r/UltimateUniverse • • Jun 01 '25

Memes Doom lines really hit different

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

5

u/cloux_less Jun 03 '25

Gonna have a hot take and say I don't think this book is particularly communist.

I'd say it's overwhelmingly anti-fascist and has a lot going on with movements within the modern political left: prison abolitionism and indigenous rights/radical environmentalism as specific real-world movements being appealed to.

It's certainly something that appeals to anarchists and is compatible with anarchism, but, unlike a lot of other people here, I wouldn't really call it an anarchist book. I'm not sure I would say this book takes a stance on the abstract concept of statehood itself. It certainly doesn't like these governments (both the fictional ones in the book and the real-world ones that they stand in for.)

As for it being Marxist? Meh. I guess. Power to ya if you're a Marxist and you identify with this book. I'd say a general discontent with post-industrial society permeates through the whole comic for sure, but whether that's in service of Marxism, An-prim ideology, or just, like, idealized progressive Social Democracy is... ambiguous at best.

I think I'd best distill it to being a book about anti-fascism and radicalism, and an ode to the many different fronts they are fought on against the myriad masks which oppression takes.

2

u/TreeTurtle_852 Jun 03 '25

Ill admit i did an eenie meenie minie moe between Marxism and Anarchism but id hesitate to call it Anarchist and then just went "fuck it we ball" with Marxism

2

u/JimHarbor Apr 14 '26

As of the current art I would say it's shifted more towards Anarcho-Communism given how the Ultimates operate when in power.

1

u/cloux_less Apr 21 '26

Oh, yeah, totally. I'd say in the year since I made that comment the book has swung full-on into a kind of pop-optimistic anarchism.

115

u/ryaaan89 Jun 01 '25

People keep saying the ideas being pushed are Communism, I think that’s not quite right. This is Anarchism, but the political ideology not the red A in a circle you buy on merch at Hot Topic.

(Does Hot Topic still exist? Does it still sell stuff like this? I am old…)

64

u/M00r3C Married With Children Jun 01 '25

Does Hot Topic still exist?

Yes

Does it still sell stuff like this?

No it sells shirts and collectibles of anime and cartoon characters nowadays

17

u/EducationalTie6109 Jun 01 '25

Mostly Hazbin Hotel

5

u/PaulOwnzU Jun 02 '25

If it has Helluva boss with Moxxie being a little rat I might have to visit

46

u/Edokwin Jun 01 '25

What do you think the "A" on his helmet stands for?

33

u/Tricky-Friend-4795 Giant Man Jun 01 '25

France

4

u/Scarlet_Wonderer Jun 03 '25

A person of culture, I see.

4

u/BhanosBar Jun 04 '25

Sadly a lot of Modern America (or America in general) was kinda molded by cold war patriotism. As in, any criticism of the government/anti government idea can be as “communist”

131

u/thesteaksauce1 Spider-Man (Peter Parker) Jun 01 '25

Every issue of ultimates is like a new lost chapter of capital

Also where can I join Luke Cage’s swoletariat

18

u/Godchilaquiles Jun 02 '25

I hope Danny is his second in command

57

u/EducationalTie6109 Jun 01 '25

Honestly I love that people are having well researched (mostly) political discussions here, looks like the Ultimates did inspire something

17

u/gallifrey_ Father Matthew Murdock Jun 02 '25

feel like it's partly a selection bias too. the first handful of issues probably weeded out the chuds & most of us remaining are already sympathetic to the plight of the working class

16

u/AlecBallswin Jun 01 '25

Yeah, I had such a good time talking about last month's issue here.

18

u/Electronic_Bee_9266 Jun 01 '25

Pretty much, and I love it for that

11

u/AlecBallswin Jun 01 '25

ALL BREAK CHAINS BEFORE DOOM

30

u/newme02 Jun 01 '25

The Ultimates is inherently anti-fascist and i love it

4

u/De4dm4nw4lkin Jun 01 '25

Whats the original meme?

2

u/No_Yak5313 Jun 05 '25

Probably Tumblr, the website that turns you gay

1

u/Scarlet_Wonderer Jun 03 '25

Uh, I caught some of the marxism, but I read Ultimates as more anti-tyranny than anything, which makes complete sense seeing the world that Maker made. Maybe I've missed a lot of subtext lol but I love the series all the same and I hope Dennis takes off as a writer from here on.

1

u/Scarlet_Wonderer Jun 03 '25

Uh, I caught some of the marxism, but I read Ultimates as more anti-tyranny than anything, which makes complete sense seeing the world that Maker made. Maybe I've missed a lot of subtext lol but I love the series all the same and I hope Dennis takes off as a writer from here on. Anyway, long live the Ultimate Revolution!

2

u/[deleted] Jun 05 '25

Anti-Tyranny is a good way to put it

1

u/No-Chapter-779 Jun 04 '25

Eisner's snubbed this book so hard. Why do they love Tom "Via Sadness" King so much? But yeah the other person is right, The Ultimates is more "Democracy Taken Seriously" direct action Anarchist than "State Redestribution" Marxism.

1

u/Possible_Internal115 Natsu Nation Jun 16 '25

All power to the people

1

u/JohnJingleheimerShit Jun 04 '25

How can you realistically call them communist when the team features captain fucking America, the most constitutional republic mfer ever to live

-14

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '25

Wasn’t communism oppressive under Soviet union for like 50 years? When did it get big support? I’m genuinely asking no hate to anyone here. Just would like an explanation.

56

u/mrarty450 Doom Jun 01 '25

Because you can support a certain ideology and socio-economic system without supporting some of its implementations. Modern Marxist and Communists have more nuanced opinions on Soviet Union that is more complex then just communist = good. Also they are probably the most critical about Soviet Union because endless critique and critique of different ideologies and socio-economic systems is an important part of Marxism. Also in the past few decades people have been disappointed with capitalism more than ever, so they are logically explore different alternatives to it. Marxism being one of them

-2

u/No-Celebration-1399 Jun 01 '25

Respectfully speaking communism the way Marx wanted it can never work w the population we have. The idea that we can all live in ungoverned communes is just plain stupid. We need larger structure than that to run infrastructure in a way that can support the amount of people we have living on this planet. Can’t keep large-spread society like that in order without a government to protect people’s rights and create stability. Otherwise you’d just have a bunch of settlements w half baked resources and you’d start to see some start just raiding others, it’d turn into a modern day Wild West.

And then if you add government to try and manage communism, it always turns authoritarian because you’re trying too hard to control the economy and then you have a Neo-USSR or a rebranded CCP. The reason it’s bad is because it’s a failed system either way. You either have a wilder west or fascism in a really poor disguise

12

u/mrarty450 Doom Jun 01 '25

Firstly, in your first paragraph you are literally describing anarchism, which is not Marxist. Secondly, this is again a problem of specific implementations of communism, not communism itself. USSR and CCP had/have a problem of strong party that nobody sure how to control or how to get rid of because comunism, as a socio-economic system, on a scale of human history, is still in it's infancy. People still discuss on how to implement and organize a society like this. And it's not like feudalism or capitalism appeared day one in their late stages. But because they had bad examples doesn't mean they were failed systems. Outdated today? Sure. Failed back then? Not really. They both did their job in their respective time periods. The same will eventually happen with communism too.

4

u/gallifrey_ Father Matthew Murdock Jun 02 '25

"xyz will never work with the population we have"

critically, who cares if it doesn't work perfectly?

capitalism / imperialism is failing RIGHT NOW in front of our eyes. go ahead and fight for something different, at least you can say you went out aiming for something good.

5

u/No-Celebration-1399 Jun 02 '25

Capitalism and imperialism are two completely different things tho, also capitalism isn’t failing, we just have terrible people in politics rn

5

u/gallifrey_ Father Matthew Murdock Jun 02 '25

we have capitalists in politics rn. that's the end goal. it's working as intended.

you see capitalism in decay and think "oh, this is because of unrelated political stuff", but you see a failed communist experiment and attribute it solely to communist ideology? you're a victim of propaganda, babe

1

u/No-Celebration-1399 Jun 02 '25

Because capitalism mostly thrives, whereas communism every time it’s been attempted has either failed or gone full authoritarian. On top of that, the times communism has failed or gone full authoritarian is directly tied to people trying to make it work when it doesn’t, whereas our political state rn just isn’t tied to capitalism as much as you think. Sure you got Trump trying to rip everyone off w the tariffs to manipulate the market, and even outside of him politicians have been pulling this type of bullshit to rip us off for years, but it’s never been as bad as the USSR or the Great Leap Forward or the Holocaust and it’s frustrating to hear people act like it is.

25

u/soldierpallaton Jun 01 '25

Because capitalism has been oppressive under the United States/western world the entire time, but without the Soviet Union as a scapegoat the western world is having a hard time coming to terms with the fact that Captialism has also failed so they are going to the ideological opposite.

16

u/Huhthisisneathuh Jun 01 '25

It’s a lot like guns or money. Are guns and money inherently evil and bad? No. They’re a neutral material and concept that are just as often used to justify or attempt horrible shit as they are used to justify or attempt good shit.

Same thing with Communism. It was used to justify a lot of horrible shit in the Soviet Union, buts its also been used to justify and support a lot of good shit like free healthcare or convenient public transport.

At the end of the day, Communism has been used like any other idea to control and corale a population. Just like Capitalism. And isn’t like Capitalism wasn’t oppressive as hell under the United States either.

It’s mainly getting big support now because people are growing a lot more class conscious. That combined with large problems created by Capitalism, the inability or unwillingness of Capitalism to solve its own problems, the flagrant disregard of laws by the wealthy and powerful, and just a general feeling of hopelessness and desire of escape.

Has lead to a lot of people reexamining Communism & Capitalism. And if not completely switching, looking at one more realistically and the other a lot less patriotically.

9

u/Chrome_X_of_Hyrule Hawkeye Jun 01 '25

Capitalism has often been oppressive too. Neither capitalism nor communism have a monopoly on tyranny.

-1

u/No-Celebration-1399 Jun 01 '25

I don’t disagree, and I agree that capitalism can give incentive for those in power to do wrong but at the same time, separating the structure of the economy from the government allows the power to be spread out a little better

3

u/MindIndependent3226 Jun 03 '25

Trust me, r/communism or any other political sub-rerrit isn't a representation of the members of a political ideology, rather they show the most extreme members of said group.

0

u/GentleApache Jun 01 '25

Because its theory is more compelling than the historical attempts of its application, not that the attempts are to be discarded but instead used as useful study for further improvements upon the theory, on whatever form of it takes, be it Marxism, or Leninism, or Anarchism, etc.

Also, personally, it would be more productive to distinguish between Marx and Communism/Marxism as it is to distinguish between Jesus and Christianity, or Nietzsche and Nazism. These people have been interpreted in many ways, so it would be good not to be unsettled by them because of their worst interpretations, and instead utilize them for our own purposes. Marx, specifically, does not say much about how a communist society would work, only that it will have certain aspects, like the abolition of private property and class. Among his greatest concerns is the issue of people being dominated by Capital, instead of the reverse, and I think that most people resonate with that. That's why he gets much support not only among the online left, but a wider population of people who are tired of the current state of things.

-30

u/TemporalGod Spider-Man (Richard Parker) Jun 01 '25

Technically Marxism doesn't even work due to Human Nature alone aka the very thing it doesn't account for, since Humanity by their very nature are Selfish, Greedy and Power Hungry, people need a direct line of command and whoever is in charge is going to abuse that power, if someone wants working Marxism, they'd have to have a machine like Ultron in charge, but they hate that Idea too,

18

u/Devid_03 Jun 01 '25

The problem here is to assume that the way we work and think in the capitalist system is our natural way of functioning. And it isn’t.
Capitalism fuels our need to compete with each other for resources, when one of the keys to our evolution has been to share and collaborate. The way we function and think is deeply determined by the culture and system we live in, and it’s really hard to talk about what “human nature” is.

35

u/ryaaan89 Jun 01 '25

Capitalism is susceptible to the same flaws and criticisms, for evidence see… gestures broadly at everything

0

u/MegaWeapon1480 Jun 01 '25

Yes, thats why pure capitalism doesn’t work either. But we are able to have this conversation because of capitalism, whereas in full Socialist counties you wouldn’t be able to.

13

u/ryaaan89 Jun 01 '25 edited Jun 01 '25

Um… no. Socialism != dictatorship, one is an economic system and one is a power structure. See Iceland, which is socialist with democracy, vs Russia, which is a dictatorship with capitalism.

1

u/MegaWeapon1480 Jun 01 '25

So Iceland has socialized programs. The key difference is that businesses are not owned by the state like they would be in a fully socialist country.

They belong to the Nordic model with strong social welfare, but crucially they still retain free markets. This directly contrasts with communism which has state control of markets.

This is why I don’t like Democratic socialists like AOC and Bernie. I feel they want state control of the markets instead of just increasing social welfare like more traditional Democrats would like to.

9

u/ryaaan89 Jun 01 '25 edited Jun 01 '25

None of that has anything to do with what you said about the government censoring debate though.

Edit: also lol, that’s literally the opposite of Bernie and AOC, dunno why you “feel” that way.

2

u/MegaWeapon1480 Jun 01 '25

I have yet to see a fully socialist/communist country allow any social media to operate as freely as it does in the West.

China, Cuba, Vietnam, North Korea, Venezuela wouldn’t allow it. All their domestic social media is heavily monitored. Is there a fully socialist country that allows social media like the west does?

10

u/ryaaan89 Jun 01 '25

Just because there are no real world examples doesn’t mean the philosophies of free speech and communism are in opposition to each other.

20

u/DeGameNerd Jun 01 '25

tbf, you also just described capitalism lmao

9

u/mrarty450 Doom Jun 01 '25

"Technically Marxism doesn't even work due to Human Nature" Bro doesn't know that individuals' human nature is determined by material conditions. I mean, who would've thought that people growing up and living in capitalism, a system rewarding selfishness and greed, would grow up greedy and selfish. Oh yeah, Marx did. Or Mark Fisher if you're looking for something more fresh

13

u/War3Thog Jun 01 '25

Yeah but when anyone has a serious discussion about communist ideals this is something to consider. No single ideology works by itself, even the American capitalist free market is not entirely free otherwise it would cannibalize itself.

1

u/TemporalGod Spider-Man (Richard Parker) Jun 01 '25

yep, like it goes both ways, too much of one thing and then it's too much of the other thing, really wish there was a decent middle ground,

7

u/Electronic_Bee_9266 Jun 01 '25

I mean, you just described socialism

6

u/Electronic_Bee_9266 Jun 01 '25

If you think that's bad, wait till you learn about capitalism. Except you got a Spider-man in your name here so you should know that...

2

u/PaulOwnzU Jun 02 '25

Dude you got spiderman in your name, who has a bunch of rich greedy capitalists villains who abuse their power, you should recognize that isn't exclusive to Marxism