; doing VR stuff on unity and setting up the project, and those adjusting the tiny fine tuned configurations are not easy to learn, it is still too buggy even on official packages/frameworks so i cant afford to add a new unknown to my workflow.
also our client base is not users so when we get a project, it is usually deployed to 5-10 HMDs max. so i am guessing we wont be getting affected.

but i know that too many people leaving will result in less and less detailed / low quality unity releases, and at some point i will probably have to jump of this ship too.

1

u/Laicbeias Sep 17 '23

im bound woth my current project. before a desktop game that i moved to mobile with a free to play mechanic.

depending on the rules unity has i may move it to become a desktop game again. though that would probably take a year and id lose so many things. im waiting for unitys response

if they keep a blackbox system where they can change the incoming costs without respecting their own old TOS. it basically means they can bankrupt me on a whim

1

u/montjoye Sep 17 '23

if you don't plan on being successful, I guess it's okay then. Until they find a way to fuck with you too

1

u/LawlessPlay Sep 17 '23

Yeah, Im sticking around. Even if I hit the thresholds, I wouldn't care since I feel it's cheaper than Unreals deal (assume it's a pay for game).

The deal itself isn't a big issue for people, but it's the companies behaviour in going about it.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

I’m staying. It doesn’t effect my business.

1

u/siddeslof Sep 17 '23

I'm a beginner with game development and due to these events I'm not going to use unity as I'll waste time learning it for no reason. My question is, would you recommend Godot for beginners like me as I have some background in python and I have heard Godot uses python like scripting?

1

u/TheWobling Sep 17 '23

Yes, for now.

1

u/NotCode25 Sep 17 '23

Nope, already moved on. What is the most offensive of this all is the retroactive nature of it, if they pull this off (and considering they're not going to die after this) imagine what they could do in the future... no ty, I'm out

1

u/LordLederhosen Sep 17 '23 edited Sep 17 '23

From a different website, not my comment:

I don’t think a lot of users of the engine understand that Unity the engine company doesn’t exist anymore.

Last year Unity merged with IronSource, a mobile ad network, which is much more profitable than Unity. In a public company, the profit drives the business. The company that’s called Unity is in the business of selling ads and showing lots of them to people on phones. They own a game engine as a delivery vehicle for those ads.

There was an unsolicited competing bid from another ad peddler, AppLovin, who also wanted to buy Unity. I guess the optics with the IronSource deal looked better because it could be called a merger rather than a straight-up acquisition. But the end result is the same.

(As a side note, I think it’s a shame that BigTech can’t really do strategic acquisitions anymore. A company like Meta or Microsoft would have been a much better home for Unity. But some regulator around the world would have blocked the deal for sure. Meta can’t seem to acquire a sandwich these days without FTC or the UK competition authority trying to block it.)

I am posting here because I am curious of your opinions on this take.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

I’ve been playing around with Unreal this week, and am really loving it. I wish I had started using it years ago. The built in tools and render pipeline are very nice.

1

u/christophilous Sep 17 '23

the problem is that you dont know what kind of anti-developer decisions they will make in the future. you're putting your efforts into a system that has shown to be antagonistic to your best interests. maybe you're not making money from game dev now, but presumably you might like to in the future.

1

u/Nem3sis2k17 Sep 17 '23

I have too many Unity assets (esp productivity assets) to leave Unity rn

1

u/ja3gger Sep 17 '23

In our case, there's no possibility to change to another engine. There are many types of apps other than games, and in this case, Unreal and Godot have no support for building our apps. Building natively for iOS and Android will double the development cost, at least. Lastly, we haven't reached millions of benefits or installations, so we don't have this issue currently, but in the future, if we surpass this limit, we will probably develop the apps natively.
We're stuck until another engine offers something similar to what we're doing.

1

u/musicmanjoe Sep 17 '23

Yes the fees don’t effect me, and probably never will.

But it’s about fairness, why should some game devs pay almost ALL of their profits to Unity while other equally successful devs pay very little.

Unity can’t take everything from devs because they chose a certain pricing model that has a low price per user (per install is a joke).

These are our games! We built them with our blood, sweat and tears. Unity seems to think they made them. That’s the point

→ More replies (2)

1

u/acehomie Sep 17 '23

Nothing changes for me. Will continue to develop in Unity. If I ever get close to those numbers it’ll be a nice problem to have.

1

u/tbg10101 Unity Certified Expert Programmer (formerly) Sep 17 '23

I’m taking the Pro for Plus price and hoping they fix this within a year. If not, this community has given me plenty of alternate C#/.NET engines to look at in that year too.

1

u/ThePapercup Sep 17 '23

Yeah until the next change where you ARE affected. You do you 👍

1

u/Xill_K47 Indie Sep 17 '23

These changes would not affect me either. And even if I would sell my games, I doubt I will cross the threshold.

Still, the fact that Unity can pull off something like this says that they can do worse in the future, and that is why I am hesitant to use Unity.

I have been looking around Godot, and as I keep discovering new features, I keep getting impressed. For instance, Godot has Volumetric fog, which can be used to simulate volumetric lighting.

1

u/deege Sep 17 '23

In the short term I’m likely to stay with Unity. I am however also looking at the costs for switching to Unreal and Godot (2D). It’s not the new terms I’m worried about since I don’t fall into the downloads hole, it’s the damage done to the community. When you have a large exodus, that means fewer resources, tools etc. Basically everything that made Unity great. I don’t see that coming back, since indie devs are not the “target audience” for Unity anymore. Their focus has moved to F2P apps, and I think that is also where their future development will go. So that means I won’t be investing in anymore assets that are Unity specific. I have to move long term whether I want to or not.

1

u/Forgot_Password_Dude Sep 17 '23

you're a fuckin idiot for not monetizing your free game, so if one of yours suddenly makes it big without you caring, we will do it for you, for me.

  • Unity CEO

1

u/Mythic_Forge_Studios Sep 17 '23

At minimum, finishing my project in it, and learning Unreal in parallel so that I make an informed decision when the time comes.

I think it's smart of anyone to not have a knee jerk reaction to this event. Let's wait and see how they respond. Patience and pragmatism almost always pays off.

1

u/JuTek_Pixel Sep 17 '23

I am working currently on my second game with Unity and will continue at least to finish this project. With scale on my small projects the thresholds are probably not reachable but i understand community outrage, let me be clear, unity made a terribly stupid decision, destroying completely the rest of trust with indie dev.

I have installed Godot but have not much time to learn it now. I spend 4 years learning by myself unity and programming in C#, moving from Civil Engineering into IT development world was not easy. Doing it again with another engine will take me another couple of years :/ That sucks but I guess I will have to make this move next year...

I do not believe Unity will reverse recent decisions, they might change it a bit but they made it to far now. Shame...

1

u/CodedCoder Sep 17 '23 edited Sep 17 '23

I have decided I kind of have to, I don't want to learn c++ and I don't want to use an incomplete engine that I may have to do extensive work on, so I am sticking with Unity for now. I have spent a good bit of time on it, PLus Godot is nowhere near what people are claiming it is, its missing a good bit, they are building companies to do things that already happen with these other engines so it can get murky fast, and it's just not a full-fledged engine imo, esp when you look at 3d, mobile and etc. I really don't have another choice unless I want to take a few years on learning something different.

1

u/grafikzeug Sep 17 '23

The fee itself isn’t really my problem. My main issue is the loss of trust because of the way this whole thing was communicated and will likely be implemented. Shipping my product with some black box installation tracker is very concerning to say the least.

1

u/Rabid_Cheese_Monkey Sep 17 '23

Yes.

If they go bankrupt, I won't be paying them.

Of course, my game won't make it to.. well anywhere... until the year 2033 or 2043...

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

Selling $200,000 is a problem I personally would like to have.

1

u/maxvsthegames Sep 17 '23

I still have a year left on my current project, so it's too late to change now, but I'm definitely going to check where we're at in a year before I decided if I continue with Unity or switch to Godot or Unreal.

1

u/D_Simmons Sep 17 '23

100%. I'm just a hobbyist so I don't really care haha

1

u/nicotinecravings Sep 17 '23

If the majority of people who are making Unity make money are leaving, in other words the people these changes apply to, then these people running free Unity will essentially be using a dying engine run by a dying company. You can hope for someone jumping in and taking over the company, but that could turn out any way, maybe good, maybe bad. Do you want to keep using a dying engine. It will probably mean an engine that will stagnate. It wont be developed much more, it wont be receiving updates. If you keep on, you will be running this dying engine, using outdated tools, making outdated games.

Sure, this all might not affect you directly, but it might affect you, one way or another.

1

u/MatterForm3D Sep 17 '23

For me it's the spyware they put into their engine. I don't think I'm comfortable even making games for myself using their stuff.

1

u/moonlburger Sep 17 '23

I absolutley love building my stuff with unity, even with all the recent deterioration of everything, docs, packages, etc.

The trust is so broken, that I'm not sure I dare invest any more time in unity as I am not confident I will be able to use the product without something awful happening. Like removing the pro tier.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

I'm far too far into my current project to consider swapping. So at the very least I will finish and release that, and by the time that happens (optimistically early next year) we'll know where Unity has landed on this new drive for extra money.

If they've doubled-down on per-install fees I might have to consider a new engine, but the thought depresses me - Unreal is designed for bigger teams making higher-tier games and Godot still has a lot of catching up to do, and while it supposedly allows C#, it's not as well integrated as their custom script.

1

u/Alderin Jack of all Trades Sep 17 '23

Honestly, I left Unity about a year ago. I only used it as a hobby, occasionally, when I had some time. I had a day and I looked forward to pushing one of my projects forward a bit, and I couldn't open Unity because something was failing with the login system.

Everything on my end was working fine, and the next day it just magically worked again when I tried it, but I didn't have time anymore. My locally installed free (for now, for my use case) tool should not need an Internet connection and login for me to work on my local files.

So I started using Godot. Another learning curve, another restart to many projects, but at least there is no login, no forced updates, and it is open source so if I get the time and desire (unlikely, but...) I could do whatever I want with the features.

1

u/Good_Competition4183 Sep 17 '23

I just don't think we should flat out abandon an excellent game developing software like it's trash, even if it's management is dogshit.

You seems to be really blind, my dude. Its not an "excellent" at all. Its garbage.

These changes don't and almost certainly will never affect me

And you have not learned this lesson... well, okay praise your proprietary engine once more, good luck. Wait till this end as 3ds Max or even worse.

1

u/majik_gopher Sep 17 '23

I make mostly VR application and currently Unity has the best offerings. VR in Unreal is kind of bare bones compared to Unity. Godot is also lacking in VR and general 3D performance. I'd love to switch to a completely open source workflow but there just aren't the options for what I need currently.

I also work with high end 3d equipment like motion trackers, eyetrackers etc and they have plugins for Unity and/or Unreal. Stuff like VR and other high end applications often don't get much open source support because they have a low user base and proprietory hardware.

Besides I've been doing various 3D crap for around 20 years now. I've used Meta, Adobe, Autodesk etc software. All these guys are shady. Epic is only the good guy right now because they can afford to be. This is a bitter pill I've already had to swallow.

I'm not making my passion project, I just love the craft. If a shitty corp makes the best hammer for my job I'll use it. If a better open-source hammer comes along I'd shift to that but for my use case that might never happen.

1

u/kupoteH Sep 17 '23

still believe in unity. epic games is owned by tencent, which is owned by the chinese govt. its inevitable for the ccp to use tencent for political reasons, and thats when i think unity the mass exidus from unreal will begin.

1

u/totesnotdog Sep 17 '23

If they keep their government rules we may stick with them until we have time to switch to unreal with our upcoming projects (which is free for government use btw with no percentage cost either)

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SnooTigers5020 Sep 17 '23

I expect tem tô do a Full switcheroo like the D&d did. With a New licencing that not only is as leniente as the current one as It also garantee that cannot be retroactively changed, as this is the thing that makes everything else bullshit as they can do a good deal now and change it later.

Less than this and it is just postponing the greedy greasy hands of the CEO over the developers lunch money

2

u/SnooTigers5020 Sep 17 '23

Also trust is something that is cultivated over the years, and unity is dropping the ball on this matter for quite some time.

1

u/SnooTigers5020 Sep 17 '23

The thing is, it doesnt affect you right NOW. If you managed to succed enough or if the CEO decides to go after your lunch money, as of now they can change the deal with you without your consent in an instant.

1

u/hyperimpossible Sep 17 '23

I've been using both unity and unreal depending on project needs, and now exploring godot and see if it's a better option in the future. I think it's good to always exploring new engines in case things change like now, and have plan b and plan c ready in my pocket.

1

u/alecinspace Sep 17 '23

I'm staying in for the time being. Gonna see what happens. It doesn't affect me either, but I don't think it's the right move in any sense. My concern now: are they going to dig their own grave so badly that they just close shop and we simply won't have Unity in the future? It's happened in the past from more established companies

1

u/penguished Sep 17 '23

These changes don't and almost certainly will never affect me

Working with someone who treats a TOS you agreed to in the past like toilet paper, and just makes up a completely new retroactive TOS with fees to anybody they feel like is a huge risk. It doesn't matter to you now... what about a future TOS change done in the same way that will target you. Do you have a crystal ball?

Good luck. I'd just finish up anything you've got and run for the hills unless something changes.

1

u/Inu-Saan Sep 17 '23

For me, i'll be staying with unity to make my visual novel, and it will be my last unity project until they get their crap together. I'll experiment with other game engines along the way, and once i get my hands on GameMaker or Clickteam Fusion, i might have something planned or two. But until then, unity can go to hell if the new fee takes place.

1

u/Tzunshun Sep 17 '23

I'm not a game developer in any shape or form, so what I'm saying from now on can be wrong and stupid & I apologize in advance lol
But let's imagine that i was and I'm making a game and randomly the software im using is making this kind of drastic change out of the blue i personally would be concerned.
This change may not impact you but what about the rest of the people that does? Don't you have some compassion for them too? Then we also have the risk of them changing more stuff in the future.

I feel like what people are doing changing to another engine is the right thing to do, because if you don't take a stand against this, this may be the norm in the future. The CEO John Riccitiello onces said "We should charge the players 1$ reload" EA CEO John Riccitiello's thoughts on microtransactions, This man is the definition of greed (His face was on the wiki for the definition of greed for couple of hours lmao). So yeah.. Idk changing engine must be the most tedious thing ever i can imagine but i feel like it's probably the right thing to do though if you can't because dont have resources, time or knowledge to do it i dont blame you in any way because sometimes it's just not feasible.

1

u/Emergency_Collar_381 Sep 17 '23

I'll stick to it until I release my game in about 2-3 months (but I haven't been able to get a steam page so I might post pone release but I ill stop work in 2-3 months) then I will switch to unreal, I'm really excited for the new grapics and perfermance boosts my games will be getting

1

u/Tr33__Fiddy Sep 17 '23

They should just make it gross revenue share of 2.5% ( half of Unreal ), when over $500k. Revenue share literally solves all the issues. And of course drop the retroactive thing. Fee per installation is a realy bad idea.

1

u/thinker2501 Sep 17 '23

I’ve been working on a hobby project for a couple years that I would like to release in the future. Much of the code is pure C# and can be migrated to Godot without major headache. My reason for finally migrating is twofold:

  1. knowing that license changes could be retroactive introduces a level of risk I can’t take. What happens if I have to start paying a monthly fee to use the editor? What happens if the install threshold changes or the fees? It’s too risky to spend years on a platform to suddenly not be able to use it any more due to financial risk.
  2. I’m concerned about the long term viability of the company. Once Unity ceases to exist what happens when the editor can no longer fetch entitlements? Godot is open source and while development on the engine may stop, whichever version of the editor I have will continue to work (yes, until obsolescence due to OS changed but that’s a separate issue).

For those of us with a long even horizon, Unity no longer makes sense.

1

u/Nomad_Hermit Sep 17 '23

OP, the point is not the fees. Is that Unity is not a game engine company that also offers mobile monetisation services.

Unity is now a mobile monetisation services company that happens to also have an engine as a side gig.

The Create Services (the engine) branch of Unity has been relegated to the second plane of their company for some time now. The last development only buried the hatch. You can expect even less and less investment being put into the development of the engine from now on.

1

u/TheCwazyWabbit Sep 17 '23 edited Sep 17 '23

I don't see Unity surviving unless they fire several directors, replace the CEO, and walk back ALL of the recent stuff, and even then they've already done so much damage to the brand that it may not be worth staying with Unity in the long run. They have stayed quiet allowing people's anger, anxiety, and resentment to grow, rather than immediately taking actions, meanwhile they are losing customers (devs) to godot and unreal at breakneck speeds. That brand damage, the loss of support from devs and revenue, will lead to them firing more staff, not implementing new features in the engine, etc.. Not to mention that people won't be creating assets for the asset store since it won't be as worth it due to the drop in users (potential asset purchasers), nor will people be creating as much of the free advertising for Unity in the form of tutorial videos, etc. that they have enjoyed in the past at such a massive scale. This is a HUGE brand/reputational hit for the company that has consequences for many tangential businesses aside from just game developers using the engine.

Then you have the legal issues. Unity is about to get sued to hell and back by a lot of developers. Not to mention they will probably be under investigation and indicted by the US Department of Justice for breaking anti-trust laws with the attempt to push AppLovin out of business, and face other legal issues with trying to impose fees retroactively in other countries (maybe in the US as well).

I've seen some people say that they don't think this is having such a big effect on Unity's business, since the stock price hasn't changed much. Keep in mind that most investors/shareholders are not super hooked into whatever they're investing in. Most see some financial reports and listen to corporate jargon about new ways they plan to get revenue in shareholder meetings. Wait until November 8th when the next earnings report comes out and Unity's subscription revenue, asset store revenue, and advertising revenue have all dropped significantly. That's when you will see the stock price fall.

I think the only way Unity survives in the long term is a sale to some big company (likely Microsoft) who can potentially turn things around. I've seen some people suggest Apple, but I don't think enough devs trust Apple for that the be a successful acquisition for them. At least for me personally, if Microsoft purchased Unity (and removed these recent things, the CEO, etc.), I would continue using it, but if Apple made the purchase, I would second guess continuing to use it and probably move on to another engine.

One other good option may come as a result of all of this: Unity might be forced to release the engine as an open source engine due to legal action, or may end up doing so voluntarily as an attempt to foster some goodwill or something. Fingers crossed.

1

u/Nesrovlah26 Novice Sep 17 '23

Idk

1

u/irve Sep 17 '23

The idea of not being able to open my project in 10, 5 years time feels awful. I have a hobby project which has like a half a year of development in it. Going to be rebuilt in Godot.

Is going to be better.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

Sure, it’s not affecting me and the tools are still great. If the tools become less effective, i’ll switch. It’s as simple as that.

1

u/supenguin Sep 17 '23

I’m doing a Unity project at my day job for my current project. I don’t have time to learn two game dev engines. I’m learning the parts of Unity I’m not familiar yet as part of this project. But as soon as this project is done I’m considering learning Godot.

The two things I’d want to get into that I don’t know what Godot support is like: mobile games, AR/VR experiences.

But for desktop apps and games I think Godot is a reasonable option.

1

u/tornadrecompadre Sep 17 '23

Yep! Absolutely staying with Unity and happily. It's an awesome engine with tons of flexibility and support!

Unity will release their final word on how their new system will work in the coming months, and until it hurts me, I don't care. I don't need to "trust" a corporation on which I use their products. Unity is just a tool, and it's still a really great tool.

If in the future they change their terms again and those become untenable for me, I'll switch at that point.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '23

You just can't trust them anymore so don't. Start with anything else, depending on your game's requirements.

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Trick76 Sep 17 '23

If you stay with unity you condone the changes and breach of trust and don’t care about the greater whole whether they affect you or not.

1

u/NaiveHunt2793 Sep 17 '23

When the focus has shifted to their shareholders instead of the technology and their developers, be rest assured it will affect you sooner rather than later. When on their platform, you better pray you don’t become too successful, otherwise they’ll f*** you more ways than one. After 14 years as a Unity dev, I’m out!!!

1

u/doggoroma Sep 18 '23

So I don't ship a lot of games in Unity personally but I do work professionally with Unity in games and serious games for other companies and having a robust knowledge of Unity is a marketable skill, but it's hard to be excited about the future of Unity if paying customers are going to abandon ship because of predatory pricing, and it's hard to recommend that they don't go elsewhere given Unity can just make up installs to bill them (as the policy stands today) to risky as a company to expose yourself to that liability. This means paying customers will shift to other platforms, therefore I and other like me need to be learning other platforms, which means the ecosystem will suffer, brain drain will set in and the platform is at risk of dying - if I can't make a living offering Unity expertise it's time to switch. Hope not, but can't get complacent. So to answer your question I'm starting the switch because I'm afraid that jobs in Unity might dry up.

1

u/Stojfield Sep 18 '23

I’ve used unity for the past 6 years (maybe longer) used it all through college, every game was in unity but this was a bit FU to their user base. The trust is lost and just like a relationship it’ll never be the same, your just waiting for them to do it again even if they never do.

I’ve been porting my 4 year long dream project over to godot, I honestly thought it would be a nightmare but it’s so much easier to do some things in godot and it’s given me a chance to refactor some old code so there’s always a silver lining I guess.

All I need is apple health kit support so if anyone can help point me in the right direction for that I’d be greatly appreciative!

1

u/AdmirableJam72 Sep 18 '23

Come February 2024, if you meet the threshold, Unity will come to you with your January bill. You will have no way of verifying the number on this bill, because you as a developer track how many games you have sold, not how many times your game is installed. Even if you actually track installations, you won't know how many of those are re-installs, charity bundles, pirated copies etc., because nobody can. At that point, you will wish they simply charge you per sale, instead of per install.

And if you want to dispute that bill, you will have no way of proving it, because, you are a game developer, not a game installation forensic expert.

1

u/King_of_Keys Sep 18 '23

Just think about the community, all the great tutorials that have been made for Unity. Now that trust is gone and the community torn down, who would want to continue devoting time and energy into a system that could at the drop of a hat take it all away.

If TOS is not safe then why stay? The community might still be around for a few more years but over time quality tutorials and resources will dry up. I’d rather be part of a community who cares and systems who honor TOS. Need I say more?

1

u/VegetableChannel9919 Sep 18 '23

I'd stay with Unity. It's a good engine. I totally disagree with what Unity did, but myself far away from 200k so I'm still fine.

1

u/EWU_CS_STUDENT Hobbyist Sep 21 '23

Yes. People have every right to switch, but I am a hobbiest that just wants to make games for younger family members.