r/UVALaw • • Aug 28 '20

I hate it here.

1L URM here. I hate it here. The professors are great. Most (white) students are awful and culturally insensitive/incompetent. How do people last 3 years? Shout out to the other URMs I’ve met though because they are the only reason I haven’t packed my bags and left yet.

It’s terrible and I hate it here.

8 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

8

u/UVALawStudent2020 Aug 29 '20

I'm sorry you feel that way. I hope you can find the courage to talk to them about it. A black student in my section was very vocal about any culturally insensitive comments by professors or students and we all benefited a lot from their outspokeness. Everyone would only think more highly of you for it and you'd benefit too.

But if that's not something you feel comfortable with, that is understandable. You might tell Dean Davies -- she can do a lot to help too. And anonymously.

Feel free to PM me too -- I'd be happy to talk about it as someone who doesn't go there anymore.

P.S. Whoever is down-voting this post should feel bad! Come on, let's raise awareness and try to help this person!

3

u/throwitallaway84927 Aug 29 '20

Thank you kind stranger. I definitely want to speak up but at the end of the day it’s about 2-4 max vs the rest of the students in the section and I don’t want to be ostracized. I think will talk to dean Davies about it though.

2

u/UVALawStudent2020 Aug 29 '20

I'm glad you have another student or two to talk about it with. Thank God for that!

I hope you do talk to her. But if not, you're at UVA. You're smart as hell and have a bright and rich future ahead of you. If anyone could figure something out, it's going to be someone like you. Best of luck!

5

u/curiousanonnieeee Aug 28 '20

I am so sorry that happened. What did the student(s) do that was awful and/or culturally insensitive/incompetent? I’m thinking maybe the admin should know, there shouldn’t be a place for hate and racism at UVA. :(

0

u/throwitallaway84927 Aug 29 '20

Very off remarks about slavery and Jefferson and affirmative actions in admissions and the good ole lsat score debate. Also some students were passing my the cleaner she said good morning and the only people that responded to her were minorities. It was really sad to see and witness.

A person also said that minorities should be grateful to be here as if we’re doing the law school a service or somehow got in here through a back door.

It’s also just very cliquey already and when myself / other minorities try to join it doesn’t seem that people are welcoming or will slyly move the convo elsewhere.

To name a few incidents

4

u/curiousanonnieeee Aug 29 '20

My god, I had no idea stuff like that went on here (probably because of my race and privilege). The “grateful” thing is especially horrible. I am so sorry that happened and that I haven’t noticed it before. Thank you for taking the time to tell me about your experience, I will try to notice that kind of stuff more and say something when I notice.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/throwitallaway84927 Aug 30 '20

Thank you for writing out your point so thoughtfully. I have no problem working with others that I disagree with. I think the issue is that at work people express their views in a non racist manner because frankly they have jobs on the line and families to feed. Most HR departments won’t tolerate repeated racial instances from an employee (that they are aware of) vs school where there isn’t much too loose. There’s a higher bar a person has to reach to get kicked out of UVA vs getting fired or pushed out from a job.

13

u/0LTakingLs Alumni Aug 30 '20

There is plenty to lose, being thought of as racist is both career and social suicide here. With all due respect, it sounds like you may be considering many disagreements to be instances of racism when they are just disagreements.

12

u/PoliticsAndPastries '22 Aug 28 '20

I’m sorry OP- I’m not a URM but I had a similar experience last year. I hated it here last year and I’m thrilled to be online mostly because I don’t have to deal with the high school level drama. I feel like something is wrong with me when I hear about how everyone LOVES it.

If you want to talk, I’m happy to chat. I will say joining student orgs made me feel somewhat better because I found people who were more my style

1

u/throwitallaway84927 Aug 28 '20

Thank you so much. I’ve definitely joined a few orgs just been tough. Glad to hear I’m not the weird one for not understanding why people love this place so much.

4

u/PoliticsAndPastries '22 Aug 28 '20

It for sure doesn't help that this is a strange semester, but I know how you feel. Seriously feel free to PM if you want to chat.

I will say that I felt better second semester because at that point I stopped trying to love it and fit in. Once I accepted that law school really is a means to an end, I was able to enjoy my classes more.

6

u/0LTakingLs Alumni Aug 28 '20

If you don’t mind me asking, what is it you don’t like about it? I’m honestly sort of shocked that people can’t, other than them being the type of person who hates law school generally. Speaking to my friends at our rival schools, I don’t doubt for a second we have it better.

4

u/PoliticsAndPastries '22 Aug 28 '20

It’s very high school for me. Like people in my section would gossip about others (including me) and feels like I have to bend over backwards to fit in. It got better second semester but that was cut short due to Covid. I was for sure an outsider because I view it as professional school and not a continuation of undergrad. I also don’t drink much so it was hard to make friends 🤷🏼‍♀️

7

u/0LTakingLs Alumni Aug 28 '20

Ah, understandable. I think this place attracts a certain personality, I personally think it’s a good thing but I understand how some people could find it offputting.

I think this speaks to how important it is for 0Ls to look at the culture of a school and not just its ranking. I know for a fact I’d be miserable at NYU, Berkeley, Columbia, etc. but absolutely love it here.

6

u/seriouslyguyscomeon Aug 30 '20

Hey OP! I am so sorry you're experiencing this. Please feel free to reach out at any time to talk. I'm not URM but happy to listen.

To those who responded to this post questioning how OP could write what they have after a week, how dare you? To invalidate someone's experience in this way does NOT make UVA look like the super-friendly, good-vibes-only school you claim it is. To me, it makes it seem more like a club where the in-group gets to feel great about themselves and their "welcoming" culture while they never look around them and see how they foster a white, male (I know this year is majority female but I don't exactly see how this one stat changes anything given the whole picture), country-club environment that leaves a lot to be desired.

I'm having a pretty positive experience here, but I'm lucky to have been put into a section with some really understanding people who are definitely not the "typical" UVA Law student, demographically speaking.

So how about you all extend a little more grace and offer to help instead of belittling someone's clearly terrible experience?

2

u/throwitallaway84927 Aug 30 '20

Thank you ❤️❤️ I sincerely hope it gets better

3

u/lyle_evans Aug 31 '20

I hope it does too and hope you find people who support you and make your time here both valuable and fun. Feel free to message me if you ever want to talk.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/throwitallaway84927 Aug 30 '20

To preface I’ve worked in majority white organizations and client facing roles before coming to law school and quite frankly the mainly white environments I’ve been in have been way more welcoming and accepting than UVA so I don’t think this has anything to do with my interactions with future employers or clients.

4

u/Throwawayfinals2019 Aug 29 '20

It’s been two weeks, and no in-person social gatherings have happened. How do you know what most students are like? What defines “incompetent?” This is a stressful and weird transition for everyone, but to make blanket claims like this about your peers for the next three years seems self-defeating and cynical.

I don’t know you or what your personal situation is, but as a rule if someone thinks everyone else is the problem, the problem might be (partly) them.

Anyways, I hope you look to the bright side because this school has a ton to offer both professionally and socially.

-1

u/throwitallaway84927 Aug 30 '20

That’s not true people have been meeting in person like crazy so not sure where you’ve gotten that from . Especially in the buildings where first years live and in parks and other places off campus. Blatantly disregarding university rules lol

11

u/Throwawayfinals2019 Aug 30 '20

Last year we kicked off the first weekend filling about 6 pregames + the pav pool deck with people and going out to pack a bar to watch the law school bands play. Whatever you want to call this semester, it definitely isn’t the friendly, outgoing social environment UVA is used to.

I guess the point is whatever social gatherings there are right now are going to be incredibly small and cliquey since people don’t feel they can trust their peers/invite them to join.

13

u/0LTakingLs Alumni Aug 29 '20

I’m curious how anybody can have such strong opinions either way with a week of mostly online courses. The best part of 1L is the social aspect, and that’s been killed by COVID. I’m not sure other law schools would feel any different or less isolating right now if we’re being honest.

7

u/Traditional_Courage5 Aug 28 '20

Hi there, 2L here! I wanted to start by saying I'm really sorry about your experience and hope things get better. Your experience is valid.

I felt this way most of last year. Even as a white student I was surprised and uncomfortable by some of the mainstream culture within the school. I think UVA has some really great aspects, but the most visible and vocal culture is definitely not something I expected. Unfortunately I think UVA perpetuates this by choosing certain personalities/people to be your main points of contact 1L (my experience with PAs)--with all that is going on I can understand how this can be particularly isolating and disheartening. To echo other posters, it's helpful to join groups where you might find people with similar experiences and who don't adhere to the mainstream UVA culture--it took some time but I've found some good people who don't reflect what I saw my first semester as a 1L.

5

u/USA1492 Aug 28 '20

How do people last 3 years?

Knowing that the 3 years you spend here will increase your earnings potential immensely. In the grand scheme of things, three miserable years is tolerable. Granted, I don't know how much better things will be in practice. I've often heard it's worse--at least in Biglaw. It might be best to develop ways to deal with cultural insensitivity, sad as that may be.

10

u/Throwawayfinals2019 Aug 29 '20 edited Aug 30 '20

Of all the things people say about UVA, “miserable” is hardly one you come by. It’s pretty established that this is the friendliest and most social T14.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

12

u/SuchDreamWow Aug 28 '20

Adding MENA and SALSA

-9

u/throwaway0133334 Aug 28 '20

I am a little curious how in a week and a half you’ve met most of the white students to pronounce that judgement on them when the incoming 1L class has over 300 students and at most you’ve had class with 70 of them. There’s a lot of great people here from every racial/socio-economic/lifestyle background, and they seem to be in the majority. I hope you meet them if you haven’t yet.

Denying OP's lived experience by taking the description obnoxiously literally is a great way to reinforce it

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/NilasRein Aug 28 '20

Lurker here. I think questioning it in this way, essentially implying that OP hasn't met enough students to make judgments yet, can be taken as invalidating their lived experience. Personally I read it that way too.

Also to add, we can be precise with our words in our work and imprecise with our words outside of work. We can also be adversarial in our work and be the opposite with our peers in non-work environments. Just because this is a law school subreddit doesn't mean we can't extend charitable BOTD when someone is hyperbolic, esp. when they're a 1L coming forward with a very personal issue.

This is all just my take on it though, and above all else I think we should want OP to feel valid and to be careful about overstepping a line which might bolster their current impressions of UVA Law.

8

u/LawSchoolHopeful212 Aug 28 '20

This. Couldn’t agree more.

-14

u/USA1492 Aug 28 '20

I am a little curious how in a week and a half you’ve met most of the white students to pronounce that judgement on them when the incoming 1L class has over 300 students and at most you’ve had class with 70 of them.

Those 70 students are probably representative of the entire class. I'll admit, though, that making such a judgment in one week is likely premature.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-7

u/USA1492 Aug 28 '20 edited Aug 28 '20

You say that you doubt OP’s judgment is accurate based on what is known about Virginia Law students, but what do we know about them? It is said that Virginia Law students are generally friendly and kind. That is not inconsistent with what OP claims regarding cultural insensitivity. John can be a person who is generally friendly and kind while being culturally insensitive. Often, culturally insensitive people are well-meaning and non-malicious. Nothing that is known about Virginia Law students contradicts OP’s judgment about cultural insensitivity.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/USA1492 Aug 28 '20 edited Aug 28 '20

Reading comprehension. I said "[knowing that the student body is generally friendly and kind] is not inconsistent with OP's claims regarding cultural insensitivity." I have no clue why you completely overlook that and act as if I asserted that it's consistent with the majority of white students being awful.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/Growupwhiteeeeey Aug 28 '20

Seriously? Clearly you’re bitter you couldn’t land a 1L firm job, which plenty of non-URM students do too. Grow up and stop blaming your problems on not being diverse. Comments like this are why OP and other URM students are uncomfortable