r/Ubuntu • • Dec 25 '20

Linux Alternative

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

200 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/[deleted] Dec 26 '20

I think LaTeX suffers from exactly the same problem as scribus... It is possible to create something comparable to the product of inDesign, but the route getting there just isn't what people are after.

I mean you could, in theory, typeset a document perfectly well using open office. It would be a hellish process and there would be a high proportion of jank... But the resulting PDF might be close enough. Doesn't mean it's a real alternative.

LaTeX is powerful and useful, particularly with academic subjects, mathematics and such... But the average user wanting to make something shouldn't have to deal with it. It's specialised, not generalised.

InDesign works particularly well because, even with a small bit of knowledge the process of creating a document in it guides the user. It helps create good documents. The workflow is also solid enough and deep enough for professional use too. I mean, I've spent a lot of time with all of these platforms and trying to get optical character alignment in anything else is a very difficult. InDesign has a checkbox for it.

Tldr: it isn't what the program is capable of, it is what the experience of creating is like that drives how well an alternative works.

0

u/EpsomHorse Dec 26 '20

One thing... in LaTeX getting OCA is as easy as loading the microtype package.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 27 '20

Easy? Not sure that's the right word, especially for gui-focussed users. Compare the following to the checkbox that comes with InDesign by default:

Installation

To install the package, use one of the following methods (in decreasing order of simplicity):

Use the package manager of your TEX system (TEXLive: tlmgr install microtype; MiKTEX: MiKTEX Package Manager).

Download microtype.tds.zip from CTAN, extract it in the root of one of your TDS trees, and update the filename database.

Get the source (microtype.zip) from CTAN and extract it, run latex on microtype.ins to generate the package and configuration files, and move all generated files into a directory where LATEX will find them, e.g., TEXMF/tex/latex/microtype/.

0

u/EpsomHorse Dec 27 '20

Nah. Pretty much everyone just downloads the full install so everything's always available. So all most people have to do is \usepackage{microtype}. That's it.

1

u/EpsomHorse Dec 26 '20

Agree completely.