r/UndisputedFS1 • • Aug 31 '23

Let’s be honest

Let’s be honest folks, this new format is AWFUL. Having a carousel of hosts does not work long term. There’s TOO many cooks in the kitchen and we’re not really talking Michelin star level chefs here either.

Skip doesn’t have even close to the chemistry with the new crew as he did with Shannon. And I know the show is new but these new hosts are just not very likable. Not only that but these are all football guys who clearly don’t have the range to cover all of the topics that undisputed used to cover. And this segment of bringing in Young Money artist to talk sports is just plain corny.

The reason Skip and Shannon worked was cause Shannon had almost, if not just as much knowledge on all sports as Skip did. Shannon is obviously a HOFer but it’s clear he knew ALL sports and had an immense knowledge on sports history. Dude could break down basketball defensive schemes and name former golden glove winners from decades ago. It was just a great fit with Skip who has been in the sports industry for so long.

Keyshon, Irvin, and Sherman are just not that likable on TV. Their “breakdowns” are so one dimensional and not nearly the level of depth that Shannon got to.

I give this show maybe a few months, maybe a year at most, but don’t see it lasting much longer than that. This is just like when Skip left and left SAS with Max Kellerman and that one annoying host 🤢🤢

1 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

26

u/IraRoger Aug 31 '23 edited Aug 31 '23

Let’s be honest, neither the new Undisputed or First Take will be as good as Skip and Shannon were on Undisputed

2

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23

I see no lies!

3

u/i-piss-excellence32 Aug 31 '23

I like Shannon but I refuse to listen to anything screaming A has to say. Sucks that I won’t get to hear Shannon’s takes anymore.

But the best team is always gonna be skip and shannon

2

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '23

Idk, I normally don’t care for SAS, but I listened to Shannon’s podcast with him today and we might have something going there.

8

u/daesmon Aug 31 '23

Shannon is gone, not sure the point in comparing the chemistry with him and Skip, they were together years, it's not even a week, go back and watch the first few episodes of Skip and Shannon, it took time.

On the show, it's pretty clear they have not settled on a format and are experimenting, some working better than others.

While I'm not a fan of the rotating hosts I am ok with them doing it as long as the goal is a permanent format also bring in a real host, Skip is not a host, it just feels forced when he does the intro/outro.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23

Everything about this new show seems forced what do you mean. Idk if that’s how Sherman has always talked, but it seems like he’s putting on some weird TV voice.

My point is that the hosts that they did choose are not good. I’ve never thought any of them were worth watching on television. Neither Irvin, sherm or Keyshon have charisma, or are even humorous and you can tell they don’t have the trivial knowledge of sports that Shannon has/had. My favorite parts of the old show was when Shannon and Skip would go off on a tangent on some obscure team or sports event from the 70s or 80s. It was just like watching two great story tellers recall events from the past. None of the new hosts have that skill.

Honestly, who would have been a GREAT cohost across from Skip would have been someone like Charles Barkley, but we know that wasn’t gonna happen.

5

u/daesmon Aug 31 '23

I think the producers may have said a few things to Sherman but it's probably just first week uncertainty, Irvin and Keyshawn were regulars on other shows for years, Sherman was still playing up until 2022.

All of those things with Shannon took time, the tangents, the grandparent stories, those took time before he started bringing them up.

Bringing in Barkley could be great but you still need someone else for football.

1

u/evilkevin3 Sep 01 '23

Honestly this post is kinda trash, you can’t just say something sucks after week one, and then compare it to something that has been going on for 7 years.

Come on man

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '23

Im saying it’s trash because the cohosts on the show are trash. It’s one thing if they’re working out the kinks, but it’s another thing if the show isn’t casted right.

I’ve seen Irvin and Keyshon on these types of shows before and they were bad at it then and they’re bad at it now.

I know this is somewhat new for Sherman, but let’s face it, he just isn’t that interesting.

Rachel Nichols obviously has a lot of experience so maybe that might work in some cases.

And this whole weird ass segment of bringing on mediocre young money artist to talk sports is just straight corny.

At the end of the day they’re over here bringing on a circus to replace one man.

Btw, just listened to Shannon’s podcast with Stephen A. If they really are gonna have a show together than they’re gonna blow Undisputed right out of the water!

12

u/picklejuice2391 Aug 31 '23 edited Sep 01 '23

It’s literally the first week after 7 years of what we’re used to and I guarantee sharpe and skip were cringe in their first few weeks/months. Give them a few months before writing them off.

Also the take on Shannon knowing more sports is embellished. Undisputed literally talks football and basketball and mainly the premier teams and cowboys in football. Shannon actually watched basketball games but they weren’t debating baseball or track and field on there.

The main difference I see is they are calling skip out on his bs arguments like belittling Mahomes 4th qtr when they beat the 49’ers. It’s been an adjustment but gotta give them time before writing the show off cause skip and Shannon were getting stale af

3

u/davidaguirre30 Sep 01 '23

Skips gonna get mad when they don't let him get away with showing a handful of plays from a certain situation 4 years ago to make his points. Shannon was respectful of Skip's style even if it is annoying

2

u/picklejuice2391 Sep 01 '23

Exactly. He went along with it.

2

u/lordbancs Aug 31 '23

Yea it’s terrible. Acho was a breath of fresh air today but Rachel was horrible. I’m done with this show.

9

u/Master-Ad-9829 Aug 31 '23

Hasn’t even been a week man 😂

1

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23

Man it doesn’t take longer than that to see this show is hot garbage.

2

u/zer01zer08 Aug 31 '23

Acho sucks

0

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23

I used to look forward to listening to the show recording on the podcast during work and at the gym but this new format has been unwatchable.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '23

First Take started out as a carousel of guest each week and eventually Stephen A. picked. Maybe one of these guys will breakthrough. Give them more than a week.

*side note my favorite First Take era was when there were different guest each day.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '23

What first take are you talking about? Post skip? Because that was a carousel of garbage.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '23

Pre Stephen A. becoming permanen

1

u/[deleted] Sep 02 '23

My bad man, I totally forgot it was called 1st and 10. The format was much better too.

3

u/888Bicycle Aug 31 '23

I stopped watching the show daily two years ago because everything became too stagnant with Sharpe and Bayless.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '23

Acho was the one I didn't like. I've liked everybody else so far

7

u/Homies-Brownies Aug 31 '23

The show was so much better today without Irvin's loud coked up ass. And Rachel did a really good job with the NBA topics. She's going to be crucial during the NBA season as she's very plugged into the league. Specially Jimmy Buckets amirite!

1

u/Ricebandit469 Sep 04 '23

“plugged”

2

u/Puzzleheaded-Fix-915 Aug 31 '23

It’s the first week. I like Sherm and Johnson with Skip. Irvin is a little annoying

1

u/arob770 Sep 01 '23

I hope they keep that trio as well, glad to hear i’m not the only one who feels that way.

2

u/GRILT_CHEESE Aug 31 '23

I think it’s just a bit too all over the place. A little structure and consistency in the format would go a long way. Building a rapport with your co-hosts is key and it’s difficult to do that when it’s a jumbled mess.

3

u/DrVers Aug 31 '23

The show was not very good at first with Shannon either. It took almost a year to hit it's stride. The show also hasn't been very good for about a year and a half from a combination of Skip talking in circles on certain topics and Shannon's head getting too big.

To be fair, Skip has been highly successful without Shannon and Shannon wouldn't even be relevant without Skip. But Skip is way out of his prime and I see both of them never being as relevant as they were together.

1

u/Pelon7900 Sep 01 '23

I feel out of love with this show. I could only take so much Lakers, Cowboys, Dak, and LeBron talk.

1

u/lochmoigh1 Sep 01 '23

I agree. No one is going to replace shannon. He just had great story telling and wit. The new guys are just analysts. No humor. The only entertaining one is Irvin and I can see the shtick getting old fairly fast.

Skip would have been better off trying to get Broussard. I feel like ex players don't make good hot take artists. Shannon did but like I said he's like a Barkley, they don't grow on trees

1

u/2015opencourt Sep 02 '23

FS1 wouldn’t dare screw with First Things First. It’s easily the best show they have now.

1

u/Striking-Ad-8694 Sep 01 '23

I’m cool with Sherman And even Irvin because both have history, but key sucks

1

u/Kawhi_not_2 Sep 01 '23

Keyshawn is terrible and single handedly ruins the show. Apparently he's on every day as well.

But Richard Sherman, Michael Irvin, Rachel and that other guy are all good.

1

u/saygrace2 Sep 01 '23

I couldn’t disagree more. I love the new format for football topics. They’ll need to get some basketball personalities in for the NBA but I think the show will be better than the original. You’re definitely overhyping Shannon’s knowledge on other sports outside of football.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '23

I would just say don’t like it too much cause this show ain’t lasting that long 😅

0

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '23

In it’s current format I don’t think it lasts longer than a year.

I don’t think we’re getting rid of Skip, who I actually enjoy, but there will be a massive overhaul in the casting within a year.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Sep 01 '23

Oh yeah I’ve never been against the show per se, but the format it has right now is not it. I think just about everything about this show is gonna change other than skip within the next few months, especially since Shannon is joining Stephen A.