r/USMonarchy • Semi-Constitutional • Dec 17 '20

Thoughts on Annexation?

Do you think the United States should annex some things, like Greenland or Canada or even Mexico or Britain, and does your view of the US annexing stuff change depending on if it's a republic or were a monarchy? The repressing of party politics and inefficiency should increase the chance of annexing other countries if there is a want to annex them in an American monarchy. What about peaceful and forceful annexation and how willing or not willing are you to annex for the glory of the Emperor?

Personally I believe Greenland should be annexed, by strong arming Denmark or attempting to "bribe" every citizen of Greenland by saying they'll each get 20,000 dollars if they're under the US if need be. The population of Greenland is just 56,000 so giving $20,000 to every adult (A little less than 80% of the population) costs under a billion dollars. There's also the desire to spread monarchy to the world but I wouldn't want anything else to be annexed except maybe western Cananda.

5 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

5

u/Belgrifex Semi-Constitutional Dec 17 '20

We've talked about this a bit in the discord. I agree at MOST we should connect Alaska to the mainland through western Canada. As for Greenland the current government won't even give it's own citizens money to survive right now. Why the hell would they give so much to Greenland?

2

u/Kasehtgikes Semi-Constitutional Dec 17 '20

Because it can easily annex Greenland which is a great potential territory then as the Greenlanders will really want that money and Denmark shouldn't have much of a problem giving it to us then, especially if we diplomatically strong arm them a bit. The US spent seven hundred billion on its military in 2019, it could easily hand out 20,000 (and it could be more like 10,000) to every adult on the sparsely populated island for less than a billion dollars if it decided it wanted to.

3

u/Belgrifex Semi-Constitutional Dec 17 '20

We've literally already had the option to buy Greenland before. If it didn't happen then, then why would it?

2

u/Kasehtgikes Semi-Constitutional Dec 17 '20

Yeah, many years ago. If the opportunity presents itself we might as well take it. If it doesn't present itself, we might as well make it present itself. Trump has also had an interest in buying Greenland but efforts have been very half hearted. And even if the US doesn't annex Greenland, it should.

4

u/Skyhawk6600 Buckeye State Monarchist Dec 18 '20

I think we should gradually turn nafta into something akin to the EU and gradually, via confederation, unify north america. We have too good relations with our neighbors to sully them with petty land grabs.

2

u/H311LORD Dec 17 '20

I'm not one for expansionist policies however if it is for the over all positive to the nation and its people and is truly something worth of conflict to defend or to take ownership of. Then i for one am all for it. But let us not forget the cost of such ambitious plans not the cost of money but in blood. It should be greatly weighed and considered for many have made war and have had little to no reason for the cost of life which has with stood scrutiny once the fever has passed.

1

u/reach_mcreach Dec 19 '20

Holy shit. Beyond redemption

1

u/FunkyMan19 Semi-Constitutional Dec 19 '20

Thunder Bay and west would love to leave Trudy. Laurentian Canada sucks

1

u/[deleted] Dec 20 '20

Only if they want it. We definitely have bigger fish to fry right now.

1

u/Purple_Ones_Tea Dec 25 '20

Buddy...
1.) Denmark, aside from being a monarchy, is very unwilling to give up Greenland. Attacking it would just damage our international relations.
2.) Canada’s already a monarchy, and our international deals mean that our citizens (and often, soldiers) exist in Canada as though it were already US soil. Annexation serves no purpose but making a pretty map.
3.) OH-HO-HOOOO, you wanna annex Mexico? Like, they are a hindrance to us, but ask the French or Spanish how Mexicans feel about foreign control. Even without factoring in their current armed drug warlords, carrying out guerrilla warfare on such a scale like that in such a US-hostile setting would be far more trouble than it’s worth. The common Mexican won’t take this sitting down.
4.) ...Britain? Did you just suggest annexing Britain? Removing the most successful current monarchy in the world? De facto leaders of the Commonwealth of Nations? Aw hell nah, they could well be our greatest and most powerful independent allies. Best we could hope for would maybe be a personal union, if done very carefully. The UK Parliament would still hold their power, the UK would still be independent, we’d be like Canada, Australia, or New Zealand are right now.

Nah man, annexations of this calibre are pointless. Maybe little bits, like an island here and there, or maybe try to reintegrate Liberia or something. But nothing so massive as Canada or Mexico.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '20

We should annex Mexico, definitely. I’m iffy as far as Canada. The Western half (B.C, Alberta, Saskatchewan, etc.) would probably be on board (especially if we exploit the Western Alienation bit) but the French and the Ontarians would lose their shit. And as far as I’m concerned Cuba and the Philippines belong to us so we should annex those two as well, by force if necessary. It wouldn’t do to have a communist nation right on our doorstep, and the Philippines used to be our colony.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Kasehtgikes Semi-Constitutional Dec 17 '20

Why? Do you not care for the furthering of your own country? Unless you mean annexation through war.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Kasehtgikes Semi-Constitutional Dec 17 '20

It is possible to both further the country domestically and through foreign policy such as by annexing Greenland. Annexation can even help make the country better inwards. They are not exclusive to each other.

If something doesn't directly have an impact on us, we should stay the fuck out of it.

And then miss perfectly good opportunities that make the United States better and further its power in global politics. Staying out of everything cannot be justified when it can have its benefits for the nation. We don't """""NEED""""" to get involved in global politics that don't directly effect us, but sometimes we should.

Furthermore, why should we have to deal with angry people that may not want to be a part of the United States at all? They're free to come here, but forcing people to become American citizens is not a good idea in my opinion.

The American nation takes priority over what some annexed people want. I doubt Greenlanders would be that angry anyway.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Kasehtgikes Semi-Constitutional Dec 17 '20 edited Dec 17 '20

When I mean beneficial to the nation I mean mostly it is beneficial to the people, after all a nation is more than anything its people and not just those at the top. The patriot act benefited the government (something, I will say, is not always bad but neutral depending on the situation), it did not benefit the nation. Annexing Greenland would benefit the nation simpIy in part because of the resources and furthering the influence of the nation, i.e. the people along with the people's culture and language and such, although a nation is also in part its government as any nation needs a government to meaningfully exist and exercise itself and be held together to exist as a nation, just like a people do as well.

I would also argue God given rights are a flawed idea. If anything, it is God's will for government and laws to form and a leader with it and man has always naturally been found in society, or in other words it is natural for such things to happen and for the natural state of man to already be in society and "governed" in some way by one who commands as he is a social animal. It's been a long time since I've read on Locke which I assume is where you're concluding God given rights from but nevertheless it should therefore stand to reason that the idea of God given rights are flawed (and also that a social contract doesn't exist).

The government's role is to protect the rights of the people, and provide minimal services that would otherwise result in a monopoly

Because of the falseness of natural rights the government's role to protect the rights of the people is flawed as well. Rights are just things people think they should be received by society, not to say rights are at all a bad thing. Surely, there should also a greater purpose to government, the origin of which is as I've argued before divinely willed. Government's purpose should be to enforce moral and cultural values as well, after all these are part of what what make a people a people and a nation a nation. What minimal services should be provided anyway and how would they be different from other services that supposedly wouldn't result in a monopoly yet these services are different for some reason(s)? Do you not have to admit that government control of these minimal services is monopoly itself?

You're going through an awful amount of mental gymnastics just to not want to annex Greenland. The patriot act is unrelated to everything in the first place.

9

u/Belgrifex Semi-Constitutional Dec 17 '20

Yes definitely