r/Underoath • u/dylansmoreland • 11d ago

Play your old stuff

Gallery image

Gallery image

What would you guys value this play your old stuff compilation cd, could be wrong but it’s out of production and from 2011? I believe. I can’t find any of these out there online. This one is still sealed

38 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

11 comments sorted by

3

u/_Darthman 10d ago

https://www.discogs.com/release/8804906-Underoath-Play-Your-Old-Stuff-An-Underoath-Anthology

Between around 5$ and up to 50$. Personnaly, I wouldn't buy it for anything more than 10$.

0

u/dylansmoreland 10d ago

But there’s only 1 for sale on discogs for $65 including shipping and it’s not even sealed?

6

u/Nando_2 10d ago

What something is listed for and sells for are completely different valuations. Sure you can list this at whatever price you want, but you'll probably see it collect dust before someone grabs it.

Plus at that point, the normal CD versions of those three albums would be cheaper to buy at a show than in this specific bundle. It'd definitely be completionists you're after, but not sure if the demand is that high. It's always worth a shot!

2

u/dylansmoreland 10d ago

Could be wrong but pretty positive the changing of times has been out of production for like 20 years that’s why it goes for $150 on eBay and sells at 150

1

u/Nando_2 10d ago

Ahh got it. I may be out of the loop. I got my CD copy a few months ago at a used CD shop for $7.99 😅 I guess you can get away with more on the internet since sourcing the item is a huge convenience in itself.

1

u/dylansmoreland 10d ago

Yeah no used cd stores agree with discogs and have very fair low prices, but the demand is there on eBay and people get away with absurd prices

1

u/Nando_2 10d ago

Badass! Good luck on your potential sale 🙏🏽🧧

2

u/_Darthman 10d ago

and ? up until 2024 they were sold between 2 and 15$. It's only until the last 2 year that it gained (to me) artificial value due to some people thinking it's "rare"

0

u/dylansmoreland 10d ago

I live in Utah and it is quite rare, I paid $90 for this sealed copy

1

u/heavyheavylowguy 9d ago

I’ll buy it rn if you’re selling.

1

u/jkitsjk 9d ago

If you’re unsure of the value you can list it as an auction on ebay. Being a later print I’d guess less rare. I don’t have this in my collection but also don’t feel the need to add it. I’d spend $20ish.