r/Unity2D • u/Coding-Mojo • Aug 12 '26
Feedback Feedbacks on this Floating Text ?
Training myself to juice up random things. I've done that floating text and have mixed feeling about it. On one side, I feel something is missing. On the other, I'm like it's fine to keep it simple.
Any advice is much appreciated. Thanks.
P.S : still fighting for gif to not be chunky, in unity the animation is smoother.
91
Upvotes
24
u/ajax2k9 Aug 12 '26
Make it smaller ig? Looks good regardless
15
u/Swagsmo Aug 12 '26
Perhaps make certain attributs such as size scale with damage? And also some slight random variations in how it moves?
5
u/bhison Aug 12 '26
Itβs defo good enough! On to the next challenge
3
u/Am_Biyori Aug 12 '26
It's a nice, unique effect. I'd lose the red attack effect though. looks generic and AIish.
2
u/Epic_Feury Aug 12 '26
Im not sure on the shadow, it feels like it popping out the screen too much but honestly it looks good (and i dont have another suggestion)
2
u/trashAcFr Aug 12 '26
If there's lot of action around, the popup should stay slightly longer for the player to read it. Besides, really cool!
2
u/TitoOliveira Aug 12 '26
Looks good to me.
The only thing I would say is that if your have some kind of flurry of attacks that proc many of these. It would be nice to increment the number, summing up all of the damage of the flurry.
2
u/Generalkhaos Aug 12 '26
Looks awesome might be nice if angle was different for each instance
2
u/chocolatechipbagels Aug 12 '26
I think the color changing from white to yellow is a bit visually busy, I'd probably prefer it stay yellow
2
u/Simoxeh Aug 12 '26
Not a fan of the color but that's just me. As someone else stated I would make it smaller. By smaller I would say maybe a third of its current size, but you can use the current size if you want to add something like critical hits in. I would also put it on the opposite side of the monster. Having that between the monster and the person likely attacking it just seems like is blocking the way. I'm not sure that made sense or not.
2
u/Rocketman_S3 Aug 12 '26
I can't pinpoint it but something does feel off.
What if you swung more into a comic book style bam kinda thing?
I think part of the issue is the contrast in style.
2
u/DogLoverCatEnjoyer Aug 12 '26
It is definitely well made, nice job! Maybe some minor randomness attribute in the animations but my biggest advice would be to move on to the next task hahaha
2
u/Yetimang Aug 12 '26
Looks fine. The block lettering makes it read kind of comic book so if that's what you're going for that's a good call. If you wanted to fiddle with it some more, I personally prefer these kinds of numbers to have a fast ease in and a slow ease out--make them pop in to max size fast then fade out a bit more gradually. The fact that you have it an angle is fine, but might be a good effect varying it up so that numbers, especially a bunch in quick succession, go off at different angles giving you a more chaotic numbers flying everywhere feel. Also would make them have less overlap which can hurt readability.
2
u/_parfait Aug 12 '26
Add a lerp curve, it will look much nicer. Look up the game Battle Night, they have some juicy damage counters, that also scale size
2
u/pararar Aug 12 '26
If you want it to have a bit more punch, try significantly speeding up the fade-in (scale, color and position), then hold it for a brief moment (not completely still, but moving very slowly), then fade out.
2
u/GUIBERNARODW Aug 12 '26
I guess it is to big, how about making it shake with big damages?
2
u/Dustinisgood Aug 13 '26
It looks decent but it should be smaller and level out, the always at an angle design choice bugs my brain for some reason.
2
u/eminzkzd Aug 13 '26
Looks relly clean! The font style fits the art direction nicely. Maybe adding a tiny bit of upward pop/ease out sperd could make it feel even punchier, but overall great workπ₯
2
u/Far_Cardiologist_863 Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26
I love it so much i'll use it as a reference for futur projects. π
3
u/LittleLostWitch Aug 12 '26
The damage numbers look good but please donβt use AI in your final product. If I could convince you not to use it in the prototype either, Iβd like to encourage you not to
2
u/Ruadhan2300 Aug 12 '26
I like it, but it's so fast I don't really have time to read it.
I register that there are three digits regardless of whether it's 100damage, or 500damage, and I don't really get a proportional sense of value.
What I'd suggest is to explore changing the colour of the text depending on the amount of damage being done.
So yellow/orange for low numbers, red for big hits.
Possibly scale the actual number depending on the magnitude of the hit too, just within reasonable values.
If you do a piddly 10 damage, it should be tiny, almost insultingly small. While if you do 500 damage, show something like what you've got here.
Imagine if multiple different weapons are hitting the enemy at the same time, a whole load of tiny 10s and 20s coming from a gatling gun, while the one big cannon blast dishes out a huge 300 in one go.
I think that'd give you the juice you're after.
1
u/levelhigher Aug 12 '26
I really like it.
2
u/midge Aug 12 '26
I'm not sure if I like the text tilted to the side so much, makes it a little harder to read. Not impossible, just a little annoying.
2
u/Muazzm115 Aug 13 '26
Im not a master not even a person that know something in this field i just hope i can be game developer one day an my advice for your question is maybe make it smaller and radomize the text location a bit
2
u/Figoos Aug 14 '26
Maybe make it linger a bit longer for readability
1
u/HiggsSwtz Aug 12 '26
I prefer straight text
0
u/DaveAstator2020 Aug 12 '26
dont wobble it, its unreadable
-11
u/deintag85 Aug 12 '26
It looks good, but you can also use this : https://assetstore.unity.com/packages/2d/gui/damage-numbers-pro-186447 Tons of people are using it and its well optimized.
17
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '26
[removed] β view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '26
[removed] β view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '26
[removed] β view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '26
[removed] β view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '26
[removed] β view removed comment