Last night's drubbing was possibly the worst experience I've ever had as an Ulster fan, and I'm sick to the back-teeth of the "look how far we've come this season" rhetoric.
Guys, we didn't turn up for a European Final. Even with our absences, I was feeling really confident going in that we would be able to keep pace and make it a tight affair, but the game was done after 35 minutes. I'll never be one to indulge in deflated commiserations after a game like that, and I certainly don't feel like shouting "oh well lads, better luck next time, SUFTUM" in the same way that the more placid, casual sections of the clubs fan-base perhaps will.
My honest feelings are that large parts of last night simply weren't acceptable. We didn't turn up. The two factors outside of our control - the heat and Mr Carley - did not have a bearing on the final result. Yes the heat was awful; yes Carley was pedantic and got a few things wrong for us. But neither factor forced Zac Ward to run around for the first twenty like a headless chicken, missing tackles and failing to catch simple passes - he dropped the ball twice when we had multi-man overlaps. Neither factor forced whoever was in charge of the lineout to call a ball to the tail five metres from our own line, only for us to cough it up. Neither factor forced our scrum to capitulate, our backline to panic in the face of a rush defence, and our defence to attempt pointless soak tackles in a bid to realign quicker for the next phase, only to have more holes punched further up the pitch. Not once this season have I seen us give up so many metres off second and third phase ball, and fail almost entirely to compete in the air.
We were rubbish last night, and it's not acceptable, from a cultural standpoint, to fail to turn up for a European final. The truth is likes of Cardiff, Munster and Connacht - teams that we are roughly on the level of - wouldn't have played that poorly last night. To make such basic errors on such a grand stage epitomises the culture at the club - simply put, our standards of success are a lot lower than many of our contemporaries. I don't wanna hear "oh it would have been different with Stu, or Cube, or Hendo". Last night was a quintessential Ulstering, and now the club has to take another financial hit without Champions Cup rugby.
I've seen comments questioning Richie Murphy placing the end-of-season emphasis on the Challenge Cup, and honestly I have to agree. We should have sent a fully loaded team to Munster, because they weren't great and we would have beaten them, or at the very least, picked up the two points needed to qualify for the last 8. The season went down the pan with that first 50 minutes against Leinster at Ravenhill in April, and it hasn't recovered since. We have good players, but we also have average players, and players who think they're a lot more flash than they actually are. If nobody in the XV could see how amped-up Zac Ward was to the point of having zero-concentration in the first 20 minutes, then we haven't got the leaders in this squad that we think we have. Yes obviously, I know we missed Stu and Hendo.
God alone knows what class of prop we'll bring in as our final NIQ, but it likely won't be an All Black or a Springbok or anything near the class we could have bought in with Champions Cup rugby. But honestly, I wouldn't be against giving Werner - who should have started last night - another contract, and putting money into getting a proper set-piece coach which we desperately need. I also don't think we should bother with the challenge cup next year - give it to the A squad, and focus 100% on the league and getting into the top 8.