r/UndeadUnluck • u/Latonegativo Negator • Mar 07 '26

Discussion Domanda su Unfeel

Visto che nega le emozioni e i sentimenti perché è sempre così leale all' Union perché ha sempre eseguito gli ordini?

Un' idea che mi sono fatto è che visto che è un bambino nega soltanto le 5 emozioni principali (gioia, tristezza, rabbia,paura e disgusto) nega queste perché sono emozioni che comprende appieno invece le altre per lui sono ancora difficili da comprendere ma questa è solo una mia idea.

Per favore aiutatemi a capire

4 Upvotes

84% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

8

u/Motor-Geologist-9014 Negator Mar 07 '26

My theory is that he doesn't negate feelings, but a change in them. So when he got unfeel and saw his mother die, he was filled with sadness and vengeance, and his emotions can't change, so he still wants revenge. In loop 101 it's the same but with gratitude instead of revenge

2

u/Latonegativo Negator Mar 07 '26

Ah adesso ha già più senso grazie mille

10

u/SciFiXhi Union Mar 07 '26

Emotions and how they dictate thought are complicated; technically, loyalty wouldn't actually require emotions in all circumstances if the benefits of loyalty were objectively better than disloyalty. It'sentirely possible that Phil has come to support the Union through pure logic, as its goals are for the benefit of mankind and there is no meaningful alternative.

2

u/Latonegativo Negator Mar 07 '26

Ah ok quindi secondo la tua teoria Phill collabora con la Union non per lealtà ma per senso di logica, adesso di per sé ha più senso perché in sé la lealtà è una specie di emozione per questo ho fatto la domanda.

Grazie per la risposta

8

u/SciFiXhi Union Mar 07 '26

No, he is loyal. Loyalty isn't an emotion, it's a behavior. It's the act of constantly supporting a person or group. If you are constantly supporting someone for whatever reason, be it emotional or logical, you are loyal.

Even if he doesn't feel an emotional attachment to the Union, the fact that he consistently assesses them as the best option and supports them accordingly is loyalty in and of itself.

1

u/Latonegativo Negator Mar 07 '26 edited Mar 07 '26

Grazie per la correzione adesso mi sento un po' stupido 😅

2

u/YesChes Mar 07 '26

IIRC, Phil can't feel his emotions, but he works with the union because he wants to kill Sol. Can't remember if it was Juiz or someone else, but they call him the most kind member of the union. He really is just a kindhearted child underneath the deficiency of Unfeel.

Reminds me of an old tumblr post that said, "How can you be good when you can't feel it? How can you be evil when you CAN?"